HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

monadINtop

145 karma · joined October 6, 2023

submissionscomments
monadINtop··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
If I dont go to work I starve. If I organise with my colleagues for a more favourable contract I will be removed by security guards. If we protest this we will be arrested by police. Are you able to only recognise force the moment blood is being spilled?
monadINtop··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
I consider you wrong since an alliance presupposes a unity of interest whereas the interest of a worker (get more money, work less or maybe more nuanced: have as much control over own work as possible, have as much exposure to fruits of work as possible) is directly opposed to that of what you call the "company" or, really, the owners of the company (compel the worker to produce as much as possible, and pay as low a wage as possible to extract as much profit as possible).

Brushing this dynamic under the rug by conceptualizing it as a mutual agreement of "I will work for you for this wage" is at best glib, even if we ignore the elephant in the room that the worker doesn't choose to work since unfortunately we all need to buy food and a place to live, doesn't choose his wage since the entire labor market is practically the same and not in his power to influence nor shop for an alternative (we don't live in a text book where people can make purely rational economic choices since are born to a context and we live in places and have access to a given pool of resources etc) and lets not even glance at the lack of political alternative to this economic arrangement in this historical flash of time.

monadINtop··on How the continuum hypothesis could have been a fundamental axiom
then you are interested in a version of physics that doesn't exist, even though some might choose to supress the details at low level
monadINtop··on How the continuum hypothesis could have been a fundamental axiom
You need measure theory for probability, economics, QFT and Physics, etc. And who is doing "all the math"? The vast majority of resarchers who "do math" are largely in PDEs and other fields that simply use the technology of math for "things that you find in reality" like engineering problems or machine learning and so forth. And most mathmaticians would agree that it is some of the most uninteresting and ugly kind of math.

Whereas the relative minority of people who study really abstract things like say k-theory or large cardinals in set theory are largely doing it out of interest in it's intrinsic beauty. And this is especially true for idk, some esoteric subfield of tropical geometry or modal logic or something, who's relevance to "things you find in reality" are completely orthogonal as to the motivations of those people who chose to spend their lives uncovering the truths within them.

Math research isn't about blindly marching from proof to proof by mechanical deduction with no conception of the larger picture like a uniform bubble spreading outwards, it is done by small communities of scholars who hack away at a specific nexus of interesting problems and structures for their own sake.

Sometimes, like with spin bundles or lie algebras or non-abelian geometry, yeah you can apply it to "real" problems, but that's not how the theory was developed, and as a theoretical physicist I will tell you that you will find no greater blindness to the underlying structure or ugliness in the use of the technology than those people that exclusively wield the technology against "real" problems, instead of appreciating it for its own sake.

monadINtop··on Some people with insomnia think they're awake when they're asleep
it was revealed in a vision
monadINtop··on Researcher suggests that gravity can exist without mass
yeah, and they pushed it as a theory of everything (which I think they had justification to believe for the first few decades [~] to get funding. So I also blame the entire economic system that academia is unfortunately embedded in.

[~] It still isn't neccesarily ruled out, it's just incredibly unfeasible at the moment as a physical theory since it is currently very poorly understood and like centuries away from experimental tests (as is any GUT or QG theory i.e. this is not a criticism of string theory but basically any theory past the standard model). However it is extremely interesting currently as a subject in mathematics, and it has deep connections with current research in algebraic geometry and the geometric langlands program.

monadINtop··on Researcher suggests that gravity can exist without mass
No one should hate string theory??? No one should hate any area of valid research? That sounds extremely dogmatic and reactionary.

String theory specifically is an extremely rich and fruitful theory that has had huge application to mathematics (mirror symmetry, no ghost-conjecture and the mysterious moonshine etc.) as well as inspiration for theoretical physics (AdS-CFT, Supersymmetry etc.). It is telling that none of the loudest voices telling people to "hate" an area of theoretical research have studied it (or often studied any physics or math, since the technical details, or even a grounded understanding, are superfluous to their "arguments").

>Hang on. Which one are you trying to say is right or wrong?

I'm saying they are both wrong

If you want to hate something, hate the pop-sci articles that sold it as a "theory of everything" for 20 years, and hate the environment that made it neccesary for researchers to peddle that bullshit in pursuit of funding, don't dogmatically hate an entirely valid area of research just because some mouth pieces who peddle narratives of a very technical field to an audience who aren't able to meaningfully engage with it, have decided to turn against it (i.e. Sabine hossenfield and eric weinstein or whatever their names are).

monadINtop··on Researcher suggests that gravity can exist without mass
So it's an absolute moonshot that posits that all observed discrepencies of galactic rotation curves is actually due to a coincidental and highly unlikely distribution of topological defects (that are not consistent with the full field equations) that have not been observed, and also fail to explain every other feature of dark matter at various different scales. nice.

Its fine for a paper but doesn't really make sense as an article unless you are more interested in ad revenue from titles like "we don't need mass for gravity" than the ideas being presented. These science article websites live solely off of people who aren't equipped with the prerequisite background to actually critically parse the ideas that are being presented.

This is probably the reason why everyone ~online~ (and not in departments) loved string theory two decades ago, and virulently hates it today, and also think that dark matter "is just a bunch of BS from the physics establishment" and that things like MOND or this are even remote competitors to the general consensus (which is basically just - we have no idea but we probably just need an extension to the standard model / quantum gravity at somepoint in the far future).

monadINtop··on [dead]
Here's to surviving in the face of a near century long ethnic cleansing and apartheid.

Its gonna be very strange one day to look back on this period of history and see everyone claiming that they were always against it, just as they do now with colonial india, south africa, slavery, anti-semitism, and black civil rights.

monadINtop··on The Cognitive Design of Tools of Thought (2014) [pdf]
What a waste of time. Who provides funding for this? Also mildly annoying to use "isomorphism" outside of mathematics to describe a relation or analogy between things. You can just say relation or analogy.

Relying on the technical mystique of precicely defined jargon in a context where it doesn't apply should indicate that there is a lack of substance in the ideas being presented, which is why the author feels compelled to obfuscate it.

monadINtop··on AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training
https://www.jstor.org/stable/25006809

https://www.counterpunch.org/2021/09/10/noam-chomsky-and-the...

stop spreading lies that have been debunked for decades, not everyone share your inability to parse information from outside your ideological bubble

monadINtop··on AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training
There is zero understanding of the cause of internal experience. We can't even strictly define what it is. My contention isn't that materialism doesn't appear to be a reasonable canditate for cognitive process, but that we still have no idea HOW any of that happens. We may never know.

People who claim that it is obvious that neural networks and LLMs replicate the functioning of a brain, any brain - let alone human, are just wrong. They are wrong to assume that it is obvious that just making bigger LLMs will somehow generate a being with the capacity of internal experience, whatever that may mean. They are wrong when they act like they have solved the problem of understanding cognition by just forgetting to mention the hard problem of conciousness. They are even wrong to simply assert that neurons and neural networks are "to do" with cognition. Hallucinogens and brain damage affect subjective experience, and both of those things are involved with the vascular system of the brain. Would I be right to say the vascular system produce cognition? Why doesn't anyone argue in favor of that view since it is not too far off from the same reasoning?

Obviously, it's reasonable to assume that neurons are somehow involved with subjective experience, most serious neuroscientists and other researchers would hold that same assumption. But you need to EXPLAIN how, preferably with evidence. It is the burden of the one claiming they have finally figured it all out to present a convincing theory, or at least conjecture the path to get there. Loudly and smugly asserting that your assumption is correcter than the other people who have spent decades working on the problem doesn't make the problem dissolve, but it is especially irritating when the incentive of the loudest people doing so is in the pockets of the shareholders they are indebted to.

monadINtop··on AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training
Is creating things of aesthetic quality not of value with respect to the human condition? Is not some subset of that aesthetic quality derivative of the intuition and intention of a human mind? Sure, if you want to build some tehchnology to make designing packaging for dog food more effecient go ahead, as long as it isn't the previous dog food packaging creators that are being made to absorb the economic cost of the new technology (which they are).

But I hope at last some subset of human art strives to do more than that, and I think it's a bad thing that the incentive to increase revenue at the expense of quality has now expanded past being a tool to improve efficiency of laborious tasks and is now instead cutting costs via cutting artistic value.

monadINtop··on AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training
No, you need intelligent things to be intelligent.

And it would probably be good to distinguish between "things that appear superficially intelligent" and "things that have genuine capacity for internal experience" while you're at it, since the popular perception on this forum seems to be to just declare that physicalism/materialism is obviously correct and explanatory and we can just brush the hard problem of conciousness under the rug. People are so eager to endow the statistical model that has been designed to produce responses that are statistically feasable in a given context (a very impressive feat of technology to be clear) as having internal experience.

Chomsky happens to be more right about LLMs than 90% of the popular discourse will ever be able to understand, which isn't that suprising considering the impact if this "crank's" earlier work.

monadINtop··on AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training
The distinction is philosophical. Tech bros consider "art assests" or consumer oriented products as art. In their eyes its capibility as a tool for profit is a downstream effect.

My point was that since their entire purpose in life revolves around developing and refining technology for the reproduction of capital, it reveals their blindness to any deeper aspect of the human condition than what can be sold for a profit. When people post 3d versions of the Mona Lisa or a shitty remix of Monet's water lillies with breathless praise, it's because in their eyes the stylistic reproduction or reinterpetation of the literal shapes and colors on a flat screen is all there is to art, not merely because it demonstrates utility in replacing already exploited sectors of creative workers.

I don't think we disagree about any of this. I think that I'm just making a tangential point to the article in response to a dumb comment, while you are talking about the subject more directly. Otherwise I fail to see what you think is naive, if only because I've seen so many examples of this rot of understanding around the essence of artistic expression from the mouthpieces of silicone valley and our wider, increasingly corporatized, culture.

monadINtop··on AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training
Yep, you're right. But idk why you phrased that like it's a rebuttal to my criticism. This is another failure of our economic system, for incentivising the owners of art production to churn out literal mindless slop to cut costs, instead of safe guarding artists and creators for the sake of their intrinsic value to society and humanity.

Since, of course, they must eternally seek to reproduce capital to the detriment of everything else.

monadINtop··on AI doppelgänger experiment – Part 1: The training
lol sometimes I wonder if the reason so many tech bros make so many grandiose statements about how AI has already trancended the bounds of human creativity is because they've never really had actual experience with art and literature and music growing up. They say things like this and then you go and look for an example of these incredible works of artificial art and it is the biggest pile of shit you have ever seen.

Just like how they think that these glorified typing assistants function identically to the human brain. I mean maybe they really do replicate the level of creativity and intelligence of the people who believe these things, but maybe the people with decades of research in linguistics and neuroscience are right to be skeptical.

Its kinda like when people talk about research mathematics like its all adding really big numbers together or calculating really tricky integrals.

monadINtop··on ChatGPT-4o vs. Math
People don't uncover new mathematics with formal rules and symbols pushing, at least not for the most part. They do so first with intuition and vague belief. Formalisation and rigour is the final stage of constructing a proof or argument.
monadINtop··on ChatGPT-4o vs. Math
No. Not in my experience. Anyone with experience in research mathematics will tell you that making progress at the research level is driven by intuition - intuition honed from years of training with formal rules and rigor but intuition nonetheless - with the final step being to reframe the argument in formal/rigorous language and ensure consitency and so forth.

Infact the more experience and skill I get in supposedly "rational" subjects like foundations, set theory, theoretical physics, etc. the more sure I am that intuition / belief first - justification later is a fundamental tenant of how human brains operate, and the key feature of rationalism and science during the enlightenment was producing a framework so that one may have some way to sort beliefs, theories, and assertion so that we can recover - at the end - some kind of gesture towards objectivity

monadINtop··on Strangely Curved Shapes Break 50-Year-Old Geometry Conjecture
the technical math definition is a rigourous formulation that encapsulates exactly the same thing as what we mean when we say things are curved, but one that also extends far more generally into contexts where our old intuition fails.

The same is true for most mathematics. For example, we are introduced to multiplication as repeated addition: 3x == x + x + x or 2x == x + x and more generally nx == x + x + ... + x, for n number of times. Of course this is only defined over naturals, what would it mean if we instead took n to be fractional, negative, irrational, or even complex? We of can easily generalise multiplication over larger and more complex fields and spaces, but in doing so we must abandon our old intuitive idea that nx is x + x n-times.

monadINtop··on Schrödinger equation emerges mathematically from classical mechanics (2012)
it's not more likely, it just does. If we couldn't re-derive all known laws of classical mechanics and thermodynamics from the large scale limit of quantum mechanics, than we would have rejected quantum mechanics as wrong (or incomplete) decades ago.

This paper seeks to show that some of the mathematical framework of quantum mechanics "pops out" of some intuitive (depends on your perspective i guess) machinery from classical mechanics. It doesn't really mean much fundamentlly, and doesn't really reflect the historical derivations of the equations, but it is interesting to look in retrospect how readily some of these equations pop out from seemingly basic frameworks.

Its also interesting to consider the actual historical discovery of these concepts, or any scientific concept that generalised existing theories to a far deeper and more unifying result (e.g classical -> quantum mechanics, newtonian mechanics -> general relativity). You are required to somehow develop a theory that not only extends beyond horizons currently seen, but also one that correctly replicates the theory it seeks to supercede. And of course, you are limited to theoretical tools you already know, since no-one has yet figure a way to reach into the future and pluck out a more suitable notation or mathematical framework. Its like a literary character trying to write the story it is embedded in.

Of course, there are always hints to the keen observer, especially tucked away at the foundations: much of special relativity unravelled itself directly from the laws of electromagnetics, since in the equation the speed of light is never specified, and the naive galilean assumption that everyone made - that time and space are absolute, and speeds must be specified relative to observers - was the veil obscuring our vision. If you take the courage to abandon the doctrine of absoluteness of time and space, and to declare that the speed of light doesn't need to be specified in terms of some preferred reference frame, since the speed of light is invariant for all observers everywhere throughout the universe, the intractable gulfs seperating what we know from what we don't vanish like a mirage, and meld together naturally into a more fundamental, and unified theory.

And we can take the same step again, by noticing the strange coinicdence that in Newton's theory of gravitation and mechanics, the inertial mass happens to exactly equal the gravitational mass, magically cancelling each others contribution. If we declare that these two phenomena are infact exactly the same thing seen from different perspectives, and we realise that the apparant difference between somebody accelerating and somebody falling is an illusion, obscuring the fact that both are simply bodies taking the shortest path through the warped 4-dimensional manifold of spacetime, we once again unify all of our observations into a elegant, geometric theory of immense power and stunning beauty, one that can peer into the hearts of dead stars, and into the birth of all things, despite being first revealed in the brain of an absent minded jewish man, sitting in a cluttered office filled with pipesmoke, in a time where europe was fragmented from the collapse of empires and feudal houses, with wars fought with bayonets and horses still in living memory.

monadINtop··on James Webb Space Telescope captures high-resolution image of Uranus
that comparison should make you appreciate the unfathomable distances between even the most local astronomical objects, not underestimate it.

The distance between continents is hard enough for the human brain to comprehend, and imagine the difficulty in trying to caputure an image with a telephoto lens of some resolvable feature in japan, from europe or america (forgetting the shape of the Earth's surface for a moment).

Of course ever graceful, nature offers us a compromise. Most astronomical object (galaxies, nebula) are very big, and very very far away. It is not resolution that makes it difficult to see them (since they span an appreciable arc-width of our sky, e.g. search pictures of the angular width of andromeda galaxy or the orion nebula compared to the moon), but how faint they are.

The photons they emit are travelling across swathes of the observable universe. They travel across scales where the presence of galaxy clusters warp the geometry of space-time, a turbulant voyage for these light rays. They travel across distances where space itself inflates like a balloon, the expanding universe sapping energy from them until they arrive in our detectors or eyeballs redshifted beyond recognision. This is why observatories and satellite-telescopes need to place a huge emphasis on scaling up mirror size to scoop up all the photons they possibly can, as opposed to strictly focusing on resolution - as an earthbound photographer might naively expect.

Now consider the nature of planets, they are not diffuse clouds of molecules or dust lanes spanning galactic widths, they are tightly bound, tangible, physical objects. Now they might be our neighbours, trapped in the same spiral around the sun's gravitational well, but that doesn't mean they're "close" in any sense that the human mind could every really fathom. If we want to resolve atmospheric or geographic (is that even the right word for other planets?) features, we need to be able to achieve precise resolutions beyond what is normally required for other types of astronomical observation. Indeed, if you've every taken a class on optics or astronomy, you might be suprised how quickly fundamental limits of resolution that arise from lights wave-like behaviour - like airy disks - begin to veil that which we wish to observe, when playing around with frequiencies and aperture widths on a "humman" scale.

monadINtop··on Getting the Lorentz transformations without requiring an invariant speed (2015)
Yes but this paper isn't isn't an island unto itself. It's a nice little lemma that can illustrate a point within the subject of special relativity, from a different perspective. It could be included as a small derivation in a textbook, or lecture notes, or even broken down as an exercise for the reader.

In my experience approaching the same idea from many different perspectives yields a deeper, richer understanding of the underlying concept, and offers a path for someone to reach the big picture understanding you mention.

monadINtop··on Room Temperature Superconductor Paper Retracted by Journal Nature
Nature - Quick to publish, slow to retract
monadINtop··on "I cannot wait to possess you": Reading 18th century letters for the first time
he was the first shitposter
monadINtop··on Is there anywhere in the world someone can just live for free?
>failed

How? There was no economic failure. It ended due to a political coup. After all there was the slight external complication of a proxy war considered by many to be a prelude to the defining conflict of the 20th century.

>never expanded

Apart from across an entire country you mean?

monadINtop··on "I cannot wait to possess you": Reading 18th century letters for the first time
>tended to use meme/gifs in place of what I'd consider "real" communication

You don't consider humour a form of real communication? Are you sure you should be looking down on them

monadINtop··on NewPipe – Lightweight YouTube experience for Android
Yeah that's fair, although having an ad-free version of YouTube that was completely synced with your account had lots of advantages compared totthe seperate mirror world you get with newpipe.

Overall I'm glad both of them exist(ed), and they both had different strengths and weaknesses.

monadINtop··on Sam Bankman-Fried is a feature, not a bug
I understand the point you're making, but the statement that

> they would have been unlikely to work on nuclear weapons development, and millions more would have likely perished in a land invasion of Japan

despite being constantly repeated, is not reflected by contemporary documents and later historical analysis of decision making among Pentagon and White House officials.

The threat of an impending land invasion was not a consideration at the time when it was decided to attack Japanese civilian centres with nuclear weapons. The primary factor in the decision for their use had far more to do with the risk of Stalin joining the fight on the eastern front and thus securing a claim for territory following the inevitable axis surrender, as well as a desire for US power projection from the demonstration of an atomic weapon in War. The primary delay in Japanese surrender was the question of the fate of Empreror Hirohito, who the US ended up protecting anyway.

monadINtop··on NewPipe – Lightweight YouTube experience for Android
It will never be as good as Youtube Vanced (god rest it's soul) but it gets the job done, despite the occasional bug
← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →