HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

monadINtop

145 karma · joined October 6, 2023

submissionscomments
monadINtop··on Is there anywhere in the world someone can just live for free?
What are you talking about? Private property refers to the ownership of the organs of economic production - factories, steal mills, whatever - by private institutions (e.g shareholder-managed organisations). If your referring to markets in general, they have existed since the dawn of urban human civilisation, thousands of years before capitalism. Markets can even exist in the most despotic communist dictatorship, or decentralized anarchist collective. Buying and selling goods or having personal property is largely orthogonal to the mode of production employed by a given society.

Right now in spain, the largest buisness group in basque (10th largest overall) is the Mondragon corporation. It’s worker-owned (but not worker managed), although each worker has voting rights. Clearly it is possible - even within capialism - to have some worker autonomy over production.

In 1936, during the civil war in Spain, around 60-75% of urban industry and agriculture was restructured by anarchist labour unions and run and managed by the workers to varying degrees of collectivization. Some towns abandoned the use of fiat currency entirely and instead used systems of vouchers, in small villages goods where distributed even more informally. Industrial production is reported to have increased during this time, and agricultural yields rose by around 30%.

monadINtop··on Is there anywhere in the world someone can just live for free?
>If we do have division of labor and pay each other for the work, we've reinvented capitalism.

This is extremely wrong. Every society in human history has some degree of division of labour. Capitalism is a specific economic mode of production that emerged from the embers of Feudalism a few hundred years ago, as merchant guilds and private manufacturors in urban centres gradually grew more independent whilst the noble classes who had subsisted off the labour of an agricultural underclass had gradually lost power. The exact process and reasons for this is extremely complicated and vast in scope.

There is also an unimaginably vast spectrum of potential ways of organising economic production in a human society, and many civilisations historically have exhibited different iterations of these. To make the claim that it is impossible to devise a system different from where

>we don't pay each other,[and] the incentives are very strong to be a free-rider

is not only to ignore not an entire field of historical and anthropolgical research, but also to not even bother to imagine any alternative to a very particular and unique economic system that we happen, by pure chance, to find ourselves in our infinitesimally narrow slice of time.

monadINtop··on I trapped scammers in an impossible maze [video]
Right, and I'd further argue that one of the most significant deciding factor in such cases is the relation of those former colonies to the hegemonic power (either in the region or globally).

For example places like Singapore and South Korea have had positive and close relations with the United States, both diplomatically and economically, and specifically in the case of South Korea, have been the recipient of an immense amout of US foreign aid in the context of the Cold War.

On the contrary, places like Cuba and North Korea who favoured political self-determination, and economic policies that focused on bolstering the local population over trade with the US, have very quickly turned into advesarial relationships. In both these cases they ended up aligning themselves with the alternate superpower. This uneasy situation proved tolerable for a few decades (for example, North Korea's economy actually recovered quicker - intitially - than South Korea after the Korean War despite sustaining far greater damage from the bombing campaign), but once the USSR collapsed, Cuba and North Korea entered into the sad state they are today being completely isolated, economically and politically.

And then there's also the issue of governance. Both South Korea and North Korea were brutal dictatorships for decades, but eventually South Korea liberalised their political system, whilst on the other hand North Korea is, well, North Korea. (The same is true, to some degree, of Cuba as well but I would like to qualify this by saying that the depiction of the despotism of Cuba's government in western media tends to be unfairly exaggerated - due to obvious reasons - compared to other regimes of similar or worse nature such as Saudi Arabia).

But this can't be soley due to a difference in ideology, since most of the countries the US supported during the 20th century where infamous for the brutality of the regimes (Park Chung-hee, Samoza, Noriega, House of Saud, Ferdinand Marcos, Pinochet, Papa Doc, Humberto de Alencar Castelo Branco and so on). Or even more covert campaigns of support and influence such as Operation Gladio in post-war Europe, the Free Albania National Comitee, Iran-Contra, et cetera.

However this is a far more controversial topic and it's not my intention to start an argument around politics and ideology. I simply want to make the point that the effectiveness/ineffectiveness of a given government has far more to do with historical and economic context than the merit of any particular policy or competency of a governing state. Of course this is still a very valid and important topic, just one that I feel is given undue weight relative to other factors.

All of this is of course a huge over simplification and doesn't do any of the numerous topics I've skimmed over any justice.

monadINtop··on Swedish Ports Threaten to Block Teslas from Entering the Country
In essentially every case outside of a rounding error, most people within a given company (or society) derive their income from selling their labour on the job market. This makes them workers, and thus they share a common material interest with each other. A very small minority of people in a company (and society) instead derive the primary portion of their income through the speculation of their capital. Their material interest is contrary to that of the workers, since they would profit from less stringent labour laws and cheaper wages, and vice versa.

Even if we consider pathalogical cases such as a blue-chip stock like TSLA that has become the focus of brief and anomalous phenomenon of retail trading, the magnitude of capital invested by retail traders into publicly traded companies is negligible, relative to the economic influence of traditional investors such as hedgefunds, and other whales in finance.

And even still, retail shareholders by definition engage in the economy primarily by selling their labour. That is how they generate the income required to put food on the table. Therefore they are still primarily workers and thus share the same material interest as other workers, as opposed to shareholders.

Therefore in every case we can say that the claim

>Tesla shareholders almost certainly outnumber its employees

is a misleading one, in this context.

monadINtop··on Swedish Ports Threaten to Block Teslas from Entering the Country
The only universal truths I know are in category theory, and maybe physics depending on your disposition. But that word has nothing to do with economics or the social sciences.

P.S. Is private capital included in your definition of "institutions"? Or is it only labour unions that, at least on paper, actually represent the interests of the majority of people (since most people are workers and not shareholders).

monadINtop··on Swedish Ports Threaten to Block Teslas from Entering the Country
What's your opinion?

For me this is pleasant news. It's a nice change to see workers and labour retain some ability to project their power, which in turn is in the interest of the vast majority of people.

Since the inception of modern private capital, labour disputes have always tended to be skewed towards corporate interests but it seems that this trend has been rapidly accelerating in recent decades.

monadINtop··on I trapped scammers in an impossible maze [video]
No worries man
monadINtop··on I trapped scammers in an impossible maze [video]
> I believe one of the worst outcomes of colonization is that these countries lost their monarchies and lacked a natural progression to diplomacy

I think this is a very loaded and fraught perspective that ignores a large amount of context.

Colonial powers generally co-opt local heirarchies and utilise the pre-existing state machinery to expediate the process of resource extraction and pacification since doing it from scratch is usually too costly and prone to instability. In many cases this may inflame pre-existing class confict and further entrench social division. It is rarely the case that pre-colonial power structures simply just vanish and are replaced by the colonial force, and furthermore they don't simply vanish post-colonisation leaving behind a template-less society.

Ex-colonies don't exist in a vacuum. Every society on the face of the earth is embedded in a complex global web of economic and political influence. Post-colonial nations can still be implicitly, and sometimes covertly, subjugated through asymmetric trade agreements, power projection, and a whole range of other processes. It is naive to assign blame of a corrupt or floundering region to a simple moral decay in an isolated system of people that just never figured out how to govern themselves. The answer is found when one instead considers the given region's place in the continuum of economic and historic processes that are far too complex to simplify into an narrative independent of context.

And finally, how does a monarchy naturally progress to "diplomacy"? To my knowledge there doesn't exists a single theory that can describe a universal archetype of a how a given human society is supposed to "naturally" develop. Even in western countries, the process of economic development from a feudal mode of production to the current capitalist parliamentary-democracy, is an extremely complicated and poorly understood topic that covers an area of research far larger than the scope any single historian or political theorist. Everything we see indicates that there is absolutely no fixed model of social development, especially not one that isn't contigent on an unimaginable number of nonlinear factors. I think it's reasonable to say that the development of any given society is completely unique to itself, and is the result of it's own unique position in relation to the outside world, and to history.

monadINtop··on Algebra
Yes people who follow the rules and do well in "school maths" are very likely to also do well and succeed in "higher mathematics".

Unfortunately, this selection misses (most?) children who may not be well suited to "school maths" - for whatever reason. But these children may succeed just as well in "higher mathematics".

Two anecdotes: (1) June Huh dropped out of high school and stagnated for 6 years in university. In his 6th year, he ran into the fields medal Heisuke Hironaka. It was only then his "slow thinking" and deep creative insight (perhaps the things that hindered him in "school maths" type courses?) proved to be fruitful in higher mathematics. June Huh now has a fields medal.

(https://www.quantamagazine.org/june-huh-high-school-dropout-...)

(2) I was frequently in trouble at school and underachieved relative to my predicted grades. I resented the route learning and arbitrariness of "school mathematics". Due to some miracle I'm currently working towards a PhD in theoretical physics, in the mathematics department of a top university, and I also spend about 90% of my free time working through various advanced maths textbooks for fun. Turns out I'm quite suited for thinking about higher mathematics, despite not being particularly well disposed for school. If my school experience was different, I probably would have done a PhD in pure mathematics instead.

← PreviousPage 4 of 4