HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

monerozcash

393 karma · joined September 23, 2025

submissionscomments
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
The big difference is that the oil in UAE is easy to extract and use, the oil in Venezuela isn't.
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
Their stated rationale also doesn't have to be their true rationale. For example, it's hard to believe that this is about oil rather than the headlines for Trump.
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
>Pretty sure given enough efforts could play for others as well.

Not really, given the investment involved in developing the necessary technology in the first place.

Only way this could make sense for any third country would be if it was strategic, but Venezuela is kind of poorly located for that.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
Big difference between helicopters in Caracas and fancy stealth aircraft over Iran.

You could shoot down a helicopter with a WW2 AA gun.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
US controls those supplies anyway because nobody else is going to develop the capabilities to profitably extract Venezuelan crude. Not Venezuela, certainly not China or Russia.
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
From what I understand from friends who still spend a lot of time in Donetsk because their businesses are there, you might be taken to a basement and shot if you say the wrong thing.

It's pretty bad, but sure, if you just go along with it you'll probably be fine.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
This is fundamentally incorrect. A dictator can oppress 90% of the people by just treating 10% of the population well, provided the 90% isn't allowed to heavily arm themselves anyway.
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
Trump says a lot of things which aren't remotely credible. WTI price is under $60 and going down. The last thing they need is more crude supply into the market lowering the benchmark price even lower.
monerozcash··on US captures Venezuelan leader, Trump says
The opposition has been very public in their lobbying for foreign intervention in Venezuela, this is basically what any kind of effective intervention would look like.

It seems more than reasonable to assume that they were in fact invited in.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
It's possible, but we'll probably never know. However, the WTI price is under $60 and going down. The last thing any big oil companies need is more crude supply into the market lowering the benchmark price even lower, especially particularly expensive (to extract) Venezuelan crude
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
Sure, and it's silly. There's very little oil in Venezuela that isn't too expensive to extract.
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
>Someone should tell Trump that because he’s not been remotely subtle about his thought process.

Maybe Trump just believes it'll be a good lie for his target demographic, because it certainly is a lie.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
China is moving away from oil at such a pace that any massive development of first the extraction technologies for Venezuela and then the actual infrastructure would probably take too long to be particularly useful.

Venezuela is also simply too far from China to be a reliable source of oil.

monerozcash··on US captures Venezuelan leader, Trump says
Hey, sure. I guess you could add EU states and most Latin American countries to that list too.

My point all along has been that in the end this probably depends entirely on who you believe about the elections.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
It's also rather telling that nobody in Caracas seems to have really tried to stop the US from doing this, it doesn't take all that much to shoot down at least one helicopter.

You'd expect them to have air defenses on high alert 24/7 prepared to immediately respond to any US actions.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
Well, while comparing Maduro and Hitler is a bit excessive, he has successfully driven out like 8 million people from Venezuela. That's something.
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
And if that doesn't work? You could, for example, envision a situation where 10% of the people are well treated and armed by the government. It'd be very hard for an unarmed ill-treated 90% to conduct any kind of uprising if the government was sufficiently well organized and brutal.
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
Which would happen anyway because only US companies are (maybe) capable of extracting Venezuelan crude at a profit.
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
I believe matters of international law are typically decided upon by a randomly selected panel of internet commenters.
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
I think you're misreading my original comment, I was merely stating that there will be no meaningful calls for Trump admin to justify themselves because they succeeded in pulling this off without making a mess.

>Step out of your American exceptionalist bubble for a second. How would you like if the inverse were true? There's some shady elections in US so Venezuela decides to throw bombs on Washington. How would you enjoy that?

I'm neither from the US, nor a huge fan of the US.

I do think Venezuela could probably have been right to depose Trump in a similar manner had he managed to cling to power after January 6, but that's an absurd thing to speculate about.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
I seriously doubt either China or Russia could manage to extract significant quantities of Venezuelan oil at a profit even if the US lifted all sanctions and completely forgot about Venezuela.

The costs of getting production set up at are so high compared to the relatively bleak outlook for the oil market, it's likely that Venezuelan oil isn't a hugely attractive proposition for anyone.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
No doubt, but I'm simply making the point that it doesn't make economic sense for US to go after Venezuelan oil.
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
> Which is why if you are going to overrule the laws of another nation, you should have at least some backing from the UN first. Deciding on your own that the the courts are wrong is just international vigilantism.

On the other hand, if much of the world agrees with you anyway, not bothering with asking the UN might not matter at all.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
I mean the real answer to "why" is probably going to be pretty boring considering the nature of this administration.

That's not to say that the steelmanned "why" isn't much more interesting than the real "why".

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
It's really a shame topics like this attract such lazy ideological struggle on HN. Reiterating Trump=bad over and over simply doesn't make for interesting conversation regardless of how true it may be.

Even on this particular story, there are so many interesting HN-worthy details to discuss. Instead we're stuck lazily debating whether this was right or wrong.

You can find higher-quality, much more aggressively moderated conversations on topics like this on r/CredibleDefense. However, even that subreddit struggles with the traffic from high-profile events like this.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
That's not setting any kind of precedent at all.
monerozcash··on US captures Venezuelan leader, Trump says
> Any judgement on legitimacy is reserved to the Venezuelan people

The whole point is that the Venezuelan people have supposedly voted for Edmundo González and not Maduro.

monerozcash··on US captures Venezuelan leader, Trump says
What part of that do you think requires evidence? The US has been very public about who they consider to have won the previous elections, and the opposition has been very public in their lobbying for foreign intervention in Venezuela.
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
>The rightfully elected leader of a nation can't call for a second nation to invade and bomb their nation.

Why not?

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
> If there is a need and money to be made they will find someone with the tech or deep enough pockets to develop it

There's no need and there's likely to be no money to be made. The extraction costs will probably be closer to $60 per barrel, which is more than you can sell it for.

← PreviousPage 2 of 14Next →