HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

monerozcash

393 karma · joined September 23, 2025

submissionscomments
monerozcash··on US captures Venezuelan leader, Trump says
I don't think I've stated anything that requires evidence, but please feel free to be more specific.
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
Whether or not the US action here was "unilateral" depends entirely on how one views the electoral fraud claims.
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
The only comparable large-scale extraction projects in the world would be the oil sands in Canada.

This is a super small niche, with oil margins constantly getting squeezed around the world it'd probably be tricky to convince anyone to significantly scale up production in Venezuela even if the US lifted all sanctions and whatnot.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
Ah, but then who can?

I think my assumption that the legitimacy of a government rests in the eye of the beholder is pretty reasonable.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
I haven't seen any reporting suggesting that they continued bombing after they grabbed Maduro
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
This is especially silly because the US is always going to control oil extraction in Venezuela because nobody else has the technical capabilities required to do so profitably at a large scale.

There's no need to really fight with the Venezuelan government over this, unless Venezuela decided that they'd rather leave the oil in the ground.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
There's not loads of idle refinery capability just waiting for more Venezuelan crude in the US.
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
Yeah, literally nobody but the US could possibly profitably extract Venezuelan oil at any meaningful scale.
monerozcash··on US captures Venezuelan leader, Trump says
Yeah, basically. The rest of the world, of course, gets to assess those claims on an individual basis.
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
I think you're stretching a bit, I'm simply proposing they have a pretty good case here because much of the world openly agrees with the US claim that Maduro did not actually win the previous elections.

>In this case the actual motivations have been stated publicly by Trump a few years ago, they want the oil back. They will happily support whoever ends up in power so long as they hand back the oil rights.

That's obviously not credible, you can't profitably extract Venezuelan crude without US involvement. There's simply nobody else with the capabilities to do so. Venezuelan oil is particularly difficult to get out of the ground, it's tremendously difficult to extract profitably.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
>Were they? And is that the justification the US has cited? If not, you're writing fan fiction and that's not really interesting.

This is all necessarily speculative, we might never have sufficient visibility to know all the facts.

I'm merely attempting to provide the strongest reply the administration could provide if they cared to try. I believe it's reasonably grounded in facts.

1. US government openly does not recognize Maduro as the legitimate head of state of Venezuela

2. US government does recognize Edmundo González Urrutia as the president-elect.

3. Venezuelan opposition has been heavily lobbying in an effort to get foreign governments to intervene in Venezuela

All of these things are verifiable facts, I think they can be distilled into my perfectly reasonable suggestion as to how the US could fend off such criticism.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
It's only unilateral if you reject the electoral fraud claims.

>And if you think this intervention is about protecting democracy I have a bridge to sell you.

No, I certainly don't think that. I'd suspect it's mostly about personal grievances and Trumps desire to make a show. But still I think it makes more sense to focus on the best-case justifications than trying to guess at the real reasons behind why this administration does what it does.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
Depends on the point of view. I certainly agree that there are many very good reasons to see this as bad, but I don't think that concerns about Venezuela's national sovereignty rank very highly on that list.

From the perspective that regime change often goes horribly wrong? Absolutely.

From the point of view that Maduro was effectively in charge of a coup that the real elected candidates were desperately seeking foreign support to stop? Harder to see the intervention as bad, as it is probably the only way to rectify the situation.

There's no doubt that this heavily depends on one's personal views, so there's no obvious answers. At least the concern about regime change is fact-based and pretty much universal, regardless of personal beliefs. The concern about whether or not it's right or wrong for the US to go and arrest Maduro depends largely on how one views the recent Venezuelan election results, and therefore inherently relies on some major assumptions on matters where we're unlikely to ever see conclusive proof.

Of course, there are also pretty good technical reasons to believe the electoral receipts published by the Venezuelan opposition. I believe they would have been pretty much impossible to fake. That topic and others related to it have been pretty much endlessly discussed on HN already: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41123155

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
Yeah, probably not. I'd also imagine that the significant show of force by the US would have forced many in the military to assess their options, even if they might otherwise have supported Maduro.
monerozcash··on US captures Venezuelan leader, Trump says
No, I don't think anyone seriously doubts whether or not Trump actually won the elections after which he was appointed president.

The same however is not true of Maduro, where "Maduro did not actually get sufficient votes to win the latest election" is a pretty commonly held view backed by evidence. You might reasonably doubt the veracity of that evidence, but directly comparing Maduro's position with that of Trump is simply ridiculous.

monerozcash··on US captures Venezuelan leader, Trump says
I think it's not an unreasonable assumption to start from that the US government is working in collusion with the opposition it openly backs in Venezuela? It also feels silly to imagine that Venezuelan opposition was really hoping anything other than this while openly courting US support.

Also, to be fair, the comment I was responding to earlier referred to the Venezuelan opposition as a US puppet. I think that effectively concedes this point anyway.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
I like how we went from "international law" to "noble goals", I suppose that's pretty on point :)

> Also, shouldn't he then be doing this in many other places in the world?

No, I don't see how that would follow. I can choose to give money to a charity, but that does not mean I have to choose to give my money to all the charities in the world.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
What if he was the leader of a brutal coup and the legitimately elected government requested foreign help to have him removed?

It's really really difficult to paint this as inherently bad, it's hard to see how the conclusion here doesn't entirely depend on how you feel about the results of the previous Venezuelan elections.

monerozcash··on US captures Venezuelan leader, Trump says
>It doesn't matter what Americans consider to be the representatives of the legitimate government.

Really? I thought the US just arrested Maduro. To me, that seems like something that would matter.

>Maduro was the legitimate government, American wishful thinking is just another affront to Venezuelan sovereignty.

Can you actually try to explain why? Can you explain why a reasonable person looking at this from the outside should arrive at the conclusion that "Maduro was the legitimate government"?

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
Your question rests on the assumption that Maduro is the legitimate leader of Venezuela, that's a huge assumption.
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
Sure, yeah, but you'll just give yourself a headache trying to keep track of all the ridiculous things this admin puts out.

The reality is that there a lot of people across the political divide at very high levels of government who deeply dislike Maduro for a variety of reasons, some perhaps more pure-hearted than others.

Oil and drugs are obviously not even how they're justifying this to themselves. The oil in Venezuela isn't that interesting because it's really only US and some Canadian oil companies that are capable of extracting it. The US is always going to control oil production in Venezuela, no matter what.

But yeah, instead of focusing on all the silly statements the admin puts out you might as well just guess at the eventual steelmanned argument they'll present in writing at a later date.

monerozcash··on US captures Venezuelan leader, Trump says
Why would it be invading the country if they were invited in by what they consider to be representatives of the legitimate government?

I think to begin with you'll have to actually present the argument as to why Maduro should be considered the legitimate leader of Venezuela.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
> we just straight up kidnap a foreign head of state

Head of state according to whom?

>Is the goal now to just put Maduro through a televised sham trial as a new cover for the Trump admin?

Would they really need a sham trial?

monerozcash··on US captures Venezuelan leader, Trump says
Why would it be illegal? Or disgusting? Presumably US actions are backed by the people they consider to be legitimately elected representatives of Venezuelan government, and if so amount to little more than assistance in local law enforcement.
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
I'd suggest twz, they'll have much better informed takes than wikipedia https://www.twz.com/news-features/explosions-ring-out-across...
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
I certainly don't doubt the competence of the US army, but the fact that they spent only minutes on active SEAD bombing raids to enable this operation suggests that it wasn't just cool tech or super competent SOF operators that truly enabled this operation.
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
The obviously reply to that would be "The US forces were invited by the democratically elected Venezuelan leadership to put a stop to the ongoing coup"

The concept of "international law" here is pretty confusing because to begin with you'd need to choose who decides what counts as a violation of Venezuelas sovereignty. Presumably the people backed by the US are okay with this, and team Maduro isn't.

Presumably, if you were to agree that Maduro wasn't in fact the legitimate leader of Venezuela, you'd just consider this an internal issue with US helping in local law enforcement matters.

If you disagree and consider Maduro to be the legitimate president, presumably no amount of justification will help you see it differently. But then, I'm not sure anyone particularly cares about your opinion either.

monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
I mean, do they really need to justify it any further? They just arrested Maduro while causing very little collateral damage, if they'd failed dramatically then they'd have much more questions to answer.
monerozcash··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
Maduro arrested https://truthsocial.com/@realDonaldTrump/posts/1158304287678...

Considering the general incompetence of this administration, this level of success with such a surgical operation seems completely out of character.

Incredibly impressive operation, whether or not you agree with it. Although the ability to operate helos over Caracas with such impunity may very well suggest high-level collaborators in the local military.

monerozcash··on Finland detains ship and its crew after critical undersea cable damaged
The stated Russian doctrine doesn't really explicitly call for a nuclear response to a naval conflict in the gulf of Finland.
← PreviousPage 3 of 14Next →