HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

monk_the_dog

253 karma · joined October 3, 2009

I love working on computer vision problems. email: monk (dot) scott (at) google's mail.
submissionscomments
monk_the_dog··on What happens when you ask people to pick the lowest unique prime number.
Yes, this is how it's played. It really is a fun little game, especially if you and your opponent are the type of people who over-think things. Try it sometime!
monk_the_dog··on What happens when you ask people to pick the lowest unique prime number.
This reminds me of the game "clomp" (which I may or may not have invented+) but I used to play with my brother on car rides. Here are the rules:

1) Pick any integer. Your partner picks an integer without knowing yours. The first person to think of a number says "clomp". They are locked in. The other person can say their number any time after "clomp". Honor system. No cheating.

2) If your number is less then your opponent, but not one less, then add your number to your score.

3) If your number is one more than your opponent, then add your number and your opponents number together and add it to your score.

4) Otherwise no score.

5) First to 21 or more wins.

+I may have stolen this from Martin Gardner, I honestly don't remember if I came up with it or I read it. My brother came up with the name "clomp".

monk_the_dog··on The codebreaker who saved 'millions of lives'
I recently learned about Tommy Flowers and Colossus from this book: http://www.amazon.com/Colossus-secrets-Bletchley-code-breaki... The British kept Colossus secret for a too long and Flowers did not get enough credit (and von Neumann seems to get too much). BTW, I do recommend the above book. But we warned that it's a collection of essays by different authors so it can be uneven reading.
monk_the_dog··on VimOrganizer : An Emacs' Org-mode clone for Vim
Everything I want is there: text objects, visual mode, windows commands, macros, everything from ex that I use. Try it, you'll be pleasantly surprised.

The only two issues I've noticed are:

1) '\c' does not work for case insensitive search 2) I had to install an extra packages to get 'g;' (goto-last-change) and 'C-r' (redo) to work.

monk_the_dog··on VimOrganizer : An Emacs' Org-mode clone for Vim
Yes. Babel requires emacs. Quote from the article:

<quote> VimOrganizer also lets Vim users access Org-babel, a subproject of Org-mode that allows execution of source-code blocks in org-format documents. Uses for Org-babel range from writing technical research papers to simply using a VimOrganizer document as a "language-scratchpad". Over twenty languages are supported, including C, R, Lisp, Python, Perl, Ruby, and others. VimOrganizer calls out to a running Emacs server for Org-babel processing; functionality and speed are essentially the same as when editing with Org-mode in Emacs. </quote>

BTW, I love both org-mode and vim. My solution is to use a vim mode in emacs. My preferred one is "evil" (I recently switched from viper+vimpulse, which is also good). Evil lives here: http://gitorious.org/evil/pages/Home

monk_the_dog··on RIP Jim Gray - Closure in Disappearance of Computer Scientist
There's an inspiring article in The Communications of the AMC on the group of people who came together to help search for Jim Gray when he disappeared: http://cacm.acm.org/magazines/2011/7/109892-searching-for-ji...
monk_the_dog··on Fez soundtrack contains hidden data
I saw "Indie Game The Movie" last night (http://www.indiegamethemovie.com/). They followed the ups and downs of developing fez and super meat boy (and some braid).

If you're racing to develop something before you run out of money, take a break and go see this movie. You'll love it.

monk_the_dog··on Show HN: Microryza, crowdfunding research AND sharing results
I'm not asking for anonymous giving. I'm asking that my user name appears on the backers page instead of my full name.

It doesn't bother me that the project (or the site) knows my real name. However, I feel better if future employers of mine don't know about my love of hot chilis :-)

monk_the_dog··on Show HN: Microryza, crowdfunding research AND sharing results
Yeah! All I'm really looking for is for the person to acknowledge my donation.

BTW, I did just donate a small amount to the chili project. One more piece of feedback. My real name shows up on the donation page. Not a big deal, but I'd prefer if my user name appeared there instead. I'd like to remain semi-anonymous.

monk_the_dog··on Show HN: Microryza, crowdfunding research AND sharing results
I know it's irrational, but I want something in return for donating. For example, I'd give $20 or so to the hot chili project if he'd send me $2 worth of "something really hot" to me. Somehow getting something in return makes me feel more connected to the project.

Love the idea. Hope it catches on.

monk_the_dog··on Vi and Vim vs. Emacs Shootout and Deal
I use emacs with viper and vimpulse (http://www.emacswiki.org/emacs-es/vimpulse.el) and I'm very happy. This setup does support text objects.

I have not used evil, so I'm not sure how vimpulse compares with evil.

monk_the_dog··on Online graduate-level machine learning course from CMU's Tom Mitchell
Once upon a time I thought about using ml/vision in slot machines. I would try to read the gamblers emotions/age/sex and the slot machine would change stimulation (music/lights etc; not mess with the odds) to try to keep them at the machine longer.

I thought it was a good idea until I actually visited a casino. People sit at the slots in what looks like a hypnotic state. The emotions don't change much. I don't think I could have made a measurable difference.

I'm not surprised the gambling industry is using ml, but cool to hear about it. Thanks.

monk_the_dog··on Online graduate-level machine learning course from CMU's Tom Mitchell
Zeratul, you're obviously into ML. Would you mind if I asked what your application is? I'm just curious.

I work in computer vision. When I do a machine learning problem, I spend most of my time brainstorming and implementing good features. I'm getting deeper into ML (and loving it). I'm always curious what other people are doing with ML.

monk_the_dog··on Online graduate-level machine learning course from CMU's Tom Mitchell
I just took a quick look on the chapter on clustering. Looks good! I'll put it on the ever growing stack. Thanks!
monk_the_dog··on Online graduate-level machine learning course from CMU's Tom Mitchell
You make a good point. Ensemble methods seem to outperform single classifiers. There's no reason you can't have an ensemble of SVMs. The paper should have included something other than an ensemble of trees.

I tried to find a paper comparing an ensemble of SVM to an ensemble of trees and I came up empty (after a quick search). I did find papers showing ensembles of SVMs outperforming a single SVM. I also found a comment on a paper claiming an ensemble of trees out outperformed a "Parallel Mixture of SVM" (see here: http://www.mitpressjournals.org/doi/abs/10.1162/089976604323...). Of course, that's not a great source.

I absolutely agree they should have included ensembles other than trees. I don't necessarily agree an ensemble of SVM would have beat an ensemble of trees. It would have been interesting to see.

monk_the_dog··on Online graduate-level machine learning course from CMU's Tom Mitchell
I'm enrolled in the online Applied ML class from Stanford, and I've also been watching this course from CMU (I'm up to the Graphical Model 4 lecture - almost the midterm). If you've taken at least one stats class you'll get much more out of CMU's class.

BTW, here are some good online resources for machine learning:

* The Elements of Statistical Learning (free pdf book): http://www-stat.stanford.edu/~tibs/ElemStatLearn/

* Information Theory, Inference, and Learning Algorithms (free pdf book): http://www.inference.phy.cam.ac.uk/mackay/itila/

* Videos from Autumn School 2006: Machine Learning over Text and Images: http://videolectures.net/mlas06_pittsburgh/

* Bonus link. An Empirical Comparison of Supervised Learning Algorithms (pdf paper): http://www.cs.cornell.edu/~caruana/ctp/ct.papers/caruana.icm... (Note the top 3 are tree ensembles, then SVM, ANN, KNN. Yes, I know there is no 'best' classifier.)

monk_the_dog··on Andrew Ng's Classroom Lectures for ML
Here's two other sets of lectures that I'm really enjoying:

1) CMU graduate-level machine learning class: http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~tom/10701_sp11/lectures.shtml

2) Mathematicalmonk's machine learning lectures: http://www.youtube.com/user/mathematicalmonk?blend=7&ob=...

monk_the_dog··on Curta calculator - hand-held, mechanical arithmetic
I first read about the Curta in a Scientific American article by Cliff Stole (see scans here: http://www.leighbureau.com/speakers/CStoll/essays/Calculator... )

I am awed and inspired by this story. It helps me understand why people think a work of art is worth more if there is a story behind it. I'd love one as art for my desk (if they weren't so expensive).

monk_the_dog··on PyCon 2012
I went to SciPy this year for the first time, and I loved it. I understand that PyCon is a much broader conference, but do many people interested in scientific python show up for this?
monk_the_dog··on A Roadmap for Rich Scientific Data Structures in Python
I was happy to see "Hierarchical columns" on the features wish list. My app uses a R data frame like structure (table of heterogeneous columns with possible missing data). One "cute" thing I implemented was hierarchical columns. Super useful for what I'm doing, but hard to expose to other languages. The plan is to flatten the columns to 'parent.child' strings when using python.

I'm not quite at the point where I'll be wrapping this into python. When I do I'll take a close look at pandas. Any other recommendations? I took a quick look at pytables, and pandas looks better for my app.

monk_the_dog··on Things You Could Buy for $4B Instead of LinkedIn
Are you thinking of this article: http://www.nytimes.com/2001/02/25/magazine/jonathan-lebed-s-...

Good read for sure.

monk_the_dog··on Wall Street's Cult Calculator Turns 30
Here's a quick timeline of what I've used for calculators:

HP 28C (http://www.voidware.com/calcs/hp28c.htm): Mid 80's through mid 90's

Emacs calc mode: Mid 90's through mid 2000's

orpie (http://pessimization.com/software/orpie/): Mid 2000's through present

If you're an old HP calculator user go check out orpie. It's an RPN calculator for the console. It doesn't appear to be actively developed. Still, it has already got everything I want in a calculator and works very, very well.

monk_the_dog··on The Definitive C++ Book Guide and List
When I was learning C++ I subscribed to a great magazine called the "C++ Report". I first read about expression templates and template meta-programming in that magazine (Todd Veldhuizen's articles on Blitz). I blew my mind that people could use templates that way. Too bad it took many years to get my hands on a compiler that could actually handle templates well enough to use those techniques :-)

I'm not necessarily recommending reading those articles today - they are pretty dated. Still, it was wonderful to read about the techniques as they developed.

monk_the_dog··on The most iconic scientific images
Fair enough. Maybe Henry Petroski instilled a little too much engineering pride in me: http://spectrum.ieee.org/at-work/tech-careers/engineering-is...

Sorry if I was being a pedantic jerk.

BTW, I have these two images hanging in my office. Both are scientists discussing science. Love them.

http://ysfine.com/maga/feydirac.jpg

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/f4/Niels_Boh...

monk_the_dog··on The most iconic scientific images
Engineering and science are not the same thing. The astronaut's footprint, earthrise, and atomic bomb are all examples of feats of engineering, not science.
monk_the_dog··on Do It Yourself Masters in Financial Engineering
Nice list.

One quibble: I'd put Steve Blank's "Four Steps" under Entrepreneurship rather than "Value Creation and Design". I've read Four Steps, Universal Principals of Design, and Design of Everyday things (I have not read Rework, the other book in the category). Four Steps really covers much different material than the other other two books.

monk_the_dog··on Richard Feynman and The Connection Machine
Here's another favorite story from thinking machines: The Rise and Fall of Thinking Machines

http://www.inc.com/magazine/19950915/2622.html

For what it's worth, last I heard Sheryl Handler was running Ab Initio. I wonder if she's really the nutcase the article makes her out to be.

monk_the_dog··on Ask HN: Why is -2^2 = -4 instead of 4?
I don't know wolfram alpha, just thought I'd point out something interesting: if ^ is the xor operator, then -2^2==(11111110)xor(00000010)==(11111100)==-4
monk_the_dog··on Graphical Vim Cheatsheet
If you use emacs/viper, I recommend vimpulse: http://www.emacswiki.org/emacs-es/Vimpulse

This gives you text objects - and they are fantastically useful. It also gives you the saner window functions of 'C-w hjkl'

monk_the_dog··on The Four Steps to the Epiphany
I love his definition of a startup: "startups are a temporary organization designed to search for a scalable and repeatable business model.". Solid, concrete advice in this book - advice you can disagree with, not just apple pie advice.

Compare "Four Steps" to "do more faster", another highly recommended startup book.

First, both books have off-putting titles. I'm much more likely to buy a book called "The Customer Development Model" than anything that sounds like it's marketed to the naive or flaky: "epiphany?", "do more faster?". Can we please stay pragmatic and grounded?

Apart from that, the books are worlds apart. "Four Steps" is pragmatic and grounded. The "do more faster" book starts with an essay by Tim Ferriss, the author of "The 4-hour workweek."

As long as we're talking about Steve Blank, here's a couple of other books that I've read and liked because of things I've read on his blog/book:

* Business Model Generation, by Osterwalder & Pigneur

* Crystal Fire, by Riordan & Hoddeson

* A Radar History of World War II, by Brown

The last two book because of his "secret history of silicon valley" posts.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →