HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

moorhosj

1,065 karma · joined May 26, 2014

submissionscomments
moorhosj··on Chicago, where rich live 30 years longer than the poor
Half the state’s population lives in the Chicago suburbs, not the city. Most of the wealth is in the suburbs.
moorhosj··on Chicago, where rich live 30 years longer than the poor
Except that you are doing the same cherry picking that you accuse others of. I showed data from 2010 to 2017 to illustrate how significant the demographic change has been. For some reason, you decided to go back to 1980 to make a counter-point. Our definitions haven’t changed since 2010, so I’m not sure that’s a valid point.

To the rest of your point, test we should compare these things across cities, that is how we see the disparities. That point is more relevant to the original article and not the specific point I was responding to.

moorhosj··on Chicago, where rich live 30 years longer than the poor
I think you effectively described every American city. Even Dallas, the example of a well-run city provided, had a pension bubble that almost burst into insolvency in 2017.

==https://interactives.dallasnews.com/2017/the-85th/issue/pens...

moorhosj··on Chicago, where rich live 30 years longer than the poor
According to Census ACS from 2017, the city went from 35% Black in 2010 to 30.5% in 2017. That is a pretty rapid shift in under s decade. Hard numbers fell from 930k to 830k.

Most of the population loss is concentrated in the poorest neighborhoods. There are also plenty of South Side neighborhoods that are doing quite well (Hyde Park, Beverly, Mt Greenwood, Kenwood, Woodlawn, McKinley Park, Chinatown, Pilsen, Bridgeport, Garfield Ridge, and a few more). Those places don’t get the news coverage so everyone lumps an entire 1/3 of the city into “dump”.

==https://factfinder.census.gov/faces/tableservices/jsf/pages/...

moorhosj··on Chicago, where rich live 30 years longer than the poor
As someone who lives in Chicago, I would caution against taking the claims in this post as face value. This specific point is not true:

>3) Without adequate funding, crime has skyrocketed as the city continues to crumble, unable to provide basic services. This hits the poor disproportionately.

The demographics of the city are changing rapidly, anyone who lived here “years ago” and thinks they know about living here today is working with old data.

moorhosj··on America has never gone this long without hiking the federal minimum wage
Again, these things are already happening. Hurting today's minimum wage workers in order to save these industries from something they are already doing seems like a fool's errand. The minimum wage hasn't changed in a decade and the math is already making sense. What's the point in waiting longer?
moorhosj··on America has never gone this long without hiking the federal minimum wage
A nitpick, but the old-man paying someone to mow his lawn is not subject to Fair Labor Standards Act [1]. Specifically: "The FLSA only applies if you pay your employee more than $1,900 in a single year or works more than eight hours a week."

On your broader point, I'm not sure that those are viable "jobs" if they can't be done for ever $7.25/hr. What are the jobs going undone today because they are only worth $7.24/hr? Why isn't anyone wringing their hands over that injustice?

The real question is, what would the impact be. Isn't it possible that raising the minimum wage lifts more people out of poverty than it pushes into poverty through joblessness? If yes, it is likely worth trying.

[1] https://blogs.findlaw.com/law_and_life/2015/06/hire-a-kid-to...

edit: had the minimum wage wrong.

moorhosj··on America has never gone this long without hiking the federal minimum wage
Are we worried that raising the minimum wage will cause companies to do a thing they are already doing?
moorhosj··on FBI agent accidentally reveals own 8chan posts
There are court documents in the Papdopoulus, Manafort, Gates, Cohen, Stone and Flynn cases. Have you read the court filings to see the evidence? How much of the Mueller Report have you read?

==I need to see something convincing, that preferably consists of something more than colorful stories based on "confidential" evidence (that I have no idea is faked or misinterpreted, both of which have been done before).==

Again, this justification could be used to back up any belief when it comes to government. It is a convenient way to brush off all the lying, obstruction, indictments and convictions as some mere conspiracy. Blanket cynicism (and whataboutism) isn't a valid replacement for actual analysis. That we have hacked other countries doesn't change the facts of what Trump and his campaign did. They are entirely different cases that can be discussed on their own.

==Is Trump better? Who knows, but anything I've seen suggests the alternative is a never ending line of groomed Neoliberal clones who act as well-spoken PR managers, while behind the scenes the US military and TLA's do as they please.==

Odd that you say this as we are sending more soldiers to the Middle East [1]. What about the 1,000 soldiers and military activities happening in Niger under his leadership [2]? The bombings (often of civilians) in Yemen [3]? Attacking a Syrian airfield [4]? Did you see hard evidence that Iran bombed the oil tanker [5]?

In making these decisions, Trump is using the same intelligence community that you and he both say is corrupt and untrustworthy [6]. It makes it appear that he only wants to discredit them when it affects him (Russia investigation) personally.

None of this even gets into the obstruction of justice, felonies related to campaign finance, numerous campaign officials in prison or under indictment, or taking Putin's side over our own intelligence agencies in Helsinki. This gives us a view into the type of person Trump is and the company he keeps. You have decided to support that, which is your choice. I don't agree with your attempts to blame it on Democrats, the media or the intelligence committee. Just own it.

[1] https://www.cnn.com/2019/06/17/politics/us-additional-troops...

[2] https://www.thedailybeast.com/senators-are-stunned-to-discov...

[3] https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/12/27/world/middlee...

[4] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/06/world/middleeast/us-said-...

[5] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6DU6kCyqDOM

[6] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-44852812

moorhosj··on FBI agent accidentally reveals own 8chan posts
American media runs the ideological spectrum (Mother Jones to The Atlantic to National Review to Fox News). They aren’t a unified voice, so that representation would include contradicting messages.

It seems like people just choose the one that helps their strawman and labels that as “AMERICA”.

moorhosj··on FBI agent accidentally reveals own 8chan posts
Does Time magazine represent America in this comment?
moorhosj··on US efforts to jail Assange for espionage are a grave threat to a free media
==Three years ago the right loathed him, today they love him and conversely today the left loathes him but 3 years ago they loved him.==

Not necessarily true according to this poll [1]. The alt-right might love him, but rank-and-file Republicans don't seem to:

"A new YouGov poll of 2,455 Americans shows that a majority (53%) say Assange should be extradited to America. That majority increases among both Republicans (59% supporting extradition) and Democrats (62% supporting extradition), but decreases to a plurality (46%) among Independents."

[1] https://today.yougov.com/topics/politics/articles-reports/20...

moorhosj··on NYT promotes questionable study on Google and the media
I’m not sure drugs are that perfect of a market. The buyer doesn’t really have visibility into price/quality across sellers and drug buyers are not always rational, two conditions for perfect competition.[1]

Actual economics is far more complex than the simple supply/demand curve taught in 101 classes.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_competition

moorhosj··on NYT promotes questionable study on Google and the media
What’s the basis for this claim? Where do Ross Douthat and David Brooks fit in your model?
moorhosj··on How Did WeWork’s Adam Neumann Build a $47B Company?
==Take stodgy, often scammy, and downright consumer unfriendly industries, add transparency and accessibility to them, and viola - you have a unicorn.==

And, maybe some day, actual profits.

moorhosj··on The decline of the family has unleashed an epidemic of loneliness
Sure, except that’s not always how reality works. My mom and my mother-in-law were both stay at home mothers who got divorced. They have few employment options in the private sector after 20 years of raising children. Turns out the market doesn’t pay much for those skills. Now we have to help support them.
moorhosj··on The decline of the family has unleashed an epidemic of loneliness
This is how it traditionally works. My mom and my wife’s mom would also agree.
moorhosj··on The decline of the family has unleashed an epidemic of loneliness
==I have heard a number of friends say this, though almost always indirectly.==

Is it possible you are inferring it a certain way because of your bias? For instance, I complain about having kid all the time, but I wouldn't give him up for anything.

==There is a real stigma associated with being unhappy with parenthood, but many people do not seem to enjoy the process.==

This is something only a non-parent would say. Nobody enjoys the sleepless nights, dirty diapers or unexplained whining, but those are part of the same process that leads from laughing, to crawling, to walking, to speaking, to reasoning.

==From my own observations, eventually most parents adjust their own personal "bar" for happiness and more or less accept their lot. I'm sure they get something positive out of it, but it seems to be a tradeoff for other sources of happiness and life satisfaction which usually become unavailable to parents.==

Your wording implies that you have never actually asked a parent if they get anything out of it, but just make an assumption to fit your mental model. Everything in life is a trade-off, that isn't the same as wishing you didn't do something.

moorhosj··on The decline of the family has unleashed an epidemic of loneliness
==If you are gushing about your kids no one is going to open up about a taboo subject like that.==

This is true. Likewise, if you are explaining all the reasons you can't or don't want to have kids someone may be more likely to agree by saying "I wish I didn't have kids."

I don't disagree with what you have said, just know that taking care of your siblings is not the same as being the parent of a child (legally, emotionally, physically, etc.). When you compare them, it detracts from the broader point you have made.

moorhosj··on The decline of the family has unleashed an epidemic of loneliness
I find the HN comments on an article like this fascinating. So many people that admit to not having kids who think they are experts on what it means or is like to have kids.
moorhosj··on The decline of the family has unleashed an epidemic of loneliness
==I took care of my brother and sisters a lot as a child and it made it very clear that I never wanted children.==

Being a parent is not the same as taking care of your siblings. Using the experience of one to justify your decisions in another is short-sighted.

How many parents have you ever heard say, "I wish I didn't have kids"?

moorhosj··on Why aren’t more companies remote-first?
I’ve never run into a colleague from another department on an email chain. It happens frequently in our office kitchen. I don’t that that, or the ability to simply walk over to someone’s desk should be discounted.
moorhosj··on Why aren’t more companies remote-first?
What percentage of those remote work setups are “ideal”?
moorhosj··on The Future of Food Delivery [slides]
==Might it be better understood as a discussion explicitly about social rituals, oral traditions, and uniting humans across generations?==

This is a good point and you are likely correct. I think I was internalizing some things I've read recently on HN that haven't sat well.

moorhosj··on The Future of Food Delivery [slides]
I think you are missing my point. At it's core, food is simply fuel for the human body. In practice, it is a common thread that unites different cultures and generations. I am suggesting that we should examine why food plays such an outsized role in our cultures. Is it a part of our social nature, oral traditions, basic necessities, etc.? Is it something that can be "disrupted" like e-commerce or some other man-made industry?
moorhosj··on The Future of Food Delivery [slides]
Isn't food the underpinning of most cultural traditions? It seems to me like society (as defined by generations of civilization) has already determined that food has value for it's experience and community aspects. Maybe it's more than just an "HN class of people" thing and you could examine your own perspective?

[1] The cultural significance of food and eating - https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/c...

[2] How Food Shaped Humanity - https://www.smithsonianmag.com/arts-culture/how-food-shaped-...

[3] Understanding Culture: Food as a Means of Communication - https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&c...

moorhosj··on The Thirty-Hour Week (1936)
But everyone that I talk to is "slammed". It's interesting how the perception of working more hours is so powerful.
moorhosj··on Buyer's Remorse: High Debt and Low Pay Leave Some College Grads Rueful
Only you are comparing the two. Both engineering and humanities can involve critical thinking.
moorhosj··on Abuses show Assange case was never about law
Now you have developed your own conspiracy to prove how wrong other people’s conspiracy was. Do you see the irony?

Why did Assange defend Putin after the Panama Papers? I thought he loved transparency. When did Assange start his RT show, funded by the Russian state?

moorhosj··on Buyer's Remorse: High Debt and Low Pay Leave Some College Grads Rueful
Trades, medicine and engineering are the only viable careers for tough or smart people? Now we have moved beyond "humanities are a waste of time" to having no need for finance, accounting, marketing, legal, economics or architecture.
← PreviousPage 2 of 19Next →