HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

morningseagulls

95 karma · joined August 30, 2019

submissionscomments
morningseagulls··on Deep Learning with PyTorch: A 60 Minute Blitz [video]
>Do you write your own crypto libraries too?

Some people do. It's a good challenge.[0]

[0] https://cryptopals.com/

morningseagulls··on Deep Learning with PyTorch: A 60 Minute Blitz [video]
>Not all of us need to build their own ML algos. Just in the same way that not all of us need to build their sorting libraries or data structures.

And yet they love to ask you to do exactly that at technical interviews... coming up next: what ML algos you need to know to ace that interview.

morningseagulls··on A Code Glitch May Have Caused Errors in More Than a Hundred Published Studies
>My favorite is around 1:04:00 when someone asks a second time why he disprefers coq, and Buzzard complains that it can't represent some advanced quotient type that he'd have to work around. I'm reminded of [1]

>[1] https://prog21.dadgum.com/160.html Dangling by a trivial feature

Second what abstractcontrol said.[0] I wouldn't say being able to deal with quotient types is a "trivial" feature, because Buzzard does explain his reason for why quotient types are crucial for what he does.

The motivation is that he wants to formalise a concept that is the subject of current active research, instead of yet another concept from undergraduate mathematics. In this case, it's the notion of perfectoid spaces,[1] which was only introduced in 2012 by Peter Scholze.[2]

The justification for this is sociological: research mathematicians predominantly find the retreading of old ground boring and trivial. Buzzard wants to sell the power of theorem provers to exactly these mathematicians, so he felt that formalising something that many number theorists would be intensely interested in may have more impact.

Unfortunately, while I'd like to think that he's succeeded somewhat, the reaction I've seen is just more of the "well, isn't that nice" variety, outside of some enthusiasts, many of whom are young and/or not very influential. Mainly, it's because theorem provers still can't help mathematicians improve their productivity, because there's still a lot of stuff that's still missing in the ecosystem, and Buzzard pointed out some of the missing "features" that may help theorem provers take off.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21239067

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfectoid_space

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Scholze

morningseagulls··on Why are adult daughters missing from ancient German cemeteries?
>I have seen zero evidence of that in my travels through China

The parent comment said: "The Chinese, for example, practiced until recently strict exogamous marriage [...]". This explains your experience.

>Do you have any sources for that?

Try searching "Chinese exogamy" in Google Scholar. Surname (i.e. "clan") exogamy is fairly well-known and still practiced. Here's a passage from Rubie S Watson's afterword to the 1991 book on Marriage and Inequality in Chinese Society that she co-edited:

>In China, most unions have involved the transfer of the bride to her husband's household, which, at least initially, has often been headed by her husband's father or a senior agnate. Although not all newly married couples have lived patrilocally, residence with the husband's family has remained both numerically and symbolically significant. This has been especially the case in rural areas where more than 80 percent of the population live and where village exogamy has remained the usual practice.

If you're reacting to the statement that "[w]omen were forbidden to have contact with their biological family after marriage", this was not necessarily a strict prohibition. Because exogamy typically involves moving to a faraway village, it was usually a hassle for the bride to travel back to their biological family, and so if she actually did it, it could be interpreted as a breakdown in the marriage.

Until recently, the practice of adopting a pre-adolescent girl to be the future bride of a pre-adolescent son (tongyangxi) was also a common form of arranged marriage in China.[1] The practice can also go in the other direction, and is known as zhaozhui, or "son-in-law adoption".

[0] https://publishing.cdlib.org/ucpressebooks/view?docId=ft6p30...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tongyangxi

morningseagulls··on Erdogan threatens to flood Europe with refugees
>So shipping asylum seekers to a country with a semi-dictator or an island somewhere is considered acceptable?

I had <sarcasm></sarcasm> tags there...

Australia's asylum policy has been the subject of both domestic and international criticism,[0] particularly with its policy of mandatory detention of unlawful arrivals.[1]

>I'm curious how all this is different from what Trump has been attempting to do at the US border?

Trump LOVES the Australian asylum policy and has been praising it since 2017.[2][3] As the New York Times pointed out in July, "Trump’s immigration approach isn’t new: Europe and Australia went first".[4]

In fact, the Trump travel ban[5] is pretty much how the White Australia policy[6] would have looked like if Deakin, the attorney-general of the first federal government, had not watered down the original racial criteria in the Immigration Restriction Bill to the dictation test.[7] The bill was one of the concessions demanded by the Labor party (yes, the same centre-left union-based party that is oh-so-progressive today[8]) in exchange for supporting the minority Barton government.[9]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asylum_in_Australia#Public_deb...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_detention_in_Austr...

[2] https://www.abc.net.au/news/2019-06-27/donald-trump-tweets-s...

[3] https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2017/08/trump-somehow-ma...

[4] https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/18/world/immigration-trump.h...

[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trump_travel_ban

[6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_Australia_policy

[7] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_Restriction_Act_19...

[8] https://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-05-08/albanese-shorten-labo...

[9] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barton_Government#Immigration

morningseagulls··on Erdogan threatens to flood Europe with refugees
I'm really sorry to hear that. I'm also very puzzled: why would people take the sea route to Australia? I can understand crossing the Mediterranean sea by boat, but sailing to Australia is far more risky.
morningseagulls··on Blizzard Employees Staged a Walkout to Protest Banned Pro-Hong Kong Gamer
>I don’t see why Macau would have a stronger cultural identity than Hong Kong

They actually have their own language, Macanese Patois[0], which is a Portuguese-based creole, in addition to Cantonese, English and maybe Portuguese. Their cuisine is also a blend of Cantonese and Portuguese cuisines.[1] They don't really have a film industry, but my impression is that neither does Hong Kong these days.

It's interesting to compare and contrast the two SARs. You hardly ever hear about Macau, and Beijing didn't seem to have been as compelled to spell out what it thinks "one country two systems" should mean for Macau, as it did for Hong Kong in 2014.[2]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macanese_Patois

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macanese_cuisine

[2] https://web.archive.org/web/20140618000943/http://mobile.nyt...

morningseagulls··on Erdogan threatens to flood Europe with refugees
>Europe could too, with proper organisation

Aye, I hope so too.

However, if Erdogan follows through, he may just send the IS folks through first, and then tip off the tabloid press about how the EU is compromising its security by letting in terrorists.

Cue the backlash and outrage... and then he opens the floodgates.

morningseagulls··on Erdogan threatens to flood Europe with refugees
What opwieurposiu said. Also, here are some resources about the tactic Erdogan is using:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refugees_as_weapons

https://www.cornellpress.cornell.edu/book/9781501704369/weap...

morningseagulls··on Erdogan threatens to flood Europe with refugees
>You can pick them up from the boats, but Turkey won't take them back. What then?

<sarcasm>

Well... has anyone ever heard of Australia?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asylum_in_Australia

>Australia is the only country in the world with a policy of mandatory detention and offshore processing of asylum seekers who arrive without a valid visa.

Find some islands somewhere and send the refugees there. And then wait.

Oh, and make threatening videos like this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bvz3U-JOvOU

</sarcasm>

morningseagulls··on Blizzard Employees Staged a Walkout to Protest Banned Pro-Hong Kong Gamer
Agreed, but Epic Games, which is 40% owned by Tencent, is now claiming it won't do what Blizzard did:

https://www.insider.com/epic-unlike-blizzard-wont-ban-player...

morningseagulls··on Blizzard Employees Staged a Walkout to Protest Banned Pro-Hong Kong Gamer
>At 5% ownership, Tencent doesn't have the muscle to force Blizzard to do anything it wouldn't have already done of its own volition.

And at 40% ownership, Tencent apparently also doesn't have the muscle to force Epic Games to do anything:

https://www.insider.com/epic-unlike-blizzard-wont-ban-player...

morningseagulls··on Blizzard Employees Staged a Walkout to Protest Banned Pro-Hong Kong Gamer
>Independence is not one of the demands of the protestors. Please provide a source for that claim.

Point taken. But it was one of the demands of some protesters in the past[0], so I must have got that confused with the current demands of the 2019 protesters.

Be that as it may be, the comment I was replying to was echoing points made by the pro-independence movement in justifying their stance, in particular by highlighting Hong Kong's allegedly distinct cultural identity.[1]

I'd think, for instance, that Macau has a more distinctive cultural identity than HK, and in any case, harshreality's argument sought to portray China as a cultural monolith.

The reality is that there are at least as many cultural identities as there are provinces, and in Guangdong province alone, there are three separate dialect groups -- Yue (Cantonese)[2], Hakka[3], Southern Min (Teochew[4], Leizhou[5]) -- each with their own distinct culture.

You may see why, from a certain perspective, the cultural identity argument of the pro-independence movement is rather specious. But harshreality isn't the only commentator I've seen who's brought up HK's cultural identity as an argument.

Finally, perhaps I should let a Hongkonger speak for himself. Lewis Lau Yiu-man is a commentator based in Hong Kong, who writes for Stand News[6], a pro-democracy online news website, and contributed this piece[7] to the New York Times last month. After a historical preamble, he made this claim:

>That’s because — want it or not, know it or not — the Umbrella Movement planted the seed of separatism in the city. I don’t mean that the idea was entirely new: There had been some proponents of localism, at the margins. And I don’t mean that separatism is now the order of the day[...] I mean that the Umbrella Movement was, in fact, an independence movement — but an independence movement that didn’t know itself.

He even analyses Beijing's perspective:

>And so from Beijing’s perspective, when pro-democracy protesters and their supporters reject what it perceives as its right to intervene here, they are challenging its very sovereignty. In this, at least, Beijing is correct. It knows what many Hong Kongers don’t seem to have fully appreciated: Admit it or not, we are actually rejecting Chinese sovereignty — we are already an independence movement in disguise. And it all started with the Umbrella Movement.

So there's your source.

[0] https://time.com/4440708/hong-kong-independence-china-locali...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hong_Kong_independence#Reasons

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yue_Chinese

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hakka_Chinese

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teochew_dialect

[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leizhou_Min

[6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stand_News

[7] https://www.nytimes.com/2019/09/27/opinion/hong-kong-umbrell...

morningseagulls··on Blizzard Employees Staged a Walkout to Protest Banned Pro-Hong Kong Gamer
>Now here's a thought ... could video games and entertainment be tools for generating change in countries?

Been there, done that. It was called "soft power", and the US used to wield it in spades.

>To offset potential cost to companies, could this behavior be subsidized by our government?

Your government used to. Hollywood wasn't built in a day, you know.

>Could every game developer and internet service pulling their services from China completely compel the population to try to change their regime?

I'm dying here...

morningseagulls··on Blizzard Employees Staged a Walkout to Protest Banned Pro-Hong Kong Gamer
>We are at a place in history where we can fight not with fists and bullets, but with entertainment.

Not sure if sarcastic or genuine, but er... you know that this used to be called "soft power"? As in America used to have all this soft power and made the whole world worship how awesome American life is? Like, even Rammstein sang about how "we all live in Amerika / Amerika ist wunderbar"?

morningseagulls··on Blizzard Employees Staged a Walkout to Protest Banned Pro-Hong Kong Gamer
>I'm curious as to how China is "Leninist" at all.

China officially describe its ideology as Marxist-Leninism. I mean, depending on how strict your definition of "Leninist" is, even the USSR may not have been "'Leninist' at all".

>The fact of rule by one party that claims to represent the working class does not a Leninist state make.

The notion of the vanguard party is, in fact, a key concept in Leninism.[0] The vanguard party was conceived in opposition to forming trade unions, and was supposed to recruit from the working class. AFAIK trade unions don't exist in China, and the CPC does recruit widely, so it does satisfy the criteria of a vanguard party.

Marxist-Leninism also advocates atheism, another key aspect of Chinese policy.[1]

Also, I found this amusing: did you know Singapore is led by a party that was originally organised as a Leninist party? [2]

>In Singapore, the People's Action Party (PAP) was organised as a Leninist political party featuring internal democracy. The PAP initiated single-party dominance in the government and popular politics of Singapore.[3]

Of course, the PAP later expunged its leftist faction and swung to the right, but it still retains a lot of the Leninist structure.[4] Imagine, a billionaire's playground run by a centre-right party organised like a Leninist vanguard party.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leninism#The_vanguard_party

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marxist%E2%80%93Leninist_athei...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leninism#Philosophic_successor...

[3] Peter Wilson, Economic growth and development in Singapore (2002) p. 30.

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/People%27s_Action_Party#Organi...

morningseagulls··on Blizzard Employees Staged a Walkout to Protest Banned Pro-Hong Kong Gamer
>Measuring Hong Kong's importance for China by its GDP is as useful as measuring your eyes' importance to you by their weight.

Interesting. How does Hong Kong function as China's "eyes" in your analogy?

morningseagulls··on Malaysian government plans to promote startups by becoming a venture capitalist
>>>the state can still manufacture startups because these companies will get the red carpet from every other institution.

>Yes, but you are underestimating the ways the state itself may "help" a company fail.

Yes, but this also undermines your point that government-manufactured startups will necessarily get red-carpet treatment.

Like I've said earlier, Malaysia is more like Romania, and the examples you've listed are peanuts compared to the kind of shenanigans you can get in Malaysia.

I mean, this is a country whose PM is a nonagenarian who's made a spectacular political comeback [0], after having defeated his protégé [1] and his former party [2], and who's known for sending another protégé to jail on sodomy charges.[3] It's also a multi-ethnic country where the privileged status of the majority ethnicity is constitutionally protected[4] and backed by active affirmative action policies.[5]

Which is why there's so much skepticism in this thread about the whole thing.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mahathir_Mohamad

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Najib_Razak

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Malays_National_Organis...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anwar_Ibrahim_sodomy_trials

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_153_of_the_Constitutio...

[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bumiputera_(Malaysia)

morningseagulls··on Evolution and Software Development
Thanks, this was a nice short read. I'm skeptical, however, that just because we can refactor our way to saner software, that we won't still have software exhibiting the equivalent of a recurrent laryngeal nerve.
morningseagulls··on Ask HN: What is necessary for a startup ecosystem to thrive?
You're welcome. I wish HN has a feature to notify users of mentions: I'm surprised you saw my mention.
morningseagulls··on Blizzard Employees Staged a Walkout to Protest Banned Pro-Hong Kong Gamer
>perhaps the best approach is to use the official translated word from Chinese

Sadly, the "best approach" has a good track record of being the approach that is usually not taken.

morningseagulls··on Blizzard Employees Staged a Walkout to Protest Banned Pro-Hong Kong Gamer
>If Hong Kong becomes a Palestine-style cause celebre it will be bad for China.

Nope. Like Palestine, it'd just be another showcase of the British strategy of "divide and quit". Heck, someone wrote a book about it:

https://www.amazon.com/Divide-Quit-late-Penderel-Moon/dp/019...

morningseagulls··on Blizzard Employees Staged a Walkout to Protest Banned Pro-Hong Kong Gamer
>The discussions I've seen point more towards Legalism, a Chinese theory of governance that's similar to fascism.

I agree, but "legalism" has its own meaning in Western philosophy, so "fascism" is the more appropriate terminology to avoid confusion:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legalism_(Western_philosophy)

>Especially because China has a long, cultural history with Legalism

This is something that most people won't know without a detailed study of Chinese history. Legalism in China won the day against Confucianism a long time ago in 221 BC, when the First Emperor of China came to power, and has never quite lost its place in Chinese political thought since.

morningseagulls··on Blizzard Employees Staged a Walkout to Protest Banned Pro-Hong Kong Gamer
>Hong Kong's entire value, as far as I can see [...]

Keep in mind that that's the perspective you've been conditioned to see by the media you've consumed.

>If it becomes a homogenized satellite of Shenzhen with sky high real estate, which seems to be what China wants, what's left of Hong Kong?

Well, for one thing, the unstable political condition is likely to change the "sky high real estate" bit.

>I thought China was smarter than this. I thought they would realize the value of Hong Kong. Apparently China doesn't want Hong Kong.

Oh, please. They do want Hong Kong. They just want Hong Kong in a different way from how the rest of the world thinks Hong Kong is valuable to China.

>They want to remove the painful reminder of the Opium Wars and British influence in the Sinosphere.

The Anglosphere wants to remove the painful reminder of the Opium Wars. You seem to. China doesn't.

As for foreign influence in their own backyard, ever heard of NIMBY ("not in my back yard")?

>There will never be another place like it, and China is destroying it out of spite and ideological inflexibility.

Not quite. For one thing, Hong Kong has lost its lustre as "a place to live or to do business or to visit". Recent IMF data show that its GDP per capita is almost half that of Macau SAR:

https://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/hong-kong-economy/articl...

It's also fallen far behind as one of the world's busiest ports: Shenzhen now outranks it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_busiest_container_port...

It's not a matter of whether Hong Kong becomes "a homogenized satellite of Shenzhen", but when, because Hong Kong is already heading down that road.

What you, and other commentators, seem to fail to understand is that China absolutely wants Hong Kong, but not for it being an SAR. No. Reread Carrie Lam's leaked comments again:

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-hongkong-protests-carriel...

>Lam noted, however, that she had few options once an issue had been elevated “to a national level,” a reference to the leadership in Beijing, “to a sort of sovereignty and security level, let alone in the midst of this sort of unprecedented tension between the two big economies in the world.”

This has now been elevated to an issue of national security for China. Do you know why?

Because the Hong Kong activists are now demanding independence.

Set aside the issue of self-determination for a minute. Suppose you are playing as China in this game of Civilization and a city that you've got back is doing this. How would you react?

Would you fold to the demands of Washington and Elizabeth?

Or would you look at South Korea? At Taiwan? At how Mongolia got away with the help of Catherine?

Notwithstanding the rhetoric around the Opium Wars, Hong Kong is strategically valuable -- and not simply economically valuable -- to China because it's located on the other side of the mouth of the Pearl River from Macau. It's literally a physical gatekeeper to Guangzhou. Have a look at the geographic reality:

https://www.google.com/maps/@22.4267643,113.6415031,9z

(China does have detailed economic plans for the region: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pearl_River_Delta_Economic_Zon...)

Which is why China would hold on to Hong Kong tightly, as tightly as it'd hold on to Tibet or Xinjiang. For strategic reasons.

morningseagulls··on English has been my pain for 15 years (2013)
Thanks for the list of oddities, all of which I'm aware, but I was hoping OP could work on an explanation.
morningseagulls··on Ask HN: What is necessary for a startup ecosystem to thrive?
There's a recent discussion about how the Malaysian government wants to become a venture capitalist:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21165161

I think the creation of a startup ecosystem requires doing many things, including most of what you've just mentioned. In the case of Malaysia, many people are naturally skeptical, since the government doesn't have a good track record, c.f. the 1MDB scandal. I hope the government(s) you have to deal with is/are better than that.

On the other hand, governments are facing what Clifton calls a "jobs war" (see JSeymourATL's recommendation: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21180883), and many governments have programs that gives grants to small businesses. It's seen as an effort by governments to create jobs, so if you frame the creation of a startup ecosystem that way, you're more likely to create buy-in from the government.

morningseagulls··on English has been my pain for 15 years (2013)
>Because it's hard. You sound all wrong to yourself.

And after years of conditioning to sound "right", it's very hard to unlearn all that and sound "wrong", in order to perform that accommodation.

morningseagulls··on English has been my pain for 15 years (2013)
>That is, written English is a sane language, and spoken English is a sane language as well.

What's your definition of "sane" here?

>The problem is that they are two unrelated languages

Sounds like Chinese/Mandarin to me. :)

morningseagulls··on English has been my pain for 15 years (2013)
>Trying to explain to a child why a certain word is pronounced the way it is, even though it looks nothing like how we are pronouncing it, usually falls back to "that's just the way it is" unless I want to try explaining to them the niceties of Old French/Latin, Old English, Old Germanic, the great vowel shift, etc.

I want an ELI5 about this, please. I'm sure there's room for swords, dragons and secret treasure maps somewhere in that story. :)

morningseagulls··on Malaysian government plans to promote startups by becoming a venture capitalist
>My main experience is with Romania

Fair enough, that would explain your reaction. To be fair, Malaysia is more like Romania than some of the other countries I've mentioned.

>just excuses at spending money, badly

Yes, and funding startups is just about the perfect excuse, because new businesses often fail. However, the SCMP report also said the government has been giving grants to startups for some time now. Grants to small businesses is something that a lot of governments engage in: it's about trying to create jobs.

>Perhaps other governments are better at managing money

Nah. Other governments just behave better. Funding new businesses is always a "bad" way of spending money, in that most new businesses fail, and nobody has a good way of figuring out which ones will.

>the state can still manufacture startups because these companies will get the red carpet from every other institution.

They may get some prestige, but I'm sure a lot of startups fail eventually.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →