HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

motohagiography

18,109 karma · joined February 15, 2018

Good writing and contributing to public discourse requires a certain level of risk and often a bit of provocation. If a comment has really piqued you, chances are we have similar interests with different viewpoints and we have enough in common that you should comment. Our best is only what we do.

This handle moto-hagiography is a nonsense word based on a quip about using machines and media for self aggrandizement.

"Don't be so humble, you're not that great."

{ "footoken" : "bac0eba0e4b7674d3e5612b9e5f922a12739f765" }

submissionscomments
motohagiography··on Exif Smuggling (2025)
is this within the category of normal steganographic encodings and packers, or does it have the ability to execute itself? you can encode anything as anything. I am interpreting it's a slightly interesting tool to fool signature based detection, but isn't something like running a weird machine in an external decoder.
motohagiography··on Field of clones: How horse replicas came to dominate polo
The way to determine how you know if you have picked the best horse to clone would be the secretary problem[1] for optimal stopping. This is somewhat plausible among polo horses because of the artificially small population size of pedigreed and trained horses.

The simple version of the problem is you ride about 1/e of the total population and then the first one that is better than all previous ones is your best option. For a pro polo player who would also breed and train others in the off season, over a multi-decade career, it's not perfect, but in aggregate, they are positioned to be pretty good.

Will there be black swan horses? Absolutely. They aren't even black swans, they're inevitable, but if your goal in the sport is to compound your average performance over time without significant setbacks (loss of a prize horse), then cloning a top player's best horse is a good bet.

I find the ethical discussions around horse cloning and sports lack a lot of domain competence in both what riding is, and the stewardship and biology it entails. From a sensory and ontological perspective, a horse is basically an alien being with a peanut sized brain that it falls to our species to be responsible for its existence. Cloning a few to adapt them for survival in our world is profoundly more humane than selling the surplus from breeding programs for meat or leaving them for predators and disease. Even though the philosophers comments about objectification were paraphrased for publication, their perspective is dumb.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secretary_problem

motohagiography··on Show HN: Edsger – A handwritten Clojure REPL for the reMarkable 2
beautiful idea. i thought remarkable would be useful for a handwritten chat client. it's kind of a romantic constraint but getting a sense of meaning and personality from handwriting seems like an obvious thing.
motohagiography··on Debug Project
The effect of this could make some mostly uninhabitable areas more habitable.
motohagiography··on EY Canada published a cybersecurity report and most citations were hallucinated
People don't get it, this is marketing an example of what they could do for you. They can produce reports that say what you want to say, filtered through third party diligence and E&O policies, then take flak and blowback for tough policy choices. For the client there will be no consequences. It's not just ai slop or garbage, it's what makes them well worth it.

Slop signalling may be the new power play. Nothing quite says "FU" like a low effort AI hallucinations.

motohagiography··on To have a moral stance on AI is to be an outcast, and it sucks
the argument reminds me of the uncanny sense of being managed. i think there was a belief that having the skills that AI synthesizes was some kind of intellectual equity, when this was more of a convention and a promise than any kind of social contract that preserves the value and meaning of ones past contributions.

imo we've been living out a decade or more of the Doorman Fallacy ( https://www.jaakkoj.com/concepts/doorman-fallacy ) where people are just liquid labour with some minimum constraints to distinguish them from chattel, where the ironic effect is everyone gets treated like they are chattel but for these minimum requirements. Maybe this will move the concerns and opinions class to act to conserve some of our cultural capital base?

mostly i am not sympathetic to the author because we are not of the same tribe, but the essential argument that there's something to conserve that we arent with AI is a worthy concern. we should look less at problems and solutions and more upstream of what we want to preserve and still grow.

motohagiography··on Free full BGP feed. IPv4 and IPv6 (2020)
this is great, thank you.
motohagiography··on The dead economy theory
It's not diseconomic, but it obviates a lot of constraints that required a person to manage a coordination problem, and those were a lot of jobs. Keynesian ideas about employment and GDP are just having an apocalypse. Like someone replaced the hole diggers and fillers with a conveyor belt and I would guess Keynes critics would have some predictive power here.

A couple developers can collaborate, but several need someone to specialize in coordination to yield additional value from more workers. Whether you call it management or orchestration, the need emerges at each threshold of additional complexity.

When AI collapses the productivity of 10 people into one, that's the disruption. The best AI user is going to suck all the opportunity out of the room for the others, and that's when layoffs happen. However, this assumes a fixed pie of opportunity. That's the real problem. As though there were only so much dirt to shovel.

FAANGs are old/mature and don't have exponential growth in front of them anymore, where opportunity within them is mainly about optimizing themselves but not growing in radical new directions. AI will indeed eat those optimization workforces alive. They resemble professions because law firms and doctors offices aren't growing either. They're mostly solving internal optimization problems, not finding net new growth opportunities.

The real effect is AI radically polarizing the difference between growing and dying in an org, where any firm that isn't growing fast enough will have its fixed opportunity pie collapse as AI disrupts this regulated oxygen supply. Whereas, growing firms without ceilings on the opportunity to deliver value will use AI to grow to the opportunity available.

Professionals can do fine if they re-orient themselves to new growth with different unit pricing, but yes, anything large and slow moving is probably going to get eaten.

motohagiography··on Magnifica Humanitas
we should import it as a POPE.md skill and see if it meaningfully alters reasoning and results.
motohagiography··on Alberta to hold referendum on whether to remain in Canada
exercise to the reader. the facts in this case are not the debate, but what their consequences are. its worth addressing forum spoiling though. if you have an actual opinion, state it. but spare us the banal nihilism of people with received tactics but no intellectual capacity for conviction. it's insane to me what the civility rules enable by leaving those behaviours unchallenged.
motohagiography··on Shipping a laptop to a refugee camp in Uganda
remarkable that even without what we would think of as basic infrastructure they can still produce an impoverishing level of bureaucracy. it's like an emergent force of its own.
motohagiography··on Alberta to hold referendum on whether to remain in Canada
it's gov's own data and stated policies. discourse or gtfo.
motohagiography··on Alberta to hold referendum on whether to remain in Canada
Some modern precedents for countries established by peaceful legal secession include:

- Singapore (Malaysia) 1965

- Montenegro (Serbia) 2006

- Czech Republic (Czechoslovakia) 1993

- Iceland (Denmark) 1944

However, these are rare as most secession events are violent. Establishing a new country typically requires a revolution, and there is more support for that broadly in Canada for various reasons than any single province. The Alberta referendum is a polite signal and a test.

The boomer generation and it's broadly left politics is dying off, meaning that the LPC and NDP need to replenish their electoral support to stay in power. It is uncontroversial that they have been doing this using radical immigration policies and throwing money away, particularly via the abuse of definitions of "temporary," and "asylum." Political interference by both India (exporting their independence problem) and China (creating a resource vassal) is undeniable at this point. Canadians with a stake in the country are quite reasonably concerned that their society is being demolished and replaced.

Will they revolt, and could it succeed? It depends on whether they get US sponsorship or not. The more interesting question than the Alberta theater is whether Canada revolts and establishes a republic, or whether it gets annexed by the US or the EU. Alberta is just a canary for these other scenarios, imo.

motohagiography··on Security researcher says Microsoft built a Bitlocker backdoor, releases exploit
we all know there are limits and vulnerabilities to manage in products. however, this backdoor appears to be a misrepresentation of the core function of the product. if you deployed something you believed to be a joke, you may be the sucker at that table, as thats culpable.

maybe the license language means they make no reps about security, but if this is as described they have compromised the compliance of their customer base.

motohagiography··on Security researcher says Microsoft built a Bitlocker backdoor, releases exploit
if you have ever dealt with a regulated institution, they have an obligation to publicly report lost and stolen devices that contain PII/PHI as a breach, and the people whose data was on the device must be notified. It's a huge deal that has board level involvement when it occurs.

The ONLY control that mitigates this risk is disk encryption, and it is perniciously misleading to ship a sabotaged product on which these legally consequential decisions get made around the world- based on the specific assurance the product is designed and marketed to provide.

If true, it is a specific outrage against the laws of several countries, medical and other research ethics, public health, and the social contracts people have with their institutions. If MS is given impunity for this, a lot of regulation is not worth the paper it is written on.

before arguing further, I recommend looking at the breach notification sections of the laws in these major economies: https://www.dlapiperdataprotection.com/

motohagiography··on Security researcher says Microsoft built a Bitlocker backdoor, releases exploit
The real problem with a Bitlocker backdoor or weakness is that when a laptop gets stolen or lost, in most regulated organizations, the criteria for legally declaring and disclosing a breach pivots on whether it was protected by disk encryption.

If it's a backdoor, that's a serious fraud against their customers.

motohagiography··on Canada’s Bill C-22 Is a Repackaged Version of Last Year’s Surveillance Nightmare
These serious people you know, do they read primary sources?

- PRC police stations in Canada: https://www.publicsafety.gc.ca/cnt/trnsprnc/brfng-mtrls/prlm...

- Foreign interference in elections: https://www.elections.ca/content.aspx?section=abo&dir=comp/m...

You have no serious people.

motohagiography··on Canada’s Bill C-22 Is a Repackaged Version of Last Year’s Surveillance Nightmare
The King is the head of state, it's trivial to switch that to a US appointee. It's the highest likelihood on the list of alternatives to accepting a surveillance state. Canadians don't have the anything for a civil war, nobody who believes in anything will take MAID, Alberta secession has to go through imported "votes" and a process designed to sabotage it.

If Canada had any kind of national identity it would not have become what was recently described as a "south asian country controlled by China," in a conversation about its relationship to US national security. Outside faculty clubs pickle ball courts, and maybe dog daycare pickup runs, there is zero resistance to annexation. It would be the only time the US would ever be "greeted as liberators."

motohagiography··on Canada’s Bill C-22 Is a Repackaged Version of Last Year’s Surveillance Nightmare
I worked in privacy and security in canada for decades. We could only hold them off so long. The whole country is being demolished to be reinvented as a technocrat machine levered against human desire.

It means the solutions aren't technical, and nobody votes their way out of this. I've checked out because the demoralization campaign worked, and there is nothing to save. The outs are Alberta separation, US annexation, civil war, or MAID. There is no longer a political solution. If there were, these surveillance controls would not be necessary.

motohagiography··on Holding Community Space
"Artists are the storm troopers of gentrification," was some famous Toronto graffiti and I've been a part of the gentrifying class in a few cycles and neighborhoods in my life. It's never organic. Everything cool is a real estate play.

By this point there should be a 3-5 year formula where someone can finance buying a crappy strip mall or corner building and turn it around as the hip new thing and exit for 5x anywhere in the world. Invest in loss making restaurants and music venues operated by the people who care about them.

motohagiography··on Holding Community Space
i threw some good parties in the 90s at warehouse spaces I lived in, and this is distinct from a community space, but closely related. with hindsight, there is a specific talent for doing that.

Alex Danco's writing on "Scenes" [1] codifies a lot of the details, but nobody so far has been able to scale it.

The main factor when I did a hacker/artist space, it was the effect of relationships with musicians and scene people, not the affect of a vision to make something cool.

The defining factor of the spaces I've seen succeed vs. fail was something physical, and explicitly not software, and to a lesser extent, politics. You can have software and politics flavored things, but unless you are doing something physical like robotics, motorcycles, puppeteering, bookselling, pyrotechnics, music production, mma, it's not going to survive. Sure, there are spaces that don't do anything physical, but if you scratch the surface there is always a mysterious source of funding by the usual suspects who want to direct the scene to some other end.

The physical activity creates the competence hierarchy that is a stable and self regulating social dynamic.

[1] https://danco.substack.com/p/how-scenes-work-with-jim-oshaug...

motohagiography··on YC's Biggest Scandals
to be fair, compared to what I have seen go on in finance, government, and media, these scandals are endearingly tame.
motohagiography··on US Government releases first batch of UAP documents and videos
Interesting that the dept. of war documents aren't sufficient evidence of these points, what would be?

I get the sense it's mainly a question of who provides the information. There isn't a version of these documents that reinforces any public institutional consensus, so it's hard to separate insightful skepticism from mere narrative alignment.

motohagiography··on I want to live like Costco people
The main reason i don't shop at costco is the lack of serendipity. i won't set foot in a walmart for the same reason. My expectations for any random human encounter there are net negative.
motohagiography··on Aliens.gov will be running as a WordPress multisite
theres a tail of people who wont believe anything, and everyone will say its bluebeam, but the bob lazar S4 documentary and follow up conversation on american alchemy is very compelling.

i doubt there will be official popular contact in my lifetime, but orienting a nuclear and AI capable civilization to a place relative to others seems timely.

AI is the perfect (and necessary) bridging and filtering tech for transferring ideas from a more advanced civilization, as it's an integration layer. it's "us" as the sum of our knowledge, but its notionally superior, and can be adapted and expanded, where it's a proxy or buffer for ontological shocks.

im optimistic on this.

motohagiography··on Aliens.gov will be running as a WordPress multisite
transparency on the UFO issue removes a pillar and gateway to conspiracy thinking, and it will restore some much needed trust in the state as a set of institutions. the benefits of signalling the government is in it with its people on this issue creates a renewed sense of shared stake.

imo ufo disclosure is probably the most important thing a democratic government could do right now, and one of the few things it could actually succeed at.

motohagiography··on 40% of lost calories globally are from beef, needing 33 cal of feed per 1 cal
it seems disingenuous to problematize beef. it turns grass into human energy and also requires civilizational practices that create and preserve human dignity and animal welfare. mainly, the so called problem serves to centralize the problematizer themselves. their arguments from a position of centrally planning and managing food economies are intellectual tarpits. however, that our food supply and rural ways of life have the attention of the perpetually concerned is worthy of note. when they start with their opinions, mind your wallets and assets. in short, avoid.
motohagiography··on Obfuscation is not security – AI can deobfuscate any minified JavaScript code
slight historical note, it might be interesting to see how the brief period of "white box cryptography" stands up to AI today. At the time there were a few companies with products that had trouble finding fit (for straightforward security reasons) but they were essentially commercial obfuscators that made heavy use of lookup tables, miniature virtual machines, and esolang concepts that worked mainly against human reverse engineers.

An example was this early AES proposal: https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/3-540-36492-7_17

motohagiography··on Scientific audio equipment analysis with analyzer shows no difference in quality
I have been mulling starting a high end audio gear company. The rationale is, making something worthy of spending on, because it's something you love- is the authentic experience. If I can make something that will still be liquid at some reduced depreciation in 10-20 years, that's an honest product. I used to be a writer for luxury media as well, and there is an extremely rare ability in luxury to make it actually real as opposed to merely vulgar and expensive.

These articles are a bit like saying scientists find expensive watches do not tell time in any appreciably better way, yet even technical founders who should "know better," are still wearing them with a t-shirt and flip flops after their exit. The economics of high end audio make more sense as an analogy to jewelry or art.

After volatility, haircuts, cap gains and other risk, there are so few productive assets to invest relatively small amounts in, where a store of value that depreciates less than inflation and purchasing power is a desirable thing.

If you love music, it's a way to build a shrine to it. Arguably, the real problem is consumer gear that simulates the experience of something valuable that won't end up in a landfill, but its just crap you throw away when you move house.

motohagiography··on More common mistakes to avoid when creating system architecture diagrams
The main one i would add is a lack of symmetrical alignment. the point of a diagram is to create a shared abstraction for reasoning about a system or set of problems. The point of that is to scale work on it to other minds. It should enable others to parse it and ask useful questions.

If your diagram is ugly, you're probably mixing levels of abstraction without acknowledging it. It's a forcing function on articulating what you know and what is outstanding. Something that is black boxed should be referenced as a black box.

I use a lot of data viz because it's a high bandwidth way to show relationships, dynamics, order of complexity and its location, information problems, scope, and de-noise data. So much can be explained by having AI make you a uml sequence diagram of a concept. it is unreasonbly effective. If you are making a "chart for management" and using powerpoint or native excel charts, you're probably creating garbage though.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →