HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

motohagiography

18,109 karma · joined February 15, 2018

Good writing and contributing to public discourse requires a certain level of risk and often a bit of provocation. If a comment has really piqued you, chances are we have similar interests with different viewpoints and we have enough in common that you should comment. Our best is only what we do.

This handle moto-hagiography is a nonsense word based on a quip about using machines and media for self aggrandizement.

"Don't be so humble, you're not that great."

{ "footoken" : "bac0eba0e4b7674d3e5612b9e5f922a12739f765" }

submissionscomments
motohagiography··on Ask HN: What are you working on? (July 2025)
indeed, though i was thinking more in terms of actual investment with an expected return on growth rather than just patronage. it sounded valuable and worth investing in.
motohagiography··on Ask HN: What are you working on? (July 2025)
this is a really fascinating idea. I'm reading it as, instead of seeing my individual identity in a location dataset, it will see -DataUnionMember- with no unique identifier? When two members are in the same place at the same time, you don't know which one went in which direction?

The question of who can de-identify or unmask the data is there, but I could see the capability being required for gov, military, and police, and then as a premium service to customers.

motohagiography··on Ask HN: What are you working on? (July 2025)
to me that's exciting and optimistic because any marginal efficiency in animal testing pays off in net-humane treatment of lab animals.

it's counter intuitive, but if even a small portion of animal rights money went into tech solutions like this, they could have an orders of magnitude greater impact on welfare.

motohagiography··on Ask HN: What are you working on? (July 2025)
with AR and glasses camera platforms, this will actually be a big deal. pricing and real consumer interest and inventory levels are competitive.

If people are wearing AR glasses into big box stores that are comparing prices in real time, I could see there being a real time auction for CPG pricing the way there are for website ads now.

motohagiography··on Ask HN: What are you working on? (July 2025)
I will use this to keep track of all these emerging abstractions. it's a smart play to establish this position between the rapid cutting edge and people who need to be able to reason about it but not implement it.
motohagiography··on Ask HN: What are you working on? (July 2025)
superb and immensely valuable, this is a history of desire.
motohagiography··on Ask HN: What are you working on? (July 2025)
this is a really important and disruptive idea. amazing.

what do you need to scale this?

motohagiography··on Solid protocol restores digital agency
the challenge with getting institutions to sign health information or other data and attributes is users will fight and haggle to get their medical information signed the way they fight to get insurance payments today.

you're an institution, someone gives you some data to sign for the integrity of, what else do you want from them to hold that risk? everything basically. these protocols push coordination problems to the edge, which sounds great, except they treat all the complexity as an externality. If you're a user and you want a flexible secure wallet to hold these data attributes you can put anywhere you want, I've got an unbreakable bitcoin wallet app to sell you and it comes with a bridge in new york.

As described, the SOlid protocol appears predicated on these two counterfactuals.

the purpose of cryptogrphic data integrity for digital identity is to absolve any person or institution of accountability for their decision to use it.

motohagiography··on What would an efficient and trustworthy meeting culture look like?
> It feels rude to leave the meeting before it’s done

It's not rude to leave a meeting if there is a competent chair who can set clear beginnings and endings to topics and MC while people enter and exit during transitions.

motohagiography··on National Aviation Reporting Center on Anomalous Phenomena
it's pretty clear there exist vehicles that are inconsistent with our understanding of physics. by example, anyone who has worked in cryptography also works at the edges of classified maths and computer science, where it's also pretty clear there is a funnel in place that reduces the number of people who are capable and cleared to work on the classified stuff, and that this funnel or cone at the entrance to classified maths and comp sci topics has been very effective so far. I'd bet there is a similar scheme for the physics behind UAP propulsion.

by analogy in cryptgraphy and security, remember that people used to get isolated and discredited as conspiracy theorists for believing-in or talking about ECHELON and any suggestion about a program like BULLRUN to backdoor algorithms would get you laughed out of rooms. somehow there was always someone within a degree of security projects to spread a rumor that someone was some kind of unstable or paranoid lunatic if they spent any effort trying to discover surveillance instrumentation.

I'd suggest that these UAP craft are protected by similar social mechanisms in physics.

Further, I think we're going to see many more of these limited hangouts of advanced propulsion and energy tech because as AI reasoning capability increases, it's going to discover classified maths and physics (ask it about cryptographic attacks now), and the establishment that manages that advantage is going to need to stay ahead of that.

motohagiography··on EU age verification app to ban any Android system not licensed by Google
"age verification app," is such a phony pretext. They know that android fragmentation and the lack of consistent verifiable hardware is what prevents govts from implementing a punitive digital ID that is sufficient to punish and fine people using western standards of evidence and legal defense.

these people are monsters. don't help them, and don't be complicit. working on digital ID tech, and even disclosing vulns in it is like helping Hollerith make faster and more efficient punch cards.

motohagiography··on Britain's spies-for-hire are running wild
I'm not sure this issue is specific to intelligence, as many government employees retire from their posts and respawn as contractors and consultants. how is it different from some retired mandarins greasing institutional and enterprise sales?
motohagiography··on Women dating safety app 'Tea' breached, users' IDs posted to 4chan
obviously it would be malicious and unethical, but since that didn't seem to stop Tea users, I'd be interested in what their arguments against it would be.
motohagiography··on Women dating safety app 'Tea' breached, users' IDs posted to 4chan
for someone who thought Tea was a good idea, what would be the objection be if this leaked contributor data were used to populate a similar app to warn men off?
motohagiography··on Writing is thinking
the act of writing takes raw experience, puts it in front of the eyes, and then filters it back through your critical faculties so you can refine and reason about it. the iteration makes it higher quality thought.

making writing valuable is another skill (see this evergreen lecture from the university of chicago leadership lab: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aFwVf5a3pZM)

however when I encounter people with low written or verbal acuity, they have to survive somehow, so it's wise to observe what tools of cunning they tend to reach for.

motohagiography··on Digital vassals? French Government 'exposes citizens' data to US'
these seem like solved problems. in canada, many govt depts have procurement rules that state all data must be hosted nationally by a custodian subject to national or even provincial law, and this has been standard for decades. the firm I work for also doesn't use google or microsoft clouds for similar reasons.

the deeper problem is governments are not technology builders and cannot produce tech products because they have no unique ability to deliver anything anyone subject to them actually wants.

motohagiography··on Bitchat – A decentralized messaging app that works over Bluetooth mesh networks
this looks great for most use cases. most interception has been ruled out by the simple protocol for rooms, where the remaining attack appears to be just to clone the users keys, where it's more viable to attack the phones than the protocol, which is the point.

the spitball questions I would ask might be, a) how do you handle a theoretical timing attack where the time to respond to a room scan could yield whether a given device is a member of a known room, (the paralellism?) and b) does the GCM counter IV/nonce value cluster around rooms, so the counter for a given room will be in a shared range?

not dealbreakers or anything, this is simple and cool for its purpose, but design consideration wise, what's the thinking on those scenarios?

motohagiography··on Using Sun Ray thin clients in 2025
the Atari brand is cute, but those products are a bit schmaltzy. we should find a way to get control of one of these brands and do an LBO of an OEM like framework or system76 for manufacturing. Apple is out of ideas and they're never going to make it in enterprise, it seems like an opportunity.
motohagiography··on Using Sun Ray thin clients in 2025
someone should reboot the Sun brand as a super high end laptop and workstation company. ~$10k price point. GPU or future tech, native virtualization to run simultaneous OS images, modular and upgradable like framework's products, droppable ruggedization, sim card and isolated secure element as a crypto module, same day replacement delivery worldwide.

could do the same with Atari, Cray, even a rebrand of SGI to Silicon General Intelligence. I miss muscular tech like that.

motohagiography··on CareerBuilder and Monster job boards, file for bankruptcy
if they were levered enough and the interest rate changed vs. their revenue, it was probably inevitable. slowly, and then all at once as they say.
motohagiography··on CareerBuilder and Monster job boards, file for bankruptcy
it's a bankruptcy so I would estimate revenues were insufficient to service both debt and operating expenses. ideally they have assets like real estate or something of value to liquidate, but regardless, it's likely that everyone except employees will have been paid.

imo there are three phases of a company: build, manage, liquidate. essentially seed/A-B, C-N rounds, PE debt rounds & asset stripping.

motohagiography··on Tell me about your favorite tree (a slow-web proposal)
a romantic idea. I've managed to achieve a kind of Walden / Wonko the Sane way of life in tech, where I work by a picture window looking out on a large field on a farm, and I in fact chop wood and get my water from a well, actually.

the way I use tech now is mainly trying to get LLM agents to work to shorten the daydreaming process by giving me the answers I need. the thing is, tech is just for building more tech. it only builds upwards on the stack, and doesn't yield discovery or growth outside it. it doesn't make me a better musician, horseman, hiker, motorcyclist, lifter of heavy things, or friend, etc. these things are only the effect of practice.

maybe the response is not so much a kind asceticism where choices of taste in tech or opinion become a proxy for purity, but to ask, what have you physically practiced vs. merely consumed?

motohagiography··on What happens when clergy take psilocybin
it was an internet rabbit hole and indeed it could be defused with some regional botany. there's some discussion about DMT content in other acacia species(?) and how it shows up in symbology.

i have the sense that one could construct a whole "ancient aliens" style ideology and paranormal theory of history around hallucinogens, but it would just be entertaining junk.

motohagiography··on What happens when clergy take psilocybin
if you are interested in a rabbit hole, look up the appearance of the acacia shrub in the bible, a source of DMT, and how some people associate it with the burning bush. quite a trip.

I've said before that I think the geometric patterns in hallucinations resemble analog signal feedback, inside an analog signalling system (your brain) that has been impaired by a chemical. other dimensions and beings aren't necessary to the explanation. there are theraputic uses for breaking cycles of thought, but I'd argue a non-spiritual view of drugs based on signalling feedback and channel impairment is sufficient to describe their effects.

motohagiography··on Frequent reauth doesn't make you more secure
recently came to appreciate the irony in proving who we are via catchpas, password complexity, and context switching 2FA is that any security method without personal irritation will get automated and broken. therefore, all security requires for us to prove the authenticity of our being by demonstrating suffering somehow- and an authentication method without evidence of suffering cannot prove we are real.

it's funny, but tracks infosec life pretty well, that we've stumbled into a proof that the necessary condition for a system to verify we are alive and are our authentic being is to offer up some minor suffering to it.

motohagiography··on Dancing brainwaves: How sound reshapes your brain networks in real time
music is the category of all possible languages, is a statement I've been mulling lately. it's less of an aesthetic judgment than the usual, "music is a language," where it's more of a comment on encoding.

I'd suggest the capacity for our brains and minds to apprehend shapes, relationships, patterns, and ultimately symbols is made from its ability to parse the category of things in music. time, difference, harmonics, consonance, dissonance, patterns. as though all the symbols and representations that emerge from our chunking and caching of stimuli into patterns are in a category of logical artefacts. we represent them- and relationships between them- as musical. Maths codifies or encodes these same relationships and artefacts, but the underlying objects aren't just abstractions, they are a measurement of essentially "musical" relationships.

it falls a bit for the "everything is X" fallacy, but if people seriously pursue the premise that our brains compute, then plausibly, the stimulus it computes over is this category of possible languages we call "music." not sure how useful the idea is, but it's pretty.

motohagiography··on How long it takes to know if a job is right for you or not
maybe we need better tools for assessing the dynamics of orgs from the outside. it's not just personalities, it's incentives.

I have opinions about it based on funding stages, but what it really comes down to is that culture is a function of growth. as an employee with a career success comes from hunting growth. the only real growth is from market fit, and even if you have market fit, if you aren't growing non-linearly you're going to get into a negative sum attrition game in the org culture (e.g. linear long term private equity returns).

questions to find answers for on the way in are:

- does anyone actually use their product and like it?

- how is that number growing? (non-linear, linear, attritive)

- what was their last funding round or change in equity ownership? (e.g. who runs it and what do you have to do to satisfy their investment)

- what's their staff turnover and where do they go?

motohagiography··on Lessons from That 1834 Landscape Gardening Guidebook
reminds me of christopher alexander, but for landscapes. they emphasize function and adaptation to what's there instead of making features that represent ideas from other places and don't belong. this came up in popular architecture discussions years ago about "ducks vs. decorated sheds"[1] where littering the landscape with symbols is what people sense as uncanny and vulgar. mcmansions are ugly because they are what poorer people think rich people like and the result ends up recieved and insincere.

the principle appears to apply to landscaping going back centuries as well. I codify it today as "the difference between effect and affect" where in the arts I pursue you start by immitating, or affecting what you think is good, but there isn't a path to being great there, as the things we think are good were the downstream effect of mastering fundamentals and the expression of a mature artist. it's the consequence of "fake it until you make it," where eventually you run out of things to immitate and are still uncanny and phony, because it isn't a sincere or original expression of the concrete environment and present conversation. Adding a grotto to a park because grottos represent rich people taste is going to be disgusting, but a walking around a copse of trees is charming because it's the effect of the landscape and a sense of place.

the <blink> HTML tag is probably the best example of this mistake, where someone thought, "computers have blinking lights, computer people must care about blinking: if we let them make everything blink we will be rich!" I suspect that logic extends to most failed startups, where people have invented the "blink-tag for X" based on this same reflected misinterpretation of what they think people want, and imitate it without actual engagement that would produce the effect of making something they in fact want.

It's funny that people have been making this same error with tree placement in parks for centuries though.

[1]https://99percentinvisible.org/article/lessons-sin-city-arch...

motohagiography··on EU Commission refuses to disclose authors behind its mass surveillance proposal
having seen this issue through the crypto wars and pgp, the patriot act, the FISA scandals, bullrun's various crypto backdoors and rng sabotage, the tls 1.3 foward secrecy controversies, twitter files, then vax passports and digital identity- these people just never go away, and there's always a new generation to replace them. it seems established now that people in tech need to be vigilant because that game is never not on.
motohagiography··on Classicide
the rationale for dekulakization is to remove the political influence and leverage of smallholders and other people who can afford the independence to maintain principles. small business owners are a similar target today. in cold political calculus, they form a layer of influentials whose products can promote them to essential power-coalition members and force the leadership to bargain with them. see how political parties have to deal with the tech platforms for political survival today as an example. not even the CCP could survive if they threatened people's iPhones. dekulakization is the political class making sure they aren't subject to being limited by that force of popular desire. we talk about how brutal dekulakization was, but rarely why.

I saw the impact of the internet on the 90's era admin class (gov), and if you can imagine the baby boom generation people who retired instead of "using a computer," the internet was a generational class usurpation where genx smallholders in tech butted out the old establishment.

I'd estimate the main effect of AI will be to accelerate a similar generational turnover, where genx people with sunk costs in broadly moated knowledge fields (law, medicine, teaching, etc) will retire early where they can, and the remainders aren't above organizing to ban and regulate it (see mark andreesen's comments about the biden admin banning NN math the way they classified areas of physics).

I'd watch the doyennes of the EU in Brussels closely, as they have become the intl representatives of the administrative class who coordinate the reaction to any tech change that forces them to come to terms with popular desire before imposing policy. Classicide is a blunt category of ideas, but when it enters the discourse, it's worth noticing- and getting ahead of.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →