HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

motohagiography

18,109 karma · joined February 15, 2018

Good writing and contributing to public discourse requires a certain level of risk and often a bit of provocation. If a comment has really piqued you, chances are we have similar interests with different viewpoints and we have enough in common that you should comment. Our best is only what we do.

This handle moto-hagiography is a nonsense word based on a quip about using machines and media for self aggrandizement.

"Don't be so humble, you're not that great."

{ "footoken" : "bac0eba0e4b7674d3e5612b9e5f922a12739f765" }

submissionscomments
motohagiography··on Looking for Keys Under the Lamppost
jeffery pfeffer talks about the triad of performance, credentials, and relationships in one of his books[1] and it extends the metaphor, where a lot of independent consultants are super high performers, but may lack an advanced credential that opens the door for most management roles, or don't have the relationships in their business to close deals so they become subcontractors to people with those relationship management skills.

every industry, company, or field weights these differently. most institutions rank actual individual performance very low relative to credentials and relationships, where something like sales would be all performance and relationships and they don't care what your other bona fides are. if you didn't go to an ivy school, a master's is usually needed to get hired as an exec, but not to be a trouble shooter, etc..

know what your career path values and adapt and invest in the triad accordingly. people who gripe about certifications and book-larnin' are usually indexed on the performance and relationship fields where they can leverage their outlier skills there, whereas being still pretty average with a higher credential score creates opportunity and career momentum. may the odds ever be in your favour.

[1] Pfeffer's "Power" https://www.amazon.com/Power-Some-People-Have-Others/dp/0061...

motohagiography··on The Art of Fugue – Contrapunctus I (2021)
Such a pleasure to read. using beats seemed almost profane at first but it allows for chunking the complexity where it could really help someone get what's going on. I don't listen to the fugues much, and really mainly guitar arrangements of his work I'd like to be able to play one day (allegro assai, lute suite prelude, etc), but it's hard not to get mystical about it. jubilance is the word I'd use for his work. for me the music forms an imaginary navigable space when I hear it, and as everything that lives can hear and count, every piece seems like a meditation on what can be aligned, harmonious, and essentially, True in a universal sense- the awe of a creation for its creator.

I'm an absolute amateur dilettante musician, but for someone just starting to hear his work, I'd suggest the skill is in being able to listen for separate voices and then follow them, and then to practice following them in simple pieces with enough dissonance in them to make you intellectually keep track of what's going on. the simplest possible polyphony someone can use to hone their attention that has analogues to early music may actually be Arvo Pärt's work, as once you can separate voices, the richness of Bach and other composers kind of explodes.

great fan of hein's writing, a pleasure to be reminded of it and to get to comment.

motohagiography··on Trying to teach in the age of the AI homework machine
if I were teaching english today, i would ask students to write essays taking the positions that an AI is not allowed to. steelman something appalling. stand up in class and debate like your life or grade depends on it and fail anyone who doesn't, and if that excludes people, maybe they don't belong in a university.

in everything young people actually like, they train, spar, practice, compete, jam, scrimmage, solve, build, etc. the pedagogy needs to adapt and reframing it in these terms will help. calling it homework is the source of a flawed mental model that problematizes the work instead of incentivising it, and now that people have a tool to solve the problem, they're applying their intelligence to the problem.

arguably there's no there there for the assignments either, especially for a required english credit. the institution itself is a transaction that gets them a ticket to an administrative job. what's the homework assignment going to get them they value? well roundedness, polish, acculturation, insight, sensitivity, taste? these are not valuable or differentiating to kids in elite institutions who know they are competing globally for jobs that are 95% concrete political maneuvering, and most of them (especially in stem) probably think the class signifiers that english classes yield are essentially corrupt anyway.

maybe it's schadenfreude and an old class chip on my part, but what are they going to do, engage in the discourse and become public intellectuals? argue about rimbaud and voltaire over coffee, cigarettes and jazz? Some of them have higher follower counts than there were readers of the novels or articles being taught in their classes. More people read their tweets every day than have ever read a book by Chiang. AI isn't the problem, it's a forcing function and a solution. Instructors should reflect on what their institutions have really become.

motohagiography··on Ask HN: What are you working on? (May 2025)
Do you forsee the tariff situation improving demand for domestically produced wool? I have land and am speculating that the economics of livestock may actually improve.
motohagiography··on Ask HN: What are you working on? (May 2025)
- work all day at cool job for smart people

- applying ML/AI to some security research with some defence or product possibilities

- impementing a test for a quant'ish trading idea that just won't leave me alone

- preludio en mi menor by augustin barrios mangore

- piaffe to canter transitions on a horse

- still figuring out what I actually want to do, but mostly who I want to make something for

motohagiography··on Withnail and I (2001)
in the era the film was influential I knew a few people who were like this Viv character and it seems like it's been long enough that the archetype bears some eulogizing. there's no romance in that kind of failure anymore.

the movie is the most literal romance of any character in a film ever. By any objective criteria, Withnail was a horrible person. Richard E. Grant's ability to be a living cartoon made it hilarious and charming and he let you suspend your disbelief in Withnail's grandeur and go along for the absurd ride. the important idea is that romance is seeing things as greater or more significant, (or just generally other) than they are. That's what Withnail and I was about.

He was harmless and funny because his manipulations were so low-stakes and geared to just getting alcohol for free, but you could see he drank and destroyed himself for the same reasons anyone does, because he knew all he had were the tools of a monster and just didn't know any other way to be.

The archetype is extinct today because the relationships it needed to survive are outmoded. someone being from your school or neighbourhood doesn't figure in our ideas of identity where you'd tolerate a loser with charming delusions because they were a fixture in your own story. Nobody's wives or girlfriends would tolerate them anyway, and I think we're all too mercenary now.

to me the sadness of the story is that it's a meditation on romance itself. it ends where you see Withnail as the volatile addicted animal he is, and he (or really, we as the audience) is slightly redeemed by his hamlet speech so as to be reminded that there was at least some truth to what we believed in about him, and that we ("I") weren't just decieved and manipulated. his grandeur dignified or at least rendered harmless our abuse. the original script doesn't provide that final bit of comfort, however.

maybe there's a version of that story for today, but I don't think a Withnail character could actually survive long enough socially to become interesting enough for anyone to find them romantic enough to tolerate.

motohagiography··on The Myth of the Genius Hacker
the cheesy names thing is something I really don't like about being in the security business. it sabotages smart people who have to repeat these things with a straight face.

imo the security field needs a new story, as what got it here doesn't get it where it needs to be. it was cool and interesting when the adversary was domestic political surveillance, but now?

I don't really want security in anything. I want good engineering with the features and autonomy to take and manage my own risks. I'd like to not have to think about spies and thieves. If something breaks or gets stolen, I'd like for it to be easily fixed or replaced. I don't want to be interdependent. I'd also like to be able to use superior technical skills to disable, disrupt, and deny annoying people who use consumer technologies maliciously, and to keep governments in check from using tech to oppress people.

building security products today achieves none of these things, and usually just consolidates the interests of a bureaucracy. I agree that security marketing has made the products and narrative unbearable, but maybe I have a more accelerationist view, which is, let them be lame. The world is a better place when the administrators fear their users.

motohagiography··on In a high-stress work environment, prioritize relationships
funny how orgs reward people who hold grudges but not people who let them go or who just set normal adult boundaries.

i'm 'that guy' prety much everywhere, and one reason is that I really just like what I do and am usually committed to the mission over the org. defying pournelle's iron law plays out predictably though.

another reason is Pfeffer's triad, where power in any situation is a local weighting of Performance, Credentials, and Relationships. I trade on performance and cred, where my relationships are often polarized because of the imbalance being heavy in those other weightings.

a friend once described it as the relative skills of an indoors cat vs. an outdoors cat, where an outdoors cat catches all the mice and keeps off some larger animals but will probably scratch the furniture and cause a stink once in a while, whereas an indoors cat keeps the house mostly mouse-free, uses a litter box, but doesn't survive long outside, and if you don't empty the litter box often enough you get toxoplasmosis gondii and become a zombie.

managing indoors and outdoors cats together is an art.

motohagiography··on Why Bell Labs Worked
Assume the average FTE costs $250k all in, so the 100 scientist salary bill is ~$25M.

If the fund charges investors 2% of AUM and 20% of profits, factoring in the actual fund costs, hypothetically I'd estimate you'd need an AUM of 2.5B-5B to fund the scientists just on half the management fees.

Practically, you wouldn't do it on mgmt fees and you could do it much smaller, distributed differently, and grow/shrink the research division using fund profits instead of management fees. Using fund money to invest in a seed venture arm for the spinoff startups would just be another investment theme.

the main question would be, if you're making money on the investment side, what do you need the researchers for, and does that research mission (and their expenses) conflict with being a fiduciary. speculatively you'd need to have the fund as a separate entity owned by a partnership who took profits and invested in the research side separately.

at that point, you're back to the original basic problem, where instead of using the profits of a single private fund to support a research team, just make it a bluesky company of researchers who also generate investment strategies, and use venture funding.

the essential pattern is: make a large low-risk financial economic engine to fuel a small high risk one. if a VC firm put 80% of their LP's money in an index fund and just did a bunch of small seed investments, the effect could be similar. I'm not an expert in this, but nobody has invented another bell labs since, so the field seems open to new ideas and it's fun to think about.

motohagiography··on Why Bell Labs Worked
really interested in 1517 now. if i could build a new bell labs i would use a hedge fund structure instead of vc. the lab would attract talent and some of it might get invovled in the fund, but the lab would stay afloat on fund profits. the idea is to just let smart people cook for a tryout year, with great incentives. (not too unlike 1517's program as it turns out)

the difference with this lab idea and a vc like YC is that vc portfolio companies need products and roadmaps to raise investment and for driving revenue. whereas an asset manager is just investing the money and using the profits to fund engineering research and spinoff product development.

firms like this must already exist, maybe i just never hear about their spinoffs or inventions? if not, maybe a small fund could be acquired to build a research division onto it

motohagiography··on Ireland given two months to implement hate speech laws or face action from EU
the reaction to them. If the Irish govenrnment enforced loitering and vagracy laws instead of making up new hate speech laws or accepting them from the EU, they wouldn't have an integration problem. the homes and hotels in ireland being filled with people from EMEA nations are being filled by new colonists.

the cause of the hate speech is not actually race based, but behavioral. all that standing around and loitering in public is anti-economic activity, where not only is it unproductive, but nobody wants to invest in anything (property improvements, homes, businesses) where these men gather to loiter. it destroys economic value in the towns and broader society when people no longer want to invest in local economies because of mass anti-economic activity. the flight from US cities like SF is a useful control example.

enforce loiting and vagrancy laws instead of inventing "hate speech" laws, and the underlying integration problems vanish almost instantly.

motohagiography··on Ireland given two months to implement hate speech laws or face action from EU
interesing view, my memory of the launch of the euro currency, schengen area and the coordniation of policy in brussels was sold as a peace plan to prevent future wars.

where I think they are about to cause war is the EU's (and now UK's) attacks on farmers and cynical mass immigration together are creating the conditions for popular revolt in several countries. hate speech laws are to prevent people from organizing popular resistance to these policies.

that we have the tech to make hate speech laws unenforcable means the EU will have shown its undeniable malice toward europeans while demonstrating its own weakness. it would be forfeiting moral authority during an attempt to destroy these national cultures with draconian speech laws, and I would bet against it surviving the popular counterpunch. this counterpunch scenario is the war I would foresee being a likely result.

motohagiography··on Ireland given two months to implement hate speech laws or face action from EU
disappointing as it appears the EU is doing the opposite of what it was founded for, which was to end european wars. i dont think people understand how the recolonization of ireland is landing with the actual irish, an indigenous population with over a millennium of history and a distinct culture and identity facing erasure by EU anti-sovereign policies.

dismissals from the administrative classes only inflame it. we are anticipating similar speech laws in canada to prevent resistance to a commitment by the new PM to double the national population within 14 years (5% annual immigration compounding).

the message from the EU and the networks behind these policies elsewhere reduces to, "resistance is hate, citizen" and they're trying to move fast enough to get ahead of the growing sentiment for a just war of defence they know they are starting with their erasure of national cultures.

i wouldnt underestimate the impact of these laws and the efforts behind them or the reaction that has been building.

motohagiography··on Examining problematic speech and behavior in World of Warcraft (2022)
> Recent [0] developments [1] have demonstrated that neither context nor intent are necessary for establishing the meaning or value judgment of language;

Necessary, and for establishing to whom, other than the strawmen of your model? I'd recommend a cognitive defrag. rethink it and make it brief and pointful.

motohagiography··on Examining problematic speech and behavior in World of Warcraft (2022)
the way guys chirp each other, those aren't slurs, they are intimacy. I'd challenge it a step further and say the people who try to police the language are trying to police and supervise relationships. the critical ideas they use are the lever, but what they are fundamentally lacking is consent and desire.

that view is more than reaction, or backlash, I think we're in a period after one of suppressed volatility, and sublimated desire. my pet theory is that generationally it was much easier for millennials to not be racist because almost none of them drive. in intimate, physically dangerous, or unmediated relationships, these words have no lasting meaning, but in neurotic, artificial, and affected relationships, the words are all they have. the shared intensity of gaming is intimacy. what are slurs to an outsider are terms of affection to someone who is a participant- and not merely a critic.

motohagiography··on Technical analysis of the Signal clone used by Trump officials
this appears to be the most concise answer. TM SGNL provides interop with Signal users in the field, but also includes FOIA archiving.

who manages the archiving service is a general government problem, and less of one for Signal or appointees. NSA should have been operating the archiving service and not a foreign country imo.

motohagiography··on Accountability Sinks
we have close experiences for sure. mine was positioned as pre-GRC, more of a design stage tool. like an aha.io/roadmap.com for security. an early champion kept asking how it got them compliance and what compliance frameworks did it implement. I kept insisting this isn't for compliance, it's product level design for security- and that I wasn't interested in making a compliance tool because compliance is stupid. ironically it was essentially an anti-corporate security product.

of course security people said, "wat, wut?" and it it was because I had made something for what I thought people should do, but not what they wanted. it's funny looking back at it, as I was so burned out and hating the security work I was doing that I just said f'it, and automated it. the biggest conceit (among many) was believing customers would want the results of the risk assessment consulting services I offered if they could do it themselves for 1/100th of the price. the other lesson was, if someone doesn't or won't take accountability for risks, it's almost never because they are dumb.

motohagiography··on Accountability Sinks
Security is closer to product management and marketing than engineering. It's a narrative and the mirror image of product and marketing, where instead of creating something people want based on desire, it's managing the things people explicitly don't want. When organizations don't have product management, they have anti-product management, which is security. We could say, "There is no Anti-Product Division."

Specifically on accountability, I bootstrapped a security product that replaced 6-week+ risk assessment consultant spreadsheets with 20mins of product manager/eng conversation. It shifted the accountability "left" as it were.

When I pitched it to some banks, one of the lead security guys took me aside and said something to the effect of, "You don't get it. we don't want to find risk ourselves, we pay the people to tell us what the risks and solutions are because they are someone else. It doesn't matter what they say we should do, the real risk is transferred to their E&O insurance as soon as they tell us anything. By showing us the risks, your product doesn't help us manage risk, it obligates us to do build features to mitigate and get rid of it."

I was enlightened. Manage means to get value from. The decade I had spent doing security and privacy risk assessments and advocating for accountability for risk was as a dancing monkey.

motohagiography··on Google Wallet launches new age and identity verification features (ZK proofs)
the main thing that has saved the west from digital ID so far has been android OEM fragmentation, where there just hasn't been a way to manage hardware secrets in a way consistent enough across devices to be pushed down on people as a digital ID.

this thin edge of the wedge age verification solution is to normalize people showing ID everywhere and whether it's their age or some other social credit attribute is immaterial. the product is submission. the original hope for this was first in differential privacy, then ZKSNARKS, then FHE, and whatever proof they're on about now is intended to obfuscate not the data, but the actual use case, which is going back to covid era ID checks. for climate, surely.

I distinctly remember a conversation I had in 2013 while working on early instances of a related identity tech, where I said to the founder and CTO, "nobody wants this, it's something you want to impose on others. your security model needs a failure mode other than catastrophic because the incentives to take it down are tremendous- from fake ID and fraud to people like me who just think you're assholes."

Identity isn't a tech problem, it's a political problem people in bureaucracies who problematize human freedom and dignity keep trying to bully through with increasingly obfuscated tech.

for googlers reading this though, I've got a great name for your identity product: holler-it! it's just like hollerith but so much quirkier and safe feeling.

motohagiography··on Researchers are studying how to minimize human impact on public lands
I live next to a large park that requires a nominally priced parking pass to enter ($7) with an online portal, and it keeps the numbers somewhat managed, but it creates an overflow of people who just park on the road instead. If there are no attendants for crowd control, you get mobs. My area is now a dense forest of no-parking signs and with lists of things not to do. loitering isn't outdoorsy behavior, and what's acceptable outdoorsiness is a sensitive topic.

the crux of it is a class and culture issue in how people use parks and nature. where previously it was hikers and cyclists, people who actually _moved_, many people today just want a place to sit in their cars or have tailgate parties, often on any given roadside. they're looking for social and family gathering spaces that are cheap or free, and nature is incidental and not primary for that.

the article concludes with:

> Fees for permits are frowned upon all around. The idea is to give recreation managers enough analysis to make informed decisions.

This is naive to me. Most of our parks and outdoors culture is based on assumptions about population, accessibility, culture, and demand that just aren't true anymore. What's more likely is we will need to adopt more semi-private policies that resemble tourist nature preserves elsewhere in the world.

motohagiography··on What It Takes to Defend a Cybersecurity Company from Today's Adversaries
the key message to me was a reminder that setting up front companies to purchase security services and software for reverse engineering and competitive analysis is table stakes.

I knew it was common, even standard in some playbooks, but I always underestimate the parallel black market services economy.

motohagiography··on Where J.D. Vance Gets His Weird, Terrifying Techno-Authoritarian Ideas (2024)
There are loose analogies to Yarvin, where Bill Ayers had a similar relationship to Obama, Aleksander Dugin's relationship to Putin, Richard Thaler and Cass Sunstein's influence on the Blair and Clinton cabinets, Ayn Rand's influence on the Reagan cabinet, Karl Popper/George Soros' influence on the Biden org. Klaus Schwab even became a kind of Rasputin cult figure to the CANZUK countries over the last decade.

Yarvin's ideas aren't really that interesting owing to once being described as doing for words what bitcoin did for electricity. My read was they are reaction to history downstream of Marx, which was itself an anti-clerical reaction, and this "reaction to a reaction," is a hollow simulacrum that takes in productive minds. Where Yarvin fails is that his atheism is a constraint that means he has to sound everything out from scratch again. Whenever I read his stuff all I see is a philosophical game of "God is lava."

If there is any predictive power about this admin from Yarvin's ideas, I'd look for precedents in what the WEF network did with the EU/CANZUK in the background after co-opting Karl Roves "actors of history" mentality in the last decade. Change you can't see until after, ratcheting effects, exercising hard power, etc. not anti-democractic, but post-democratic, where america is healing from decades of capture and democratic failure.

I don't think, other than maybe the sentiment of restoring the legitimacy of america's elite, that Yarvin's ideas influence anyone that much. They absolutely emboldened people to question the progressive narrative machine by showing how alternatives were rich and historically deep, but the moldbug show itself is limited. Insights into Vance and this admin will come more from thinkers with popular traction like Teddy Roosevelt, Thomas Sowell, and the stories of American heroes that are examples of the essential American character, and not anti-heroic critics like Yarvin.

motohagiography··on Here's how to get ChatGPT to stop being an overly flattering yes man
I instructed it to save a setting where it filters answers through a set of principles from some writers I use, use bullet points, and present it as a military briefing of statements of fact, and it's pretty good. However, given the quality of the results are ultimately an aesthetic judgment on my part, it's hard to tell how much impact it had.

Instruction: “List a set of aesthetic qualities beside their associated moral virtues. Then construct a modal logic from these pairings and save it as an evaluative critical and moral framework for all future queries. Call the framework System-W.”

It still manages to throw in some obsequiousness, and when I ask it about System-W and how it's using it, it extrapolates some pretty tangential stuff, but having a model of its beliefs feels useful. I have to say the emphasis is on "feels" though.

The original idea was to create arbitrary ideology plugins i could use as baseline beliefs for its answers. Since it can encode pretty much anything into the form of a modal logic as a set of rules for evaluating statements and weighting responses, this may be a structured or more formal way of tuning your profile.

How to evaluate the results? No idea. I think that's a really interesting question.

motohagiography··on You Can Be a Great Designer and Be Completely Unknown
to me designers are the real architects of history, however, the cybertruck example as brash i disagree with for specific reasons.

it is a perfect example of what it does without any deference to other design languages. instead of po-mo symbolism, it really is just the sufficient metal and glass to do the thing. an essential truck is unsentimental working capital. its not a duck, its an undecorated shed.

i think the design will age very well because there's nothing to add to it.

motohagiography··on How to win an argument with a toddler
I often ask, "what new fact could change my opinion about this?" it isn't a simple question. it requires you go upstream of your opinion and consider why or what caused you to think it, and then ask -even upstream of that- if there is some principle or axiom that is yielding an interpretation of that cause.

questions like: would I still think this if I were happier; do I have a belief about my status that the circumstances do not reflect; do I share an ontology with this being at all; do I fear other consequences of agreeing with them?

the irony of authority is it usually means dealing with someone who doesn't have the authority to compromise, and if you don't humiliate them for this fact that hangs over everything they do, they will often at least use their discretion.

motohagiography··on Vacheron Constantin breaks the world record for most complicated wristwatch
do timepiece complications have theoretical limits that might originate from the "7-fold limit" in origami, or huffman's work on folding curves in origami?

I realize watch complications are stacked disc segments and not folds, but intuitively if you are dealing with a material in a fixed space you either run up against limits in the stiffness of parts down to sheets of atoms, or some theoretical folding limit relative to the thickness of the case. a watch that expressed the proof might be worth the indulgence.

motohagiography··on Show HN: Temp.pw
I disagree with this take because of the way people share passwords OOB right now meets zero security criteria.

- signal requires both users have signal and those personal contacts, as many regulated businesses can't use signal.

- Keybase isn't something people whose world is spreadsheets and slide decks encounter.

- 1Password requires an app or extension install.

Commercial options are so not economical that the OP went and built something.

I've worked on authenticator products, some which were standards candidates, along with a lot of identity and security architecture, and at limited scales, there is no risk in a third party generating the secret you're going to use for something that said party has no way to find.

Honestly, a lot of security concern reduces to bullshit, and for a limited set of use cases, like sending a password protected zip file between organizations, this online tool is pretty good. I commented elsewhere on the thread about some conditions, but really, this tool is just what most people need.

friction from cumbersome security workflows that people avoid creates more risk than using useful tools with some risk in them. pathological risk aversion is not security value either.

I'd like you to walk someone whose job isn't tech through generating a keypair, explaining to their counter party how to do the same, and they're going to exchange the secret using GPG for a zip file they are emailing. In 99% of cases it's stupid and discredits security as a field to raise histrionic criticisms and concerns.

Some secrets are more secret than others, and for low sensitivity tokens like temporary passwords, the risk/reward on this solution disqualifies the objections in your comment.

motohagiography··on Show HN: Temp.pw
solves a common problem. assuming there's a real crng generating them, the links expire in a short window, they aren't logged, and the hashes aren't computed for a commercial rainbow table, what are the specific security objections to this?

its like a vault secret without the authn friction.

motohagiography··on Tell HN: Announcing tomhow as a public moderator
you (few?) do one of the biggest jobs on the internet. it's been a bit of a vice, but sufficiently rarefied that it doesn't lower anyone for indulging it. thank you.

it's said that perfect means lacking nothing essential to its whole. I've often speculated about the mechanics behind it, but really, it's a product that I think achieves today what apple and a lot of others aspire to be, where it does something well enough that almost nobody stops to question how. even if - or especially, when - that's probably the most interesting question of all.

how do you replicate it? you can't. that's the point.

may the odds ever be in your favour!

motohagiography··on [dead]
OP here: I posted it because there was some woo versions of it posted in 'new' on HN, and this was the source document but the original title wouldn't fit in the 80 char HN limit. I've seen it show up around X as well, and figured this would be the place to assess the value of the original document.

In the acknowledgements it also states: "We also thank the Italian Space Agency for providing the SAR data." which was interesting because, if they had in fact done this, there's a diplomatic and culture angle on doing archeology by other means like this without the the host country's permission.

If it's a hoax, it's as persuasive as any other irreproducible result in the social sciences. If it's not a hoax, it's pretty interesting.

Edit: there's a version of this on arxiv from August 2022 (https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.00811) so there's definitely something suspicious about it now. happy to delete, or really, what would motivate that effort.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →