HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mplanchard

5,132 karma · joined April 5, 2019

https://blog.mplanchard.com/
submissionscomments
mplanchard··on Google changes its search box
Thanks, I will do that
mplanchard··on Google changes its search box
I know a lot of regular people who hate this, but Kagi can be a hard sell for regular people. What are y’all’s recommendations for free search engines at the moment? I used to rec DDG, but I feel like their results are much worse than Kagi’s at present
mplanchard··on Photo GIMP – A Patch for GIMP 3 for Photoshop Users
When I first started using emacs, I bounced off of spacemacs because it was all very unfamiliar and confusing, with a lot of its own terminology added on to emacs’. I tried again later with doom emacs and, maybe because of some familiarity gained in the spacemacs run, managed to make it stick.

A year or two ago, I ditched doom and rolled my own emacs config, having gained the necessary knowledge and confidence to do so from my years with doom.

Both doom and spacemacs exist to make the (relatively) strange nature of emacs more welcoming to users of other IDEs. I’m not sure I would have stuck with it without them, so I’m not sure the hard way is always better.

mplanchard··on Consider the Sister
This is a beautiful and moving piece of writing. Thanks for the share.
mplanchard··on I love Linux, but I can't quit Windows
Yeah, similar experience here. One pattern that was helpful for us was defining a nix file that just contained a mapping of names to lists of packages: dev, ci, and so on, so that if you wanted to install something that was on the nix search page, you could just go toss it in there and immediately get it locally. It also made it clear which package sets would wind up where, and allowed recursion so you could say that like dev was rust-base ++ rust-dev ++ js ++ common, or whatever.
mplanchard··on I love Linux, but I can't quit Windows
We used nix for developer environments, and nix to define docker containers for our production services. The biggest problem is the “nix people” can become blockers if there is an issue and they aren’t around to figure it out, because most engineers are just not going to learn nix.

However, we felt the benefit was worth the cost, overall, especially because we used the same flakes and therefore versions across all dev and deployed envs, and we didn’t have to deal with the hassle and performance issues of running all the dev services in docker containers.

mplanchard··on Cisco workforce reductions
At least for our team, quite low. We had a very comfortable buffer, which allowed us to deliver in time to coordinate with the rest of the org. It may not have been a bad strategy overall from the top-down perspective, but it wasn’t a lot of fun as an IC
mplanchard··on Rewrite Bun in Rust has been merged
Bun is owned by anthropic. They get infinite tokens, and anthropic gets a fluffy PR piece slash advertisement.
mplanchard··on Cisco workforce reductions
Yeah I mean, I was being a bit sarcastic. As the sibling points out, I was getting paid a full time salary to largely do whatever I wanted. But, it was also soul crushing to have so little meaningful work to do. I left within a year of the acquisition as a result.

The actual job was working on a python server for the acquired company, and it’s not like there wasn’t more work to do, but we were not allowed to go outside the bounds of the work that had been allocated for a sprint, which was always conservative in order to allow for more accurate overall plans. It’s certain that it was different in other departments or areas or acquired companies, but that at least was my experience.

mplanchard··on Cisco workforce reductions
I briefly worked for Cisco after an acquisition, and it was a great time: I would get my sprint’s worth of work done in two days, ask if I could do anything else and be told no, and then spend the rest of the two weeks doing whatever I wanted, which at the time was learning Rust.

All that is to say, I would not be remotely surprised if Cisco has more employees than they strictly need. But, this email from the CEO is comically out of touch. “We’re doing great, better than we’ve ever done, so we’re going to fire thousands of you” is a chef’s kiss encapsulation of American corporate culture.

mplanchard··on The limits of Rust, or why you should probably not follow Amazon and Cloudflare
100% agree with your take, speaking as a professional async rust writer for like five years now.

I’ll add to it that structured concurrency patterns in async Rust can be legitimately awesome and very fun, once you’ve bounced off the traits in the futures crate enough times to use it in anger. The type system can be annoying, but as usual, it’s almost always technically right, and once you understand the ownership flow required for your nifty chain of future combinators, is not too too bad.

mplanchard··on Software Developers Say AI Is Rotting Their Brains
And how many managers are on the line for incidents?
mplanchard··on “I applied to be pope”: Losing grip on reality while using ChatGPT
Dawkins is too busy falling in love with his AI girlfriend to care: https://unherd.com/2026/05/is-ai-the-next-phase-of-evolution...
mplanchard··on “I applied to be pope”: Losing grip on reality while using ChatGPT
The fact that we as a society are allowing things like “Delve” or whatever the “AI psychiatrist” app is that I see ads for sometimes on the subway is a gross abdication of responsibility and reason. Of all the possible uses for LLMs, that has got to be one of the most out and out irresponsible and dangerous ones I could imagine.
mplanchard··on Learning Software Architecture
It’s tangential to your point, which I agree with completely, but this is also exactly why I get so frustrated with the idea that higher education is about acquiring job skills. Ideally, regardless of major, a university teaches you how to think, critically and deeply, and how to learn. If you have those things, job skills are easy to pick up, but instead we treat college like an RPG skill tree, where you’ve got to put points into your intended career path in order to unlock the skills you’ll need to do the job.

Edit: although I do think university focus is important for subjects that are less about job skills and more about knowledge synthesis, such as most sciences, critical analysis, and so on, if you intend to not just do a job but contribute to the overall knowledge base of the field.

mplanchard··on A HN post with negative points – how?
I have not hit it yet, if there is one. Only options are upvoting, flagging, etc.
mplanchard··on Postmortem: TanStack NPM supply-chain compromise
I like a lot about nix, and this is one of those things: built derivations are addressed by the hash of their inputs: without changing something about the inputs, you (barring bugs) cannot get an incorrect or poisoned cache artifact
mplanchard··on Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career
I used to think this, and I’m sure there are plenty of bad architects who add net-negative value, but having worked on some extremely difficult systems as an IC, I would have given anything to have future me able to hand down a scalable architecture from on high, vetted by past experience and domain familiarity.

Not having that, I developed the knowledge myself through trial and error, but we would have saved a lot of time, money, and stress doing it right the first time.

In general, I think this kind of “architect bad” take underestimates the cost and the stress of being responsible for a system that ultimately isn’t a great fit for the domain, and needing to balance hacking another fix onto it vs migrating to what now know is the right thing.

mplanchard··on The One Dollar Counterfeiter
I don’t get a paywall for this even in private browsing. Just me somehow?
mplanchard··on Bun's experimental Rust rewrite hits 99.8% test compatibility on Linux x64 glibc
Yeah, totally unrelated to LLMs, this has definitely happened to me when changing core types or interfaces in our large rust codebase.

However, a) I think the compiler telling me everywhere I need to fix it is great, and b) even before LLMs, using compile mode with emacs and setting up a macro to jump to next clippy warning, jump to code, fix, and then repeating in batches of like 20-50 could often make it go quite fast.

mplanchard··on The One Dollar Counterfeiter
If you want to know more, there is a much better and very entertainingly written series of articles about this, from a 1949 issue of the New Yorker: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/1949/08/27/old-eight-eigh...
mplanchard··on Hardening Firefox with Claude Mythos Preview
It would be amazing if we didn’t have to have this conversation on every single thread about anything related to Firefox.

Firefox/Mozilla tries literally anything to expand their feature set, customer base, or revenue stream? They need to stop spending money on that and instead spend money on the free product of theirs that I care about, in exactly the way I want.

Google surveilles the entire world, spends huge amounts on lobbying, degrades their own websites on other browsers? Not a peep, usually.

For my part, I pay mozilla for their VPN service, which I’m sure many here would decry as useless spending that should be going to firefox instead.

mplanchard··on When everyone has AI and the company still learns nothing
There are a lot of potential reasons.

Here’s a thought: consider the potentially analogous case of performance-enhancing drugs for athletes. The drugs unambiguously make them better at their jobs, but the drugs have severe long-term health costs and wreak havoc on the fairness of the playing field. It’s easy to see why an athlete might choose not to use them, even when others are.

Of course, those negative factors alone are not enough to dissuade people en masse who want to get a leg up on their competitors, so the use of performance-enhancing drugs must be further restricted by institutional bans.

mplanchard··on 'Point of no return': New Orleans relocation must start now due to sea level
Most of my family is there, and I spent much of my childhood there. I have the same feeling as you. It’s such a beautiful, unique place, and I don’t think the locals will ever abandon it. City park with those beautiful oak trees will always be one of my favorite places on earth.
mplanchard··on Three Inverse Laws of AI
Something that bothers me about the intentional anthropormorphization of the LLM interface is that it asks me to conflate a tool with a sentient being.

The firm expectations and lack of patience I have for any failings in most of my tools would be totally inappropriate to apply to another human being, and yet here I am asked to interact with this tool as though it were a person. The only options are either to treat the tool in a way that feels "wrong," or to be "kind" to the tool, and I think you see people going both ways.

I worry that, if I get used to being impatient and short with the AI, some of that will bleed into my textual interactions with other people.

mplanchard··on Async Rust never left the MVP state
Some of the burnout no doubt being due to the catastrophizing of every decision by the community and the extreme rhetoric used across the board.

Great to see people wanting to get involved with the project, though. That’s the beauty of open source: if it aggravates you, you can fix it.

mplanchard··on Introduction to Atom
I hand-rolled an atom feed for my statically generated blog. It’s a reasonable, easy format to work with.
mplanchard··on A couple million lines of Haskell: Production engineering at Mercury
I read most of your comment as phrasing the things that make rust unique as being additional burdens relative to what you would prefer, which is fair, but often they are what I appreciate about the language. Explicit result types are a great example.

Rigidity is a trade off: it can make initial development slower but refactors significantly easier, just as an example.

I don’t think any of your examples show it to be niche. It operates well in most of the space where C++ is a good option, and a bit beyond that (embedded, firmware, but also higher level things where you want performance but don’t want to worry about memory safety).

mplanchard··on A couple million lines of Haskell: Production engineering at Mercury
“I’m not going to use Rust because I don’t like it” seems like what you’re saying, which is totally fine. Plenty of people, myself included, manage to write and enjoy writing general application code in Rust. You’re allowed to not get it, just like I’m allowed to dislike writing C++.
mplanchard··on VS Code inserting 'Co-Authored-by Copilot' into commits regardless of usage
Oh yeah sorry, I was being sarcastic. I think it’s hilariously bad, but I also avoid MS products like the plague as a rule.
← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →