HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mr_tristan

1,282 karma · joined October 3, 2015

Greybeard engineer
submissionscomments
mr_tristan··on Why isn’t new technology making us more productive?
I suspect the hyperactive hivemind culture that's been one result of new technology. Sure, there's a lot more passive consumption going on, but really, what I see is a non-stop communication stream where nobody really gets to that moment to really let the mind rest and get properly bored to put together the bigger ideas.

When I try to isolate, even for a couple of hours, I get criticized by coworkers or my spouse about not responding quickly. So I end up spending my time mostly communicating or trying to get back on track. It's rather sad.

Ideally AI could offload these constant distractions, so unnecessary communications just don't need everyone's immediate response. But, well, I'll believe it when I see it

mr_tristan··on Pop culture has become an oligopoly
This sure seems to be what happens when the long tail runs into the paradox of choice.

One thing I've noticed, it is now way easier to create content over this time period as well.

I now have a camera that can record beautiful 8K video, I can produce high-quality music records, and I don't have to rent or hire anyone. I've got a CNC that can crank out perfect templates for my woodworking. But there are now millions of others who can (and are) doing the same thing.

And thus, it's stupidly easy to find something new, but it's hard to find something new and consistently good. So we just gravitate to the proven because, ugh, our free time is valuable.

My only sense is that the oligopoly will persist, and probably become even more focused. But the "1000 true fans" approach for small-time producers is still the best way forward. Don't even bother trying to compete with big-time media, just try to build strong connections, thus being a "trusted" choice.

mr_tristan··on Preventing Burnout: A Manager's Toolkit
My main sources of burnout these days are: 1. useless information overload, and 2. lack of focus time. And it's rare that I've actually met a manager who could even see this as a problem.

My main way to deal with this: just ignore 99% of my incoming notifications. The only notifications I need are "SLA is broken". Everything else should just be low priority async systems, and honestly, email worked pretty well for this but everyone just loves using Slack or a similar tool now.

And the entire business loves to work against you too...

Most of my managers have just loved throwing juniors into the mix with no structure on how they'll be mentored - just let the senior engineers figure it out. Ergo, I now have to periodically check Slack and review notifications again just to make sure none of the juniors reached out.

Oh, and don't forget the other random people who grabbed your name from delivering a bug fix six months ago and just want to check on a thing "real quick" or ask a "small" question.

Modern office communication is a clusterfuck, and probably contributes more to stress and reduces productivity more than any other aspect of work. And trying to remedy this as an individual contributor is usually unsustainable. It's a management problem, and sadly, this "management toolkit" gleefully avoids this.

mr_tristan··on Today’s creator economy was built on subscribers and patrons – what comes next?
Recently, I've started getting into Youtube again, but following a couple of different hobbies much more closely; woodworking/making, and photography. What you describe is echoed by a few of them, namely, they do not really attempt to make a sole living purely off of Youtube. Instead, Youtube is kind of a marketing channel for them with auxiliary advertising revenue.

Basically, they sound a lot like you, in that they're all running a small business, typically as opposed to pure client work. But I don't think any of them see Youtube as a basis of their revenue; it's more of just another marketing channel.

A couple of different takes on this:

- Sean Tucker, photography: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dI02c5DnRUg - Lincoln St Woodworks: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fDxs5Y13rlk

I suspect the best generalization is the "1000 true fans" approach, where they're just trying to use different media to just contact those true fans. And build a business around that interaction, and just monetize everything else they can

mr_tristan··on Just say no to :latest
Pinning can be far less painful with tooling to review and manage all the changes. One example would be the Maven versions plugin: you can use it to query "what's been updated", update to next release, etc. The list of goals is pretty explanatory, and a good starting point: https://www.mojohaus.org/versions-maven-plugin/

When evaluating new toolchains, I often ask myself "what is the versions plugin equivalent here". There's often commercial offerings that help this process out.

Dependency management is one of these topics that rarely gets attention until much later in the ecosystem's lifetime. So chances are you'll need to find or create tooling to fill gaps.

I mean, you can do the whole "damn the torpedos and see what breaks" approach, but, I'd prefer a way to review changes. And I'd prefer doing those updates _separate_ from other changes.

mr_tristan··on Write plain text files
I think of it as "content and presentation should be as independent as possible". This is the content side: don't bother with fancy unreadable formats.

I've been thinking about this as I try to think about my own personal website. I'd like to have my content versioned, but, was really not loving the idea of tying myself to even a static website generator.

This is where I still ponder an approach more like antora (https://antora.org), where you can have a "doc repo" vs a "site repository". Thus, the concept of a version is really obvious.

I've also recently reorganized my professional notes into... a git repo that is only structured markdown files, one file per day, organized by year/month. And... it just works great.

mr_tristan··on Can Slack-mania be cured with systemized discipline?
Was about to recommend this, too. Newport's description of the "hyperactive hive mind" is almost dead on what this author is calling "Slack-mania". And Newport shows this is much bigger in scope than just the introduction of Slack or MS Teams. New technologies have repeatedly created way too many points of communication now that it's so easy to, well, communicate with anyone.

I found his observations about needing to separate specialist time from support-style time to be very intriguing.

mr_tristan··on What we lost
Yes, it's very much the expectation that I need to somehow be immediately available that makes it rude. I don't know how many times I have to respond, "Hi! Do you have a question? If you want to chat, feel free to schedule some time on my calendar, I'm free most of the day."
mr_tristan··on What we lost
To be honest, I think this is a sign that the company really isn't experimenting, and probably won't figure out how to stay fully remote post-pandemic.

The best thing my company did was host a single "async week". Absolutely no video calls, only async. A lot of communication shifted after that week.

For example, my group has eradicated "round robin" calls, where individuals share their status or whatever. Instead, you create a card on a doc that's mostly a kanban board. That card just links to notes in another doc. So... we basically have an agenda system that: a.) keeps regular meetings on point quickly, and b.) keeps notes of what's been decided. We wouldn't have figured this out without ripping off the band-aid and forcing everyone to do it differently for a week.

mr_tristan··on What we lost
> A video conference is a sterile dehumanizing experience. A good in-person meeting is pure jazz. Its elegant sparring between those who care deeply about the things they are building, and watching and participating in this banter is one of the joys of my professional career.

This gave me a chuckle. After 20+ years in the business, the "pure jazz" in-person meetings vs "complete waste of time" in-person meeting ratio was, I don't know, 1:100. I can think of maybe 2 or 3 out of the last several years before the pandemic that were really consequential.

There are great reasons to meet and hash things out, but honestly, if everyone's in the office, I've found that it's a green light for lazy managers to work out communication and team build by... having more meetings. Not running them well, not writing any actual decision down, just having a meeting and thinking it's progress.

My main hope is that people use this remote-first time to really learn how to write and share writing. But, if I end up just getting people to learn how to start a Slack DM with a question instead of just "Hi! Are you there?", well, that will also be progress.

mr_tristan··on Poll: Do you prefer the office or work from home?
I've been fully remote since 2017. It's not just about personal convenience. The fully remote teams I've been a part of tend to have far more efficient meetings. I've now pushed status checks or round robin style stuff to Slack workflows. Every meeting I go to in this "good" remote world has an agenda, and generally good discussions. And I actually feel like more of a part of large organizations.

Yeah, we are planning proper "meatspace" get togethers, which will help gel the team more. But that's 2-4x a year. I don't think that needs to happen a lot to really reap some social benefits.

For everyone seeking more social interaction; just go find it locally, outside of work.

I guess I'm fully in the camp of work being intense, but time bound. And that's what remote work affords me, though I've learned to draw the lines between my work time and my personal time starkly. Once you get it right, office environments feel like such a drag in comparison.

mr_tristan··on Ask HN: How do you deal with getting old and feeling lost?
I agree with all of this, and just want to add a note about mental health; take your stress levels seriously and learn to know your triggers.

While most of us working in tech tend to live pretty cushy lives, but, we are surrounded by silly frustrations and limitless distractions that can sum up and become pretty stressful. Learning to spot, "I'm getting stressed" and finding some way of mitigating this is really important. It changes your mood dramatically.

Interestingly, the three things the parent mentions are actually all good ways of mitigating stress.

A second note: you don't have to do "running" or aerobic exercise if it ain't your thing. I see a lot of people think "exercise" means go running or biking, something aerobic. I tend to think, if you need music to get you "in the mood" to work out, it's probably not your thing. Just experiment. I eventually found olympic weightlifting. I'm now significantly fitter than I was in my 20s as well. The best exercise is the one you feel inspired to keep up with naturally.

Finally, learn to experiment without needing to be "amazing". Just do it for the fun. The whole "Get Back" series about the Beatles was eye-opening for a lot of people, mostly because of how mundane it really was. I don't think McCartney or Lennon ever sat down to write a "profound" song, they just scratched an itch, over and over again.

mr_tristan··on Adobe tricks users into a 12 month contract
Subscription models are great for professionals (and companies), but amateurs, a single year of the Adobe Photoshop + Lightroom bundle is over 2x what a perpetual Affinity Photo license costs. (I just wish Serif came out with a photo management product, but in the meantime, it's not too bad to use digiKam for some management and `aws s3 sync` to back photos up in an s3 bucket.)

What's sad is that it was not easy to even see that there's still a Photoshop Elements product these days with a one time price, though I have no idea what the support is, and what upgrades cost. I had to search around to find it. It costs $99, though there's sales and bundles yada yada yada. The Adobe "comparison" page (which I still don't know how to navigate to) just seems like they want to funnel everyone into the subscription offering: https://www.adobe.com/creativecloud/photography/photoshop-vs... It seems like Elements would be the "hobbyist" license, the subscription model would be the pro version, but it's very, very not clear.

The product that gets subscriptions right is Autodesk Fusion 360. There's a Personal Use tier that's free, which provides pretty much all the features you need for most hobbyist style 3D design and CNC usage. You need the serious features, you pay the expensive license, but, you're probably making money at this point, so it's a necessary tool. Fusion 360 changed it's licensing in 2020 which confused a lot of people, but really, they used to have a "startup license" or "personal use" license that was really vague, and I think was being taken advantage of by actual businesses. It's just simpler now, and I think it's more obvious.

mr_tristan··on The 4-day week is flawed – workers still want it
I've worked at a couple of companies now that introduce a "month off" day, which isn't tied to a particular holiday. At one place, they made it a "use it or lose it; your choice", so typically the last Friday of the month became an unofficial holiday. At my current place, it's preselected to be a day everyone takes off together.

When this was introduced at one company, they noticed that "sick days" actually dropped massively, to the point it really cost them nothing to introduce month off days.

Personally, it's amazing what that one day does for your mental health. You just pile on chores or take an extra day off, and boom - 4 day weekend which feels like a real vacation. And because everyone realistically is off together, you're not missing much.

I kind of see the 4 day week as an amplified version of the month off day, and would be curious to see if there's any comparison between the two ideas. And I'd be curious what the frequency of "sick days" taken are in a 4-day week company vs a 5-day company

mr_tristan··on The case against masks at school
The CDC is not so much asleep at the wheel, we just don't have any kind of coherent public health system in the USA. There's basically an independent public health officer for practically every county, and there's very little coordination between them and the CDC.

Michael Lewis' book "The Premonition" is eye-opening to how dysfunctional public health is in the US.

And it's not like he's alone, even the head of the CDC this week called for a reform of the public health system in the US (https://www.politico.com/news/2022/01/21/rochelle-walensky-c...). The only picture I'm getting is that the CDC doesn't really feel like they can do anything.

mr_tristan··on Is old music killing new music?
I'm not convinced the arguments in this article are really the cause. We're in an era where musicians have to build a following by means other than their music.

I'm just not sure how an aspiring musician would connect and build a young audience outside of social media. I doubt they could consistently build engagement in a streaming platform alone, it's just too hard. They're just one recording along with decades of other recordings.

The social media era hasn't really included musicians very well. I can't really think of a single case where I discovered music via social media. And I'm not even sure how I'd go about finding it. A lot of this is just that the music industry itself is kind of small and insignificant to big tech. And it's not like any of these platforms want to send people to streamers like Spotify or Apple Music.

mr_tristan··on How do you visualize code?
I'd be curious what you're working on, or if you have any links that are shareable.

This is a truly hard thing to do. I sometimes use visualization plugins in IDEs, or hand roll visualizations. For example, spit out an HTML page that basically lays out up some textarea columns with sample data between code. But it's usually really, really ad hoc. And of course, very company confidential so I can't share much...

I'm also curious about using something like this d3-graphiz project to, say, animate a sequence diagram: https://github.com/magjac/d3-graphviz - just haven't gotten around to it yet (the demo seems like it could be handy: https://bl.ocks.org/magjac/4acffdb3afbc4f71b448a210b5060bca)

mr_tristan··on How do you visualize code?
I find that programming languages are themselves a great reference... for the logic of a single thread. The moment you start doing concurrent development, or hell, even basic event-driven code, it gets much harder to "just read along". This is where I would kill for visualizations to help out.

Like, if you fork your process at a point, vertically split the text into two columns with a line saying "new thread over here". And then highlight any points of synchronization.

I think when people think of visualizations, it's "everything is a 2D graphic". When really, there could be new ways to laying out and navigating text-based source.

mr_tristan··on Poll: Why are people leaving their jobs?
Left about 6 months ago, and was basically shocked at the compensation bump I got. As someone full time remote since 2017, working at the latest place since 2018, it felt like a new world looking for a job in 2021. So many more options, which basically makes it a job-seekers market.

But while the compensation bump is nice, the thing that got me seeking was the company itself. After an acquisition by VMWare, I watched it deteriorate over a year or two. To make anything happen, you had to basically go into "hero mode" working tons of hours, etc. And then you'd see pretty incompetent managers, the kind that treat engineers like cogs, continue to get promoted. Oh, and add no real clear direction on the products themselves.

So I guess that's "company culture"? I think there's a lot of people in this bucket, where "too much stupid at the current place" plus "lots of opportunity" means it's time to look around.

mr_tristan··on “I am literally losing sleep” over Java (1996)
I think it's the core, the 2D engine, just never got the love it needed to be a great place to start. Nobody seemed to prioritize making that happen.

Like, the antialiasing was noticably fuzzy. I never found an applet that looked like it belonged on the webpage. And when I built a few, it was a lot of work to even get font rendering to not be horrendous. And even then, you'd see what the browser rendered vs what the applet rendered and they were always off. I remember using images instead of font rendering sometimes.

So, if you made a swing app, it was easy to put together, but hard to make look "professional".

By the time of the Oracle acquisition, I'm pretty sure everyone just realized the browser and mobile "won" and that's why we just had JavaFX get broken off the platform and basically put out to pasture. But it's not like much went into the core platform itself to make building great UIs easy. The underlying 2D rendering just a great place to start.

I mean, even today, there's some serious performance issues with IntelliJ on 4k monitors with scaling. https://youtrack.jetbrains.com/issue/JBR-526

When I look at where JetBrains is going, it sure seems like they are building on top of a better 2D engine, in this case, skia: https://github.com/JetBrains/skija.

mr_tristan··on Facebook said my article was false – now the fact-checkers admit they were wrong
Fact checking just seems like another business we haven't hired to solve a problem generated by the platform itself. I find that the problem here isn't fact checking, it's just the control of these private social media platforms is too broad.

This points to why there needs to be a clearer mechanism of rights for an individual's content. Meta owns a free license to not only repost your work, but also to modify and generate derivative works from it. What I don't understand is what they own when it comes to public content shared via links. Given the success of AMP, I suspect the answer is "you don't own much of anything on the internet".

DRM so far has been successful at allowing content generators to counteract the control of content providers. I sometimes wonder if we need easier personal DRM. Then, if some provider decides to misrepresent you, you can just yank the license. Or at least, there should be some kind of contract between the license holder and the provider.

Maybe web3 helps here? I'm still leery of putting all your eggs in a centralized blockchain system. But other than PDFs, I can't think of other approaches you can take.

mr_tristan··on You can't lure employees back to the office
I will never go back to a team that's even partially "colocated" because I've found, that when the team gets async right, it's enormously annoying to go back.

But, as someone who has experienced full time work in a couple of different places, let me start by saying it is hard to get right. A ton of process has been built up in a sync world, like, most of your agile process recommendations. So you have to approach async with a constant experimentation, and question all the "best practices" of the past.

A few observations that work well:

1. Slack workflows are your friends for stuff like status checks, or cross-team communication. 2. Have meetings regularly (like, daily), but, have a clear agenda.

If you ever have a meeting that's a "round robin" sort of thing, that's a giant red flag for me. Every time I've gotten people used to a daily Slack thread for "my status" it's gone really well. And any other meeting it just makes it better to offload that kind of thing.

At the same time, meetings are useful, if they have a good agenda. Managing a regular meeting agenda is tricky. What I've found that works well is to have some kind of kanban-like tool where anyone can propose a topic. Then you just go through any of the open topics until you're out of time. We usually pair the kanban board with a meeting notes document that we can cross link to for each topic. Then, any follow ups or whatever can just be tracked.

If you smooth out the communication like this, a lot of the interpersonal connnections, morale and spontaneous interaction problems get fixed. The dynamic will never be like having everyone together, but, I've noticed that the meetings I attend are actually useful. Which is 99% of the reason I will never, ever, join a company that wants me physically located again.

What's still not clear to me is exactly how to build broader cross-team connections. I suspect the right way to do this is to actually just move teams every 12-24 months.

mr_tristan··on To secure the supply chain, you must properly fund it
I found this article and discussion to be a bit deeper: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28539185

I'm not really convinced security issues in open source libraries is a funding problem. Sure, sometimes money might help, but it might also just be used to add unnecessary features. I really see a management problem.

Additionally, how many projects have you worked on that does any analysis of it's dependencies? I've found it to be rare. I can count on one hand the number of developers I've met that bothered to learn commands to list their dependencies. Most have no idea that there exists tooling to say, "hey, there's something new".

Seems like we need just better understanding and prioritization of "ecosystem health". And it probably starts with just more users paying attention to what they're using. Maybe it's publishing clearer MTTR statistics, or better security updates, or all of the above. But it seems like we should all start with shoring up our own processes and workflows, instead of just saying "just find someone to give money to".

mr_tristan··on What happens to developers who never go into management?
FWIW I found this book to be a better survey of ways an experienced dev can take their career: https://staffeng.com/book

This article seems a little flippant. I’ve found very few “specialists”, personally, or legacy coders. Most of the time experienced devs tend to become leads or architects. Sometimes leads do management, sometimes not.

I’ve been an engineer for over 20 years now, and I’m definitely seeing more places defining very senior IC positions now than when I started. But I don’t know it will ever be super consistent.

Everything, such as where I work or my career trajectory, is quite fluid. I’ve realized and accepted as a more experienced dev, I am the one that has to lead the transition to, say, driving new product or technical directions instead of management. And I need to be at a place where I can make that happen. So far, that’s never been a static, predictable situation; but largely because of how the business itself is. In the last 10 years, a major company event, such as an acquisition, or a major leadership change like the CEO quitting, completely shifted the dynamics of the org. Usually negatively. So, I read the tea leaves, see if I have any ability to drive good directions. When the answer has been no, I move on to the next one.

Basically I’m seeing a lot of people expecting structure where there won’t be. Nobody will pave a clear career trajectory for you after about a decade. So I find it’s more important to ask “how can I negotiate what I want here” instead of “what title will I have”.

mr_tristan··on Ask HN: Skill you want to learn in 2022?
You might want to look up carpentry, instead of woodworking. They're actually pretty different in skills and approach.

It's like, with woodworking, step one is often "make everything perfectly square". In carpentry, nothing will ever be square. So you just have pretty different problems to solve

mr_tristan··on Ask HN: Was Your Turkey Dry?
Spatchcocked my first turkey yesterday, which I cooked in a pellet grill; came out great.

I usually do that with my chicken, which also comes out nicely, so I guess I was pretty used to it. But it's honestly pretty easy, and I agree, much faster to cook well.

My other real tip is to just spatchcock and season the skin night before and let the skin dry out in the fridge. Makes for nice, crispy skin. I drizzled butter over the skin twice during the cook, and the color came out beautifully

I also used an injection for the first time instead of brining, which was easy.

I suspect I could have cranked up the heat and got this 14 1/2 lb bird cooked in 3 1/2 hours, no problem. It actually feels quite forgiving.

mr_tristan··on What's the Future of IDEs?
I suspect there needs to be some newer patterns in open source build systems that help the cloud-based IDEs become a "thing".

It's the build systems that give me confidence that my IDE choice isn't some permanent lock-in. I almost always add .gitignore rules to never check in preferences from anything made by JetBrains, and you know what? It always seems to work fine. For example, my Java project structures are defined by Maven and Gradle, not IntelliJ. IntelliJ uses those conventions.

For this to _really_ take off, I sense we just need to be able to bounce offline or online if we want to. And the way that's going to happen is just via the build system defining the structure and workflow.

This could happen, but it requires a lot of build work that I don't see happening right now. At least, not in the open

mr_tristan··on I test in prod
I'm not really sure I like the term "test" for what you do in production, because ideally, tests should have well defined starting and ending states.

I feel like chaos engineering [1] is a better definition for what's being discussed here - constantly run experiments in prod, but do not consider them "tests". Making sure you _can_ run _useful_ experiments is the key.

1: https://principlesofchaos.org/

mr_tristan··on Reframing Tech Debt
I've found most "tech debt" planning to be incredibly vague and nebulous. Many engineers can identify what makes them uncomfortable, but it takes real effort to fully explain why, and what the real impacts are.

Maybe trying to think about "tech wealth" or "tech capability" might change this. Instead of a ticket to "improve error handling" it's "ensure the system can recover from a DNS failure safely to the DB without manual intervention". This sounds more like a feature, because, well, it is.

I've found most of the places talk a lot about having good quality, but few actually did anything concrete about it. Most changes ended up not making any impact. And this is over the course of a 20 year career.

mr_tristan··on Individuals Matter
I’ve experienced a corollary to this: individuals don’t instantaneously gel into teams. I’ve found places that try to solve hard problems by “finding good folks and putting them together on a ‘squad’”. Or, deciding to reorganize and just breaking up teams and mashing them up in weird ways.

What I have seen work: swapping managers. Leaving the team intact but bringing a new manager in can actually change execution a lot. But this is just not how a lot of businesses like to think.

← PreviousPage 3 of 10Next →