HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mrshoe

4,866 karma · joined October 7, 2008

busy busy busy
submissionscomments
mrshoe··on IPad UI Roundup
The new and simple method was to use automatic saving and persistent data – but with iWork on the iPad as a serious content creation platform, this isn’t an option anymore.

Why not? Can we not think outside the box even when we've been outside the box? Or am I missing something?

mrshoe··on Evolution of a Python programmer
I'm proud to be a Lazy Python Programmer... but not lazy enough to skip "What's New in Python 2.5":

    def factorial(x):
        return x * factorial(x-1) if x > 1 else 1
mrshoe··on How I Trie to Make Spelling Suggestions
Rather than re-implement this it might be better to use an existing library. In Python, I've used pylevenshtein:

http://code.google.com/p/pylevenshtein/

However, I've found the Jaro-Winkler distance to be more useful than the Levenshtein. You can find good implementations for Jaro out there as well.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaro-Winkler_distance

mrshoe··on NFL Games Have 11 Minutes of Action
And unless they're in a no-huddle offense, there is usually very close to 30 seconds between the tackle at the end of one play and the snap of the ball at the start of the next. So, if you enable the 30 second skip button on your TiVo, you can watch an entire game in a half hour.
mrshoe··on The Irony of iPad: A Great Day For Open Technologies
I fail to see the irony here. Apple is not trying to stifle innovation and control absolutely everything we do with their devices. As he points out in the article, Apple is the biggest driving force behind open web standards and their implementation in WebKit.

The motivation for the App Store is simple: consumers want an easy way to buy apps, and developers want an easy way to sell apps. If you want to take advantage of the payment processing, bandwidth, store interface, and marketing provided by the App Store, you have to adhere to their ToS. I'm sure Yahoo! Store has ToS as well.

However, if you want to roll all that on your own, go right ahead. As pointed out in this article, no one has done more to support you in that endeavor than Apple -- including a lot of support in WebKit and iPhone OS specifically for web apps on these devices.

It's not just a question of web vs. native, either. Even if all iPhone apps were HTML5/CSS/JS, you'd still have to adhere to Apple's ToS in order to sell through the App Store, and you wouldn't have to adhere to them if you sold through your own store.

mrshoe··on Why testers?
The dog analogy is a bit off. Programmers are not like dogs. We can remember mistakes we made a year ago and still learn from them. You want a short feedback cycle, not because it's the only way your programmers will learn anything, but because you can only improve so much each cycle. The only way to improve the necessary amount is to go through a lot of cycles, preferably in the shortest possible time.

Feedback from testers is great, but I've found a bigger reason why I love our QA team. For whatever reason, it's hard to implement something and test it at the same time. It's just hard to make my brain think in both modes at once. It's also hard to test something that I've implemented, because my brain is biased by the thought processes it used during implementation. Trying to think in both modes (implementation and testing) means I'll probably end up doing neither effectively. If you have a great QA team, you don't have to think in both modes. It's great.

That hints at his point about letting incompetent programmers do QA. I completely agree with him. A tester thinks differently than a programmer. Hire great testers. So many companies make that mistake.

I'm glad to see Joel take a public stand on automated tests, too. Automated tests have their place and their value, but his criticisms of them are completely valid. No amount of automated testing can obviate the need for good human QA. For some applications, automated testing can be such a pain to get right and maintain, that it's often more work than it's worth.

mrshoe··on Ask HN: Cases where software patents have prevented progress?
I would point to the current HTML5 video element debacle:

http://lists.whatwg.org/htdig.cgi/whatwg-whatwg.org/2009-Jun...

Patents are playing a large role in ensuring that what could be a wonderful thing for the web will almost certainly not be.

mrshoe··on Flurry Notices Cupertino-based Users Testing Apps on Apple Tablet
From Peter Farago, Flurry's VP of Marketing, in the blog comments:

This is a fair question. We feel confident that we are looking at the tablet device for two main reasons, that I can share with you. Also note that, as a company, we have experience tracking new Apple hardware devices in the past.

1) If this were an iPhone we were looking at, the hardware would tell us when we ask it (via the software). So we can rule out that this is an iPhone. Also, we already see verified iPhone devices testing OS 4.0 and these leave (Apple's Cupertino, CA) campus, whereas this device does not. This makes sense given the secrecy around the new tablet device as the launch event nears.

2) The apps being tested match up to what the devices is supposed to feature (e.g., news, books, etc.). We cannot share further detail here due to Terms of Service agreements we have with customers that use our service, but feel that if you were able to see the data we see, at the level of granularity, it would be clear to you as well.

Of course the truth will be revealed on Wednesday, but we wouldn't publish such a report without a high level of confidence.

Flurry is not interested in building a business on rumor, but rather authority, credibility and accuracy.

Point (2) seems less than rock solid, but (1) lends a bit of credence, especially since they've already seen iPhone OS 4.0 devices. It could just be that they're doing less testing of apps on 3.2 iPhones, however.

mrshoe··on The Internet of 2009 in numbers
I bet the 10.3% of internet users in Latin America represent a bigger business opportunity than the 14.6% in North America, due to the difference in market saturation.
mrshoe··on Hustle (how to learn new stuff)
I lived in Russia for two years. When I first moved there (I was 19) I went through the painful experience of being immersed in a foreign language. For a couple of months I couldn't express myself clearly, if at all. I couldn't put more than a couple of words together. I only understood about half of what people were saying to me. I couldn't even ask the bus driver to stop so I could get off at my stop.

After that short period, though, I became very comfortable communicating in Russian. I realized that there's probably no way to learn a language without going through that painful period. I think the same is true of programming languages. You're going to have to stumble through a couple thousand lines of horribly written code before you become fluent. You might as well start writing those now and get it over with.

I just started in a new roller hockey league this week. I still can't skate backwards well. I know that if I want to learn I'm going to have to fall on my butt a bunch of times. As long as I stay cautious and don't allow myself to fall, I'll probably never learn.

mrshoe··on Dropbox (YC S07) Announces 4 Million Users, Hires A VP From Salesforce
When you say "server based searching" I assume you mean things like Google's web search. It's fast because they dedicate tens of thousands of machines to storing the index and executing the queries. They can do that because their millions of users are all searching the same data set (the web). Dropbox couldn't do that because each user would be searching a different data set (their own files).

The fact that it's run on a server machine and not on a desktop machine has little effect on performance, and it probably doesn't make sense for Dropbox to provide the resources for good search when your desktop should be able to do a fine job of it.

mrshoe··on The Real Bill Gates joins Twitter
Any idea how he acquired that twitter account and for how much?
mrshoe··on Startup Equity For Employees
Since he never answers the most burning question ("how much equity should I expect?"), I'll throw out some numbers based on my experience:

If you're being hired as a C-level executive, you might expect up to 2% - 3%. If you're being hired as an engineer, expect more like 0.25% - 0.5%. I'm sure it varies quite a bit, but that's what I've seen personally and heard from friends.

mrshoe··on On how Google Wave surprisingly changed my life
Every once in a long while I need to collaborate on some sort of document with my coworkers, but the vast majority of the time I just want chat.

As you point out, Wave's UI is horrible for chat. That's why we're building http://shoptalkapp.com; it's similar to Campfire. We use it every day and couldn't live without it. It's like a virtual office.

mrshoe··on Other startup got there before me. Stop or continue?
What will it take to switch.

Why does he need anyone to switch? This competitor has just launched their product. That means they have very few users and almost no brand recognition. 99.9% of the world will have no idea who launched first and won't care.

You don't need to convince anyone to switch from your competitor's product. You just need to convince people to use your product, which is a problem you already had. In that sense, the launch of a competing product shouldn't affect your roadmap at all.

Longer term, you should be worried about the huge imbalance in resources. That's solvable, though: if you get any traction with your product you can raise funds and hire a team.

mrshoe··on How to say nothing in 500 words
Don't miss George Orwell's take on this subject:

http://www.mtholyoke.edu/acad/intrel/orwell46.htm

mrshoe··on Conversations in 140 Characters or Less are not Exactly Meaningful
The character limit is not the bottleneck. Twitter-like services aren't good at conversation because of the latency. Everyone here has experienced chat/IM. The reason you can have an actual conversation there is that it's rapid-fire.

That's why we've focused on reducing the latency for ShopTalk. Even using HTTP and comet, we've been able to give it a real interactive, rapid-fire feel. Chat isn't as sexy as newer trends like microblogging, but it's far more useful.

mrshoe··on Bit.ly Pro announced
All problems in computer science can be solved by another level of indirection

I see two big features here: 1) Recognizable URLs, and 2) analytics.

Do all HTTP requests need to go through bit.ly to achieve these features? Nope. http://nytimes.com is a pretty recognizable URL, if you ask me. I'm sure their server logs provide all the analytics they need as well.

Someone should "cut out the middleman" and invent a world wide web that doesn't require URL shorteners. Oh wait, Tim Berners-Lee already did that.

mrshoe··on FlightCaster (YC S09) open-sources Crane: Hadoop Clusters on EC2
I guess this poor commenter can take the downvotes as a "no" answer to his question?
mrshoe··on Just Say No: VC terms that can really hurt
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=972346
mrshoe··on How to reduce healthcare costs and improve quality
Just to play devil's advocate, here's a mind bender for you: we should be grateful to that asshole.

The insurance company is paying his salary because it costs them less than would the care that he manages to deny. If he didn't exist, the insurance company's costs would increase. This means that insurance premiums would have to increase. Whether you buy your insurance directly, or it's deducted from your paycheck, or your employer pays for it in full, that increased cost of insurance premiums would trickle down to you in the end.

mrshoe··on Less is Better: Interview with DHH
This interview is from a couple years ago, but the article gives no indication of that aside from this note at the very bottom in italics:

This article was originally published on the User Interface Resource Center (UIRC). For more info, please see http://uxmag.com/uirc

Just FYI...

mrshoe··on You Think The Google Interview Is Tough? Try Getting A Job At A PE Firm
I would hope that engineering positions at financial companies require an interview process similar to that of Google's (although in practice my hunch is that they're not as strenuous, like you said), but my comment and the article aren't referring to engineering positions.

The simple truth is that people like the interviewee in the article just don't work on nearly as hard of problems as do Google engineers. Being an engineer myself, I've never had a finance job, but I've had plenty of friends and roommates who have. They need to know some math and have some Excel skills, but most of their time is spent on phone calls and Powerpoint decks. That's why even an easy first question in an interview for an engineering position (e.g. write a C function that reverses a string) is more difficult than the questions asked of these guys. Just look at the example of the most grueling question in the article. Describe the process of a leveraged buyout? That doesn't really require any analytical skills, creativity, or problem solving.

I really think it's suboptimal to have finance people running our businesses, Wall St., and our economy. In my experience, they have a hugely inflated sense of self-worth, which is based mostly on their hugely inflated salaries.

mrshoe··on You Think The Google Interview Is Tough? Try Getting A Job At A PE Firm
Nice try, finance guys. 3 hours in a small room with "an asshole" doesn't sound like fun, but it's still not nearly as challenging as an interview at Google or Apple (I've interviewed at both). Those companies require 6 to 10 hours of grueling interviews and the real questions are much more difficult than the ones listed in the previous Business Insider article on the topic (at least for programmers). They couldn't list typical technical questions in that article because 99% of their readership wouldn't even understand them.

I've never been a fan of this kind of blind arrogance in the finance industry. I hoped the recession would at least have some effect on that, but it probably won't. Engineers don't have nearly enough power in this society.

mrshoe··on Why everything you think about User Centred Design is wrong
Some of the points in this article are correct (e.g. UCD isn't applicable to every single design decision), but the main thesis depends on a couple of false assumptions.

He asks, "Which of the following ways would you think gave you the most valuable feedback?" He submits that almost everyone would agree the real hammer will provide more valuable feedback than the paper or foam ones. This part is true. The next statement is false. He states that UCD practitioners would have chosen differently had the product been a web site instead of a hammer. They would have chosen the paper prototype, he says. That's just not true. UCD advocates the use of paper prototypes, not because they provide more valuable feedback, but because they are much easier to build. This means that you can test more of them in a shorter period of time. That's a very important distinction.

His graph of the UCD process essentially depicts it as a waterfall process, where there are several design steps with big Implement and Deploy steps at the end. That's also usually far from the truth. UCD is very iterative and, if done correctly, involves launching early and using data from real-world usage at each iteration.

It's easy to criticize something if you fabricate its weaknesses. The title of this post is pretty ironic.

mrshoe··on An Early Look At IE9 for Developers
Honest question: what does Microsoft stand to gain by doing all this work instead of just using WebKit?
mrshoe··on The Basecamp outage / slowdown today
Why don't they just come clean and apologize for any inconvenience this may have caused me?

Edit: Sorry, I know HN doesn't encourage one-liners and jokes, but I couldn't resist this one... I guess you had to be at Startup School to appreciate it.

mrshoe··on Curtis "50 Cent" Jackson on Business: Make Everything Your Own
There are some powerful concepts in here. A lot of HNers are seeking financial independence and they embody much of what 50 cent wrote in this piece. However, I hope we all remember his comment about not becoming dependent on our own money as well. Strength continues to come from within, even when you're not working for the man.

I also like the application of these thoughts to addictions, in all forms. Any addiction is an incredible loss of power.

mrshoe··on Ask HN: Developer workstation setup to promote startup culture?
I'm honestly not sure if one can hook up 2 20" or 24" monitors to a MacBook Pro these days, but even if you can't it's nice to have a desktop with a mouse and keyboard and not have to plug/unplug your laptop from everything all the time. Also, I prefer linux on the desktop (for my work machine, not personal) and Mac OS on the laptop, but that's just me.
mrshoe··on Ask HN: Developer workstation setup to promote startup culture?
As much as I love Macs, I think I can be more productive writing code on a linux box. I'm going to assume that applies to everyone else :-), and say you should save some money on desktops by getting everyone a linux box with 2 Dell monitors.

Spend that money (and more) on getting everyone a MacBook Pro as well. As anonjon points out, if you don't give out laptops you might be discouraging working outside the office more than encouraging working at the office. An important part of startup culture, imho, is to not require face time at the office.

Shameless plug: I agree with you that encouraging collaboration is key. Since lots of teams are working in a distributed fashion these days, we think they need some other way to collaborate effectively. This is why we're building http://shoptalkapp.com . We've found that it even encourages more collaboration for those that are in the office.

← PreviousPage 6 of 14Next →