HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

msbarnett

12,236 karma · joined April 12, 2010

submissionscomments
msbarnett··on Meld for Macs
Well that's fine, really – they should make decisions about what tools to buy based on how much it makes them, not how much it makes me, just the same as I don't base my decisions on what tools I buy based on a hypothetical Estonian contractor's salary.

I'm not really "forgetting" anything so much as I was making a statement about myself – you'll notice the prominent "I" and "me" in "Eh, for how much use I get out of a merge tool, $150 is pretty meaningless for the right tool" and "Ok, but I’m a software developer and this is a professional tool with which I do a job that makes me several hundred thousand dollars a year." – which for some reason has prompted a bunch of "well, whatabout median American income making non-developers" and "well, whatabout underpaid European developers". I am neither of these things. Wasn't talking about them. North American saws probably aren't priced affordably for Estonian carpenters either, when it comes down to it.

msbarnett··on Meld for Macs
> Or they realise the hubris you need to have to think 150$ to be a meaningless amount of money. It's already quite a sum at the median American salary and the USA is one of the most affluent countries from which HN readers hail.

Ok, but I’m a software developer and this is a professional tool with which I do a job that makes me several hundred thousand dollars a year. I don’t know that it’s “hubris” to recognize that relative to the income this helps me create, its costs are a rounding error.

Obviously $150 is a lot of money for a lot of people making a much lower income!… but those people likely aren’t in the market for a 3-way diff & merge tool, so I can’t imagine why you’d expect a discussion of this tool to have to add a disclaimer accounting for them? This is a professional tool whose costs exist relative to the income they create for the professional who wields them. My plumber brother-in-law certainly doesn’t refuse to spend tens of thousands of dollars on the equipment he uses for his job on the basis that this would be too expensive for someone working the counter at a fast food store. Nor should he – the costs make him money, and that’s what’s important.

(indeed, compared to almost any trade you can think of, we're lucky that our tools cost so little)

msbarnett··on Meld for Macs
Eh, for how much use I get out of a merge tool, $150 is pretty meaningless for the right tool. We're talking fractions of fractions of fractions of a penny per use over many years. If it makes my life better those kinds of tooling costs aren't even worth thinking about.

That said, I haven't used the new Kaleidoscope (although I was a fan of their last version and happily used it for 8 years or so), and currently use Sublime Merge.

Edit: someone care to explain to me why this completely innocuous comment on my personal philosophy of tool value is worthy of downvoting to -2?

msbarnett··on Intel's New Chimera: Alder Lake
> Thus reasonable to speculate that a process node advancement would at least put Intel's chip on par with M1 on both perf and efficiency

We'll see, but I highly doubt that Intel-at-equivalent-of-TSMC-5nm will be performance/watt competitive with the M1. Apple gets that power efficiency via an extremely wide-and-deep design that intentionally trades off a surprisingly low max clock ceiling (3.2GHz) for power efficiency while maintaining an absurdly high IPC (something like 75% higher than Intel's IPC at only one process node smaller) that makes it much more competitive on performance than conventional industry wisdom ever expected (there is and has been for years a strong belief that a design as wide as Apple's would be grossly inefficient because you could not possibly extract enough instruction level parallelism to keep so many decoders/execution units saturated -- hence we've spent over a decade with 4-5 wide frontends being the "practical maximum" that allows them to still target ~5GHz turbo speeds, which was believed to be basically the best/only path to high performance within what was believed to be the limit of "achievable" IPC. The M1 blows these fundamental assumptions out of the water).

So Intel makes conventional design decisions that make up the performance of their lower clock-for-clock IPC by turboing well north of 5GHz, at the cost of consuming something like 7x the max power of the M1. A single node shrink isn't going to buy them a 75% increase in IPC (their last 4 or 5 node shrinks combined haven't bought them that much IPC increase), so Intel@equivalent-of-TSMC-5nm still going to have to burn power like crazy to stay competitive on performance, and that's going to cost them efficiency that the node shrink just can't paper over.

It will lead in absolute perf, but its not going to be nearly as efficient.

msbarnett··on Intel's New Chimera: Alder Lake
1 process node behind. Intel 10nm has similar or better transistor density as TSMC 7nm.
msbarnett··on Success in Canada means moving to America
The person I am directly responding to was disputing the idea that employers are paying US rates in Canada at all ("That’s quite an assumption that US companies are paying US rates in Canada."), not SV rates specifically. Please don't try to shift the goal posts.
msbarnett··on Success in Canada means moving to America
The US company I started working for during the pandemic is paying me US rates, in USD, so I wouldn't call it an "assumption" just because you accepted a job in which you're getting paid 20% less.
msbarnett··on Ask HN: Who decided copy+paste should copy styling/formatting?
You can remap “paste-and-match-style” to command-v globally, thankfully.
msbarnett··on Ask HN: Why does nobody support h.265/HEVC anymore?
The licenses have already been paid for the hardware implementation, that doesn't explain, eg, Chrome's refusal to leverage hardware decoding (and stop burning so much power on laptops).
msbarnett··on Apple's director of machine learning resigns due to return to office work
False dichotomy. You can do both, and an industry-wide effort to exercise our collective power would likely increase the salaries obtained via either route.
msbarnett··on Qualcomm’s M1-class laptop chips will be ready for PCs in “late 2023”
The _vast_ majority of 3rd party apps on my M1 Mac are Universal? Ableton, Alfred, Affinity Photo, 1password, Backblaze, Capture One, CLion, FastRawViewer, Firefox, Irident, Postico, SublimeText/Merge.

The only notable non-Universal binaries are: Calibre (Intel-only) and Podman Desktop (Apple Silicon specific build)

msbarnett··on Florida governor to investigate GoFundMe over Canada trucker donations
Yeah I'm done with this website. The state of these comments is an absolute embarrassment, this is purely just a misinformation flamewar
msbarnett··on I’m a public school teacher – the kids aren’t alright
It comes from their full comorbidity tracking dataset: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/health_policy/covid19-comorbid...

Some of these aren't common comorbidities, but they nonetheless factor in to the "died with N comorbidities" averages

msbarnett··on I’m a public school teacher – the kids aren’t alright
> All persons with severe outcomes had at least one risk factor; 78% of persons who died had at least four.

It’s worth discussing what these risk factors are, since they’re a lot more common and broader than people imagine.

I myself have at least 4 CDC identified factors: I’m lactose intolerant, have an anxiety disorder, seasonal allergies and “caffeine dependency”.

While the overall number of adverse advents in my age range aren’t terribly concerning, the “at least 4 risk factors” discourse strikes me as terribly misleading because many of these “risk factors” that are used to handwave away deaths are common and utterly benign. How many other people in this industry have acne, are on the autism spectrum, suffer from depression, experience lower back pain?

Practically everyone I’ve ever worked with is probably pushing 4 factors.

msbarnett··on I’m a public school teacher – the kids aren’t alright
> And afterwards, everyone is then either vaccinated or recovered or dead and we can drop all of the precautions. What am I overlooking?

Omicron is spreading rapidly for a wide variety of reasons, but not least among them is the fact that it significantly escapes any prior immunity gained via vaccination or infection with a prior strain of the virus.

It’s not at all clear to me why we’d assume that this will mark “the end” - if anything this seems like a good indication that we’ll see future strains with this measles-like contagiousness that significantly escapes any prior immunity gained from Omicron. And this is on top of the fact that immunity to coronaviruses in general does not seem to be particularly long-lasting.

At which point, unless we have significantly invested in hiring a lot more nurses and creating a lot more hospital beds (which I see no signs of), we will be looking at bringing back at least some restrictions in many jurisdictions to avoid having to cancel many medical procedures that have spent the last 2 years getting canceled repeatedly.

msbarnett··on Covid-19 vaccines and treatments: we must have raw data, now
Simply removing the name isn't enough to anonymize the data, because as another commenter noted, the data submitted includes detailed patient histories and information about all of their other conditions, which is more than enough to uniquely identify someone.

And you can't simply strip out that data, because a lot of the subsequent analysis of effectiveness is dependent on it.

msbarnett··on Music subscriber market shares Q2 2021
Ehhhhh there's just the 2 of us, so with none of the other benefits, which to me are worth $5, it's not an interesting deal. Plus neither of us spend any time on YouTube so that whole "Premium" ad-free thing is just meaningless access to absolute junk content.
msbarnett··on Music subscriber market shares Q2 2021
> So what exactly is the rationale to pay for Apple Music?

For $20 my wife and I both get Apple Music, Apple TV+ (several shows we enjoy on there), 200GB Cloud Storage, and subscription access to a bunch of video games.

2 subscriptions to YouTube Music by itself would cost us the same $20, with none of the other benefits (and it has a muuuuch lousier selection of stuff I like, at least – plus a lot of the user-uploaded content has audio quality on par with some 96khz mp3 I'd have gotten off of napster two decades ago, whereas Apple's increasingly streaming lossless)

msbarnett··on Music subscriber market shares Q2 2021
Amazon Music is a throw-in on Prime, so technically I "have" it as a subscriber to Prime, but I've literally never used it.

Of all of the players in this space, it's not clear to me that Amazon's "subscriber share" reflects anything at all considering that it's not something you subscribe to on its own and not generally considered a major benefit of the subscription it's included in. Would be interesting to see what the actual usage statistics look like.

msbarnett··on mRNA Boosters Don’t Block Omicron, South African Study Shows
By lowering its R0 below 1. Which doesn't not require "sterilizing" vaccines (which is good, since neither the smallpox nor polio vaccine eliminated infection or transmission with anything close to 100% effectiveness).
msbarnett··on mRNA Boosters Don’t Block Omicron, South African Study Shows
An unsourced “I claim most people have this misunderstanding, therefore the claim that vaccines work must be responsive to this incorrect understanding (plus some vague mishmash of implications about conspiracies to change the definition of vaccination, or something)” doesn’t strike me as a terribly productive line of argument to be honest.
msbarnett··on mRNA Boosters Don’t Block Omicron, South African Study Shows
> If that's not enough, change the definition of "vaccines"

If “vaccine” meant “thing that 100% stops you from ever even getting infected”, most vaccines throughout the history of vaccination wouldn’t meet that definition.

But that’s not, and has never been, the definition – so nothing needs to be changed.

>> Vaccine: A product that stimulates a person’s immune system to produce immunity to a specific disease, protecting the person from that disease.

That doesn’t mean what you seem to think it means (so-called “sterilizing immunity”). A 20-fold reduction in hospitalization is by any read protecting you from a disease.

msbarnett··on Rail Theft Soars in California
I'm more than familiar with the boroughs of New York City.

The 450 "vandalized and in some cases looted" statistic you provided was for New York City as a whole. If you would like to confine your focus to Lower Manhattan, the onus is on you to find the relevant statistic for Lower Manhattan, because that 450 includes vandalism from all over the city (to repeat your own quote with appropriate emphasis, "An estimated 450 businesses across New York City were vandalized and in some cases looted in late May and early June, according to the city's Department of Small Business Services.")

To really get a true picture of things, we'd also need to know what the background level of vandalism for business in a more-than-a-month time window is - because I assure you, it is not zero.

> I could also say 450 is only .000001% of stores in the USA, so there's no problem! Same logic you're using, by the way

No, the logic I'm using is that if .000001% of stores in the USA were "vandalized and in some cases looted", then the statement "Huge percentage of stores were vandalized and had their goods stolen" made about the USA would be laughably hyperbolic and incorrect simply on the cold facts.

msbarnett··on Rail Theft Soars in California
This: https://www.osc.state.ny.us/reports/osdc/retail-sector-new-y... suggests that there are more than 36,000 retail stores in NYC.

450/36000 == 1.3% of retail businesses were "vandalized and in some cases looted", phrasing which suggests rather less than that were actually looted.

The suggestion that "Huge percentage of stores were vandalized and had their goods stolen" seems absurdly hyperbolic given these numbers.

edit: corrected accidental use of state wide number

msbarnett··on Airlines deny boarding to passengers from wild Sunwing party flight to Mexico
> I don't like the idea of an airline stranding people in a foreign country

If you're going to break a number of laws on a flight, I don't think it's terribly surprising that the same business, or other airlines, might decline to do business with you in the future.

Ultimately, these are private enterprises and you're not entitled to your preferred mode of transportation for a return trip to Canada. It would be a lot more inconvenient to have to bus or rent a car to drive all the way back, but if you're going to break a bunch of laws the consequences may, unsurprisingly, be inconvenient.

msbarnett··on Facebook collecting people's data even when accounts are deactivated
> Facebook does not maintain "accounts" on non-users in a meaningful way and they have stated this multiple times to multiple regulators

And surely they'd never mislead anybody regarding what data they keep.

Which admittedly makes it a bit hard to explain how, despite having completely deleted my account several years ago (yes, not just deactivated, I went through all the little guilt-trip pleas not to delete), they managed to accidentally (a bug, presumably) send me a Friend Suggestion email several weeks ago (suggesting someone I actually do know, no less) considering that by their own words they should have wiped both that email address and the social graph associated with it several years earlier...

msbarnett··on Tauri – Electron alternative written in Rust
Spotify is built on Chromium Embedded Framework, not Electron. Common misunderstanding.
msbarnett··on 11-week Kellogg’s strike to end after multi-year agreement reached
You don't have to work to put insect larvae in food, especially grains. It's separating out larvae that's the usual challenge. Seems like exactly the kind of QA challenge you'd have with a completely green workforce.

I'd assume these production lines involve contact with any number of plastic parts that could break or shave off if operated incorrectly. Same with the glue from packaging hitting the food if you don't do it right.

msbarnett··on 11-week Kellogg’s strike to end after multi-year agreement reached
I'm pretty sure it's just inexperienced workers with zero training or experienced supervision making obvious, predictable mistakes in food preparation (over-baking, failing to evenly apply icing to pop-tarts, etc).

Your reading seems like a very big stretch given how pedestrian most of these mistakes are.

msbarnett··on 11-week Kellogg’s strike to end after multi-year agreement reached
They were scabbing. Predictably, quality appeared to go through the floor as a result

eg) https://twitter.com/RespectableLaw/status/147225737151065293...

← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →