HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mtndew4brkfst

458 karma · joined January 15, 2012

Elixir, Rust, Kubernetes
submissionscomments
mtndew4brkfst··on Omarchy, a Linux Distribution by DHH
This is my impression - if you explicitly don't want to use toolbox or devcontainers I don't think you're on Bluefin's happy path at all, and the maintainers don't seem concerned enough by that to improve other experiences.
mtndew4brkfst··on Programming Extensible Data Types in Rust with CGP – Part 1: Modular App Constr
With the limited sample set of previous writing about this tooling - my impression is that it seems impossible to offer a succinct but still compelling description of this particular dialect of Rust.

There are thousands of words of prose to describe it between this and the shell-scripting post, and a lot of code-level seams and abstractions introduced in the snippets. Yet I still can't tell you why I should want to do the new things that this code style would make possible for me to do.

I also probably wouldn't enjoy trying to onboard a new contributor to a hypothetical project using this style, no matter how experienced with Rust they might be. DSLs, which I would consider CGP to be one, have a pretty high friction rate if they haven't become dominant/widespread.

mtndew4brkfst··on I Switched from Flutter and Rust to Rust and Egui
Anyone considering it will need to decide for themselves how to feel about it, but I think it's important to prospective users to highlight that the current licensing model for Slint requires either GPL3-compatible licensing of your work, advertising for Slint within your own software, or paying ongoing licensing fees and/or royalties.

https://github.com/slint-ui/slint/blob/master/FAQ.md#licensi...

I only mention this because those constraints are notably more restrictive than the vast majority of the Rust crate ecosystem.

I take no particular stance on whether this is a fair or good practice or about the technical suitability of Slint beyond this concern, I just think it's a hurdle for most people so they should be made aware early and often.

mtndew4brkfst··on Darklang Goes Open Source
My point was that José and Chris being continuously employed working on the language and Phoenix respectively (by the companies I named) are probably considered a form of commercial backing by most people. If you want to split hairs about specific timing or magnitude of investment, that's kind of nitpicking IMO. It's not grassroots at basically any point.

José founded Dashbit after Plataformatec got acquired but up until ~2020 Plat directly funded the creation and iteration of the language, with it originating as an internal research project.

https://elixir-lang.org/development.html

José Valim created Elixir in 2012 as a Research and Development project inside Plataformatec.

https://plataformatec.com/

Dashbit José Valim has openened a new company to help startups and enterprises adopt and run Elixir in production.

Those companies employ a useful fraction of the language core team, too.

mtndew4brkfst··on Show HN: Lstr – A modern, interactive tree command written in Rust
lib.rs has a nifty (and occasionally shocking) portrayal of this on their crate pages.

https://lib.rs/crates/lstr

says for this one the deps clock in at: ~19–29MB ~487K SLoC

mtndew4brkfst··on Show HN: Lstr – A modern, interactive tree command written in Rust
That's not intrinsically or pervasively true, although it's not uncommon.
mtndew4brkfst··on Darklang Goes Open Source
What do you consider the financial and developer contributions of Dashbit née Plataformatec, Dockyard, and Fly.io?
mtndew4brkfst··on LLMs and Elixir: Windfall or deathblow?
Dialyzer is easy to intentionally or accidentally mislead, so it's only as good as the quality of human-authored typespecs (which are sometimes absent from major mainstream Hex packages) and the inference is simultaneously more open-ended and unhelpfully precise than most people are accustomed to if they have prior experience with something like Rust or TypeScript. People also frequently struggle to accurately interpret its output.

I still find dialyzer to have non-zero value, but it's not uncontroversial and it's not usefully integrated with the vanilla language tooling. Mix/elixirc is not generally going to throw you a bone if you violated a syntax-correct type spec. It's an opt-in secondary tool and that diminishes its utility a tad.

mtndew4brkfst··on LLMs and Elixir: Windfall or Deathblow?
Making this point in typed vs untyped debates about Elixir/Erlang specifically has never once lead to either an educational moment or a change of opinion on either side. You know exactly what they meant by that, and you're using a different definition than they are to try to pull a pedantic gotcha. It's snide and unproductive.
mtndew4brkfst··on (On | No) Syntactic Support for Error Handling
It's a pale shadow of an actual Option/Result type, though, and the way most community and professional Elixir code uses ok-tuples is hardly what I would call rigorous. The with special form leads to sloppy pass-the-buck design IME, and nothing in the language design or Credo ruleset is likely to steer anyone to do better.
mtndew4brkfst··on Jjui – A Nice TUI for Jujutsu
My anecdotal experience is that I indirectly need/benefit from rerere much less often because I'm not usually resolving the same specific conflict more than once. I fix it the one time and then jj is rebasing a whole lineage for me, starting from the early commits, not from the single-branch leaves. That way I don't get "I rebased one branch and fixed this one already, but now I have to do it again for a second branch that shared the same conflicted commit as the first."

By contrast, git rebase --update-refs does not handle sibling branches but detaches them instead, and git replay hasn't had much TLC for UX yet. Plus, the last time I tried replay it was still obliterating commit signatures.

https://git.github.io/htmldocs/git-replay.html

mtndew4brkfst··on Jjui – A Nice TUI for Jujutsu
I was a Magit user for most of a decade and I deeply missed it when I first switched to jj. I still think something like it would be a huge boon for the community and I hope one comes to fruition eventually, but in an editor-agnostic form like matklad suggests here:

https://matklad.github.io/2024/12/13/majjit-lsp.html

With that yearning in mind, jjui is the jj TUI I like best so far having tried them all. It's snappy, has useful and intuitive keybinds and presents them well, and good stability so far. Doesn't quite seem to like it if I resize the surrounding zellij/terminal pane while it's open though.

Lazyjj was a little laggy and crash-prone for me on all of the same repos, and jj-fzf is a tragic pile of bash so I can't recommend ever using that.

mtndew4brkfst··on Demonstrably Secure Software Supply Chains with Nix
The laborious extents to which the Guix project would go simply to alienate people who own certain classes of computer hardware. I have a list of Nix criticisms as long as my arm, but at least its documentation and user community never chastised me for my work laptop's OS or brand/model.
mtndew4brkfst··on Feather: A Rust web framework that does not use async
It's historically been heavily gamed as well, so it's not much better than a thumb in the wind. Good and bad results might both be due to very non-idiomatic non-representative code there. Both the false positive/negative outcomes have happened in the past, then been fixed after recognition and feedback.

IIRC TechEmpower contributed indirectly to the controversy about actix-web and its use of Rust unsafe keyword.

mtndew4brkfst··on Elixir is not owned by Big Tech
I think "nearly the whole ecosystem is primarily driven by consultants for consultants" is a flimsy house of cards, rather than a virtue like the author of the article.
mtndew4brkfst··on Accountability Sinks
So why not elaborate as "Franz Kafka" when you mean the author? It can only clarify and it just takes 6 more characters. People who know both won't be bothered, and people who know neither will have a better time looking up the context.
mtndew4brkfst··on What I've learned from jj
There are many available paths to learning that don't leave you beholden to what was in training data from ~2021. This attitude will definitely hurt one's opportunities for personal growth and enrichment.
mtndew4brkfst··on What I've learned from jj
If anything, I think the jujutsu project as it exists today is probably most attractive to people who already know Git quite well. It's hard to articulate why a given VCS design or workflow is pleasant without having some firsthand experience of nontrivial things that went wrong or at least chaotic.

Among the hard work on the jj maintainers' plate is making it just as attractive and intuitive to people without that background.

mtndew4brkfst··on Migrating away from Rust
I don't find the single-vendor governance / commercial origins of those two languages very reassuring, but that's not something that will trouble everyone equally if at all.
mtndew4brkfst··on Migrating away from Rust
None of those are to my personal taste and I think Kotlin is the only one with unambiguously strong adoption in industry. I'm trying not to make value-judgment statements about others that do like them.
mtndew4brkfst··on Migrating away from Rust
For me personally, doing the clone-everything style of Rust for a first pass means I still have a graceful incremental path to go pursue the harder optimizations that are possible with more thoughtful memory management. The distinction is that I can do this optimization pass continuing to work in Rust rather than considering, and probably discarding, a potential rewrite to a net-new language if I had started in something like Ruby/Python/Elixir. FFI to optimize just the hot paths in a multi-language project has significant downsides and tradeoffs.

Plus in the meantime, even if I'm doing the "easy mode" approach I get to use all of the features I enjoy about writing in Rust - generics, macros, sum types, pattern matching, Result/Option types. Many of these can't be found all together in a single managed/GC'd languages, and the list of those that I would consider viable for my personal or professional use is quite sparse.

mtndew4brkfst··on Unauthorized Experiment on CMV Involving AI-Generated Comments
That's a sacrifice I'm willing to make, personally.
mtndew4brkfst··on Tracking types of non-parents in the United States
Well, I guess a lot of the threat is to do with the children and tax burden of one specific man...
mtndew4brkfst··on Tracking types of non-parents in the United States
The actual existential threat to my own country has little to do with how many children people have or what their personal tax burden is.
mtndew4brkfst··on Tracking types of non-parents in the United States
On the face of it that sounds like childless taxpayers of all varieties subsidizing people who have many children. That's a "solid idea"?
mtndew4brkfst··on I gave up on self-hosted Sentry (2024)
It has its own conference now! Definitely not a signal for something that is reliable set-it-and-forget-it tech.
mtndew4brkfst··on Why training AI can't be IP theft
Best possible outcome. Unlikely to be, but maybe even the intended outcome from legal's POV.
mtndew4brkfst··on Fedora change aims for 99% package reproducibility
Some of the more drawn-out arguments are in or about the RFCs repo, though, so it's not just chat platforms or forum where the fights break out. To your point the RFC repo is also something that not every would-be contributor would touch or need to.
mtndew4brkfst··on Fedora change aims for 99% package reproducibility
a miserable pile of software packages </sotn>
mtndew4brkfst··on Fedora change aims for 99% package reproducibility
Real as you or me, though I disagree with almost everything else the quoted poster expressed other than that forks are happening and the dividing lines include cultural norms rather than strictly technical disagreements.

https://discourse.nixos.org/t/breaking-doge-to-recommend-nix...

Same author quoted the original text on their Reddit thread and was mostly uncriticized there:

https://old.reddit.com/r/NixOS/comments/1joshae/breaking_dog...

I personally found it incredibly distasteful and also fairly representative of the quality of conversation you often get from some of the Nix community. I'm not offensive, you're just thin skinned, can't you take a joke, etc. is extremely common. You'll have to judge for yourself whether it's bigoted or dog whistle or neither.

I'm a former casual community member with modest open source work in that ecosystem (projects and handful of nixpkgs PRs) before I left permanently last spring. I no longer endorse its use for any purpose and I seek to replace every piece of it that I was using.

I still hear about the ways they continue to royally fuck up their governance and make negligible progress on detoxifying the culture. It took them until last fucking week to ban Anduril from making hiring posts on the same official forum.

← PreviousPage 3 of 8Next →