HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mukyu

2,004 karma · joined July 16, 2009

submissionscomments
mukyu··on P2P Web Apps - Brace yourselves, everything is about to change.
This reminds me of http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2245149

All of this talk strikes me as coming from people that have implemented neither large web applications nor distributed or p2p applications at all dreaming up schemes with no idea of how they would actually work.

I think an illustrative example is how Twitter spends significant engineering effort (with Cassandra and now Rainbird) just to implement a counter in a scalable fashion.

mukyu··on SelectOut: Opt out of being tracked online
The FTC has been making noise about actually doing something. [1] There are also proposals to W3C defining a 'Do Not Track' HTTP header rather than cookies. [2]

[1] http://www.ftc.gov/opa/2010/12/privacyreport.shtm

[2] http://www.w3.org/QA/2011/02/do_not_track_at_w3c.html

mukyu··on Is TED Elite?
Technology does not change the world, are you serious? To believe that you must think that everything from irrigation techniques that allowed agriculture and formation of cities to improved forms of transportation and communication that allowed cultures to meet did not have impact.

She also says that the people criticizing TED have not been, when the first link she uses is the story of someone that has been to TED. The articles she talks about could use more 'journalism' and 'a simple google search' to improve them, but no mention of anything that is actually wrong with them.

mukyu··on Minecraft creators’ next project is a strategy game: Scrolls
There were effectively cards that do 'destroy a random card'. [1] There are also several cards that result in searching the deck (and then reshuffling it) which require time/effort and yet were made.

[1] http://www.wizards.com/magic/autocard.asp?name=chaos+orb

mukyu··on Hyperpublic Developer Challenge Stats and Recap
It would be interesting to know the distribution of incorrect answers for the problems. Another interesting thing would be how many incorrect guesses people had for each puzzle (that is, how many people had >5 guesses and did not solve it and such up to how many solved it firs time).
mukyu··on Blog Incorrectly Gets Labeled as a 'Content Farm' by Google
It is funny how all content farms say they aren't content farms and that their content is 'high quality'.
mukyu··on The Hyperpublic Programming Challenge
I wonder how many people solve it and then do not send in their key. I know I'm not. I cannot be the only one that was more interested in doing the challenge than the rewards.
mukyu··on Rent-seeking
The things that first came to mind when reading this were domain name squatters and scalpers. Do I have the general idea?
mukyu··on The Boy Who Stole Half-Life 2
In the reddit thread ( http://www.reddit.com/r/gaming/comments/fpkav/the_boy_who_st... ) he* has answered some questions.

* I'm not actually sure it is him, but he is plausible enough.

mukyu··on It's Time for Server-Side Browsers
With desktop applications you can use the same language/code on both the client and the server side. That did not lead to decentralization. Well, that isn't cross platform you might say. However, Java mostly covers that and still it did not happen. There are also numerous tools that allow you to write in one language (Java with GWT, some lisp one I cannot name) that runs on the server side that automatically generates equivalent javascript for the client.

There is no reason (and you provide no argument) that using the same code on the client/server results in decentralization. Furthermore, we have the fact that it already exists and still did not lead to decentralization.

mukyu··on It's Time for Server-Side Browsers
The best I have been able to make of it is that he wants to make a protocol where anyone can make an application/service and distribute arbitrary data via the browser. Basically, the internet at large except all of the 'computers' are actually web browsers running on actual computers.
mukyu··on Dan Bernstein's CurveCP in experimental release
Isn't the point to have this work below the application layer? We have to make a new encrypted and authenticated transport layer and also rewrite all of the application protocols?

Then again, with key distribution being done with nym urls the network stack is more like a tangled ball of yarn.

mukyu··on It's Time for Server-Side Browsers
Could someone translate what this is actually trying to talk about into something clear? This blog post reminds me of someone on weed trying to relate to you this profound idea to you and rambles on stream of consciousness style. He wants there to be no 'centralization' (that is, servers) and have things run on a cloud of people's web browsers, yet at the same time it still talks to mysql somewhere? We won't need any one site to hold data and things just magically work by sending things out into the ether?
mukyu··on Google translate bug
Machine learning isn't perfect, news at 11. Google Translate works by taking a large corpus of documents that have been translated into various languages to train a model. The input phrases are then interpreted using the inferences the model derived from the corpus. If there was not enough information relevant to the input the model is basically guessing. It gets things wrong. There isn't a wizard behind the curtain.
mukyu··on How ~75% of PirateBay traffic is seeded by 100 people driven by profit
Most of the content on tpb comes from the scene which does not condone p2p sharing. These people just have access to scene releases early and want to profit from it.

http://torrentfreak.com/bittorrent-releasers-slice-the-top-o...

http://torrentfreak.com/bittorrent-releasers-are-the-new-kid...

Sadly, the report does not list any of the usernames of those that they studied. However, if you just go to a category, pick a frequent submitter, and look at their uploads most of the time there tags from many different groups. Some even try to claim other's releases as their own.

mukyu··on Wikipedia's Notability Requirements And The Slash
I'm sorry that you are incapable of taking 5 minutes to find read the specific Wikipedia policy pages that mentioned by name. Just because you know nothing about subjects and like to bullshit about them on the internet does not mean that everyone else does the same. Since you mostly seem to be interested in hearing yourself speak I will not engage you further.
mukyu··on Wikipedia's Notability Requirements And The Slash
Plan A only bothers whomever tries to maintain [[List of esoteric programming languages]] or wherever you pick as a battleground. I know it sounds to you like you can really "stick it to the man" and they will swoon over your brillant tactics and relent, but you will only bother people that actually care about esolangs in the first place and Monsanto certainly isn't going to be around. The best you can hope for is some people get blocked and pages protected.

Wikipedia's policies would consider it self-published. It does not matter that you would be writing about languages that you are not affiliated with. Again, you are not going to change Wikipedia's policies by pointing out that Wikipedia itself is self-published in their eyes.

I think you are vastly overestimating the number of people that have even heard, much less care about these esoteric languages.

I do not know why you ascribe these emotions to me, but they are not in the least accurate. I do not think my personal opinion on this set of articles is at all significant. I do not care about them, either way.

Frankly, what disturbs me is how you have very strong opinions about how Wikipedia does or should work with an incredibly superficial actual understanding. For example, why do you argue over how Wikipedia sees Lulu? Have you even read Wikipedia's policy on Reliable Sources or Verifiability? It is not as if Lulu itself or other things like it are new. It has been debated a number of times and at length. You have no knowledge of the issue and provide no insight.

mukyu··on Wikipedia's Notability Requirements And The Slash
My actual thoughts on the issues related to inclusion and deletion are not what I was trying to address. I contributed to Wikipedia for a time and saw and was part of deletion sprees on both of the sides. Something like this happens every three months I would guess. Mostly, my thoughts on it at the moment are 'not this shit /again/'.
mukyu··on Wikipedia's Notability Requirements And The Slash
Plan A doesn't work. It is actually easier to delete things from pages than deleting pages themselves. If you edit war over it you will lose.

Plan B does not work. Wikipedia guidelines do not consider self-published sources as 'reliable' and things published by Lulu are considered self-published. Wikipedia does not consider itself a reliable source either. It is also not going to disappear in a puff of logic like God in hhgttg, no matter how witty you think it is.

Plan C has not worked in the years of people deleting things that appeal to far broader audiences than esoteric programming languages. They are still around. How well do you think this will work?

Plan D is something many people have done. In a way, Wikia is a giant example of it. In other cases they go to wikinfo or create their own wiki.

This post is exactly like 100s of others that someone writes whenever Wikipedia deletes (or even tries to delete) something that they care about. The ground is well-tread and it brings nothing new or interesting to the table. The internet does not need another blog post where someone spends an hour in isolation writing about it.

On an irrelevant note, mediawiki does support subpages (the slashes), but articles cannot have them as article titles may contain slashes. This has absolutely nothing to do with Wikipedia's notation of notability and the reasons people try to get rid of non-notable content.

mukyu··on Programming languages are being deleted from Wikipedia
Getting people to rally around anything that someone is trying to have deleted is a sure-fire way to get it deleted, protected from recreation, and basically never coming back. It is like some kind of 'defend the hive' kind of reaction.
mukyu··on Stuxnet is now on GitHub
I wanted to post about this, but I could not remember the name and googling things like '(collaborative OR crowdsource) static binary analysis' was futile. Thanks, it was driving me insane.
mukyu··on Stuxnet is now on GitHub
https://github.com/Laurelai/decompile-dump/blob/master/outpu...

"WARNING: CHLLCode::appendTypeIdent: declaring type void as int for param2"

http://www.google.com/codesearch?as_q=WARNING%3A+CHLLCode%3A...

http://boomerang.sf.net/ is clearly what was used.

mukyu··on Stuxnet is now on GitHub
No. There is just too much information lost going from source to binary and when you use optimization the results are more information lost, not less.

The idea works well enough if you just want get optimized asm though. http://events.ccc.de/congress/2010/Fahrplan/events/4096.en.h...

mukyu··on Anon claims that it has the source code to Stuxnet
I doubt that HBGary had the source to Stuxnet. Even the source is not that useful. Its infection vectors are known. It does not really use novel worm techniques. They would not be able to sign a different rootkit payload without the stolen certs. The source does not give you control of the command and control infrastructure, so they cannot use or update any of the currently infected machines (this is speculation, I do not know the specifics of Stuxnet in this regard). The PLC payload is useless and would have to be rewritten and tested for a different target. Basically, having a copy of Stuxnet and/or the source for it is useless for using it as a weapon.

The source would be great for the people looking for evidence of who wrote it and what their intentions were, but that is about it.

mukyu··on Toyota, The Media Owe You an Apology
"As with the report on Tuesday, the preliminary examination given to Congress in August found no evidence of flawed electronics in vehicles that crashed. That examination found only one instance in which an accelerator pedal became trapped under a floor mat and none in which a pedal became stuck or sprang back too slowly."

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/09/business/09auto.html?pagew...

One instance out of millions of cars.

mukyu··on My Email Privacy is Worth more than $36 per year
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://...

My Email Privacy is Worth more than $36 per year

By gherlein, on February 6th, 2011 - No comments I’ve been using Google Apps Mail to host my mail for herlein.com for years. In fact, I was a very early adopter. I’d say I was in the beta, but hey, so was everyone! Seriously though, I was pretty early. It seemed like the thing to do. I had been hosting my own mail forever and had a server die (the real death) and was tired of fighting spam. It was a free, seemingly reliable alternative.

Over the last few years I’ve become increasingly frustrated. As a free solution I had no support, so when my wife’s emails were going missing I had no help in chasing it down. I never did solve it. I had mails forwarded to me that were indeed sent, but alas, they never showed in her inbox. That’s probably when I found that there were two inboxes – the real one accessible from POP/IMAP and the web interface. Last year I seriously played with using a local client (on Linux) for at least my mail. It was a baby step to the real leap I wanted to make, which was to get off GMail altogether. But none of the Linux clients were really to my liking; they all had some warts that were just too ugly for me to cutover. This last week my wife started having problems accessing a web site that happens to be hosted on Google sites. It was a really strange permissions problem, apparently because logging on to get herlein.com email set a certain user permission in the new Google App infrastructure. I spent 15 minutes chasing that before realizing that I really want no part of it.

I’ve been able to ignore the privacy implications of using Google for a long time. However, lately I’ve had a growing sense of unease. After all, NOTHING IS FREE. I was getting email services but was paying in units of privacy… and we don’t yet know the conversion rates for that currency! As I scraped through the new Google App infrastructure I realized that Google’s email is really complicated – it’s not just a simple email interface anymore. They are bolting on a ton of things underneath that we don’t know much about. Hell, they may not know much about them either, to be fair. Does the right hand know what the left is doing over there? Even if they do, am I comfortable with that much more of my data and traffic crossing that system?

You see, Google is an advertising company cloaked as a technology company. I work in advertising and I joke that part of my job is trying to make Minority Report style ads really viable. But Google is DOING THAT NOW, just without the silly retina flashes, and not in ways we can even imagine now. Over the last few years they ‘index’ all my email, measure my click throughs, and with the Google Apps infrastructure can see a lot deeper into my traffic and inner workings (assuming I host docs there, etc). To what gain? Ads. Better and more specific relevant targeted ads. Good for them, they are building a business. I won’t address any moral issues around all this. For now, it’s legal, they got there first and so far they are executing on it. Nice. And supposedly they provide an opt out. But their system is so darn complicated under the hood, will it really work?

Except that I don’t have to play. Or at least, I can choose to not accept services in exchange for aspects of my privacy that I cannot measure (yet). I can move my email to another provider, for starts.

So I did. I turned on a Rackspace email account and pointed my MX records there. Unfortunately I didn’t realize that GoDaddy DNS sets the timeouts to 1 week by default for MX records, so I’m keeping Google set at a lower priority and keeping it active for a week, just to be sure I don’t drop an email (as a side note, I’ll be moving my DNS off GoDaddy soon too – I simply hate their GUI). I don’t really care for the RackSpace web interface for mail, but it’s functional. That’s my backup really anyway, since I do most of my mail on my mobile, or from my desktop. And now that I have cut over to all Mac’s at home I just use the Apple Mail program. It has warts too, but it’s functional, and I love how well spotlight finds stuff on my hard drive. I don’t need Google to search mail! Really! That technology is so commonplace now. That value add is commodity! Rackspace has a special deal for SliceHost customers (I host this blog on SliceHost) so my email will cost me $36 per year. I suspect that my privacy is worth a lot more than $36 per year!

My only remaining question is: why didn’t I do this sooner?

mukyu··on Dispelling the New SSL Myth
There is also http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AES_instruction_set
mukyu··on Bing search results showing up in Google
I do not think it would matter if Sergey and Page personally delivered a stone slab engraved with a statement that Google does not use their toolbar's clicks. As you say, you would have to rely on trusting their statements. You seem to require extraordinary evidence that they do not and have no evidence to back up that they actually do use it, and yet cling to belief that they do.

Matt spent 5 paragraphs on the subject, and yet you have laser focus on one statement that is not even contradicted by other evidence and try to derive whatever you want from it.

Here are some other comments from the panel at bigthink, but I'm sure you will find enough wiggle in them to assert that Google faked the moon landing.

Matt Cutts: "I'm not sure that users realize...when they search on Google and click... those results appear--those clicks appear to be encrypted and sent to Microsoft which then appear to be used in Google's [sic] rankings?"

[stuff about EULAs]

Harry Shum: "Everyone does this Matt you know.."

Matt: "Google... I want to categorically deny that Google does this."

Harry: "That Google does what?"

Matt: "We don't use clicks on Bing's users in Google's rankings."

http://bigthink.com/series/62#!selected_item=4845 around 25:00

mukyu··on Bing search results showing up in Google
You are being disingenuous. That you cannot find them explicitly denying something does not therefore make it true nor provide any evidence that it is true.

“Absolutely not. The PageRank feature sends back URLs, but we’ve never used those URLs or data to put any results on Google’s results page. We do not do that, and we will not do that,” said Singhal.

http://www.toprankblog.com/2006/04/matt-cutts-on-toolbar-dat...

In this one, Matt Cutts all but explicitly says that they do not use it.

mukyu··on Bing search results showing up in Google
Google has said they do not use clickstream data for ranking from Google toolbar.

They did have variations of their tests. Cutts mentioned this during the bigthink panel. Sometimes they went to Bing first or not, sometimes they clicked on the links and sometimes not, and various other things.

← PreviousPage 8 of 12Next →