HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

munchhausen

420 karma · joined March 11, 2009

submissionscomments
munchhausen··on Oracle Consulting Rate Card
> But if you want to remove all the "probably's" from that sentence you can pay 10x as much and have Oracle do it for you.

It looks like you're assuming that the guys Oracle sends out to do the job are true domain experts, and that's a giant leap of faith.

munchhausen··on Rent a Mac in the cloud for development
Also, someone who lives in a country that is not loved by Apple.

Here in central Europe, a Mac Mini goes for 1200$ without a monitor, and that's in the cheapest online store (where you will have to wait for over a week for it, as they do not have them in stock).

Also, since there are no Apple stores, repairs and warranty in general is a pain to deal with.

Considering these circumstances, a "Mac in a cloud" seems appealing, especially if you need it just as a testbed.

munchhausen··on FreeBSD 9.0-RC1 Available...
No commercial support makes the software a non-starter in most IT environments, that's the (sad) reality. FreeBSD is a good example of why that is a problem - while technically sound, it is at risk of becoming a fringe OS used only by a couple of enthusiasts and FreeBSD developers themselves. For a project that produces an OS, that is a big issue, since you need users to make sure your OS works on various hardware configurations, or else you will become an "experimental" OS like Plan 9.
munchhausen··on FreeBSD 9.0-RC1 Available...
> * ZFS - which is miles ahead of btrfs for production use

Can you explain in what way? btrfs is less mature, sure, but "enterprise Linux" vendors are about to start fully supporting in their next minor version update releases, and that is a good indicator of production use readiness, since they wouldn't do that if they weren't pretty sure it's not going to blow up in their face via an endless stream of bug reports.

> * racct and jails - cgroups is a mess

Thank you for sharing your opinion, an explanation of why it is a mess would be nice.

munchhausen··on Puppet vs Chef, Fight
> From an ease-of-use / ease-of-maintenance perspective, Debian (and its derivatives) blow RPM-based systems out of the water.

What kind of a comparison (Debian vs. RPM-based) is this? Does dpkg(1), as opposed to rpm(8), really make all the difference in "ease-of-use"?

Of course, I understand what you mean, however, don't you think that if Debian really blew RHEL and SLES out of the water, its adoption in the enterprise server space would be a bit higher? You are kidding yourself if you pretend that the commercial distros are only used because they come with support, and also need support, being intentionally crippled.

Obviously, a meaningful comparison of Debian, RHEL and SLES does not fit into a HN comment, but as someone who has used all three, I would always choose Debian last, and not only because of the lack of commercial support.

(By the way, the main point of the support you get for RHEL and SLES is not access to a guy on the phone. The real value is the L3 support, i.e. bugfixing. As a Debian user who runs into a bug that cripples your system, your options are:

a) fix it yourself

b) pray to $DEITY that Debian developers fix it soon

c) try to expedite b) by harassing Debian developers in bugzilla, which is going to be as inefficient as you'd expect.

As a paying customer of Red Hat or SuSE, you are entitled to and will receive a fix for the bug ASAP, and although ASAP often translates to "a couple of weeks", it is still a hell of a lot better than what Debian can offer.)

munchhausen··on VirtualBox is garbage
There are many voices in defense of VirtualBox in this thread already, but I will still add mine, because VirtualBox has been a great tool for me and I feel it deserves to be defended. For the last three years I use Virtualbox to run Windows and Linux VMs on a Linux host. Other than a handful of weird hickups of Windows XP guests, which can probably be attributed to the guest OS, I did not run into any major problems in what must be thousands of hours of guest and hypervisor uptime.

VMware Workstation, OTOH, crashed my host(!) system hard several times, which actually drove me to Virtualbox in the first place. Granted, that was three years ago, but I did not have any reason to give VMware Workstation another try, as Virtualbox works very well for me.

munchhausen··on Dear procrastinator
"The reason why human-beings procrastinate is to feel in control of their life."

Agree completely. Having said this, your suggested solution is incredibly hard to put into practice for many procrastinators out there.

I have bills to pay and a family to support, and working for the Man seems like the only option, at the moment, to meet my financial obligations. I don't particularly enjoy my day job, and I wouldn't do it if I didn't have to. To maintain an illusion that I am not just a slave tied to a very short leash, I procrastinate. Ignoring my email inbox full of pending tasks and spending the day outside in the sunshine instead can feel very liberating, but obviously it doesn't solve anything, and doesn't get me a step closer to greater freedom.

"life as a sequence of awesomely fun and exciting things" sounds great, but the reality is that only a very small percentage of people are lucky enough to lead this kind of life.

munchhausen··on Linus Torvalds dumps Gnome3 for XFCE (G+ discussion)
s/Linux interface designers/GNOME interface designers/

I don't think that KDE4 or Xfce, much less other alternatives, are moving towards a tablet-inspired interface.

munchhausen··on Windows 8 to feature stripped-down kernel, built-in virtualization
Where did I hear this before...ah, yes, I remember now:

Stripped-down 'MinWin' kernel to be at the core of Windows 7 and more http://www.zdnet.com/blog/microsoft/stripped-down-minwin-ker...

munchhausen··on Plot thickens in Airbnb vacation rental horror story
This article, as far as I can tell, does not contain any new information about the EJ saga. I am quite confident that, had the subject matter of the submission not been AirBnB (and thus killing it might give rise to accusations of censorship on part of YC), this submission would have been killed as a dupe, and rightly so.

What is the point of submitting the same story over and over again, albeit from different news sources? The fact that it has 98 points at the moment is proof that the angry mob PG was talking about¹ is a reality. It's sad to see this kind of behavior on HN.

¹ http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2822860

munchhausen··on Why is America the 'no-vacation nation'?
> One, you're discouraged to take time off -- you can lose your job if you're not "devoted".

I don't know that this is the case in many European countries, including Eastern Europe (at least the part of it that is in the EU). First of all, in most (all?) EU countries all workers get 4 weeks paid vacation minimum. If you do not use up all of it, your employer can offer you to "carry over" the vacation to the next year. If they do not offer you that option then they are obliged to "force" you to go on vacation after it becomes clear that you will not use up all of your vacation days. Some employers will offer to instead compensate you extra for the vacation days you did not use up - this is legal in some EU countries only.

> Two, you have to work over capacity to support yourself and your family.

I'm sorry to be so blunt, but this just doesn't make a lot of sense, since those mandatory 4 weeks of vacation are paid vacation - i.e. you get paid the same amount you would receive had you been working instead of being on vacation.

Just about the only reason why you could potentially make less money due to vacation is if you regularly do a lot of overtime (which you obviously cannot do while on vacation).

munchhausen··on [dead]
I have a friend that works at a company which is in the print media business and the entire staff uses Macs by decree. They also use OSX Server for common office needs like file-sharing and VPN, probably because it's the path of least resistance - they can afford to have their IT support staff trained only on Mac OSX, don't have to struggle with potential MacOSX <-> Samba interoperability issues, etc..

(Interestingly, their web-servers are Linux boxes, run by contractors.)

It is my understanding that this is a pretty common scenario as far as OSX Server use cases are concerned.

munchhausen··on Sony was running unpatched Apache with no firewall for months before breach
A firewall would not mitigate a vulnerability of Apache, however it might very well make it harder for the attacker to connect to a remote shell that they open on the server after exploiting Apache.

Unless the attacker would be able to get root on the box via a privilege escalation vulnerability, they would not be able to disable a firewall that blocks access to ports other than 80.

munchhausen··on Attachmate lays off Mono employees
Sensationalism at its best is at work here. Attachmate/Novell laid off a lot of employees in the US today, and "internetnews.com" goes on to extrapolate that "Today Attachmate laid off an unknown number of U.S. based Novell developers that were working on the open source Mono project". Indeed, the number is unknown - it may as well be zero.
munchhausen··on Tell HN: Please bring back comment scores
> Points should be normed by impressions, and then smoothed (or given credibility intervals or something).

I agree that this might work better for determining correctness of informative comments than just plain point scores, however point scores work better than nothing at all.

munchhausen··on Tell HN: Please bring back comment scores
Starting with an assumption that all comments are wrong is a prudent approach, which also considerably lowers the utility of HN for certain types of usage.

I read HN primarily for the informative comments, not the opinion pieces. A high comment score on an informative comment that contains a factual statement is a relatively good way how to easily tell that the information has been validated by the community and is likely to be correct.

munchhausen··on James Gosling joining Google
Judging by Gosling's current code editor preference, I would be surprised if that were to happen. Apparently he uses Netbeans and vi for coding:

http://james.gosling.usesthis.com/

munchhausen··on Time-saving tips for Linux
One thing that's definitely missing from that list is the "undo" feature of bash which is bound to Ctrl-/ by default. It reverts the last edit you did on the command line. (The keybinding invokes the undo action also in emacs.)
munchhausen··on Red Hat's response to the "obfuscated" source code accusations
> Not to anywhere even close to approaching Red Hat's extend

This needs a citation.

I for one do not agree with you. Looking at the statistics of top kernel contributors for kernel 2.6.35 by lines changed¹, Red Hat can claim 7.8% of lines changed while Novell (SuSE) is at 4.7%. The difference is considerable but I do not think it's fair to say that that it's "Not to anywhere even close to approaching Red Hat's extend[sic]".

These statistics obviously cover just the kernel. The Linux environment is much larger than that, and it should be pointed out that SuSE is _the_ major contributor to KDE with openSUSE being generally regarded as the top-of-the-line KDE distribution. Novell also contributes significantly to GNOME.

I do not want to turn this comment into a laundry list of SuSE contributions to Linux, so I'll just say that IMO SuSE are certainly holding their own as the 2nd largest enterprise Linux vendor in terms of contribution to the general Linux ecosystem. If you do not agree, I would appreciate it if you could back your opinion with substantial evidence as opposed to just making unsubstantiated claims.

¹ http://lwn.net/Articles/395961/

munchhausen··on No more desktop Linux systems in the German Foreign Office
> Getting anything equivalent to Active Directory up on Linux is an absolute nightmare, or at least so it was last time I tried. Making something as basic as making a Linux machine join a domain and authenticate against the DC work cost me a full weekend, and yet in the end I just had to give up.

I feel that your account of making a Linux machine play nicely with AD deserves a 'YMMV' addendum. In my experience it is not common that this should be so difficult to implement with a reasonably up-to-date Linux system. It also doesn't hurt to use a distribution that has undergone testing for this usage scenario, which is definitely true for the "enterprise" distros - both RHEL and SLES should give you very little trouble when it comes to joining a domain and authenticating against AD. It is indeed mostly a "just works" type of thing in the majority of cases.

munchhausen··on London Stock Exchange smashes world record trade speed with Linux
> Yes. The Linux version is developed at http://www.milleniumit.com/media_room/gui-press_releases.php

Can you elaborate on this? Are they developing a fork of the Linux kernel? A new Linux distro? Or could it be that they are developing the trading "platform", using a commodity Linux distro?

munchhausen··on Sitting more than 6hrs/day increases likelihood of premature death
I use the FREDRIK desk from IKEA. It is adjustable, it is a standing desk, and does not look like it should fall apart anytime soon - what more could you ask for?
munchhausen··on Mongrel2 Says, "Goodbye Python"
We're getting into the debate of what constitutes a "core system", and I'm afraid there's as many answers to this question as there are debaters.

As far as the update routines are concerned - you can already have those, by self-selecting which packages do you want to update. As a pro-active measure, you can even lock down packages which should never be updated.

This seems to be fine to me - the advanced user has the means to control the update mechanism, and the casual user can just do an all-encompassing "apt-get upgrade" or an equivalent to make sure that she has all the security fixes.

munchhausen··on Mongrel2 Says, "Goodbye Python"
You answered your own question - /usr/local/bin. I don't know about MacOSX but on Linux, this is the solution to your problem - "stuff that belongs to me (the sysadmin) but runnable by all users".
munchhausen··on Mongrel2 Says, "Goodbye Python"
> /usr/bin/python should be whatever I want it to be.

Why /usr/bin/python? /usr/bin/ has been for ages the "system" area - why would you want to suddenly usurp it for yourself?

/usr/local/bin/python will on most Linux systems be executed ahead of /usr/bin/python, because /usr/local/bin/ usually precedes /usr/bin/ on the $PATH. Thus you can have your cake and eat it too.

> The bottom line I guess is that mixing core OS components and user installed software in the same directory structure with no way of differentiating them is simply bad design.

Linux distro makers agree with you - if you do not customize environment variables, user-installed software goes into /usr/local/ and the OS package-management (which can be considered "system" I guess) puts executables into /usr/{bin,sbin}.

This tends to work well as long as you keep in mind that everything outside of /usr/local/ (or your customized installation path) may at any update change subject to the will of the "system". I think this is a reasonable setup - it gives the OS vendor the ability to update the system, while giving you free reign in your /usr/local/ playground.

munchhausen··on Vmware (A division of EMC) to buy Suse Linux from Novell
I don't think it does - it is just the SuSE venture that is being sold to VMware. I would imagine that the copyrights are held by the "rest of Novell".
munchhausen··on Vmware (A division of EMC) to buy Suse Linux from Novell
> My memory of the exact details are a bit fuzzy at this remove (I might be e.g. confounding versions 2 and 3), but its fatal flaw was no memory protection.

You are correct, Netware 3 ran everything in Ring 0, which also made it so fast. Memory protection was added in Netware 4, but you can still opt for running applications in non-protected address space all the way up to Netware 6.5 (latest, and almost certainly the last version).

munchhausen··on Vmware (A division of EMC) to buy Suse Linux from Novell
ESX Server does not have community support, but it has commercial support.

If you are tenacious and patient enough to make it past the first tier of support, you will get your crashed server fixed, possibly faster than it would take to wait for an answer on a mailing list.

munchhausen··on Vmware (A division of EMC) to buy Suse Linux from Novell
I didn't know that vSphere used a SuSE kernel - that's interesting. I assumed they roll their own for sure.

There must be more to it though - a couple of hundred million dollars for a Linux kernel which you can have for free anyway would be a steep price, even if we consider it as a talent acquisition to get the engineering team which built that kernel.

munchhausen··on Vmware (A division of EMC) to buy Suse Linux from Novell
So what could be VMware's plans for SuSE Linux? I am not familiar enough with their strategy to be able to speculate on this question, but I am curious - it certainly does not look like an "obvious" acquisition to me.

Keep in mind that SuSE Linux was not profitable under Novell - IIRC the SuSE venture finally broke even in the last FY, so it's not like VMware are buying SuSE to rake in the Enterprise Linux revenue.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →