HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

musage

610 karma · joined September 1, 2017

> Since, however, men are neither ants nor bees, the whole thing is a delusion. Public life takes on the deceptive aspect of a total of private interests as though these interests could create a new quality through sheer addition. All the so-called liberal concepts of politics (that is, all the pre-imperialist political notions of the bourgeoisie)-such as unlimited competition regulated by a secret balance which comes mysteriously from the sum total of competing activities, the pursuit of "enlightened self-interest" as an adequate political virtue, unlimited progress inherent in the mere succession of events -have this in common: they simply add up private lives and personal behavior patterns and present the sum as laws of history, or economics, or politics. Liberal concepts, however, while they express the bourgeoisie's instinctive distrust of and its innate hostility to public affairs, are only a temporary compromise between the old standards of Western culture and the new class's faith in property as a dynamic, self-moving principle. The old standards give way to the extent that automatically growing wealth actually replaces political action.

-- Hannah Arendt, "The Origins of Totalitarianism"

> Apart from my tech criticism, what I notice about reading those links is the very detached, indifferent, irresponsible, even COLD attitude from everybody involved in cheering on this experimental AI algorithm -- from the Google research authors, the Tubefilter authors and commenters there and in the Y Combinator discussion. While a few people complain about their music choices or political videos, or how they can make money from the new algorithm -- most of them don’t think ahead about consequences, or about other people at all. They should have just kept their experiment in the laboratory.

> Nobody discussed how the gimmicky algorithm would affect real people or ruin cultures around the world. Nobody there, in all seriousness, “thought of the children”. Now we, here, are discussing and solving THEIR industrial fallout, like factory pollution spread over a community. This is why James Bridle’s timely article was so essential to identify “infrastructural violence being done to all of us, all of the time, and we’re still struggling to find a way to even talk about it, to describe its mechanisms and its actions and its effects”.

> In my opinion, the negligent people who gave the green light to this untested algorithm or cheered it on are, in fact, responsible accomplices to infrastructural violence. And the violence is real. Their "Frankenstein AI" foolishly recommended toxic movies that harmed millions of children (and adults). The AI cheerleaders felt no hesitation to exert control over what billions of people watch and think, in a very sneaky way -- while allowing greedy marketers to manipulate their choices to make ad money, and allowing sinister pervs to groom the children watching those badly recommended movies.

https://www.reddit.com/r/ElsaGate/comments/7ebw14/reverse_engineering_the_youtube_algorithm/dq3v7jp/

submissionscomments
musage··on E.O. Wilson on Introversion, the Limits of IQ, and Where Ideas Come From
> I'm more than ever of the opinion that a decent human existence is possible today only on the fringes of society, where one then runs the risk of starving or being stoned to death. In these circumstances, a sense of humor is a great help.

-- Hannah Arendt

musage··on How the West Got China Wrong
> State is the name of the coldest of all cold monsters. Coldly it lies; and this lie slips from its mouth: "I, the state, am the people."

-- Friedrich Nietzsche

Of course, Nietzsche wrote this before companies with "no I in team" and whatnot :P

> What's wrong with having an independent sovereign government

Nothing, but "nationalism" to me implies some sort identification with a symbol, rather than interacting with reality. Sufficiently developed individuals don't "belong to" groups, it's the other way around. Tribalism is a great method to stop that development dead in its tracks.

http://orwell.ru/library/essays/nationalism/english/e_nat

> The emotional urges which are inescapable, and are perhaps even necessary to political action, should be able to exist side by side with an acceptance of reality.

In so far that is the case for what you would consider nationalism, carry on. To me, a sense of responsibility towards the place where you live and towards the people that live there is just that, while nationalism adds more and only bad things to it. I generally see it used as crutch or excuse.

musage··on How GDPR Will Change The Way You Develop
> a continuous drag on developing new technologies

Any and all of them? Because of anonymized IP addresses in server logs? I wouldn't even buy that when it comes to the web, but certainly not to mention talking about computers and software in general, or even "tech in general", whatever that would be.

musage··on What I Learned Burning $14k on YouTube Ads for Candy Japan
I made a little Elsagate scraper thingy, scrapes video metadata and thumbs of channels and takes note of featured channels, channels mentioned in descriptions and channels videos that get mentioned belong to; then I go through those, tag them as EG or not EG, rinse repeat. My point is that EG channels link lots of channels showing hands unpacking sweets and talking about them (just like they link to official cartoon channels and whatnot).. I'm just seeing this tiny, random fraction, and yet there's so many it did dent my faith in humanity some more.

I really wonder about the target audience, I can't come up with more than toddlers and Anne Wilkens from "Misery"... as for the creators, they "just want to make some money", and I know I'm mean about something that harms nobody and is voluntary to watch. Though I'm not blaming them at all for being linked from EG, I do find them demented in their own right, and can see why EG would approve of them.

musage··on In an Era of ‘Smart’ Things, Sometimes Dumb Stuff Is Better
> I was all-too-frequently chosen to go bang the chalk dust out the erasers, becoming coated from tip to toe in said dust.

Our teachers had a small bucket of water and simply cleaned the sponges themselves, if we had to do it it was fun rather than a health hazard.

> Not to mention the need for a deep cleaning of the board periodically

Again wet sponge technology comes to the rescue, plus window cleaning thingies to get the blackboard to dry before the next lesson. That school was ass backwards in so many ways, but even they didn't manage to mess up using blackboards.

> the moment it starts to crap out it's tossed and replaced from a backup container sitting nearby

How does all that plastic compare to some colored chalk and water though? What's involved in producing colored chalk versus producing whiteboard markers? It's a honest question because I have no clue, but of course the implication is that it seems likely to me, not having looked into it at all, that chalk is way more environmentally friendly.

I also think the skill ceiling for chalk, and the possible range of styles, is greater, so to speak. But I never really saw gifted whiteboard use, and did have some teachers who had beautiful handwriting on a blackboard and used little tricks to make neat graphs or images, who had a real sense of craftsmanship if not artistry about it, so I'm probably biased in the other direction.

musage··on Who Killed the Junior Developer?
The Dunning-Kruger effect is a bias and as such deals with probabilities. It doesn't mean any given individual says they're the best (in their neck of the woods) at something is definitely wrong.
musage··on Bloxels – Build Your Own Video Games
> It is very sad then that so many children are hurried along and not given time to think about themselves. People say to them when they think that they have been playing long enough: "You are no longer a child. You must begin to do something." But although playing is doing nothing, you are really doing something when you play; you are thinking about yourself. Many children play in the wrong way. They make work out of play. They not only seem to be doing something, they really are doing something. They are imitating the grown-ups around them who are always doing as much instead of as little as possible. And they are often encouraged to play in this way by the grown-ups. And they are not learning to be themselves.

and

> People who for some reason find it impossible to think about themselves, and so really be themselves, try to make up for not thinking with doing. They try to pretend that doing is thinking.

-- Laura Riding

> Most of us are unable to sort out reality - we can't distinguish between a thing and a symbol for that thing . This springs from several causes. One cause is that we are isolated from the natural world, where the distinction between a thing and a symbol is more obvious. Another cause is our educational system, which simply reflects the intellectual laziness of the society in which it is embedded. A third cause is resistance on the part of vested interests - if we could think creatively, we would be difficult to govern, and advertisers would have to appeal to reason instead of emotion.

-- Paul Lutus

> I have a foreboding of an America in my children's or grandchildren's time -- when the United States is a service and information economy; when nearly all the manufacturing industries have slipped away to other countries; when awesome technological powers are in the hands of a very few, and no one representing the public interest can even grasp the issues; when the people have lost the ability to set their own agendas or knowledgeably question those in authority; when, clutching our crystals and nervously consulting our horoscopes, our critical faculties in decline, unable to distinguish between what feels good and what's true, we slide, almost without noticing, back into superstition and darkness...

-- Carl Sagan

> Education is the point at which we decide whether we love the world enough to assume responsibility for it, and by the same token save it from that ruin which except for renewal, except for the coming of the new and the young, would be inevitable. And education, too, is where we decide whether we love our children enough not to expel them from our world and leave them to their own devices, nor to strike from their hands their chance of undertaking something new, something unforeseen by us, but to prepare them in advance for the task of renewing a common world.

-- Hannah Arendt

I think critical thinking are important. Autonomy. So sure, teach your children to customize and program the devices they probably end up using to some capacity either way. But also allow for the fact that "technology", unqualified like that, might be kool-aid, and that following the trajectory of previous generations is not necessarily the best possible direction to go in. Imagine having children that are less alienated than yourself, wouldn't that be cool? People that can hold eye contact longer, that fidget less when they have to wait in line for 3 minutes? Who can bear their own company? Who can let their inner eye stray across their past, their surroundings, their self, at the speed they chose, without any compulsion to ignore or distort things? For as long as they want, instead of not at all? Yes, absolutely cue parodies of spoken word diatribes here, and whatever else. I'm just virtue signalling, and so on.

At any rate, the question isn't "technology or not", the question is what technology and what people use it for, rather than what it uses people for (on the behest of others who are on the run from themselves).

musage··on Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They Shot an Unarmed Person
> Cathartic for people who want to rant about Americans and guns and ACAB

How are such straw men intellectually gratifying? How is that not tedious boilerplate? How is you reading something a hundred times even a factor compared to hundreds of murders swept under the rug? Don't wanna read about it, put an end to it.

musage··on Exploring what loneliness does to the human body
Air with 0.00002% oxygen isn't technically the "opposite" of breathable air either, but if it fills the lungs ("quells" the space for other air), the effects are the "opposite" of the purpose of breathing.
musage··on Knife-threatening app banned by Google
Thanks, but "yes" would have sufficed. The operative keyword in your comment still remains "seems". Seems to you, I would add.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VZrF7v6jfLw

musage··on Knife-threatening app banned by Google
Talk of a knife getting stabbed into a kid? Are you for real?
musage··on Former employees say Lyft staffers spied on passengers
I rode in plenty taxis and never in ones that had either of that. The drivers seemed pretty relaxed about the whole thing, as was I.
musage··on Jack White bans phones at gigs for “100% human experience”
Speaking of scary, check out this breed:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15913342

> Having lived through the horrors of the pre-smartphone days

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15913665

> I remember life before smartphones. I remember boredom. It sucked. I would never go back to the agonizing pain of sitting in the DMV for three ours or standing in line at a grocery store just for some "missed moment" where I study the shitty tabloids in line or DoT pamphlets.

> Romanticising the past is not new. Whether it's television, hot showers, or smartphones, there will always be cynics who wish a simpler life on the rest of us.

musage··on Jack White bans phones at gigs for “100% human experience”
Nah, they won't be able to wonder anything anymore. The spaces where human personality might develop will all be filled and sealed shut.
musage··on Former employees say Lyft staffers spied on passengers
What do you do when you pay with 20$ for something, but get change for 10$? Why are "argue with them", "accept the loss and move on", "karate chop" and infinite other things not among the options?

> You need to know that I was in their vehicle, otherwise how can they charge me if I ruin their car. You need to know they were my driver.

How did taxi drivers handle that for the last nearing 100 years? People before us managed sticky situations without destroying human civilization, so can we.

musage··on NSA Deletes “Honesty” and “Openness” from Core Values
They don't need to be crooks, either, doesn't seem to stop them. They don't need to come up with childish logos combined with super cereal latin text, but they're still doing it; something like "Total Information Awareness" isn't the expression of a need, it's the symptom of serious issues. If they knew what they needed they wouldn't be doing what they're doing, and wouldn't need to circle the wagons of the "Intelligence Community" for emotional support.

Do companies that pollute the environment and obsess about environmental activists so much that their undercover people outnumber the undercover agents of intelligence agencies NEED to be so very pathetic? I'd say they "just" need to stop whatever they think they are doing and be grateful towards those giving them a hint, but nope -- they can't eat what's on their plate, so they shit in our food. And anyone even dreaming of suggesting putting first things first probably wouldn't make it past apprentice in most such orgs.

musage··on China, Unhampered by Rules, Races Ahead in Gene-Editing Trials
We can't even make it on Earth without horribly fumbling it, how would moving out to dead rocks help?

This is how we play for time, this is the whimpering with which we fade out. Looking straight at the iceberg, saying "it'll probably transform to cotton candy if we hit it fast enough". The drunk captain and the armed guards letting no sane person near the bridge is how you know everything is fine.

musage··on China, Unhampered by Rules, Races Ahead in Gene-Editing Trials
> "To them, violence, power, cruelty, were the supreme capacities of men who had definitely lost their place in the universe and were much too proud to long for a power theory that would safely bring them back and reintegrate them into the world. They were satisfied with blind partisanship in anything that respectable society had banned, regardless of theory or content, and they elevated cruelty to a major virtue because it contradicted society’s humanitarian and liberal hypocrisy."

-- Hannah Arendt

Where you see a "shadow" or something "hampering", I see a railing. Where you hear criticism of the jealous people left behind, I am waving at a dot that is getting smaller and smaller.

musage··on Linus Torvalds: “Somebody is pushing complete garbage for unclear reasons.”
> Imagine you go to a restaurant, and the waiter just repeatedly brings you the wrong order, repeatedly.

I agree with you in general, but that's a bad example IMO. If they are stressed out and make honest mistakes, even if they're totally incompetent and stupid, I would probably laugh harder each subsequent time and assure them it's no big deal, and it would be true. With anyone, but doubly so with anyone who handles my food.

If on the other hand they just didn't care etc., I'd leave at some point and never return. The point at which there would be something to get nasty about is also past the point where it would still make sense to be nasty about it, if you know what I mean.

Not that I think Linus is being particularly nasty, and as I said, I generally agree. But that example rubbed me the wrong way, I just had to speak up, sorry ^^

musage··on Paying journalists to promote brands in articles
Are you sure? Surely they realize that someone saying the lines are blurry "these days" does in no way imply that they have not always been blurry.
musage··on Paying journalists to promote brands in articles
Are you claiming all journalists are corrupt?

"This file may be named image.jpg, but there is no JPEG data in it to be parsed."

"I doubt there was ever a golden age where technology was perfect."

"A very keen observation, this still isn't a JPEG file though."

musage··on BlackRock’s Message: Contribute to Society, or Risk Losing Our Support
X amounts of pollutants per mile might be fine, X * N amount might be "destroying the world". Encapsulating it in a boolean doesn't make it magically that simple.
musage··on How America Fractured in 1968
Why not link that account?

Mentioned in another comment:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoenix_Program

> Military intelligence officer K. Barton Osborne reports that he witnessed the following use of torture:

> > The use of the insertion of the 6-inch dowel into the canal of one of my detainee's ears, and the tapping through the brain until dead. The starvation to death (in a cage), of a Vietnamese woman who was suspected of being part of the local political education cadre in one of the local villages...The use of electronic gear such as sealed telephones attached to...both the women's vaginas and men's testicles [to] shock them into submission

Yes, I bet a some anti-social people used the protest movement to engage in their own oppression ("killing pigs" and "killing commie charlies" is the same thing in a way), but using them as a fig leaf is blatantly profiting of their deeds to hide yet other vile deeds, and to smear the best parts of a generation that at least tried.

That professor may never know even just one first-hand account of a person murdered as they looked away, and in turn may never know the life they actually lived. People don't like to hear that, but sometimes, who you think you are is just a shiny consolation price for being distracted from what you're actually serving. People can fool themselves and beyond a threshold, they're usually too weak to ever stop fooling themselves. They fell down the gravity well, let them serve as a warning. See them, see the well, and judge their words accordingly.

musage··on BlackRock’s Message: Contribute to Society, or Risk Losing Our Support
Google translates it as

> Property obliges. Its use should also serve the public good.

which is more or less accurate.

> If you want to spend your resources on public good, find a good charity.

That's kinda like saying cars should only go fast, if you also want to not die when taking a breath outside, you have to wear a gas mask or deploy nanobots that remove pollutants from the atmosphere.

Public transport is fastest when everybody just uses kung fu to move others out of the way, and when the doors are razor sharp and close on a timer -- if you also want people to not be injured, go to a hospital.

musage··on Simone Giertz makes a living creating shitty robots (2016) [video]
Making people less fearful of machines by derping around and normalizing Google Home and et al, how is that something to write home about, proudly?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ab47XHidvwQ&t=1m55s

You might as well call "social experiment" videos "entertaining people with science" because there goes theory and engineering into the pixel displays people consume them on.

Oh, but call to action for victims of some thing or other, so how could anyone possibly "hate", right? Isn't she self-deprecating enough, already? This is the equivalent of cat videos for nerds -- same shit, different target audience. A dime a dozen, and it's all crap in the same patterns. The sad part is, most people aren't shills, this is simply what they come up with anyway, even when they're not backed by marketing teams, they do their best to produce similar output.

I think it's insulting my intelligence, as part of a pebble on a beach of shit. And instead of allowing each pebble to hide behind the beach, I hold the beach against each pebble.

musage··on Facebook Overhauls News Feed to Focus on What Friends and Family Share
Just show all things from all subscribed sources in chronological order, add pagination, filtering and sorting, and you might have yourself something.
musage··on What's the Difference Between Children's Books in China and the U.S.?
> They’re inanimate letters.

Cats don't actually starve when they don't get to eat those.

And why only say that now? What does the "compassion for the cat" have to do with it it either way?

What German fairy tales about non-conformist things being destroyed were you raised on? And did your learning of penmanship involve any of that?

And they don't even bend the (part of the) rules (under discussion here), non-conforming letters still get eaten.

musage··on What's the Difference Between Children's Books in China and the U.S.?
It's about the fate of the letters, not the cat. At the end, non-conforming letters get made just so they can get exterminated. Great.
musage··on Apple's privacy feature costs ad companies millions
To me "trust" is an absolute thing; it comes in degrees, but the anchor is absolute, and in you. "rather trust" in contrast is relative and something entirely different. Yeah, sometimes we have to bite bullets or choose poisons, but I'd still set apart from things I really like and want to see prosper in the world.

For me, not collecting data warrants trust, not whatever mental gymnastics involving "collecting data, but". If that data is vital for companies or applications beyond a certain scale, then I don't trust companies or applications beyond a certain scale, and would prefer to see them all pruned by consumers using their brains to vote with their wallets. Some behemoths so desperately want a world in which they're vital, to me that's a world doomed to die in important ways. That's not aimed at Apple, but among tech companies, they don't even make my list of considerations for top N thousand I like or trust. Not to mention companies and organizations in general.

But more importantly it's not like I have to chose whom of a bunch of shady fucks I trust most. If I don't trust any of them, that's fine with me, too.

As for business, I like the people at my local bakery. I trust them with bread, I guess, and I know when they smile they mean it. Those people have stature to me, and the bigger a company is, the more pervasive marketing is in it, the more it resembles a lot of tiny people playing big person. I don't trust that, and I laugh when those then put out marketing to make themselves seem 0.1% as cool as random individual people are to me, to whom the thought of being cool doesn't even occur. True, Apple might be less of a POS than its direct siblings, but that's still a rounding error in the grand scheme of things. I'd say we'll outright settle for one or several of them and the precedents they set at our own peril.

Sorry for the rant, please don't take this as some sort of violent disagreement with you, I was really just ranting. But it does sicken me how far we fell.

musage··on Fujitsu's Citywide Surveillance
You know, part of me just wants to mirror that, and ask "what is your actual question?", but okay.

Just in the sentence I quoted, "complicated" crimes is just padding, but of course, you can't sell "getting more complex" with the argument of "crime still exists". Then there's "unexpected" natural disasters, which is padding, too. Of course, natural disasters aren't social challenges. "This situation" -- of which there is nothing left other than "crime exists" -- always existed, and what is a "global concern"? People all over the world have been concerned with their personal safety for longer than history exists, so what changed?

Nothing changed, and if I had to guess, based on what we know about corporations and governments monitoring people who care about the environment in the least I'd say they want to peddle total control to prevent uprisings that will come when the natural disasters (we can predict to get worse, since we keep destroying our environment) get out of hand. But that's just a bonus, without that it's just marketing gibberish, and that I needed to point any of this out further eroded my faith in humanity.

← PreviousPage 2 of 11Next →