HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

musage

610 karma · joined September 1, 2017

> Since, however, men are neither ants nor bees, the whole thing is a delusion. Public life takes on the deceptive aspect of a total of private interests as though these interests could create a new quality through sheer addition. All the so-called liberal concepts of politics (that is, all the pre-imperialist political notions of the bourgeoisie)-such as unlimited competition regulated by a secret balance which comes mysteriously from the sum total of competing activities, the pursuit of "enlightened self-interest" as an adequate political virtue, unlimited progress inherent in the mere succession of events -have this in common: they simply add up private lives and personal behavior patterns and present the sum as laws of history, or economics, or politics. Liberal concepts, however, while they express the bourgeoisie's instinctive distrust of and its innate hostility to public affairs, are only a temporary compromise between the old standards of Western culture and the new class's faith in property as a dynamic, self-moving principle. The old standards give way to the extent that automatically growing wealth actually replaces political action.

-- Hannah Arendt, "The Origins of Totalitarianism"

> Apart from my tech criticism, what I notice about reading those links is the very detached, indifferent, irresponsible, even COLD attitude from everybody involved in cheering on this experimental AI algorithm -- from the Google research authors, the Tubefilter authors and commenters there and in the Y Combinator discussion. While a few people complain about their music choices or political videos, or how they can make money from the new algorithm -- most of them don’t think ahead about consequences, or about other people at all. They should have just kept their experiment in the laboratory.

> Nobody discussed how the gimmicky algorithm would affect real people or ruin cultures around the world. Nobody there, in all seriousness, “thought of the children”. Now we, here, are discussing and solving THEIR industrial fallout, like factory pollution spread over a community. This is why James Bridle’s timely article was so essential to identify “infrastructural violence being done to all of us, all of the time, and we’re still struggling to find a way to even talk about it, to describe its mechanisms and its actions and its effects”.

> In my opinion, the negligent people who gave the green light to this untested algorithm or cheered it on are, in fact, responsible accomplices to infrastructural violence. And the violence is real. Their "Frankenstein AI" foolishly recommended toxic movies that harmed millions of children (and adults). The AI cheerleaders felt no hesitation to exert control over what billions of people watch and think, in a very sneaky way -- while allowing greedy marketers to manipulate their choices to make ad money, and allowing sinister pervs to groom the children watching those badly recommended movies.

https://www.reddit.com/r/ElsaGate/comments/7ebw14/reverse_engineering_the_youtube_algorithm/dq3v7jp/

submissionscomments
musage··on The growing body of evidence that digital distraction is damaging our minds
> But the person I was replying to was fretting that, god forbid, a child be more distracted by a phone like x or y person they know was distracted by games, and not become z person they should be.

But that's the thing, they weren't. I can't find that upstream in this thread. But I'm happy to hold that position.

> It's so ironic, because so many distractions have existed for decades, but you've turned out fine.

I'm not convinced that many people actually did. Right now, it's getting more and more absurd, more and more shallow and violent, and climate and pollution nobody really feels responsible for. The branch we evolved on is being cut off, and we suffer from bystander paralysis. But we're fine because we can actually sleep well in this pathological mess? How sure are we that the people who act out in silly or destructive ways are not more sane still than those who don't even do that? Personally I'm not sure at all.

> Why not let your child discover for themselves what turns them on, despite the distractions and all?

Because they're not by themselves, we're not talking about kids finding mobile devices in the woods. It's kinda saying let the kid deal with the onslaught of machines and algorithms made by all adults except their actual parents, as if the whole world only wants their best, while the parents just selfishly want to have a second chance at their regrets and so on.

I super duper disagree. I don't disagree with your point in a vacuum (Franz Kafka expressed similar thoughts in letters to Elli Hermann), but in this context I do. Like when someone says "too much sugar is harmful" and someone else talks about how we shouldn't expect others to conform to our ideals of beauty. Yeah, it's technically correct, but in context it smells, because it's not addressing the actual point made in the least, and is making assumptions about people you don't know the first thing about.

If a kid gets hooked to ElsaGate videos ( https://i.imgur.com/AlTHFn5.jpg ), who am I to say they're wrong? Someone paying attention. If 99.99% of the people on the planet said "it's fine" that wouldn't make it fine, it would put 99.99% of the people on the planet my personal trash heap. When I was a child, I didn't hold back with my opinion, so why would I do that as an adult? I haven't even found ONE serious adult who can actually take in ElsaGate (the linked image is a joke, a tiny crop of a still frame of a trailer, but even that's too much already). And that's just a derpy bumbling first step, this shit will evolve and iterate. But oh yeah, let's mock "think of the kids". This is cavemen playing with nuclear bombs, bragging.

There's being hurt a little bit, and there's being swallowed whole, and the thing about getting swallowed whole is that you don't live to get hurt a little bit another day.

musage··on Fujitsu's Citywide Surveillance
> Currently, urban infrastructure is increasingly getting more complex as we face many social challenges, such as complicated crimes and unexpected natural disasters. This situation requires that the establishment of a safe and secure society become a global concern.

Where to begin... if you're looking for social challenges, don't look further than people who can't think on an adult level being fed marketing materials by people who are just as lost, and no longer seem to even feel the need to hide it.

musage··on The growing body of evidence that digital distraction is damaging our minds
And how does that apply to what it was replied to, namely this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16100002

If "but they're not you" (what they? there is no they in that comment) is such a great argument that it absolutely needs a response, "you're not the person you're talking to, stop trying to influence them, they're not you" is a sufficient one. Your own medicine, take it first.

musage··on Apple shareholders push for study of phone addiction in children
> doesn't necessarily mean that "new things kids like are especially likely to be bad" is a good heuristic

That heuristic is a strawman. Who employs it? Quote someone, I doubt you can. And then there's the countless new things kids like that nobody on the planet says a peep about, how do those figure in?

As for "heuristics", consider the notion that if kids like something new and untested en masse, they themselves may not be able to discern what is going on, so adults need to pay attention. Full stop, that's before getting into the actual signs that this particular issue might not be all peachy.

A study is just a study. You can hardly fearmonger about Apple sponsoring studies that skew the results against mobile devices. So why does this thread even exist? Because FUD exists, and even though this isn't FUD, it needs to be pre-emptively countered by false assurances in the form of memes?

Last but not least, it's not as if "let's study X" is how it used to be said... so to imply the equation "let's study X" == "X is of the devil for sure!" shouldn't slip under the radar the way it does.

musage··on Apple shareholders push for study of phone addiction in children
But we're soley not operating on "extreme suspicions because something is new" here. The letter does cite some studies, for starters. And you're mixing up "haven't always borne out exactly as predicted by the most worried people" and "have never borne out".

There was a time when using x-ray machines in shoe shops seemed totally benign, like a fun, useful thing. Suspicions about that "new thing" as well as others were correct. Including here, that list starts with "comic book" and ends with "internet and facebook" addiction, which are absolutely worth studying.

musage··on Apple shareholders push for study of phone addiction in children
What opinion is expressed here? There's a vague implication of "this is unfounded" they cannot even be bothered to put in clear words, much less make a case for, while trying to make up for that by repetition. So it's not okay to "think of the children", ever, but let's play good Samaritan for what is nothing more than a meme because it's a "valid opinion". Got it.
musage··on Apple shareholders push for study of phone addiction in children
And, like clockwork, your type of comment shows up, completely unaware of the irony.
musage··on Apple shareholders push for study of phone addiction in children
Couldn't that be rewritten as "advocating a position for affiliation instead of advocacy"?

And if I point out a potential bug in your or our program, is the claim "you only do this to impress people who hate this type of bug" (which can rarely be proven or refuted) a good enough reason to not even look into it?

musage··on CPU Usage Differences After Applying Meltdown Patch at Epic Games
I just threw up into my mouth a little.
musage··on Corporate B.S. Generator
I haven't worked on this for ages, and never really finished filling up all word lists with enough words, but just to give you an idea for how you can get fun results in a super simple way, some excerpts from the files that make it up (the "algorithm" is actually easiest part, the hard and fun bit is coming up with words), and some examples:

some examples for some word lists:

    buzz adj			atomic, neutral, energetic, dynamic
    buzz adj process		integrating, horizontal, dynamic
    buzz adv			dynamically
    buzz noun device		generator, module
    buzz noun process		integration
    buzz noun resource		wisdom, community, client, security, information
    buzz noun resource plur	clients, partnerships

    corp adj corp-feature	governmental, associated
    corp adj corp-status	incorporated, associated
    corp adj resource-feature 	public, open, governmental
    corp name			indigo, paradox
    corp noun process		processing
    corp noun resource		information

    gen letter 			a, b, c
    gen name given female	gabi
    gen name given male		bobby
    gen name sur		smith, frank
snippets using those:

    corporation°[Buzz adj] [Buzz noun process] [Corp adj corp-status]
    corporation°[Buzz adj] [Buzz noun process] [Corp noun corp-type]
    corporation°[Buzz adj] [Buzz noun process] [Corp noun corp-type] [Corp adj corp-status]
    corporation°[Buzz adj] [Buzz noun resource] [Buzz noun process]
    corporation°[Buzz adj] [Buzz noun resource] [Buzz noun process] [Corp adj corp-status]
    corporation°[Buzz adj] [Buzz noun resource] [Buzz noun process] [Corp noun corp-type]
    corporation°[Buzz adj] [Buzz noun resource] [Corp noun corp-type]
    corporation°[Buzz noun resource] [Buzz noun process] [Corp noun corp-type] [Corp adj corp-status]
    corporation°[Corp adj corp-feature] [Buzz adj] [Buzz noun resource]
    corporation°[Corp adj corp-status] [Buzz adj] [Buzz noun resource] [Buzz noun process]
    job description°[Buzz adj] [buzz noun item sing] [Buzz noun process]
    job description°[Buzz adj] [buzz noun process] of [Buzz noun resource]
    job description°[Buzz adj] [buzz noun processor] of [Buzz noun resource]
    job description°[Buzz adj] [buzz noun resource] [buzz noun process]
    job description°[Buzz adv] [buzz verb]s the [Buzz noun item plur]
    job description°[Buzz adv] [buzz verb]s the [Buzz noun resource] [Buzz noun item plur]
    job description°[Buzz adv] [buzz verb]s the [Buzz noun resource] [Buzz noun process]
    job description°[Buzz noun item sing] [Buzz noun process]
    job description°[Buzz noun resource] [Buzz noun process]
    job description°[Buzz verb]s the [Buzz noun resource] [Buzz noun process]
    job description°[Buzz verb]s the [Buzz noun resource] [buzz noun item plur]
and then both can get used in templates in various ways. Some results:

> Founded in 1974 by Ethelbert V. Bonior and Kristian Elliott, we specialize in recognition of speculation, with a value-added certification of plausability. Other areas of expertise are trust production, fusion of confusion, digitized networks counting, needs-based definition of e-business and privacy redefinition.

> Founded in 1997 by Corabella A. Franks and Marrissa Dante, we specialize in discovery of encryption, with a digitized reduction of authority. Other areas of expertise are greed tracking, interfacing of transparency, structured synergy transportation, driven computing of music and storage transfer.`

Our products include:

Eco-centric Badger Pool

For stability integration. Streamlines plausability.

    - private change enhancer
    - capability identification packager
    - re-contextualized archiver of feedback
    - sophisticated elimination of mindshare
    - ethical module enforcement producer
Tertiary Web Branch

For quality assurance response. Seizes space.

    - efficient analysis of greed
    - integrated communication visualization
    - bi-linear footprint transaction
    - feedback redefinition visualizer
    - technology responder
musage··on Intentional Fire-Spreading by “Firehawk” Raptors in Northern Australia
Personal integrity? Calm? Harmony with surroundings?

I wonder if there are animals that produce ElsaGate videos, or come up with rationalizations for them. I'm sure there's animals who eat their offspring in certain situations, but are there any that just bite them to death, to then proceed to run in hysterical circles, counting symbols and telling themselves "narratives"? Where can I find such a pathetic thing in the wild?

musage··on iMac Pro's T2 chip
Not with that attitude, and not with this crowd.

Even if that doesn't magically create good things out of thin air, I so would love to separate for good from those who don't even want good things.

musage··on German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire account
> it wasn't necessary for their rise to power [..] they could have

So you may claim, and I disagree. Importantly, "they could have" != "they did".

musage··on German hate speech law tested as Twitter blocks satire account
Hitler wasn't elected, he was appointed. Which doesn't take away from your point, but it's really astonishing how such easy to correct falsehoods about such a deeply important subject just linger on and get repeated.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_presidential_election,_...

The Nazis lied and cheated and murdered their way to power, make no mistake about it. And that was kind of like an onion, too, in that every layer of the Nazi apparatus deceived lower layers.

Apart from the intrinsic importance of things like poverty and unemployment simply because they hurt people no matter how people to react to it, what turned some people into sociopaths (and why it didn't others) is useful to know to prevent more coming into existence, and to leave the ones who aren't beyond the point of return a way out -- but it's also a destructive red herring when dealing with those who are beyond the point of return. They are eating chalk and holding up people who delivered themselves as hostages unto them, so you can have empathy they can only feign and use; and the question is, at what point does the tragedy of their hostages outweigh the tragedy of who they and their hostages will trample on, forever, if given half a chance.

I know it's cold and kind of heartless, but for many people who turns abuser after having been abused, you will also find those who have been abused even more, but did not turn to abusing others. It's not either person's fault or credit, but I can't cater to the first while ignoring the second. Insofar it's a zero-sum choice (and that's not generally the case, mind you, but it's also not never the case), I made my choice. Sometimes, the wheel that squeaks the loudest shouldn't get the grease, but simply should get replaced by a better or even no wheel.

musage··on Google used a tax loophole to shelter $19.2B
Are sociopaths entitled to not be judged by their non-sociopath peers? Why?
musage··on Facebook Is Deleting Accounts at the Direction of the US and Israeli Governments
Or anything else, except speaking up, as demonstrated here. I mean, someone made a comment implying FB only removes really nasty, criminal things, but they don't get told that "it's Facebook's business" (even though it would apply just as much, but never is applied, to supportive comments), instead the response that adds some grounding in reality does. This is a discussion site, and the correct response to GP is to respond to GP, not do something else elsewhere.
musage··on Many major websites are taking silent anti-ad-blocking measures
> Firstly, none of those examples are subtle.

Who mentioned subtle? That's not even moving a goalpost, that's conjuring one out of thin air.

> However the association of candy bars and decadence didn't come from advertisers originally.

Again: so? The point is they use it. The point of many ads being "inherently psychologically abusive" stands, and I count the space wasted on sophistry to try and wriggle out of that as further damage caused by it.

musage··on Google will turn on native ad-blocking in Chrome on February 15
It's not "free", they give it away to sell ads. With Microsoft, before the constant update stuff, you could at least say you buy version X of product Y and then you have that, like some tool in a tool shed. Now that's a shifting mess of attached strings, too, but Google was never anything but that.
musage··on Unknown Mozilla dev addon "Looking Glass 1.0.3" on browser
"and more" == "whatever"
musage··on [dead]
I think the technical term for the correct response to this is "let's roll". Boycott the related companies and people into the ground.
musage··on “I Don’t Know, Probably Made My Usual C”
Not gonna fly on HN, where any "serious" programming by definition takes place in teams, where people welcome stuff like Go enforcing a brace style just so they don't have to argue with others, but alas, it's true:

> This silent consensus had informed me, both at the lyé and at the university, that one shouldn't bother worrying about what was really meant when using a term like "volume", which was "obviously self-evident", "generally known", "unproblematic", etc. I'd gone over their heads, almost as a matter of course, even as Lesbesgue himself had, several decades before, gone over their heads. It is in this gesture of "going beyond", to be something in oneself rather than the pawn of a consensus, the refusal to stay within a rigid circle that others have drawn around one - it is in this solitary act that one finds true creativity. All others things follow as a matter of course.

-- Alexandre Grothendieck, "The Life of a Mathematician - Reflections and Bearing Witness" (1986)

> Even in literature and art, no man who bothers about originality will ever be original: whereas if you simply try to tell the truth (without caring twopence how often it has been told before) you will, nine times out of ten, become original without ever having noticed it.

-- C. S. Lewis

musage··on Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past East German Border
> the trust that was growing at that time and the hope we all began to take for granted

> my kid

You can't make this shit up.

musage··on Newly Declassified Documents: NATO Wouldn't Move Past East German Border
The fact is that they made the assurance, and then lied and said they never gave such an assurance. If you think lying isn't nefarious, that's your outlook.
musage··on Microsoft Announces Simplygon Cloud; Optimizes Mixed Reality Development
https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/gone

But good job attempting to shame unrelated people with unrelated "reading disabilities"* just to make a point you don't even have.

* Which ones would that be? Reading what you read "aloud in your head" with an actual grasp how to pronounce things? Any others you care to make up, or was it just the one and you thought using the plural would make it an even more sick of a burn?

musage··on We’re sorry, and we’re not rolling out the fees change
> Cash costs money too--you have to count it, handle it, deposit it, protect it from theft, verify it's authenticity, make sure you have enough change, spend time counting change, etc.

Holy God. I might as well say it's all equally free, since when the heat death of the universe is done with, there will be no difference between something having existed or taken place or not.

musage··on Re: Moving from PHP to Go and Back Again
Yeah, that's what I thought.
musage··on Google to open artificial intelligence centre in China
There is a difference between an analogy and a comparison. Just think of it as it working with murderers for commercial gain, and try again, as far as the analogy is concerned.

China is plenty totalitarian, too, so even as a comparison it's not that far off (though you won't be able to follow comparisons either if you think things have to be exactly the same thing to be compared). You might even say the Nazis weren't Nazis before they started and lost their war; if they had stuck with, say, attacking Poland and Russia, and had kept their concentration camps secret (i.e. plausibly deniable), they still might be darlings of Western business elites even today, as Hitler was before the stuff we now have 20/20 hindsight on.

Last but not least, a big ambition is living a life you then don't have to lie to yourself about. Compared to that, "advancing AI" isn't even an ambition, nevermind a big one.

musage··on YouTube Demonetization Screenshot Leaks and Secret YouTube Meeting
Not even once. Not even in the context of something called "Youtube for Kids". Pearl-clutching consideration for others: not okay. Pearl-clutching shock over people having consideration for others: totally on.
musage··on Re: Moving from PHP to Go and Back Again
Why can't I have my own outlook and priorities? Why can't I like what I at a casual glance at the Rust docs? When I say casual glance, I mean casual glance, and if I missed something really horrible, I'll find it soon enough once I started actually using Rust; but I'm not going to feel silly for something you can't even be bothered to point out.

People actually sit there and say not even having the option saves them discussions, and that's not satire? I program entirely for my own utility and artsy experimental purposes, so I don't care what is useful for teams, that is 100% irrelevant for how useful or comfortable a specific language is for me. Which is what my comment referred to, how much I enjoy, or not enjoy, writing in Go so far.

I didn't call the language bad, I even said I'm too much of a simpleton coder to to have much use for arcane differences. I just said that after not even having finished my first project in Go I can already tell you, without any irony, that this brace style being enforced is a deal breaker for me. I'm still finishing the project, you know. If people have all these great reasons for not minding the lack of an option and not even having a choice, why are they so insecure about one individual minding it? My comment went to +5 shortly after posting and is now at -2, I think that's just hilarious ^^

musage··on YouTube Demonetization Screenshot Leaks and Secret YouTube Meeting
I found that channel by following chains of featured channels from hardcore ElsaGate channels. You'll also find such coloring videos on channels that have blatantly messed up content, too.

> it seems like US Americans are projecting their particular sensibilities onto videos made by some people in an entirely different part of the world

What part of the world would that be? Just saying "oh, there's probably a culture that has these different sensibilities" is heard a lot around ElsaGate, without ever actually referencing a specific culture. And what is an "entirely different" part of the world? Made of antimatter?

> It's important that we don't just lump everything that makes us uncomfortable into the same category.

None of this makes me feel "uncomfortable" though, and I'm not American either, so don't lump my reaction and your reaction together as "our" reaction. Also, just because the fringe is not the center, doesn't mean they're not connected: don't lump noticing the connection together with lumping things together.

"Disturbing" or "weird" or "uncomfortable" or "nice" or "awesome" and so on are not very descriptive words. A cold breeze might make me feel uncomfortable, so might a video of a puppy getting hurt, but that doesn't describe these things. It's making it about the people calling it out, and I for one am not buying.

← PreviousPage 3 of 11Next →