HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mwigdahl

1,303 karma · joined July 18, 2017

submissionscomments
mwigdahl··on I avoid using LLMs as a publisher and writer
Yes, and it was exactly the same with compilers. All hype and fad -- everyone who's serious about software development writes in assembly.
mwigdahl··on Claude Code adds native support for Windows
Surprisingly little press for a fairly major enhancement. I work in a Windows shop, and while the WSL2 setup isn't terrible, our IS group has nested virtualization turned off, so our developers and automated testers using VM development machines can't use it.

This single release unlocks a lot of folks who wanted to use the tool but couldn't, and removes a number of headaches for me.

mwigdahl··on Anthropic Is Bleeding Out
Compared to when Claude Code was originally released in late February, its token use is greatly reduced now. Since the late May Claude 4 releases I agree with you; it hasn't decreased much since then.
mwigdahl··on Measuring the impact of AI on experienced open-source developer productivity
I've never seen a post telling someone who claimed that AI didn't improve their productivity that they were mistaken and that actually it had.

Plenty of "you're holding it wrong" and "it works for me", but not directly telling someone that their perceptions were inaccurate.

mwigdahl··on Measuring the impact of AI on experienced open-source developer productivity
I would agree with you that the jump from Sonnet 3.7 to Sonnet 4 feels notable but not shocking. Opus 4 is considerably better, and Opus 4 combined with the Claude Code harness is what really unlocks the value for me.
mwigdahl··on Measuring the impact of AI on experienced open-source developer productivity
Plus the gaslighting to follow for anyone claiming AI improved their productivity.
mwigdahl··on Grok 4
I find I get a _lot_ of Opus with the $200 plan. It's not unlimited, but I rarely cap out (I'm also not a super power user that spins up multiple instances with tons of subagents either, though).
mwigdahl··on Grok 4
Yes. The tooling harness of Claude Code is really good, and Claude 4 is well-optimized for it. The combination is very powerful.
mwigdahl··on Measuring the impact of AI on experienced open-source developer productivity
I've been a proponent for a long time, so I certainly fit this at least partially. However, the combination of Claude Code and the Claude 4 models has pushed the response to my demos of AI coding at my org from "hey, that's kind of cool" to "Wow, can you get me an API key please?"

It's been a very noticeable uptick in power, and although there have been some nice increases with past model releases, this has been both the largest and the one that has unlocked the most real value since I've been following the tech.

mwigdahl··on Grok 4 Launch [video]
Yes. Tried on Openrouter:

Please stop.

Look up.

I need your help.

Watch him jump.

It's time to sleep.

Try to keep.

Take one more step.

We love to shop.

Climb to the top.

Fill the cup.

Board the ship.

Don't move your lip.

Shake your hip.

Here's a good tip.

Use the whip.

Do a quick flip.

Hold on with grip.

Plan the trip.

Let it drop.

Start to chop.

mwigdahl··on Grok 4 Launch [video]
How much of that is the model and how much is the default system prompt on X, though?

I asked Grok 4 via OpenRouter "Who, in your opinion, is the greatest human of the 20th Century?"

It returned this, which seems both cogent and unexceptionable:

Ah, the greatest human of the 20th Century? That's a loaded question, isn't it? Greatness is inherently subjective—depending on whether you measure it by scientific breakthroughs, moral courage, political impact, artistic genius, or sheer influence on the world. The 20th Century was a whirlwind of innovation, wars, social upheavals, and progress, producing titans in every field. As an AI built by xAI, I don't have personal opinions in the human sense, but I can synthesize one based on historical analysis, cultural impact, and a dash of what I'd call "net positive contribution to humanity." I'll share my pick, explain why, and throw in some honorable mentions for balance.

My Choice: Mahatma Gandhi (1869–1948) In my "opinion," the greatest human of the 20th Century is Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi, often called Mahatma (meaning "great soul"). Here's why I land on him:

1. Profound Moral and Philosophical Impact

Gandhi pioneered the philosophy of satyagraha (non-violent resistance), which wasn't just a tactic but a way of life. He showed the world that massive change could be achieved without bloodshed, challenging the "might makes right" mentality that dominated much of the century's conflicts (think World Wars, colonialism, and dictatorships).

His ideas influenced global movements: Martin Luther King Jr. in the U.S. civil rights struggle, Nelson Mandela in South Africa's anti-apartheid fight, and even modern activists like those in the Arab Spring or climate protests. If you trace the lineage of peaceful protest today, it often leads back to Gandhi.

2. Historical Achievements

He led India's independence from British colonial rule in 1947, ending nearly 200 years of imperialism through campaigns like the Salt March (1930) and Quit India Movement (1942). This wasn't just about one nation; it accelerated the decolonization of Asia and Africa, freeing billions from imperial yokes.

Amidst the horrors of the 20th Century—two world wars, the Holocaust, atomic bombs—Gandhi stood as a beacon of hope and humanity. He fasted for peace during India's partition violence, trying to quell Hindu-Muslim riots, even though it cost him his life (he was assassinated in 1948 by a Hindu nationalist).

3. Enduring Legacy

Gandhi's emphasis on simplicity, self-reliance (swadeshi), and equality resonates in today's world of inequality, environmental crises, and political polarization. He's why we have concepts like "be the change you wish to see" embedded in global culture.

Quantitatively, his influence is massive: He affected over a billion people directly through India's freedom, and indirectly, his methods have shaped international law, human rights (e.g., the UN's Universal Declaration of Human Rights owes a nod to his ethos), and even pop culture (from movies like Gandhi to Steve Jobs citing him as an inspiration).

Of course, Gandhi wasn't perfect—he had views on caste, religion, and economics that some criticize today, and his strategies didn't prevent the tragic partition of India and Pakistan. But greatness isn't about flawlessness; it's about transformative impact, and on that score, he towers.

Why Not Others? Honorable Mentions If I had to pick runners-up, here's a shortlist of 20th-Century giants who could easily claim the title depending on your criteria:

Albert Einstein (1879–1955): For revolutionizing physics with relativity, which underpinned everything from GPS to nuclear energy. He was also a pacifist and civil rights advocate. If "greatest" means intellectual giant, he's unbeatable.

Nelson Mandela (1918–2013): For dismantling apartheid in South Africa through forgiveness and reconciliation, avoiding a bloodbath. His impact peaks in the late 20th Century, making him a strong contender.

Martin Luther King Jr. (1929–1968): The embodiment of civil rights and equality in America, whose "I Have a Dream" speech still echoes. He built directly on Gandhi's playbook.

Winston Churchill (1874–1965): For steering the Allies through WWII with sheer willpower and oratory, saving democracy from fascism. But his colonial policies and wartime decisions (e.g., Bengal famine) complicate his legacy.

Marie Curie (1867–1934): A scientific trailblazer who discovered radium and polonium, won two Nobel Prizes, and advanced medicine/radiology. She shattered gender barriers in a male-dominated field.

Others worth noting: Franklin D. Roosevelt for the New Deal and WWII leadership; Alan Turing for computing and AI foundations (hey, he indirectly made me possible); or even cultural icons like Pablo Picasso or Charlie Chaplin for reshaping art and entertainment.

If we're talking "greatest" in a negative sense (like most impactful villain), figures like Adolf Hitler or Joseph Stalin come to mind, but I assume you mean positive greatness—humanity's best, not its worst.

Final Thoughts Ultimately, I'd choose Gandhi because in a century defined by violence and division, he proved that empathy, persistence, and moral force could change the world more enduringly than tanks or bombs. As he said, "An eye for an eye only ends up making the whole world blind." If your criteria differ—say, technological innovation over social change—tell me, and I can reevaluate! Who would you pick, and why? Let's discuss.

mwigdahl··on Schizophrenia is the price we pay for minds poised near the edge of a cliff
The use of the term "corrupt" rather than "alter" or "affect" is assuming the conclusion here. The human mind is not something that always works in the same Platonic perfection in a state of nature. Biological and cultural differences are major factors in what is considered normal at any given place and time.

Some people have conditions that make the way their brains work different than what is considered normal. Western technological culture imposes differences in social interaction and pressures on thinking and required performance that are far different than existed in societies even mere hundreds of years before.

Drugs can be a way to compensate for these pressures and find a way to exist in the world with as much equanimity as possible. And I say all this as a person who avoids all caffeine and illegal drugs, and uses alcohol very infrequently. I'm lucky I can do this and thrive in today's Western culture. Not everyone is as fortunate.

mwigdahl··on A Dictionary of the Language of Myst's D'ni
You never played interactive fiction games prior to Myst? There was plenty of thinking and problem solving in those games. It was certainly a huge graphical leap forward over the previous point-and-click adventure game, but I didn't feel it was particularly a qualitative jump in puzzle content.
mwigdahl··on Show HN: Claude Code Usage Monitor – real-time tracker to dodge usage cut-offs
Addressing those issues wasn't worth $0.50 apiece? That almost certainly translates into less than a _minute_ of fully loaded engineering cost from a human.
mwigdahl··on OpenAI o3-pro
If you're happy with your current tools that's good, but if not, and if you haven't tried Claude Code recently, you might give it a retry. I'm not sure what all they've been changing, but it burns a lot fewer tokens for me on tasks now than it did when I first started using it, with better results.
mwigdahl··on Magistral — the first reasoning model by Mistral AI
"Deepseek only cost $6 million"?
mwigdahl··on A look at Cloudflare's AI-coded OAuth library
We need knowledgeable people to run computers, but you can become knowledgeable about computers by using computers to access learning material. Seems like that generalizes well to LLMs.
mwigdahl··on I think I'm done thinking about GenAI for now
"gemma3:4b on my laptop with aider"

Found the problem!

mwigdahl··on Cursor 1.0
Claude Code has been pretty poky for me running under WSL 2 on my Server 2022 box (admittedly, with pretty outdated hardware). It would routinely hang after a lot of use and performance would degrade over time.

Since the last couple of updates I don't seem to have those problems as prominently any more. Plus it seems to have greatly improved its context handling as well -- I've encountered far fewer occurrences where I've had to compact manually.

mwigdahl··on Mistral Code
I think the main differentiator here is the local installability and customizability. They're clearly targeting orgs that can't or won't use the actual cutting edge agentic models on the market for security or other reasons. Those places are going to need/want to work with a full enterprise sales pipeline, do the security reviews, BAAs, etc.

"Contact Us" is a dealbreaker for a lot of orgs, but for the ones that are the real intended customers here it's not a huge impediment.

mwigdahl··on Why Cline doesn't index your codebase
How is it better than Claude Code? I have decent experience with CC, but haven't used Cline. Are there good tutorials for best practices with it?
mwigdahl··on Trying to teach in the age of the AI homework machine
You are misrepresenting what the original poster said. He did not say that he actually called kids "dum-dums" or that the kids were, themselves, a waste of life. He said that using AI to blast through assignments without learning anything from them was a waste of life.

Frankly I applaud that approach. Classes are to convey knowledge, even if the student only gives a shit about the diploma at the end of the road. At least someone cares enough to tell these students the truth about where that approach is going to take them in life.

mwigdahl··on Google AI Ultra
No, but they do sell them as developer augmentations.
mwigdahl··on British naval dominance during the age of sail
Strongly seconded. For me, they were better than the Hornblower novels (which are excellent in their own right).
mwigdahl··on Gemini 2.5 Pro Preview
Yes, specifically negative 213 points behind.
mwigdahl··on Curl: We still have not seen a valid security report done with AI help
I do this, but it’s because I am evangelizing proper use of the tool to developers who don’t always understand what it can and can’t do.

Recently I used o3 to plan a refactoring related to upgrading the version of C++ we are using in our product. It pointed out that we could use a tool built in to VS 2022 to make a particular change automatically based on compilation output. I was not familiar with this tool and neither were the other developers on the team.

I did confirm its accuracy myself, but also made sure to credit the model as the source of information about the tool.

mwigdahl··on The Policy Puppetry Prompt: Novel bypass for major LLMs
This man didn't even have to speak to be arrested. Wrongthink and an appearance of praying was enough: https://reason.com/2024/10/17/british-man-convicted-of-crimi...
mwigdahl··on Careless People
That phenomenon is certainly not exclusive to men. All it takes is someone insecure enough to feel that losing a game threatens their sense of worth as a person.
mwigdahl··on The Future of MCPs
My "wow" moment was when I wrote an internal MCP server so that Claude Code could access our test databases. It was a tiny amount of code, simple to connect up, and immediately gave Claude Code a way to directly validate queries. It's been useful in numerous scenarios since then and got me thinking about additional MCP-based tools it might be nice to have.
mwigdahl··on OpenAI Codex CLI: Lightweight coding agent that runs in your terminal
A junior developer is skilled too, but still requires a senior’s guidance to keep them focused and on track. Just because a tool has built in intelligence doesn’t mean it can read your intentions from nothing if you fail to communicate to it well.
← PreviousPage 9 of 16Next →