HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mwsherman

3,607 karma · joined July 21, 2009

https://clipperhouse.com/
submissionscomments
mwsherman··on Airbnb Is a Risky Neighbor
Airbnb will naturally drive up rents in places where it’s being used. If a tenant has the capacity to pay (e.g.) $2000 for an apartment, but now can get an additional (e.g.) $300 a month, the tenant’s capacity to pay is now $2300.

A savvy landlord or condo association would want to capture this. Because it’s new, it’s seen as a disturbance. A little bit of thinking would reveal that there is now $XXX new money coming in the door (due to better utilization of the property).

It’s in the owners’ ultimate interest to figure out how to either a) accommodate this explicitly and safely, and capture some of the new revenue or b) prohibit it because the tenants prefer it, but know that the price of a “non-shared” building will carry a premium.

One way a condo association might adopt the idea is to point out that Airbnb’ers $$ might be used for building upgrades or to reduce condo fees.

mwsherman··on Go 1.3 is released
Appreciate the mention! Also gen is getting more, um, generic with the notion of custom ‘typewriters’, out on this branch: https://github.com/clipperhouse/gen/tree/3.0
mwsherman··on T-Mobile: streaming music no longer counts against data cap
We should consider the possibility that non-neutral arrangements will take the form of discounts, not price increases.

This is analogous to the fact that Amazon, WalMart et al can negotiate better shipping rates with Fedex, USPS et al, and can in turn offer free or cheap shipping to the end user.

This is also cheap for T-Mobile. Streaming music is not a zero impact on bandwidth, but (say) a 256K stream is small on (say) a 5mb/s connection. And like most consumer bandwidth, it assumes that most people won’t use it, most of the time.

mwsherman··on Go 1.3 is released
Yes and no, errors are just return values. They’re not special, they are conventional. So you get the whole type system to express errors – they’re just values. And you don’t have a different control flow.

It’s not without warts. You can bail with panic(), which is essentially a throw.

It’s tedious to handle errors, but that’s because actually handling errors is tedious.

mwsherman··on Help Shut the Government's Surveillance Backdoors
This is a good point.
mwsherman··on Help Shut the Government's Surveillance Backdoors
My point is that it’s a mistake and a distraction to believe this law is “action”.
mwsherman··on Help Shut the Government's Surveillance Backdoors
The NSA doesn’t obey laws. Or, more precisely, we don’t know if they obey laws.

Or, when we think a law limits their behavior, it will be challenged, where ‘challenged’ means ignored until it is discovered, then tried in secret.

Functionally, laws don’t matter here. Their existence, and their content, are not predictive of the NSA’s behavior.

mwsherman··on Founders and mental health
I don’t see anything in here that’s specific to Silicon Valley or to founders. Is there any evidence that founders have a greater incidence of mental issues than the greater population?

By which I am not asking, do we have things to worry about. Of course we do. But do we have greater reason to worry than a single mother, a middle-aged construction worker, or a 70-year-old accountant?

mwsherman··on Starbucks to Provide Free College Education to Thousands of Workers
This seems like a variation on the lump of labor fallacy.[1]

Now, the acquisition of a degree might or might not be everything we think it is, where “formal education” and “valuable learning” are perhaps-incorrectly equated. But if we assume that college is economically valuable, having more people educated seems hard to argue with.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lump_of_labour_fallacy

mwsherman··on Google Fiber franchise wins approval from Portland City Council
Not that this isn’t good news – it is – but it’s taken 4 years to get to this point: http://blog.oregonlive.com/siliconforest/2010/03/portland_ci...

Still no fiber in the ground. This sort of negotiation is such a huge barrier to entry that only very big (or incumbent) companies have a fighting chance.

Obviously, Google entering the market is a big deal and good news – two competitors is better than one. But only a company of the size and regulatory savvy of Google would even try.

mwsherman··on All Our Patent Are Belong To You
There is no legal covenant here. I imagine Tesla’s definition of “good faith” is “we evaluate on a case by case basis”.

Which amounts to “if we like you” and “we reserve the right”. If they wanted these patents to be open source, they would license them explicitly.

mwsherman··on A high-profile fork: one year of Blink and Webkit
What a great bit of dataviz. Would love to see similar for OpenSSL vs LibreSSL.
mwsherman··on What if Ansible used XML for configuration management?
I suspect that Web Components will evolve this way as well, declarative language used imperatively. http://clipperhouse.com/2014/03/31/web-components-have-we-no...
mwsherman··on Hachette/Amazon Business Interruption
Anyone know what an author pool is, how it functions? A bit of Googling didn’t reveal anything.
mwsherman··on Nitra, JetBrains’ research project for language tooling, goes open-source
That part of Visual Studio impresses me a lot, though it’s not obvious to a user. I haven’t (say) closed the brace yet, so the code is invalid and therefore a correct AST can’t be parsed.

It has to be heuristic? Or a given (say) line falls back to last known good state?

mwsherman··on FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet
A CDN only carries traffic for those who’ve paid to be on it. That’s privileged, and not neutral.

If the CDN is on Comcast’s premises, or primarily feeds a single last-mile network (which would de facto be true on a local level), then same.

mwsherman··on FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet
A new CDN node is a new privileged route. An existing CDN node is not a new privileged route.

> CDN nodes do not route traffic that does not have that node as either a source or a destination.

Correct. That is true of any router.

Netflix did buy a new route, replacing the one they were previously buying from Cogent.

mwsherman··on FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet
A CDN is a route, is my contention. Its value is being closer to the user.

CDNs are a good thing. But they are networks like any other, the difference being that the nodes are smart enough for to re-request data they already have. CDN nodes should be understood as caching routers.

Being closer to the user – the CDN’s value – rests in having a better position vis-à-vis the last-mile network. A better position vis-à-vis the last-mile network is what Netflix bought.

mwsherman··on FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet
That’s true, and it’s also true when Netflix buys a dedicated circuit to Comcast. Their traffic is no longer going over the other circuits.

Not saying it’s the right thing to do, but that it’s functionally the same.

It’s also functionally the same to say that any traffic not on the CDN is in a slow lane or being held ransom, in the sense that it will be congested until the publisher pays.

mwsherman··on FCC approves plan to consider paid priority on Internet
CDNs are essentially identical (technologically and economically) to what Netflix bought from Comcast: http://clipperhouse.com/2014/05/07/what-netflix-bought-from-...

To my mind, I can’t imagine a rule that describes a fast lane that doesn’t also describe a CDN.

mwsherman··on My Opinionated Guide To Go
Well, I think one answer if that you can quickly have a running web app without another piece of software. This is an attractive quality of Node, too. In fact, if a language doesn’t have a “5 lines to a web app” demo, I consider it insufficient.

I’d posit that 90+% of apps don’t need another http server. Big apps have good reasons for a dedicated http server – unifying SSL termination, load balancing – but they are a minority.

There is nothing to to prevent you from putting nginx in front of the Go app if that’s better.

mwsherman··on iMessage purgatory
IM and SMS are different ideas. SMS moves a message from one device to another. SMS also knows nothing about the receiving device or whether the message got there.

IM (under which I include iMessage) is user-to-user, not device-to-device. It can know about the recipient and whether messages are received.

Each of these things has advantages.

SMS works because the phone network is always tracking a device. It is very addressable. The receiving device is mobile, rarely changes, and is singular.

IM has a notion of sessions. The user signs off and on. It can travel over any IP connection. The device on which the user is addressable changes a lot. There may be multiple devices, making the definition of “delivered” a bit less deterministic.

Conflating these two makes for a confusing mental model for the user, and for failures like this.

mwsherman··on Jsfmt – Like Gofmt, but for JavaScript
The key here is adoption. Go’s adoption of gofmt is that it was there from the start and the community has adopted it.

It’d be great to have it on the JS side too. It’s a question of everyone agreeing that it’s the right one and achieving critical mass.

mwsherman··on Porting the Go compiler from C to Go
The use case is to bootstrap the conversion from C to Go, if one has made a decision to do so. You pick a cutoff time, and say “now were going to do our work in Go”.

What comes out the other end, as Russ phrases it, is a C program in Go syntax. The next phase of work is to turn it into “Go” as a human might write it.

The translated program is not meant for deployment, really. It’s to give the humans a starting point.

mwsherman··on TDD is dead. Long live testing.
As rhetorical gambits go, the “what other people do is religion” is getting pretty old.

It’s meant to reflect on the speaker as the voice of reason among the thoughtless. Who wouldn’t want to think of themselves that way? I’m the smart one who sees through the dogma!

But it doesn’t have that effect anymore – mostly it makes the speaker look someone who disrespects his readers.

mwsherman··on An idea for bookifying the web
No doubt I should. I happen to like the Pocket UI, and when I think “web site I need to get back to”, that’s where I go.

I like the idea that a book would be as updatable as a web site – that the site is the canonical source and the “book” is just one presentation. The epub seems static by comparison.

mwsherman··on Show HN: ffjson: faster json serialization in Go
On the .Net side, Jil is doing similar, creating a custom static serializer per type. It’s able to do the code generation at runtime by emitting IL: https://github.com/kevin-montrose/Jil
mwsherman··on How Microryza Acquired the Domain Experiment.com
I’m with you. It’s a better name and can really be called a brand name in that it only denotes the company and otherwise has no other meaning. That uniqueness means no competition in search results, as you point out.

Unique-er, shorter, has a cultural history with the company, evokes “Rise”.

Keep in mind that brands really become signifiers of the company, and have little meaning of their own over time. Beatles, Google, Radiohead, Amazon. All either bad or meaningless on their own.

mwsherman··on Make the Type System Do the Work
Might be interesting to compare to F#‘s units of measure: http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/dd233243.aspx
mwsherman··on Why “just use Adblock” should never be a professional answer
The insight here, which the writer doesn’t get to, is the incredible economic inefficiency all of this implies.

Ineffective ads outnumber good ads by at least an order of magnitude, conservatively. By good I mean “delivering economic value”, which might take the form of clickthroughs or general brand awareness.

If we consider clicked ads, or those that eventually result in a purchase, to be good ones, then the rest are a waste.

That waste should be understood as a degradation of the publisher’s product. We go to great lengths to get the typography and design just so – and then allow an economically worthless ad to degrade it.

The opportunity is to improve ads by an order of magnitude. This isn’t a question of eking out slightly better targeting. It means not showing an ad at all, most of the time.

Though the evidence to date is not in my favor, I have to believe that the current state of web advertising is waiting for the bottom to fall out, like print media in the last decade.

← PreviousPage 6 of 14Next →