HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

myhf

1,195 karma · joined April 19, 2010

submissionscomments
myhf··on I Am An AI Hater
Do you think that the more refined version is somehow less of an insult to life itself? It wasn't a statement about how refined the art style is. It's about the meaning and intentionality that goes into deliberate communication, and how tools designed specifically to skip over the decision making and deliberation are removing the most important part of the result.

Look at all the AI-written and AI-illustrated articles being published this year. Look at how smooth the image slop is. Look at how fluent the text slop is. Higher quality slop doesn't change the fact that nobody could be bothered to write the thing, and nobody can be bothered to read it.

myhf··on I Am An AI Hater
> the useful things it does

It's weird how AI-lovers are always trying to shoehorn an unsupported "it does useful things" into some kind of criticism sandwich where only the solvable problems can be acknowledged as problems.

Just because some technologies have both upsides and downsides doesn't mean that every technology automatically has upsides. GenAI is good at generating these kinds of hollow statements that mimic the form of substantial arguments, but anyone who actually reads it can see how hollow it is.

If you want to argue that it does useful things, you have to explain at least one of those things.

myhf··on Neuralink 'Participant 1' says his life has changed
Counterpoint: the main motivation for installing brain chips is to be able to do those things to subordinates.
myhf··on GenAI FOMO has spurred businesses to light nearly $40B on fire
But business process outsourcing companies actually perform the services they get paid for, so it doesn't make sense to compare them to GenAI.
myhf··on LL3M: Large Language 3D Modelers
The article is about language models. Language models are not capable of planning or reasoning.
myhf··on The Folk Economics of Housing
Square footage per capita can be misleading because it goes up as an area moves from low density to medium density, but goes down as the same area moves to high density.
myhf··on Evaluating LLMs playing text adventures
9:05 is a good example of the difference between a language model and a world model, because engaging with it on a textual level leads to the bad ending (which the researchers have called "100%"), but deliberately getting the good ending requires self-awareness, intentionality, and/or outside context.
myhf··on The current state of LLM-driven development
Yeah, I think that metric has grown to about 20 lines per day using 2010s-era languages and methods. So maybe we could think of LLM usage as an attempt to bring it back down to 10 per day.
myhf··on Facts will not save you – AI, history and Soviet sci-fi
The article is written by LLM and published on Substack, so there's no expectation for it to make coherent points.
myhf··on Does the Bitter Lesson Have Limits?
The original "Bitter Lesson" essay is about machine learning, but the linked article appears to be trying to apply it to LLMs.
myhf··on Experimental surgery performed by AI-driven surgical robot
I don't care whether human surgeons or robotic surgeons are better at what they do. I just want more money to go to whoever owns the equipment, and less to go to people in my community.

It's called capitalism, sweaty

myhf··on US AI Action Plan
This new AI reduces payouts by $10MM. The licensing fee is $10MM. Profit margins stay within the legal limits.
myhf··on Recovering from AI addiction
12-step programs have a 5-10% success rate.
myhf··on ChatGPT's enterprise success against Copilot fuels OpenAI/Microsoft rivalry
We're also seeing a new variant of Cunningham's law:

The best way to get the right answer from an LLM is not to ask it the right question; it's to post online that it got the wrong answer.

myhf··on I used AI-powered calorie counting apps, and they were even worse than expected
Of course it will work. Just tell ChatGPT that it is working and it will agree with you.
myhf··on A conversation about AI for science with Jason Pruet
There was literally a vaporware "AI" hype cycle in 1960. Propositional logic programming was poison to investors for 50 years because of that one, just like LLMs will be poison to investors for 50 years because of this one.
myhf··on Thoughts Upon Slavery (1774)
Cool URLs don't change [1], and that page has had the same URL for 251 years

[1] https://www.w3.org/Provider/Style/URI

myhf··on AI is turning us into glue
Why do articles like this always say things like "I've used LLMs to get some stuff done faster" and then go on to describe how LLMs get them to spend more time and money to do a worse job? You don't need LLMs to frustrate you into lowering your standards, the power to do that was within you all along.
myhf··on An image of an archeologist adventurer who wears a hat and uses a bullwhip
The problem with this kind of plagiarism isn't that it violates someone's specific copyright.

But the discussion around plagiarism calls attention to the deeper issue: "generative" AI does not have emergent thinking or reasoning capabilities. It is just very good at obfuscating the sources of its information.

And that can cause much bigger problems than just IP infringement. You could make a strategic decision based on information that was deliberately published by an adversary.

myhf··on AI 2027
accountability sinks are all you need
myhf··on Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI
The official definition of AGI is a system that can generate at least $100 billion in profits. For comparison, this would be like if perceptrons in 1968 could generate $10 billion in profits, or if LISP machines in 1986 could generate $35 billion in profits, or if expert systems in 1995 could generate $50 billion in profits.
myhf··on Tesla gets more than 20% of parts from Mexico, it will be affected by tariffs
Norwegian citizens found that they could vote themselves money and it worked out fine. It's almost always a better strategy than voting to give money to oligarchs.
myhf··on “The closer to the train station, the worse the kebab” – a “study”
There may not be a correlation, but you can clearly see that the bottom-right quadrant of the plot is basically empty, which is an important insight.

A more accurate aphorism would be "You can sell good kebabs anywhere, but you can only sell bad kebabs near a train station."

And if you look at the "minimum viable quality" instead of the overall quality, there does seem to be a linear correlation with the distance. You can use a 5% quantile regressor to easily find the lower edge of the distribution.

myhf··on Be Aware of the Makefile Effect
"A complex system that works is invariably found to have evolved from a simple system that worked. A complex system designed from scratch never works and cannot be patched up to make it work. You have to start over with a working simple system."

– John Gall (1975) Systemantics: How Systems Really Work and How They Fail

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Gall_(author)#Gall's_law

myhf··on OpenAI’s board, paraphrased: ‘All we need is unimaginable sums of money’
Unimaginable Sums of Money Are All You Need

The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Huge Sums of Money in the Natural Sciences

Unimaginable Sums of Money Considered Harmful

myhf··on MTA's A.I. bus cameras issue mistaken parking violations
No amount of automation will have any significant effect on the size or efficiency of a bureaucracy.

http://www.berglas.org/Articles/ImportantThatSoftwareFails/I...

myhf··on Show HN: App that asks ‘why?’ every time you unlock your phone
Why?
myhf··on Agile Is Dead
So true. 90% of Agile practitioners give the rest a bad reputation.
myhf··on Lars Tunbjörk documented the rise of alienating office work
Ahh, all of these offices look so cool! I love the "success" sign that has fallen down. I love the powered-off machine labeled "do not turn this machine off".
myhf··on California bans legacy admissions at private universities
> The proportion of slots available for auction or lottery is the same as the proportion of students choosing auction vs lottery.

Wow, 99% auction again this year, what a coincidence.

← PreviousPage 3 of 16Next →