HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

myrmidon

3,422 karma · joined April 14, 2014

submissionscomments
myrmidon··on Wiped out: US faces surging toilet paper prices amid trade war with Canada
Those numbers sound insane to me. This is almost half a roll per day, for a single person?

Can any average american or german person comment on how this actually works? Do you wipe like 15 times per visit, or is it just a very high amount (folded?) of sheets per wipe?

myrmidon··on Fake US thinktank set up and funded by Israel sought to game AI for propaganda
German law forces you to provide address/contact info on any commercial website (just running ads qualifies).

But this is often "abused" by lawyers to basically send cease-and-desist letters to small websites that don't have one (typically because they're unaware of the law, not because of malicious intent).

myrmidon··on US data centers tripled annual water consumption to 17B gallons
> Though you can also be mad at the industry as a whole, an industry where leaders scream as loud as possible how they will make your life worse. I think it’s perfectly justified. And DCs are a perfect fit for that, you have a huge ominous monolith to point at that nobody wants to have around them

This is exactly my problem. I'm not saying you're wrong about this in any way. But your (and many others) core problem with datacenters is not actually the water use. The water argument is just a strawman to increase environmental legitimacy, and thats a really bad and harmful practice (I do realize that this might seem minor given incompetent political leadership that spews uninformed drivel all day, but coherency and correctness still matter!)

The water argument is simply never helpful. If water is scarce locally, then let local administration reject datacenter projects for exactly that reason. If they fail to do that, fix/campaign against the local administration (because that's where the problem is at). But blanket arguing against datacenter buildout because of water usage is just bad-faith campaigning, and it is gonna hurt credibility elsewhere.

myrmidon··on US data centers tripled annual water consumption to 17B gallons
If you need to denigrate pure context as "whataboutism", then maybe your core argument is trash?

I mean, sure, lets not build datacenters that are 100% evaporation-cooled into each desert-oasis.

But if general water availability is your concern, than datacenters are so far down the priority list that any argument involving them is just laughable. And if you are against datacenters, then find a proper argument instead of making environmentalism look stupid.

myrmidon··on US data centers tripled annual water consumption to 17B gallons
At least ~30% of water is evaporated when you use it in agriculture (that is the whole point; plants typically don't go the the trouble of absorbing water just to pump it back into the ground).

Even if you use such an extremely conservative ratio (and assume that all water used in datacenters is 100% evaporated away for cooling) the argument stands.

myrmidon··on US data centers tripled annual water consumption to 17B gallons
Completely agree. Specifically:

If you are anti-datacenter, then the water argument might look appealing to you, but its NOT a good argument, and it makes not only look you like an innumerate idiot, it also negatively impacts adjacent environmental movements/concerns.

So don't push it.

myrmidon··on How credit card rewards became a $9.2B wealth transfer
> You are an economist, aren't you?

No. I do embedded software engineering for a living.

I use (in my view) HN appropriate levels of jargon (because lots of people here are involved with getting people to pay for some newfangled cloud thing or other, so I use their terminology).

In simple words: People pay more for the same (and spend more recklessly) when you let them pay by credit card, and this causes much more economical "damage" to poor peolpe than any "wealth transfer from card rewards".

myrmidon··on How credit card rewards became a $9.2B wealth transfer
I think this is disingenuous framing.

Credit card rewards are not a mechanism to shift wealth towards premium card holders (this is a negligible distraction), they exist purely to increase revenue/conversion rate, by decreasing customer price sensitivity (compared to cash payments) and encouraging financially irresponsible spending. If this did not actually work in practice, every merchant would just insist on cash and pocket the difference.

"Poor people" are hurt much more from the changes in spending behavior induced by credit card use than by paying for card rewards.

myrmidon··on Why some US restaurants are banning tips
Low Gini compared to the US, but mediocre for a European country (comparable to France, Germany, Italy; significantly worse compared to low-Gini regions like Scandinavia).
myrmidon··on Felony charges for citizen deleting phone data at US Border
They were pretty obviously hoping to find a specific crime to accuse him of (because he is a protester against the Atlanta "Cop City" thing).

But no respectable judge would ever have issued a search warrant on the basis of "we want to rifle through his messages/contacts so we can hopefully accuse him of something".

Protesters against this exact same thing were mis-prosecuted under "domestic terrorism" and "racketeering" charges before (got dismissed in 2025).

myrmidon··on Felony charges for citizen deleting phone data at US Border
There is no duty to keep a copy of messages and private data on your phone for the FBI to peruse at its leisure. Quite the opposite, actually (according to the constitution).

It is pretty clear to me that law enforcement conspired to abuse a border crossing to effect basically an unconstitutional search ("fishing expedition"), which it would never have gotten a warrant for.

This is them being spiteful after that whole thing failed. Note how law enforcement basically admits this on the record. The whole thing is a disgrace; every decisionmaker involved in this should be sacked immediately.

myrmidon··on U.S. Debt Hits $40T as America's Borrowing Binge Continues
Because it is politically much easier to just spend on medicare, social security and military than it is to raise taxes to cover that spending?

Interest on debt is already a double-digit percentage of spending, so the problem gets worse by itself.

And honestly: How many people in the US would actually change party only because of irresponsible spending? In my view, this is like priority number 4 at best for most people, and many at most moan about it instead of letting it drive their political choices. Political representatives also basically only ever throw it around as accusation against opponents, without ever actually doing better themselves (just consider the Trump-1 promise of getting rid of the debt during his first term: not even an attempt was made).

myrmidon··on Deutsche Bank becomes first foreign yuan clearing bank in Europe
Never surpass in what exactly?

If you look at absolute numbers (https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/gdp-worldbank-constant-us...), it seems likely that China will surpass the US economy pretty soon (they're a lot more people though, so per-capita is much worse).

Personally I think its most likely that chinese GDP will be larger than US GDP within 2035, but that the median citizen is NOT going to catch up to US standards in the next 50 years.

And their whole society will run into the exact same problems that many western countries are dealing with already (increasing fraction of retirees), so I'd be very careful with extrapolating their currently superior growth rate past 2040 or so.

myrmidon··on Deutsche Bank becomes first foreign yuan clearing bank in Europe
China has a massive demographic problem in the near future (after 2040ish), and it is extremely unlikely (IMO) that it is going to catch up/surpass the US in GDP per capita within the next decades.

But its relative GDP growth has been higher than the US for decades, is higher stil and is probably going to stay higher for years:

https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/real-gdp-growth?country=U...

myrmidon··on 5th Heat Dome Expands Across Europe: 40°C+ Target Western and Central Europe
Put a significant price on CO2 emissions (think like $300+/ton, instead of <$100), then tax every import from countries that take insufficient actions (or run a low CO2 emission price). Likewise, tax any export into countries that take no action.

Electrify everything where possible (especially transport and heating), get electricity CO2 neutral, get concrete and steel production CO2 neutral (lots of those would be an inevitable consequence of the emission pricing).

This would allow western democracies to basically fix the global situation on their own, by exerting economic pressure on developing countries (those want/need market access, like China).

It would make goods (and especially individual transport!) more expensive though (even if you re-emit the tax income), so you can be sure it's not gonna happen, because too many people are too selfish.

myrmidon··on 5th Heat Dome Expands Across Europe: 40°C+ Target Western and Central Europe
Erasing any datacenter ever built (and planned) would do almost nothing to stop climate change.

What we need is (global) electrification of transport and heating, CO2 free electricity and CO2 neutral concrete and steel.

Very effective ways to make this happen would be high prices on emissions, enforced on every local industry and all imports.

But too many people love their cheap fossil-based transport too much and are unwilling to make even small sacrifices to keep the climate stable; sad reality.

myrmidon··on US strikes $1.2B deal to pay German firm to halt offshore wind projects
Absolutely. Gas is a lot less problematic than coal.

But my point is that it fills (in China) a very similar role for the electric grid and countries don't get to choose what fossils are in their soil.

The US using relatively more gas than coal is not any kind of laudable achievement, it's simply whats cheaply available.

Norway does not get any credit in my book for being full renewable either (because they have "free" hydro power literally everywhere).

myrmidon··on US strikes $1.2B deal to pay German firm to halt offshore wind projects
Germany is already way ahead of the US in switching away from fossil electricity (also ahead of China).

Sure, keeping the entire nuclear fleet from ~2000 would have maybe helped, but would have required very costly (economically and politically!) investments over the last few decades, and those basically went into renewables instead which turned out fine.

See: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/electricity-prod-source-s...

myrmidon··on US strikes $1.2B deal to pay German firm to halt offshore wind projects
This is misleading, because China has no gas, and they use coal power as dispatchable source with lower capacity factor (similar to gas elsewhere).

Coal+gas electricity is basically the same fraction in China than in the US.

But countries like Germany or Spain are significantly ahead in this regard, with much higher fraction of electrical energy coming from solar/wind.

See: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/electricity-prod-source-s...

myrmidon··on How Americans View Capitalism, Socialism and Free Enterprise
> The majority of federal government spending is a wealth transfer to old and poor people

Sorry, but that's a ridiculous take.

Thats just like saying that public schools are a wealth transfer from the working class to students, or that health insurance is a wealth transfer to old and sick people.

It's neither useful nor precise. Things are never an actual "wealth transfer" when both sides consider it worthwhile-- that's just an ordinary trade.

myrmidon··on Show HN: Run an 80B Qwen in 4.3 GB of RAM on a Mac, and a 35B on an iPhone
Agree with this. As soon as things get in range for motivated amateurs, progress skyrockets.

Has also been the case for things like chess computing; a lot of the progress we made over the last decades there (even before involving neural networks!) happened thanks to software improvements because the problem got so accessible, not just faster hardware.

I expect similar trends with AI; I'd expect to get decent, human comparable capability with <200GB/s of memory bandwidth and under 60GB of RAM long term (SSDs with very high read bandwidth looks also promising, but we'll see).

I hope that in a decade or two, training will also be somewhat feasible for "pro-sumers".

myrmidon··on Europe's fires are just the start
"Base load" is not an actual demand that needs to be satisfied.

Providing base load is a privilege you get to enjoy if your marginal cost is lower than anyone elses (and you want/can keep running basically all of the time).

Renewables ruin former baseload providers (like nuclear plants) because those plants are basically no longer making money whenever the sun shines (so the economics for nuclear plants got much worse).

myrmidon··on Europe's fires are just the start
> You're wrong. If we did that [spread manmade climate change over next millennium], meltwater water supply would essentially stop (in somewhere between 8 months and 2 years), everywhere on the planet.

What exactly are you talking about here? Meltwater amounts would be roughly the same compared to the last millennium, until glaciers start vanishing (only, in that obviously favorably scenario, in 500ish years instead of this century).

I get the impression that you think that manmade climate change is somewhat helpful compensation for natural trending towards ice age. This is not the case at all, because the rate of change is too high. See https://xkcd.com/1732/.

A (natural) looming ice age is not problematic or threathening at all because that happens so slowly that we get many centuries to act.

myrmidon··on Show HN: Open-source engine running Gemma 4 26B in 2 GB RAM on any M-series Mac
How do you know that human logic is any more/better/qualitatively different from the LLMs "predictive ability"? It's already pretty easy to find humans that are strictly worse at reasoning and logic than a decent LLM.
myrmidon··on [dead]
Important for what? Not getting snitched on when comitting crime?
myrmidon··on Why copper still rules the motherboard trace
Copper price is up ~500% since 2000 btw, this is already downregulating its use.

Not sure what your benchmark for shortage is, but if we had similar price development with fuel people would've gone ballistic.

It's quite possible that this will further escalate over the next decades, because demand is continuously rising and mining/recycling is not keeping up with it.

myrmidon··on Startup founders urge U.S. government not to shut off Chinese open weight AI
This is not robbing. Undesired distillation is a ToS violation, at best.

There is not even jurisdiction over Chinese companies, because they don't sell their LLM subscribtions, unlike US companies, and those comitted much more severe violations in getting their training material than a ToS violation or two (Anthropic already found guilty).

edit: I don't see this as legal argument against the ban, more like a justification for why basically no moral person is gonna side with OpenAI and Anthropic on this. US gov can try and ban as many weights as they want, I expect that to be similarly effective as banning numbers was in the past (i.e. not).

myrmidon··on New Framework Desktop Option with AMD Ryzen AI Max+ Pro 495 and 192GB Memory
Are you generally happy with it? What do you mainly use it for?

I'm kinda tempted by the frameworks because they are somewhat energy efficient and compact (which I both value highly!) but my concern is that the GPU is on the low end for 1440p gaming (while being barely price-competitive with a self-built Ryzen9950 + 9070XT combination).

myrmidon··on Advertise in ChatGPT
Anecdotally, lots of intelligent people I know like to pretend to be completely uninfluenced by advertising, which I think is delusional.

In my view advertising is in big parts (your category 3) basically a constant side-channel attack against peoples minds, eroding decisionmaking and purchasing decisions (mostly!) to peoples detriment.

The net-beneficial aspects (product information, and, arguably, boosted general demand) could be better achieved otherwise.

myrmidon··on Who's afraid of Chinese models?
Is this excluding maritime shipping?

According to eurostat (https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/SEPDF/cac...) that is two thirds of freight volume and it probably still eclipses even rail transport in CO2 efficiency (until full CO2 free rail electrification), so this probably distorts things completely...

If you actually compare the emission fractions, you can see that the US uses much more CO2 per capita on transport compared to Europe (about 3 times as much!):

https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/per-capita-ghg-sector?cou...

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →