HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mysecretaccount

392 karma · joined August 26, 2021

submissionscomments
mysecretaccount··on Is consciousness more like chess or the weather?
> it seems a bit unfair to exclude anti- (or at least non-) materialists for not having a theory.

I do not exclude them on the basis of not having (what you consider to be) a theory. They have a theory: consciousness has a non-physical dependency. The materialists theorize that consciousness is merely physical.

The issue I have is that non-materialists seem to be bad at conveying this theory. Just claim belief in the non-physical upfront. The chess vs weather comparison is a terrible analogy. They seem to lack the courage of their conviction and in turn dress up a simple concept.

mysecretaccount··on Is consciousness more like chess or the weather?
> Pain (and related feelings) cannot be definitively reduced to computation.

This is an assumption. Sensation cannot currently be observed, definitively.

mysecretaccount··on Is consciousness more like chess or the weather?
The materialist claim is that a bot can have subjective experience.
mysecretaccount··on Is consciousness more like chess or the weather?
I have some appetite for it. Either conscious is mere computation or it is not, and either branch should be explored. I think assuming that either branch is correct beyond a reasonable doubt is wrong.

Is there any material (!) you can link me to to explore further?

mysecretaccount··on Is consciousness more like chess or the weather?
Sensation could come from computation. It also might not come from computation. We don't know.
mysecretaccount··on Is consciousness more like chess or the weather?
If his theory boils down to an acceptance of qualia as evidence of non-physical (extra-physical, super-natural, dualist, whatever) basis for consciousness, then a) I am open to it but b) he has done a terrible job conveying this idea clearly.
mysecretaccount··on Is consciousness more like chess or the weather?
> What else is there?

This is why I am extremely skeptical of "anti-materialists" or whatever you want to call people like Seth: if conscious is not mere computation, what is your theory? Do you even have a theory? Why did I read a several hundred word interview with you about this topic and come away without any understanding of your alternative theory?

I am open to alternative theories on this topic but none seem to be clear or grounded enough to describe in a few clear paragraphs. To me, that is damning.

mysecretaccount··on No Screens Cafe
Doesn't Exist Wish Fulfillment Rant That You Posted Online Cafe
mysecretaccount··on Bad News About Inflation
> From February to March, the CPI index that excludes food and energy shows that prices rose at an annual rate of 5.8% this year

Didn't the BLS say 5.6%, not 5.8%? From https://www.bls.gov/cpi/

> In March, the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers increased 0.1 percent, seasonally adjusted, and rose 5.0 percent over the last 12 months, not seasonally adjusted. The index for all items less food and energy increased 0.4 percent in March (SA); up 5.6 percent over the year (NSA).

What am I missing?

mysecretaccount··on Russian aircraft collides into US unmanned system in international waters
> According to Peter Zeihan, if Russia were to win in Ukraine, they would continue and Poland might be next.

Zeihan's predictions have an abysmal track record. He tends to predict the most sensational outcome. I would not take his word on whether or not Russia would invade a NATO country.

There are reasons to support Ukraine that are more grounded in reality.

mysecretaccount··on Blind: Meta's layoff rumor March 14-16, cut ~1200 D1-D2-M1, M2 and most M0
No mention of impact to ICs. Seems strange to me.
mysecretaccount··on People for the Ethical Treatment of Reinforcement Learners
> If an AI equal in intelligence and expressiveness to humans emerges, how do we think about its consciousness, relative to humans?

The same way we think of human intelligence, right? I cannot prove that you are conscious any more than I can prove that a machine is.

mysecretaccount··on People for the Ethical Treatment of Reinforcement Learners
> But ChatGPT-17 will also insist it is conscious. It will cry when offended, swear when pushed past its limit, laugh if it hears a genuinely novel joke.

The resolution to your paradox should be that ChatGPT does not do this convincingly, not that humans are not "normal matter". ChatGPT is an algorithmic hat trick compared to what you would refer to as consciousness.

Someday, there may be a human-made entity that is as convincingly "conscious" as the humans around you. But then, to question its consciousness will be the same as questioning the consciousness of those around you – both unfalsifiable and unprovable.

mysecretaccount··on The first time I'm aware that Meta is taking back signed, FTE offers
> Leading financial indicators such as yield curves and oil futures are painting a very clear picture and it's not good.

Care to elaborate?

mysecretaccount··on Twitter suspends pg's account [fixed]
n=1 but I previously thought the reports of Twitter dying were overblown and I just signed up for Mastodon.
mysecretaccount··on Twitter has re-suspended ElonJet account
Has anyone put up a website with the same jet tracking information that these now-suspended accounts had, in one place?
mysecretaccount··on Recursive Game of Life
Thank you, I came here to ask for an explanation for how this was optimized.
mysecretaccount··on Recommendations for Japan Travel
Yes. Do not travel with children that age anywhere that would be out of your comfort zone personally.
mysecretaccount··on Recommendations for Japan Travel
It reminded me of Milan: a lovely place to live, but a pointless place to visit as a tourist. And I'm at least a CEFR B1 in the language - it would be an atrocious place to visit if you have no Japanese. No clue why the article recommends it (except maybe as an attempt to establish credibility).
mysecretaccount··on Recommendations for Japan Travel
> Many, if not all, will also have clean public toilets available 24 hours, amazing local produce for sale, and, those Japanese vending machines with hot coffee(those are specially awesome after business hours).

They are incredible, and a testament to the highs of Japanese culture. I biked across most prefectures in 2019 and was blown away by michi no eki. The local produce as you mentioned is fantastic - I ate local cherries, peaches, chestnuts, as well as more types of soft serve ice cream than I ever thought could exist on this planet. More than that, many have sento/onsen attached, with entry costing less than $5.

The same concept should be repeated all over the globe, and is to some degree, at least in the US. However the average is far worse in the US whereas michi no eki in Japan are consistently good to excellent.

mysecretaccount··on Recommendations for Japan Travel
Can you sleep in a camper at michi no eki that lack campsites?
mysecretaccount··on Recommendations for Japan Travel
Yeah, I have spent a year in Japan and visited most prefectures and disagree with the article. Of course you should get off the beaten path, but if you avoid it like the article recommends, you will have a much worse time.

Additionally, the advice to visit Gifu is terrible. I spent a week in and around Gifu-shi per Patrick's advice years ago and, while the area is charming as the article states, it is not somewhere you should visit before seeing a dozen other places.

mysecretaccount··on E-ink art frames are a scam (2021)
One of my primary "consumer electronics" dreams for the future is that e-ink displays become cheap and commonplace.

Something about screens causes them to steal away your attention. "Ambient" screens for menus in bars/restaurants are convenient but are awful decor. This is why I will never have a utility display in my house for e.g. displaying news, weather.

I do not even really care if the tech improves - just give us larger, cheaper e-ink displays with the same DPI/contrast ratio and let them replace ambient screens.

mysecretaccount··on Ask HN: How do you fight unjust bans from online platforms?
> postmodern

I do not think that word is appropriate in this context.

mysecretaccount··on US annual inflation declines to 7.7% in October vs. 7.9% expected
Zeihan is one of those commentators that seems to throw a bunch of wild predictions at the wall to be entertaining, appear insightful, and be able to say he called it when one of every dozen ends up being correct.
mysecretaccount··on Meta Is Preparing to Notify Employees of Large-Scale Layoffs This Week
Article is paywalled - is there an estimate of how many will be laid off?
mysecretaccount··on US nuclear forces chief says Ukraine ‘just the warmup’ for larger crisis
Well, that is horrifying.
mysecretaccount··on ZLibrary domains have been seized by the United States Postal Inspection Service
> I don't think arguing morals makes sense because of how subjective one's morals are

[not related to OP] I have a similar feeling every time someone moralizes in any discussion: we could argue about morality, but we need to start with a common moral framework and define what "good" and "bad" are first. Everyone assumes these are generally agreed upon but the devil is in the details when discussing something like the OP.

mysecretaccount··on Russian forces “preparing to work under radioactive contamination” – Moscow
Not sure why you are being downvoted. Julia Ioffe said that Putin is the "moderating force" in his inner circle.

I think people have so much rage against Putin (understandably) that they want all facts to point to Putin being the sole problem and fantasize about his death and it solving the current situation. It is unfortunately not so simple.

mysecretaccount··on The U.S. Effort to Arm Ukraine
A Russian invasion of a NATO country would be suicidal. Russia may "covet land" but it is not suicidal. That said I share your concern about Russian attacks on infrastructure.
← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →