HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mysecretaccount

392 karma · joined August 26, 2021

submissionscomments
mysecretaccount··on The U.S. Effort to Arm Ukraine
> They might not be currently capable BECAUSE we're arming Ukraine but there's no reason to believe they wouldn't if they could...

The botched invasion of Ukraine by Russia shows that it was never capable of successfully invading a NATO country (though we hardly needed the example to know this). It is conventionally outmatched by NATO and you cannot take a country using nukes. With Sweden/Finland joining NATO, there is no candidate for a successful invasion except possibly the one I mentioned (Moldova).

mysecretaccount··on The U.S. Effort to Arm Ukraine
I never said that NATO should or should not take any course of action. You are tilting at windmills here my friend.
mysecretaccount··on The U.S. Effort to Arm Ukraine
I do not necessarily think the alternate history you propose is implausible, but am not sure what your point is. We do not live in a timeline where that happened. My original comment was (quite clearly) referring to the reality in which Russia is stuck in an unwinnable war in Ukraine, not a hypothetical from eight months ago.
mysecretaccount··on The U.S. Effort to Arm Ukraine
> You don’t seem to get my point though - it only has turned into a quagmire for Russia because other countries have feared the thing of which you are sceptical. It is like complaining the medicine is useless because you don’t have symptoms, when it is only because of the medicine that you don’t have them.

What did I write that made you think that I think that the West's backing of Ukraine has not been essential for Ukraine's defense/Russia's failure? My claim is that Ukraine is an example of why it is absurd to expect Russia to invade NATO countries. If Russia cannot even overtake NATO-backed non-NATO countries, no one should reasonably expect it to invade NATO-proper countries.

mysecretaccount··on The U.S. Effort to Arm Ukraine
> There are countless reasons why this or that move would make sense for Russians. For example just to spread chaos and keep the world and its resources divided and force Europe into some kind of deal.

This is not enough justification for why this is plausible. Russia miscalculated in Ukraine (though even the US thought they would perform better[1]) but it is not suicidal. Invading a NATO country is a suicidal move for Russia.

[1] https://theintercept.com/2022/10/05/russia-ukraine-putin-cia...

mysecretaccount··on The U.S. Effort to Arm Ukraine
> You are sceptical [sic] because Ukraine has turned into such a quagmire for Russia.

To be clear: this is exactly what I said, yes.

mysecretaccount··on The U.S. Effort to Arm Ukraine
I am highly skeptical of the idea that Russia is likely to invade other countries in Europe (with the exception of maybe Moldova). Even if we ignore Article 5, it is just not plausible that Russia would attempt an invasion of an additional country when it needs to "partially" mobilize its populous to even attempt to hold on to the territories it once occupied in eastern Ukraine.
mysecretaccount··on Ask HN: How do you deal with the end of globalization?
Around February 2022, I consumed every piece of Zeihan-related content I could find online. He is very entertaining but I had to give up on him because he plays a bit fast and loose with facts and makes pretty wild predictions.

As an example, early in the Russia-Ukraine war, he claimed that Russia wanted to secure one of the geographical gateways into the country and could be expected to invade Poland and Romania circa this coming winter. He said that these gateways have been historically important for Russia's defense for hundreds of years and that they want to defend them before their population becomes too old to bear enough soldiers to take them.

This is exemplary of both the good/bad with Zeihan:

- He is entertaining and has unusual takes, as you said.

- He tends to have an essentialist worldview: Russia is obsessed with its own topography so it invaded Ukraine, China is isolationist so Xi doesn't care about what goes on in other countries, etc.

- He is a bit of a state department shill (probably necessary for his career, he seems to make a good amount from speaking gigs for these people).

- He fixates on age demographics and draws many (probably too many) conclusions from them. Big props to him for introducing me to the population pyramid though: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_pyramid

- He stopped making this claim around ~summer and I'm sure will never reckon with the fact that he sincerely said he thought Russia would invade a NATO country within a year in early-mid 2022, on multiple podcasts.

I have heard him spout too much nonsense for me to listen to consistently at this point but I still check in on him just to hear what he has to say regarding major world events (like the NS1/2 pipeline bombings).

mysecretaccount··on Russia Economy Hurt by Men Fleeing Ukraine War Conscription
What happened in the 90s?
mysecretaccount··on How Ukraine is winning the social media war
> This a link to the Wikipedia article on propaganda.

It is not.

It is a link to a Wikipedia article summarizing Herman and Chomsky's propaganda model. If you are genuinely curious why people argue that US mass media is state controlled, you would be hard pressed to find a better starting point than that page. You are not genuinely curious though, so feel free to move on.

mysecretaccount··on How Ukraine is winning the social media war
That is not a link to the definition of propaganda. Did you click the link?
mysecretaccount··on How Ukraine is winning the social media war
If you're genuinely curious: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_model
mysecretaccount··on Ask HN: Would quickly accepting Russia and Ukraine as NATO members end the war?
I appreciate the sentiment, but the expectation that Russia will pay war reparations in full, at this point, is also hilarious/insane...
mysecretaccount··on Why I think there's a one-in-six chance of an imminent global nuclear war
> It's plain to read the nonverbal communication of Putin's inner circle whenever they appear on camera: they're wondering how they can get rid of him.

As much as it would be nice if it were the case, this is extremely nebulous and more likely just projection/wishful thinking.

mysecretaccount··on A Nuclear Zugzwang?
Sure. But that is not relevant to the original point: if its own imperialist missteps this century did not do it, deescalation here will absolutely not wreck the US's reputation.
mysecretaccount··on A Nuclear Zugzwang?
The US may be in the more "morally correct" position on Ukraine, but it hardly has a reputation for its "moral position in the world". It has managed to retain hard and soft power through its own invasions, and would likely not give up any of either if negotiating deescalation in Ukraine to avoid nuclear armageddon.
mysecretaccount··on Two Mexican drug cartels came to dominate America’s fentanyl supply
There are steps that can be taken to provide addicts with legal access to their fix in a way that removes cartels from the supply chain and does not equate to "legalizing fentanyl".
mysecretaccount··on Psilocybin-assisted psychotherapy vs. placebo in treatment of alcohol disorder
Equally interesting (and probably more equitable) to consider the universe in which Richard Nixon did not exist.
mysecretaccount··on A run across Mexico
Both incidents you link are cases where foreigners traveled through notoriously dangerous territory (Michoacan narco territory, and the 195 route between San Cristobal and Palenque) alone, which is totally careless and not really applicable to the story in question.
mysecretaccount··on Eating sea squirts may reverse the signs of ageing in mice: study
There is no compound in nature that we cannot synthesize in a lab, but sometimes it is more expensive than harvesting it from plants/animals.
mysecretaccount··on The Life of a Backpacker in Asia in the 1970s (2018)
There are plenty of beds for £5 in (to use your example) Laos. I had a room not too long ago for under $5, on the Mekong. I wasn't around for the 90s, maybe cheap rooms were much easier to come by, but they're not too difficult today in that part of the world.
mysecretaccount··on Extend your runway, cheap money is over
Same here. So many easily verifiable inaccuracies in his essays/videos, as well as a dogmatic adherence to demographic and geographic determinism. Still, a perspective I appreciate.
mysecretaccount··on Ancient civilisation under eastern Turkey estimated to be 11k-13k years old
"Advanced" is presumably used to disambiguate less advanced civilizations. This was among the least advanced civilizations.
mysecretaccount··on Ancient civilisation under eastern Turkey estimated to be 11k-13k years old
As far as civilizations go, Gobekli Tepe is not really "advanced".

edit: I'm not sure why the downvotes, trying to clarify that this does not add credence to pseudohistorical narratives about long-lost advanced civilizations.

mysecretaccount··on Teaching GPT-3 to reverse words
We do not have any reason to believe that mere algorithms are incapable of living up to the standards of human abilities.
mysecretaccount··on Cities with Nice Weather
Funny, Cusco may be a good candidate based on low variable temperature during the year but my recollection is that it has high variable temperature throughout a 24 hour period.
mysecretaccount··on How deep does the rot in the Russian army go?
> This is not propaganda, these are facts.

These are not mutually exclusive terms.

mysecretaccount··on Obama argues unregulated social media is a threat to democracy
> Obviously broadband is not a utility yet, although there is massive support to making it one, and it probably should be. But let's ignore the semantic tricks and change the argument slightly.

> Why is YouTube equivalent to Electricity/Water?

This is not the comparison I am making. I am comparing YouTube to ISPs and claiming that arguments for or against censorship in the former could also apply to the latter.

mysecretaccount··on Obama argues unregulated social media is a threat to democracy
> Do you accept that all of these content creators signed an agreement to use YouTube's platform, which is a private entity?

Do you accept that users sign an agreement with their ISP, also a private entity? Why should the ISP, a private entity, not be able to censor traffic for which it provides the infrastructure? Because it (like social media) has few competitors?

mysecretaccount··on Obama argues unregulated social media is a threat to democracy
> This statement is false. There are plenty of websites that self publish video and receive utility for it.

This is a "0.001 is technically greater than 0" argument that could be made for ISPs as well. Do you accept that there are thousands/millions of people who rely on access to YT to support themselves, and have an income dependent on that site that would vanish if they were expelled from it?

← PreviousPage 4 of 7Next →