HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mysecretaccount

392 karma · joined August 26, 2021

submissionscomments
mysecretaccount··on Obama argues unregulated social media is a threat to democracy
If your metric is reachability, it seems like a mistake to ignore network effects. Although you raise a good point: reachability can be mostly extinguished by access to both ISPs and the handful of large social networks.
mysecretaccount··on Obama argues unregulated social media is a threat to democracy
> You tell me? YouTube is currently not a public utility. Argue why it should be?

Access to the internet is also not currently a public utility. And yet, some seem to be fine with government censoring speech via one of these non-public-utilities and not okay with it through another.

My point is that there is no reason good reason to treat them differently. There are bad reasons to treat them differently, though, which are covered extensively on this page and mostly due to our conditioning by gov and ISPs alike.

mysecretaccount··on Obama argues unregulated social media is a threat to democracy
> Phones and roads and the internet become inherently less useful if there is more than one network. Videos do not become less useful if you have to get some of them from one provider and others from another.

That is not true, though. Self-publishing video on my personal site has effectively no utility compared to publishing it on YouTube. For my job (and the job of, thousands? millions?), it is the only game in town.

An ISP comparison would be hosting my personal site on The Internet vs. a splinternet.

mysecretaccount··on Obama argues unregulated social media is a threat to democracy
What definition of "public utility" includes Comcast but excludes YouTube?
mysecretaccount··on Obama argues unregulated social media is a threat to democracy
My argument has nothing to do with Trump. A massively visible public figure is obviously an outlier when we talk about "limiting speech".
mysecretaccount··on Obama argues unregulated social media is a threat to democracy
Although you are likely highly overrating how irreplaceable ISPs are (the situation is bad but I have switched between several in this one home over the years), that's fine. I'm saying that Twitter being a private business does not mean that it should be shielded from any criticism of its speech practices for the same way that ISPs are not similarly exempt.
mysecretaccount··on Obama argues unregulated social media is a threat to democracy
> But there are many social media platforms, and it's easy to start new ones.

There is one Twitter. Losing access to Twitter, YouTube, etc. looks like losing access to a utility to me.

And it is not easy to start a new Twitter or YouTube in any meaningful sense. One could just as easily say "ISPs are not utilities or monopolies, you can start your own intranet easily with OSS!"

mysecretaccount··on Obama argues unregulated social media is a threat to democracy
Yes, this is my point. You could make a similar argument about the social media oligopolies.
mysecretaccount··on Obama argues unregulated social media is a threat to democracy
ISPs are private businesses too. Would you be fine with ISPs regulating speech?
mysecretaccount··on U.S. State Department orders non-emergency staff in Shanghai to leave
Title wouldn't fit verbatim: U.S. State Department orders all non-emergency government staff in Shanghai to leave as Covid surges
mysecretaccount··on Biden Condemns Putin, Saying He ‘Cannot Remain in Power’
> It is contrary to the international legal system

> On the basis of UN Charter article 2(4) and (5) [...] Russia must withdraw from all of Ukraine

> If the UN unravels...

The US and Russia routinely violate international law. The UN is not capable of enforcing these laws against actors like the US and Russia. We may not like it, but might continues to make right.

mysecretaccount··on Biden Condemns Putin, Saying He ‘Cannot Remain in Power’
> The world is precariously close to returning to "might makes right".

This paradigm never left us, you (and I) are just on the team with the most might at the moment.

> We can't appease by accepting a surrender.

Again, on what basis? Because you say? The term appeasement was popularized before the existence of the existential nuclear threat, and it is not a certainty that diplomacy will lead to the same outcome as starting a hot war between nuclear powers.

We might be doomed, certainly. But we might not be, and the option currently pursued by NATO (aside from some incendiary slip of the tongue about regime change in Russia) is, thankfully, to not pursue direct conflict with Russia for this reason.

mysecretaccount··on Biden Condemns Putin, Saying He ‘Cannot Remain in Power’
We know that how exactly? Because you say so?

When the risk is nuclear war, that is not good enough. No no-fly zone, no hot war between nuclear powers. We are already risking way too much. The expected value of a 1% increase in the odds of a nuclear war is somewhere around a million casualties.

mysecretaccount··on Biden Condemns Putin, Saying He ‘Cannot Remain in Power’
A hot war between the two largest nuclear arsenals.
mysecretaccount··on South Korea Covid deaths spiking
They achieved the "best case scenario": avoid death while the disease is more dangerous (pre-vaccine, pre-omicron), then gradually open with an inevitable (but much lower) death spike. SK per capita deaths are an order of magnitude lower than the US.
mysecretaccount··on Is the Russian Air Force incapable of complex air operations?
> They were just out shelling the nuclear facility when they could make some strategic strikes.

Were they? https://www.reuters.com/article/ukraine-crisis-usa-nuclear-e...

mysecretaccount··on Estonian Cargo ship sinks off Odessa after explosion, crew members missing
That is a relief!
mysecretaccount··on Nuclear War Survival Skills (1987) [pdf]
Why are you so certain that Putin will order nuclear armageddon?
mysecretaccount··on Nuclear War Survival Skills (1987) [pdf]
Have to admit, my nuclear war anxiety has never been as high as it is now.
mysecretaccount··on Ask HN: Do you think nuclear armageddon is plausible?
Unfortunately I think the UAPs cited by the Pentagon are just as likely to be of Chinese or Russian origin.
mysecretaccount··on What happened to Russias Air Force? U.S. officials, experts stumped
Hopefully this is true of their nuclear arsenal...
mysecretaccount··on A quick breakdown of what SWIFT is and why it matters
> [Cuba citizens] are living life in misery.

Cuba has higher life expectancy and a lower infant mortality rate than the USA. I think it is a mistake to lump it in with Venezuela or North Korea.

mysecretaccount··on Explosions in Kiev and Kharkiv now [CNN]
Do you have a source for this?
mysecretaccount··on The Fog of War (Ukraine Conflict Day One)
Who made this?
mysecretaccount··on Russian forces invade Ukraine after Putin orders attack
It is pretty wild. When engaging with the same people downvoting you, they do not even seem to disagree with this take violently, but think you are pro-Russia just because you bring up problems with how NATO/the West reacted to this.
mysecretaccount··on Russian forces invade Ukraine after Putin orders attack
Thanks. I typed from memory - the demand was that Ukraine not enter NATO, not related to an application.
mysecretaccount··on Russian forces invade Ukraine after Putin orders attack
All of that seems sensible, but I am not sure it clears up my confusion: if Putin never would have allowed an independent Ukraine, why would NATO reject his demands to reject Ukraine's NATO application? If Russia was going to invade anyway, why not at least try to de-escalate and negotiate for a sovereign Ukraine?

I think that this is the primary argument of people claiming that the USA MIC is partly to blame here. I do not have a good response to it.

mysecretaccount··on Russian forces invade Ukraine after Putin orders attack
This makes some sense, thank you. I still do not know why the original commenter was flagged, it does not sound like his theory is completely ridiculous.
mysecretaccount··on Russian forces invade Ukraine after Putin orders attack
My understanding is that no one (serious) is defending Russia, but claiming that Ukraine is a new battleground for the West vs. Russia and that the NATO membership proposal/the 2014 coup was antagonistic like the annexation of Crimea. What is wrong with that claim?

Of course what is happening is tragic. We can all agree it should have been avoided, and I am curious if it could have been avoided.

mysecretaccount··on Explosions in Kiev and Kharkiv now [CNN]
Chomsky was wrong on aspects of the Khmer Rouge in the 70s due to lack of information, but he absolutely does not deny it as genocide.
← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →