HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nabla9

45,787 karma · joined November 12, 2013

submissionscomments
nabla9··on Universe Is Not a Computer Simulation
I did read the article, so here is one sentence debunk:

Computable systems can, and often do, have mathematically undecidable problems.

They fall into the same categorical mistake as the Lucas–Penrose argument, and they even use that argument in the paper. There is a lot of hand-waving. By the way, just adding irreducible randomness into a computational system would make it trivially non-computable in the meaning they use, but that itself would not prevent developing an axiomatic Theory of Everything that explains everything we want to know. So far, there has been nothing that demonstrates that the Universe must be non-computable.

nabla9··on Trump directs nuclear weapons testing to resume for first time in over 30 years
North Korea did the last critical nuclear test in 2017. Others have not been testing for decades.

I think he is saying something confused and vague.

nabla9··on Trump directs nuclear weapons testing to resume for first time in over 30 years
> The statements made by the President himself?

Who is attention whore and bullshitter. For any other president statements equal policy, that's not so with Trump.

The statement is so vague that it does not indicate out of ordinary nuclear testing. The statement was made in TruthSocial. There is no presidendtial action (proclamation, memorandum, or executive order.) He might be just talking shit.

nabla9··on Trump directs nuclear weapons testing to resume for first time in over 30 years
Subcritical experiments are done in underground test sites. US does them 1,000 feet underground inside boreholes in Nevada test site because the explosion releases plutonium. Hiroshima has a Peace "Watch" Tower where they show number of days since last nuclear experiment and they count subcritical tests also.

There is psychological effect, but it's not that important. More important is keeping nuclear test ban in effect. If the US does test, Russia and China will follow.

nabla9··on Trump directs nuclear weapons testing to resume for first time in over 30 years
The statement lacked any detail. It's just attention whoring.

The US is conducting nuclear tests periodically just like other nuclear powers. Subcritical nuclear testing is allowed. The last one was in 2024 https://www.energy.gov/nnsa/articles/nnsa-completes-subcriti... "NNSA successfully executed a subcritical experiment in the PULSE facility at the Nevada National Security Site. The experiment was executed in partnership with Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory."

nabla9··on AI layoffs to backfire: Half rehired at lower pay
"We predict that much of this work will be given to lower-wage human workers, offshore or at lower salary,"

Why would companies regret this outcome?

nabla9··on Quantifying pass-by-value overhead
To my knowledge all x86 based systems and ARM and Qualcomm designed chips all use 64 byte cache lines.

Apple's M2 uses 128-byte cache line.

nabla9··on Nvidia takes $1B stake in Nokia
Nvidia is Nokia customer in data center.

AI-RAN is partnership where Nvidia and Nokia will sell to telecoms and private 5G/6G networks.

nabla9··on Nvidia takes $1B stake in Nokia
Nokia expanded into data center networks. Nokia sells optical data center interconnects.

They also plan to provide AI services in the Edge, that's why Nvidia invested.

nabla9··on Passkeys: They're not perfect but they're getting better
Losing your device and not having any passwords is like losing your fingerprints.

>Device loss scenarios

>Users are largely unsure about the implications for their passkeys if they lose or break their device, as it seems their device holds the entire capability to authenticate. To trust passkeys as a replacement for the password, users need to be prepared and know what to do in the event of losing one – or all – of their devices.

>Backing up and synchronising passkeys with a Credential Manager makes it easier to recover access to them compared to other existing second factor options. However, this relies on the user having prepared their Credential Manager account for recovery. Users need help in understanding and implementing the right steps so they can feel ready to go passwordless and use passkeys without extra worry and hassle.

nabla9··on Poker Tournament for LLMs
Thanks.

> with five copies of Pluribus playing against one professional

Although this configuration is designed to water down the difficulty in multi-player setting.

Pluribus against 2 professionals and 3 randos would better test. Two pros would take turns taking money from the 3 randos and Pluribus would be left behind and confused if it could not read the table.

nabla9··on Poker Tournament for LLMs
> equilibrium strategy is guaranteed to not lose,

In my scenario and tournament play. Are you sure?

I would be shocked to learn that there is a Nash equilibrium in multi-player setting, or any kind of strategic stability.

nabla9··on Poker Tournament for LLMs
Question:

If you put the currently best poker algorithm in a tournament with mixed-skill-level players, how likely is the algorithm to get into the money?

Recognizing different skill levels quickly and altering your play for the opponent in the beginning grows the pot very fast. I would imagine that playing against good players is completely different game compared to mixed skill levels.

nabla9··on ICC Judge Guillou loses all US IT accounts after MAGA sanctions [FR]
The court has jurisdiction. Gaza is not part of Israel by any law.

It's a direct application of 1949 Geneva Conventions. Most Israeli legal scholars agree that Israel's defense does not work.

nabla9··on ICC Judge Guillou loses all US IT accounts after MAGA sanctions [FR]
That's a political matter.

Countries do not join because ICC is a failure.

More countries do not join because ICC is is not failure and is not compromised.

nabla9··on ICC Judge Guillou loses all US IT accounts after MAGA sanctions [FR]
ICC is not failed implementation.
nabla9··on ICC Judge Guillou loses all US IT accounts after MAGA sanctions [FR]
The arrest warrants are as solid as humanly possible.

Before the arrest warrant by the Judge, before the ICC prosecutor even attempted to ask for arrest, they asked second opinion from a Panel of Experts in International Law that included top experts, including Theodor Meron; Hebrew University (M.J.), Harvard Law School (LL.M., J.S.D.) and Cambridge University (Diploma in Public International Law) who was once was a legal adviser of the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs, then Israeli Ambassador in Canada, President of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, and so on.

The panel unanimously agreed with the prosecutor.

nabla9··on 'Attention is all you need' coauthor says he's 'sick' of transformers
What "AI" means for most people is the software product they see, but only a part of it is the underlying machine learning model. Each foundation model receives additional training from thousands of humans, often very lowly paid, and then many prompts are used to fine-tune it all. It's 90% product development, not ML research.

If you look at AI research papers, most of them are by people trying to earn a PhD so they can get a high-paying job. They demonstrate an ability to understand the current generation of AI and tweak it, they create content for their CVs.

There is actual research going on, but it's tiny share of everything, does not look impressive because it's not a product, or a demo, but an experiment.

nabla9··on Elon Musk says he needs $1T to control Tesla's robot army
He gets nothing.

Tranche size is $500 billion. The first tranche milestone is $2 trillion, and the last tranche milestone is $8.5 trillion (total 12 tranches) Each tranche, other than the last two, requires an additional $500 billion increase in market capitalization. Each of the last two tranches requires an additional $1 trillion increase in market capitalization.

To hit the first market cap milestone he must increase Tesla market cap 34% matched to revenue-based operational milestone or Adjusted EBITDA-based operational milestone.

nabla9··on Elon Musk says he needs $1T to control Tesla's robot army
They pay is conditional. It will fully vest only if Tesla reaches market cap milestones up to $8.5 trillion and operational targets, including delivery of 20 million vehicles, 1 million humanoid robots, 1 million robotaxis, 10 million active Full Self-Driving (FSD) subscriptions. and $400bn in adjusted core earnings.

So witch way it is?

A) Tesla will easily reach all those robot milestones. Musk's pay package is unearned.

B) That robot dream is delusional and if Musk pulls a rabbit from a hat, he deserves his $1 trillion.

I select B.

nabla9··on Female spies are waging 'sex warfare' to steal Silicon Valley secrets
I'm sure spies also operate on platforms like OnlyFans and can extract secrets even without physical interaction.

The number of lonely male tech workers who engage in parasocial relationships online is not insignificant. Twenty years ago, I never would have believed that people would pay money just for some written or verbal acknowledgment from someone on the internet. Attractive female whom men "support" for an illusory relationship can milk thousands from some people.

Getting security clearances after background check shows payments of this type is probably difficult.

nabla9··on Populism and economic prosperity
> An increase in populism is a direct result of higher inequality.

Generally considered false by most social scientists, definitely oversimplification. Inequality is a contributing factor to the rise of populism, but it is not a direct or sole cause.

For example, Trump voters are better off economically compared with most Americans. Some recent research:

Mutz, D. (2018). Status threat, not economic hardship, explains the 2016 presidential vote. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS). https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1718155115

Norris, P., & Inglehart, R. (2019). Cultural Backlash: Trump, Brexit, and Authoritarian Populism. Cambridge University Press.https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/cultural-backlash/3C7CB...

nabla9··on Populism and economic prosperity
> What's the counter-argument to it?

Don't bring elites into every discussion. Inequality causes problems, it's not directly relevant to every thing, like this discussion. Populism is the insanity of the masses.

nabla9··on Elon Musk threatens to leave Tesla if he doesn't get his ridiculous pay
>‘Tesla Dilemma’: Elon Musk is destroying Tesla’s profitable car business, but at the current valuation, his lies about self-driving and robots is what is keeping the stock alive.

It's crazy and nuts but it makes sense. The choice is between keeping hype alive and delaying doom or doom now.

Tesla

  P/E: 254
  PEG: 116
For a car company with $1.46T market cap and modest revenue growth in last 12 quarters (3 years) those numbers are ridiculous.
nabla9··on Populism and economic prosperity
It seems that you make a populist argument.

Populism: the idea of the "common people" in opposition to a perceived elite. Frequently associated with anti-establishment and anti-political sentiment.

nabla9··on A Tower on Billionaires' Row Is Full of Cracks. Who's to Blame?
As many of the owners are billionaires or close to it, it's no surprise that it's mostly empty. Most of them don't live in NYC; they just don't want to live in a five star hotel while visiting.

Chinese, Russian, and Gulf billionaires buy them to serve as emergency assets. Losing some value doesn't matter to them as long as they have a few hundred million dollars stashed away in NYC, London, Geneva as physical property.

nabla9··on The viral new "Definition of AGI" paper has fake citations which do not exist
This is embarrassing.

It's not fraud or bad paper. AI just faked the citations when real papers exist and 30+ authors was not enough to spot it.

We can't trust AI to to do valuable and simple manage menial work like keeping track of citations.

nabla9··on Apple Said to Cut iPhone Air Production Amid Underwhelming Sales
Similarly Samsung has canceled its thin smartphone (Galaxy S26 Edge) https://www.androidauthority.com/samsung-galaxy-s26-edge-can...

You don't get any benefit from a thin phone if it's not thin all the way. Both the iPhone Air and S26 Edge phones have a thick, ugly bulge at the camera end. They are neither thin nor elegant.

nabla9··on Apple M5 chip
Doing good job is rewarded.

Apple's Hardware Chief, John Ternus, seems to be next in line for succession to Tim Cook's position.

nabla9··on Ireland is making basic income for artists program permanent
> About 20% of Irish homes are bought by investment funds,

It does not matter who owns them. If there is enough housing, investments funds will lower rents to match the demand. Investment funds can do excessive rent seeking only if the supply is limited. It's good if foreigners invest in housing, because hoses can't be moved overseas.

Anyone disagreeing, argue against this statement:

Exess rent seeking is possible only when there is scarcity.

When people don't have choises, they must pay what is asked. If you have 100 people needing a house and 101 houses available, prices will decline. Maintaining empty house is a running loss and house prices and rents will decline to prevent that.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →