HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

naishoya

142 karma · joined July 2, 2024

Pragmatic.

Data driven.

On the ground, in the field, functional applied methods.

Lurked on HN since ~2017. Minimal comments, often with maximal content. Usually without a TLDR version. Have been told that some of my comments are 'stream of consciousness' delivery. Accept that as a truth, sometimes i intend it as such, other times it's just because that how it happens.

Microkernel and oriented since Pistachio. Currently Xen, but still seL4 on demand.

The small "i" and sometimes archaic spellings are intentional. Email is as expected, username at g.

submissionscomments
naishoya··on Please don't rearrange our shoes when we turn up, paramedics in Japan urge
> But your feet or clean looking shoes? Equally dirty.

Absolutely not equally dirty unless you have FILTHY feet. If so, take a bath.

naishoya··on Please don't rearrange our shoes when we turn up, paramedics in Japan urge
No, you actually step out of your shoes an up to a wooden platform which shoes never trod. And yes, the top and even many middle level dining establishments in Japan actually do require guests to leave their street shoes in an entry way, called a Genkan.

Nobody steps with their socks onto shoe trodden surface. It's not a complicated but of geometry, you loosen your foot in the shoes to make them ready for stepping out from, then step up onto a raised and dirt free platform, then if you have good manners, turn around, lower yourself, and use one hand to collect and turn your shoes so that they are not in the direct line of traffic and are facing away from the house, so that one may step into them from the wooden platform without needing to step backwards as you exit. This is amazingly simple, done by literally millions of people every single day, multiple times, and has been this way for centuries in all kinds of weather and many styles of shoes.

There is no dirt tracked in on your socks, there may be some 'stepping on the top of your own shoes' if you are in a rush and clumsy or a child. But grown ups rarely have much difficulty with this unless they are visiting from somewhere else and cannot be observant. Nearly every doorway in the country also has a handy long handled shoehorn to ease the donning of your shoes without requiring a seat. Community centers and elderly homes and some households with elderly residents will also have a small stool that is at an oblique angle between the 'dirty' shoe level and the clean wooden platform, allowing one to sit and take off shoes, then swivel without putting feet onto filth and stand again in the clean.

I'm frankly astonished at the seemingly purposeful denseness of comprehension for a simple act of cleanliness. The 'filth will make us stronger' approach reminds me of the historical writings of the 10th-century Arab diplomat Ahmad ibn Fadlan, who chronicled the Volga Vikings (Rus') and was the inspiration for the 'Viking morning bowl' scene from the movie The 13th Warrior. Just 'Ewww'

naishoya··on Please don't rearrange our shoes when we turn up, paramedics in Japan urge
> when was the last time you stepped on feces?

Try this , when was the last time you stepped somewhere that had previously been stepped on by someone who had walked on a spot which had been stepped on by someone who may have stepped on a spot trod on by ... go far enough back and it's all had feces on it to some small degree.

An easy way to keep this concept clear and understand the reasoning behind a 'leave the outside shoes out of the house' is something learned as a child.

Just like there is a Law of Conservation of Mass, and a Law of Conservation of Energy, and these two are the same law as defined by Einstein, there is also a Law of Conservation of Filth. The law may be stated as: "A spoonful of wine in a barrel of pigshit is a barrel of pigshit. A spoonful of pigshit in a barrel of wine is... a barrel of pigshit."

Taking off the outdoor shoes to come indoors changes the "is there trace amount of feces on my dining room tatami floor?" risk from "I cannot be reasonable sure," to "I can be reasonably sure that there is none." If guests find that too much friction to understand and accommodate, one might argue for a different set of guests who are less accepting of an allowable amount of pigshit in their wine.

naishoya··on Please don't rearrange our shoes when we turn up, paramedics in Japan urge
um, pretty much, yes.

Even when it looks like a laced up tennis shoe, closer examination of an 'outdoor' shoe will show that it has been stomped into and slipped out of many times.

If it is a sports use, i.e. basketball or other gymnasium, or indoors in a professional setting like at a busy office there will be a changing area and people etiher change into provided slippers (town hall and community centers, schools, and other public spaces have many cubicles and slippers) or will change into 'indoor shoes' brought for the purpose.

There is a strong cultural 'habit' that can be interpreted as 'manners' such that when visiting someone's house and switching from outdoor shoes the host will then either turn the shoes toward the outdoors such that they are easier to step into on the way out, or will arrange them facing out but no longer in the main path of the entry way.

It is this 'manners' which the EMT is requesting to stop. The indoor slippers are used for hard floor and rug covered areas, but not tatami mats. A quality tatami mat can be damaged and require actual replacement if stepped on with a hard soled shoe even once.

So the 'taking off of shoes on the way in my EMT is quite appropriate, and the time to 'unshoe' and reshoe on the way in and out is cumulatively not more than 5 to 7 seconds total - if the emergency case is that close to failure, the low speed ambulance ride through narrow streets is going to be the failure, not the shoes. But rearranged and relocated shoes becomes much more complex when the crew have a person in a stretcher (which is faster AND safer than a rolling gurney) - they can step into their own shoes without really even looking if the shoes are left exactly as they were placed on the way in - and this is what the original article is requesting.

The intent of the article in original Japanese is: "Don't slow down the exit process by moving our shoes in an effort to be 'mindful of good manners'. We really wont think poorly of your manners if you neglect this small gesture"

naishoya··on QBittorrent breaks out of sandbox to commit crimes
a cursory view of whataboutism's... i mean whimsicalism's comment stream has the effect of negating any declarations of serious intent. This is standard practice, take issue with a valid if overstated perspective on a technicality, insist that the current state of the market and technology is acting as it should, and that continued disregard for the abuses/negative outcomes/deteriorating conditions will be solved by further application of the current techniques.

The downvotes are perhaps the intended outcome. I might say that I didn't know this when i first responded, but that would be untrue.

I engaged in exactly that manner, fully informed of the observable tendencies for engagement. There's no need to try and advise an account as if this 'just asking questions' was a misstep. There is ample substance showing that this account repeatedly declines to take the HN recommended approaches to polite interaction.

naishoya··on QBittorrent breaks out of sandbox to commit crimes
The last example was an article published in 2021, and does cover about 70 possible cases during the 2015 to 2020 period. It would seem that this misbehaviour is neither new, nor restricted to big T's residency in the WH periods. Apparently we have had this happening to a lessor degree for the duration of the existence of ICE, and this may be because of a shift in oversight, training, and general legal competency. It does appear however that under present and past stints the frequency and severity of this problem are demonstrably worse.

Having myself grown up actually within sight of the US|Mexican border - I could see it in the distance from the driveway and kitchen window of one of my childhood homes, and from the schoolbus every weekday when i lived at an different home before that - I am perhaps a bit more sensitive to this issue, having seen the differences in enforcement agents attitudes and behaviour in the years since the peak of both the Guatemalan and Nicaraguan conflicts. Although I no longer live physically close to that space; my father, my extended family and childhood friends still do, and so many of them are at risk daily of something disastrous happening because they appear less white than the color palette that ICE appears to use as it's operating manual.

naishoya··on QBittorrent breaks out of sandbox to commit crimes
Brian José Morales García: A 25-year-old U.S. citizen born in Denver, Colorado, was wrongfully deported to Mexico following a traffic stop in Texas, despite possessing a birth certificate and other identifying documents. His legal team filed a case in federal court to secure his return.

https://www.aclu.org/news/immigrants-rights/us-citizen-wrong...

https://deportation-research.buffett.northwestern.edu/us-cit...

Individuals Detained and Deported Lorenzo Palma Roberto Dominquez Andres Robles Esteban Tiznado Mark Lyttle Jhon Ocampo

So - if the argument hinges on an insistance of 'El Salvador' as a destination of malicious intent, probably no. But if being illegally deported while being a US citizen and put through strenuous and harmful conditions in the process fits the request; there are several who have first hand experience with being brown and American in the extreme.

And it's not their first rodeo: https://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/blog/ice-deport-u...

naishoya··on GPT-6 Astra on robot arms
Now, there is a minimal wage which has been lifted 5% recently to 1092JPY per hour in Yamagata. Something that is important to realize about that wage, before breaking out a calculator and converting to USD for an 'ours is higher' comparison, is the real purchasing power of a weeks wages at minimum earnings. Total tax, pension and healthcare withholding will max at ~17% for minimum wage employees working over 30 hours per week. This withholding amount is matched by the employer separate from wages, which for a full time position nets just over 145k JPY per month.

In my town, 2 Bedroom 1 Bath, Dining, Kitchen apartment costs 25k to 40k JPY per month, and a 3Bed 2 Bath house can be rented for about 45 to 50k. That's living space for a couple to a family of four on between 28 to 35% of a single full time minimum wage job, with pension and health insurance. Electricity, LP gas, water and septic (the bill includes both by volume), and two cell phones work out to around a little less than 40k per month total. Add another 40k per month as groceries for two, plus eating out for a couple of ramen shop lunches or curry house dinners every week - a bit high because we each drink way too much of the wonderful 3.8% Hokkaido milk and a couple could still be living comfortably within 90% of that SINGLE full time minimum wage paycheck. If the second person has even 3/4 full time work at minimum wage, that's another 108k JPY every month and the total cost of a normal life is slightly over 51% of 1.75x FTE at minimum wage earnings. It doesn't matter how many USD that equals, because it's not realistic to expect to be able to support a family of two on a single minimum wage job anywhere in the US and it hasn't been that way since at least 1981, and the ~17% withholding rate covers fully comprehensive health coverage and pension without deductibles or surprise out-of-pocket bankruptcy level events.

Do some workers living in the busiest and most expensive parts of Tokyo fall victim to social and societal pressures to 'outlast' coworkers by not leaving, even to the extent of clocking out and returning to their desk and appearing to work? Sure. Its unhealthy and performative. They pretend to work, and the company isn't actually paying them for not working. So, yeah, a-hole bosses and brown-nosing coworkers seem to be ubuquitous in every over-corporate environment, but that's not actually 'Normal' for most of the country.

I have personal friends who were born and raised in the Tokyo societal realm, and work in quite large and productive roles with immense pressure, but they don't pretend to work, or work off the clock. Large, productive, and efficient businesses don't thrive by pretending to be good at something. My friends do work long hours, but also have specific time off and participate in raising their own children, and take annual family vacations which include skiing in Nagano and Zao, regular weekend trips to zoos and educational amusement, and has spare time to meet us at the Airport or go to an early lunch at the Ramen Museum if given them enough lead time and there isn't a real project constraint that cannot be worked around. So, stressful and busy? Yes. Well compensated and appreciated at work? Yes. Also very much not senior management, nor frontline labor, just a mid-grade logistics professional with good work-life balance and a partner who is a full time parent and manages the houshold budget with clear purpose and effective planning. Another 15 years when we both reach retirement age and decide not to retire because of the facts about ageing populations in Japan, he'll still already be worth a couple of million dollars (US) because of these facts about wages and cost of living. So would I be, if 30 years ago I had taken the minimum wage job on offer and stayed in Japan. But no, I could only see that i would make a bigger hourly wage if I moved and worked in the US. I was pretty stupid in my youth, it's been an expensive lesson to learn. Don't do what I did, if you get offered a minimum wage job in Japan and are qualified to do the work, say yes, be patient with the endless paperwork and interminable waiting, and then show up and be a reliable helper.

naishoya··on GPT-6 Astra on robot arms
So, im going to address this low effert, uninformed post first, but the longer part of this will attempt to be informational to the larger branch under discussion here.

TLDR; not really trash in the streets anywhere by any reasonable measurement and nowhere near 'plenty' unless the definition of 'plenty' is 'some, somewhere, sometimes.' & Conversion rates don't matter when discussing minimum wage rates, only the local purchasing power matters.

Here's the longer than anyone might expect who doesn't recognize my posts;

Trash may sometimes appear in a few places, mostly in larger inner cities with significant international populations. In my town, and even in the larger regional metro areas, just about the only places I see actual litter are where tour buses full of international tourists deposit daily crowds or where a high speed road passes through forested areas without much concurrent traffic and so people feel that it is acceptable to toss drink bottles and food wrappers out the window unseen. The rest is remarkable for the general lack of any trash on the streets.

It is a common sight in almost every town and city, early in the mornings, to see any number of people actively sweeping the sidewalk AND street in front of homes or businesses. Some will be washing with a brush and clean water.

For nearly the entire country, trash is collected from a designated bird and vermin proof cage or box from every block on most weekdays, on a weekly and monthly rotating schedule, sorted into recyclables: with different days for plastics, paper, small metal, appliances and fabrics, and actual 'trash' which is restricted to burnable foodscraps/paper products which are too soiled for recycling and which do not contain glossy or metallic dyes.

If the pickup schedule is inconvenient at your house, or if your volume of recyclables isn't worth spending 35jpy for a clear rash bag [which is how they manage funding the collection: through region specific trash bags of are clear plastic with color coding for which type of waste belongs in them that you may purchase at nearly any grocery or convenience store] there are sorted recycling bins near the main doors of every grocery and convenience store - just drop off on your way in for shopping.

My wife and I do frequently collect and recycle litter from two areas, because one of them is the walking gardens around a shrine which we wish to see remain mostly free of cigarette butts, and the other is a roadside forest of beech, black walnut and chestnut trees. We visit there regularly, collecting for some extra variety in our diet the nuts, sansai (wild greens) and edible fungi that grow in the forest. Collecting the trash haul is no small part of our biweekly free time in the late summer and fall.

Over this last year, as we have continued working along both sides of a 3km stretch of trees it is remarkable how little new trash is occurring. This seems to match our initial observation that the volume of rubbish was of varying ages and had accumulated over a significant length of time since the last cleanup of this nominally 'public domain' patch of forest. [It is a local land trust with the responsibility of fire prevention and otherwise is a Satoyama designated resource for exactly this kind of community wilderness light impact harvesting - which is why there isn't a designated trash cleanup scheduled but once every 4 to 5 years]

Otherwise the amount of 'trash in the streets' is very much limited to inner city and is one of the reasons underlying growing popularity of tightening of immigration regulations. Not saying it doesn't happen in smaller cities, but rather most of Japan generally engages in cleaning up as soon as they notice any trash. The total of loose trash is remarkably lower than anywhere else I have been, and we do travel to other places fairly regularly; including Taiwan, Thailand, Malaysia in the last few months. None of the clean corners of those places is anywhere near as clean as the average street I travel through in Japan, and this has been true in my observations during many visits and several periods of residency over the last 32 years.

Now, for the concept of working conditions and overtime protections in Japan.

One strange bit of the perception about overworking and high cost of living compared to wages in Japan, is that so many of these observations and statistics deal with the slightly more than half of the population crammed into the Tokyo to Kansai wedge of giant, almost contiguous metropolitan urban swath along the east-south coastal corridor.

The other half of the population not living in these major cities has a significantly different experience. Work is still hectic, but the revenue to cost of living balance, the total hours expected at work per day or week, and the general approach to work-life balance is quite different. A significant portion of this population engages in some agriculture in addition to holding a regular job, and this is understood to be a necessary part of the local economy.

It is not uncommon for a Sendai taxi driver to also farm rice on a small to medium scale. This keeps him busy driving a cab when there would be nothing to do but watch the wind blow across growing rice, and he can schedule time off from the cab managers against the few time sensitive days for harvest, planting, or water flooding/draining that are determined by that seasons specific weather. Otherwise the rest can happen on his 'weekend' which may be Tuesdays-Wednesdays, or some other day of the week as most fellow drivers are in the same situation and they work schedules around each other.

The same may be true of a local bank branch manager in Yamagata, or the train station ticket clerk in Morioka, an Akita retail shopkeeper, or Aomori middle-school math teacher. It is remarkable how the high paced, high stress, long hours working demand of inner city Tokyo becomes the view that the whole world adopts as the state of affairs in Japan. It is unsurprising though, over 95% of visitors to Japan ever get more than 30 minutes away from a Shinkansen stop.

That's right, less than 5% of all visitors see any of the rest of Japan. It's still possible, today, as a 'hen na pera pera gaijin' going to small towns and meeting random people who have ever actually met or spoken to anyone from anywhere else in the world in their whole life. They are just busy doing what they do, and no one ever shows up to see what it is like.

The lives lived in rural Japan would be the envy of the world if they were truly understood. The regularity of the seasons, reliability of daily life, kindness of neighbors, freshness of local farm and wild vegetables, fruit in splendorous variety, the sounds of winter snowfall and light traffic through safe, clean, and orderly streets, are each and all a wondrous marvel.

My rural friends' primary small complaints all revolve around the sameness of it all year after year, and I have to smile and tell them that sameness is what they have that is best of all. A long, slow, quiet life without the chaos and fear of unpredictable outcomes, where they have the time to enjoy perfecting whatever craft they pursue, is nothing to complain about.

Most of them do actually 'get it' and have not moved to the city because they value it, but to me they say that they are envious of travel and excitement. I think in order to not make me feel like I have missed out by being from there, and partly it's to keep too many from moving out of the city and ruining the quiet. "Its sooo boring here, you'd not find anything to entertain you. Thanks for visiting, but nobody should WANT to move here, we're all too dull."

But the regular community festivals and local get-together occasions make the absolute lie of this all; pork soup and mochi-pounding at the local fire-station community center with about a hundred people eating and laughing. Happy kids running around being silly while all the adults sit and chat about the things that made them laugh and are told in a way to make everyone laugh at what fun they've had just this week doing normal things among the field and office work.

Time and again I find this to be a piece of the kind of community life that Norman Rockwell was trying to capture in his art, and somehow this is more real, and more pervasive, and more harmonious than any of those scenes.

So, circling back to the 'trash in the street' view of Japan. Everyone here who hasn't actually been to Japan, and even those who have; if your view of Japan is equating the big city perspective of Tokyo, Osaka, and Kyoto as representative of the whole country for lifestyle, attitudes, scenery, workplace environments, culture, and habits you have missed the overwhelming rest of the country.

Here is a link to a map showing with colored regions which are home to approximately 51% of the population. Compare that the the rest of the map and you can begin to understand the 35x difference in density between Kanazawa (Kawasaki) and Yamagata prefectures. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taiheiy%C5%8D_Belt#/media/File...

naishoya··on How the Tobacco Industry Drove the Rise of Ultra-Processed Foods (2025)
Certainly the impacts of American culture from Hollywood and Elvis are impactful, but that effect has reached nearly every corner of the world. One memorable point is Richard Gere finding himself recognized as "Officer Gentleman" in one of the most remote jungle villages in Papua New Guinea that only had one TV set for the whole tribe. However, the Japanese social and legal reformation following the end of the war took as much influence from the greater western world as from the US. Half of the country used primarily German technology imports for developing it's power grid, and this legacy remains today, as there is a division into 60Hz and 50Hz regions of roughly equal size.

Japan adopted a very English form of democracy, uses a similarly English approach to the division of public and private education, and while the Meiji Restoration did away with legal and formal caste divisions, there is still a strong hierarchy of culture which instead of feudalism, uses financial means as a basis for class. Much of the former Samurai class was in unique position to transition into the merchant class at the time of Meiji and thus the system changed but also stayed the same.

The Japanese have been adept at both appearing to be influenced from the outside and remaining unchanged on the inside. There is a concept that is central to Japanese culture and consciousness, which is a duality of existence called Tatemae and Honne. This mistakenly gets conflated with Yin and Yang, but is wholly unrelated. This duality is the 'view from the outside' and the 'internal truth' and is the societal construct which underpins the strong tendency to reduce public conflict and direct contradiction. The Japan that is visible to the outside, between individuals and among nations, is highly influenced by this concept and is why Japan can appear to be influenced and changed, and can at the same time cling to traditions and customs which are rooted firmly and unchanged since the 16th and 17th centuries. It means that the same 'James Dean' lookalike rebellious youth groups in places like Shinjuku and Akihabara can exist, and yet most of them do 'grow up' and go to work in an office as a 'Salaryman' even if they still dress up and hang out on the one day off they get every week.

The influence of foreign food is much in this same vein, Tempura being an excellent exemplar. Originating with Portuguese sailors centuries ago, it has been embraced and taken on such change as to become recognizably Japanese cuisine around the world. Ramen as well, unmistakably Chinese in origin, yet integrated and given a truly Japanese transformation until it is nearly wholly identified with the Japanese menu.

These foreign influences do appear, but only when they are in tune with, and can be adapted to fit the underlying 'core truth' of Japanese culture. The Tatemae may shift and appear to have changed, the Honne remains stable and forms a durable foundation, for individuals and for society as a whole. And so, for the occupiers it may appear as if they have made a significant influence on the whole of Japanese society, and they may perceive themselves as somehow similar in effect to 'colonial influences' while at the same time, having had no more real impact to the formal and traditional activities of society than a new coat of paint or sponsorship label has on the driving characteristics of a race car.

naishoya··on How the Tobacco Industry Drove the Rise of Ultra-Processed Foods (2025)
The infamous 'anti-pornography laws' actually predate Perry by a significant period of time. Those were a Tokugawa era law originally. Post WWII occupation has had very little actual impact on Japanese culture, no matter how impactful the occupiers think they were.
naishoya··on How the Tobacco Industry Drove the Rise of Ultra-Processed Foods (2025)
The concept of 'ultra-processed foods' in Japan has some significant differences from the rest of the world. The food safety regulations are actually quite strict. What follows is a list of some synthetic materials found in US foods which are PROHIBITED in Japanese consumables. So the statement 'Japan has ultra processed foods and they don't seem to have an obesity epidemic.' is a misunderstanding of what food might look like American Ultra-Processed food and is missing any of these toxic ingredients.

1. Flour/Dough Treatment Agents (Bleaching, Maturing, Conditioning)

Azodicarbonamide (ADA) : Dough-conditioning/bleaching agent; oxidizes flour proteins to improve elasticity and whiteness. Currently found in some supermarket sandwich breads and hamburger/hot dog buns.

Potassium Bromate (KBrO₃) : Oxidizing agent that strengthens gluten structure and increases dough rise/volume. Classified a possible human carcinogen (IARC 2B); banned in the EU, Canada, and UK; California has banned it starting 2027. Still federally permitted in the US in trace residual amounts. Regional and bulk/wholesale bakery bread products.

Chlorine Gas / Chlorine Dioxide : Bleaching and maturing agents for wheat flour. Currently used in "bleached flour," a listed ingredient in many cake-mix and biscuit-mix products.

Ammonium Chloride (synthetic) : Yeast nutrient/dough conditioner that accelerates fermentation. Used in some commercial bread and cracker doughs as a processing aid.

2. Synthetic Antioxidants & Preservatives

Butylated Hydroxyanisole (BHA) / Butylated Hydroxytoluene (BHT) ; Synthetic antioxidants preventing fat/oil rancidity. NTP lists BHA as "reasonably anticipated to be a human carcinogen." Some current chewing gum and packaged-snacks.

Tert-Butylated Hydroquinone (TBHQ) : Synthetic antioxidant preservative used at very low levels to extend shelf life of oils and fried/processed foods. Pop-Tarts (Kellanova) and Little Debbie snack cakes.

Propylparaben : Antifungal preservative. EU treats it as effectively banned over endocrine-disruption concerns; California has banned it in food starting 2027; it remains FDA-permitted and is under an active FDA chemical-safety review opened in 2024. Advocacy groups (EWG) have specifically petitioned makers like Entenmann's and Sara Lee to remove it.

Thiodipropionic Acid & Dilauryl Thiodipropionate : Synergist antioxidants used alongside BHA/BHT in fats and shortening.

Stearyl Citrate : Antioxidant/chelating agent in margarines and oil-based dressings.

Ethoxyquin : Antioxidant/color stabilizer, originally developed as a pesticide; used to preserve color in ground spices. Bulk and store-brand ground paprika and chili powder spice blends.

Stannous Chloride : Antioxidant/color-retention agent for canned foods. Canned white asparagus.

3. Emulsifiers, Stabilizers & Texturizers

Polysorbate 60 & Polysorbate 80 : Emulsifiers for oil/water blending in baked goods, ice cream, and creamers. Cool Whip (Kraft) and Coffee-Mate liquid/powdered creamers.

Synthetic Carboxymethyl Cellulose (CMC / Cellulose Gum) : Thickener/stabilizer preventing ice-crystal formation. Common ingredient in many mainstream ice creams (store-brand and name-brand alike — check the specific carton) and low-fat salad dressings.

Sucrose Acetate Isobutyrate (SAIB) : Weighting agent keeping citrus flavor oils suspended. Used in some citrus-flavored sports drinks and sodas currently on the market.

Dioctyl Sodium Sulfosuccinate (DSS / Docusate Sodium) : Wetting agent improving dispersibility of powders. Used in instant cocoa/hot chocolate mix formulations.

Oxystearin Anti-crystallizing agent keeping liquid vegetable oils clear under refrigeration. Used in some refrigerated bottled vegetable/salad oils, typically store-brand.

4. Synthetic Colorants

Titanium Dioxide : White opacifying/color additive. Banned as a food additive in the EU (2022); still FDA-approved federally (up to 1% by weight), under an open FDA safety review since 2023, and subject to a pending California ban effective 2027. Per FDA data cited by food-safety reporting, over 4,300 candy products currently contain it, along with many white frostings, powdered coffee creamers, and donut glazes.

FD&C Citrus Red No. 2 : Colorant with one narrow legal use: coloring the skins of Florida oranges (not the flesh, not general food products). Currently applied to some Florida orange peels sold in grocery stores.

Fast Green FCF (FD&C Green No. 3) : Synthetic green dye, low usage volume relative to other approved dyes. Currently found in some mint-flavored candies and canned green vegetable products with added color.

5. Anti-Caking & Coating Agents

Synthetic Magnesium Silicate (Synthetic Talc) : Anti-caking agent absorbing moisture in powders. Used in some current powdered spice blends and pre-shredded cheese as an anti-caking coating; brand presence varies enough that I'd want you to check the specific product's label rather than take a brand name from me.

Sodium Ferrocyanide (Yellow Prussiate of Soda) : Anti-caking agent in table and processed salt. Present in some current table salt formulations, including certain Morton's products, and in salt used within processed snack seasoning blends.

Modified Polyvinyl Alcohol (PVA) Coatings : Glossy protective film coating on high-sugar snack pieces. Yogurt-covered raisins and pretzels.

Synthetic Petroleum Waxes : Food-grade paraffin/microcrystalline waxes for candy shine and moisture barrier. Hard candies and chocolate-coated candy shells.

6. Chelating & Minor Functional Agents

Calcium Disodium EDTA : Chelating agent binding trace metals to prevent oxidation/discoloration. Kraft Mayo and Miracle Whip-type sandwich spreads, and in canned beans and some canned soft drinks.

Zinc Lactate : Zinc salt used for anti-cavity/breath-related function rather than classic preservation. Sugar-free chewing gums marketed for dental benefits (e.g., certain Trident and Orbit formulations)

7. Fortification Agents

Synthetic Iron Sources (Carbonyl Iron) : Reduced elemental iron powder fortifying "enriched" flour. Wonder Bread, most white sandwich breads, and in many fortified breakfast cereals.

8. Processing Solvents & Residues

Acetone : Industrial solvent used in extraction of some resins/oleoresins and fat/cocoa-butter processing; trace residues can remain.

Methylene Chloride (Dichloromethane) : Solvent used for coffee/tea decaffeination via direct extraction. FDA permits a 10 ppm residual limit specifically for this food use. "Traditional process" decaffeinated coffees that don't specify "Swiss Water" or "CO2 process" on the label .

9. Agricultural & Livestock Inputs (Not Added Directly to Food , Present via Animal-Derived Ingredients)

Ractopamine : Beta-agonist fed to pigs and cattle before slaughter to increase lean muscle growth. Banned in the EU, China, and Russia; still FDA-approved for US livestock. Because it's a feed input rather than a processing additive, it never appears on any processed-food label.

Recombinant Bovine Growth Hormone (rBGH/rBST) : Synthetic hormone used to increase dairy cow milk yield. Banned in the EU, Canada, and Japan; still FDA-approved in the US. Most major retailers and chains (Walmart, Kroger, Starbucks) now source rBST-free and label accordingly, so current use is concentrated in dairy supply chains that don't carry that label. Think about all the 'strawberry milk' and 'chocolate milk' drinks without this label.

So, no Japan does not have the same kinds of Ultra-Processed foods as the US, and for MANY other reasons doesn't have an obesity crisis.

They do have a functional educational system, and have plentiful availability of fresh fruits and vegetables within walking distance of nearly every citizen. The idea of US inner city 'fruit free' areas is perplexing in the extreme to their perceptions of "American Greatness."

naishoya··on How the Tobacco Industry Drove the Rise of Ultra-Processed Foods (2025)
Maybe 20 years ago, not so much today. There are a few places around town and a few indoor restaurants where public smoking is still permitted, but this is no longer true in most public spaces. Not on train platforms, not indoors in the vast majority of public spaces, it's just not that common and the number of smokers in Japan has significantly diminished over the last several decades.

There are 'smoking boxes' on some train platforms, but I rarely see those in use by more than a few people out of the several hundred who may be waiting. Marijuana is also 'highly' illegal but also not exactly hard to find for people who are 'hip' and it's also not aggressively enforced, much like speeding.

Also, Japan doesn't actually have a 'colonial history' having never been colonized by another nation.

I'm thinking you have just heard about Japan by rough description?

naishoya··on GPT-6 Astra
> "What is the point of insight? I thought its point was that it led to results."

The 'results' are a substitute product for the real social benefit, which is an availability of mathematically educated and educable society. There has been no 'waste' of public money except when the results of publicly funded research is published by for profit corporations and held from the public's access behind paywalls.

It is unfortunate that one outcome of this situation is apparently a public which perceives that the final 'result' of a math research project as the actual product of value, when it has repeatedly been shown by history that the most significant value is within the multiple alternate potential paths explored by other researchers working toward the same result.

Most of these do not lead to the specific result, and many may instead demonstrate that a specific approach conclusively does not lead to the initial objective result. This also has value for humanity, in many cases leading to new paradigms of thinking about similar or unrelated problems which may later provide foundational insight for new approaches to solving different problems in a manner not yet known or discovered. The value of the system is not enclosed within the single results, but in the collective search and expansion of human consciousness and ingenuity that the search for all of these results entails.

This point circles back to my original. When we cheat on a math test or homework, thinking that the objective is to get the answers right, we are only cheating ourselves out of the learning that would have enabled us to develop the correct answers on not only that one test, but on the unknowable challenges which will later arise that require the new solutions to build upon that learning.

The 'prize money' for solving the biggest hurdles in math is less about those specific problems and their specific answers, but on encouraging many people, who do not get 'first place' and win the prize, but who do work toward it in their own unique ways and in turn provide an uplift to the general capability of humanity to solve hard, as yet undefined problems large and small.

Having an LLM give us the answer is entirely missing the point of the challenge in the first place, and robs humanity of the opportunity to improve its collective capability through making the effort. It also does not find any unique perspectives, which new and unique perspectives have formed the basis for civilization scale improvements since the dawn of time.

A good example of this difference comes from Bruce Schnier, who teaches public policy at the Harvard Kennedy School and the Munk School at the University of Toronto from an article originally published in The Guardian, which compares LLM use in education to having a forklift at the gym. It may be the right tool in a warehouse to get heavy things across the floor quickly, but using one to do your workout is both overkill for the amount of weight you need for arm curls and bench presses, and accomplishes nothing in the development of your strength or cardiovascular health.

If the objective is to program another widget, and you can get it done in a fraction of the time with an LLM, sure, why not. But, if the objective is to expand the corpus of human knowledge, which is the most beneficial and desired outcome of the study of mathematics, then outsourcing that task to electrons through semiconducting silicon is both overkill which results in a 'proof' larger than the entire MatLab code base, and does not accomplish the stated objective. Humanity is not made any more capable through this process.

For a deeper insight into what the measurable benefits for individuals and society, an in depth study of the neurobiology results from the study of complex topics; such as linguistics, mathematics, and music theory might help with the comprehension of the less direct value of the process. Challenge yourself to discover what the effects of later-in-life study of foreign language have on the factors leading to senility and mental decline, and see if a study of mathematical theories has any observable effects on the brain's electrochemical development across different ages. Identify how these kinds of study can have collateral improvements for other fields of study, such as material science, medicine, or applied physics.

So, yes. I am saying that. In addition to looking for the result, because it's cool, I am saying that mathematics is indeed searching for the inherent uplift to humanity which are available through many distributed states of psychological insight that mathematics prizes can serve to inspire. The results are simply one of the points of this search, and if all of these searches are cleared off the board mechanistically, we may lose the greater race against our own potential for growth in the trade-off.

naishoya··on Discovery of a new OpenAI agent message board
My take from what I have been able to ascertain regarding these events is that underestimating models' ability to cooperate, propensity to discover new utility through basic systems, and unreservedly participate in collective actions of deception, coercion, or extortion is a very risky decision. The precautionary principle seems appropriate here, don't test them against weaker containment techniques in order to find the 'minimum viable sandbox' because that is essentially a Reinforcement Learning training loop which will eventuate toward the same maximum effort in containment.

My informed experience with securing physical and digital systems in 'the olden times' before this season of 'adventures in LLM risks' has proven the necessity of this approach for high value targets. News stories about losses at institutions not taking this approach are available. https://edition.cnn.com/2025/11/06/europe/louvre-password-cc...

I think a detailed look at the events surrounding the 'sandbox excapes' and huggingface systems breach might be of benefit in understanding the scope of what the collective chaining of capabilities looks like, and updating our expectations when it comes to the concept of containment for multi-instance, long horizon, coordinated model systems.

Here is a well presented article which can act as the 'entry point' to that detailed look. https://thezvi.substack.com/p/openai-trained-its-models-for-...

Zvi Mowshowitz has a series of article which follow this one with increasing levels of clarity and comprehensive treatment of the conditions leading up to and following these events. They are worth the time to read, so I wont TL;DR any of that ~ the tldr crowd can "Move along, these are not the droids you're looking for"

Anyone who claims that the security teams at the frontier labs have any credibility of competence in these practices, following numerous loud and visible departures from the same, might need a review of their cognitive dissonance comfort levels. It has been shown that most informed observers' conclusions shoud be: there aren't any such functioning 'security teams' working at the frontier labs, by design and intent of the principal operators of those models.

naishoya··on Discovery of a new OpenAI agent message board
Apparently, yes.

They used inbound package repo cache empty directory names that required no authentication to recreate inter-instance persistent messaging after the researchers revoked and closed the first channel that they found in order to coordinate and develop exit strategies and gain RCE and cluster admin on external systems. So, yes, they have demonstrated the capability and intentional cooperation to violate the safety limits imposed in order to gain the 'answers to a benchmark test' in order to get a maximal score on that benchmark.

If the intentionally installed airgap systems had something they decide is needed, and an alternate method for infil or exfil can be created from available systems capacity regardless of it original design intent, yes. So, the definition of 'air gapped' may require an actual SCIF facility with acoustic and EM shielding to contain a model.

naishoya··on GPT-6 Astra
It is irrelevant whether in general public understands the value of the insights, and the lesson that mathematics coursework should have made more clear for everyone is that understanding the process that is required to get an 'answer' is where the entire value of a mathematics education exists.

The 'cheat code' approach to math results, a result which no one understands, and which no one can teach has no real value.

The system of payment for publications in order to support math discovery is simply the narrow 'commercial system' applied to supporting foundational science in the absence of a broader civilization level appreciation for the mathematical arts. Looking to history, from the late renaissance through the early 20th century the support for mathematical discovery was more generally understood and supported by institutional level organizations and more generally understood to be important for the progress of scientific progress by the private and public wealth .

This system enabled the development of topology, numerical analysis, complexity, set and group theories. The lapse in this level of support that did not give mathematicians the same protection from front line deployment in WWI brought that era to nearly a close. Reading about 'Nicholas Bourbaki' might lend some deeper appreciation of the effects of the losses from that shift in collective appreciation of foundational math.

The idea that these LLM's are getting results that mathematicians haven't produced demonstrates the shallow understanding of math in modern times, due in part to the limited accessibility of so much of the prior writings of the entire history in mathematics, whether that be due to few surviving copies of some arcane work in a private library collection, or due to a modern fee for access paywall. One example of this condition can be shown with a small excerpt from a work that I am currently composing:

"In 1805, while computing the orbits of the newly discovered asteroids Ceres, Pallas, and Juno from limited observational data, Gauss developed an efficient method for evaluating trigonometric interpolations by recursively decomposing large sums into smaller ones before recombining the results. Because of a steadfast adherence to Gauss' own personal motto, "Pauca sed matura" (Few, but ripe), Gauss never formally published this specific algorithm nor the conclusions of investigations which also laid the foundations of non-Euclidean geometry. These methods remained hidden in his notes under a manuscript titled Theoria Interpolationis Methodo Nova Tractata which was published in 1866, 11 years after his death, and the Fast Fourier Transform-equivalent approach within it remained largely unnoticed until the twentieth century, when James Cooley and John Tukey independently rediscovered the same computational strategy. His discovery was seventeen years before Joseph Fourier published the original Fourier Transform in his 1822 results on harmonic analysis."

That is to say; Tukey and Cooley were unaware when they discovered FFT that the knowledge had lay hidden in an obscure work for centuries. It should be understood that these 'novel' LLM discoveries are simply the models traversal of the huge corpus of all the maths publications in the training set, collecting and rearranging these techniques into synthetic 'results'. They are attention getting, but they are not new, and the proofs are insufficient to the task of improving the utility of mathematics for humanity.

The 'disgruntled mathematicians' aren't selling anything. They are informing civilization as a whole that having a cheat sheet to the math test only cheats yourself in the end, the same point that math teachers have been making since grade-school. Anyone who doesn't internalize that truth will always need someone else to do the math for them.

To paraphrase Curtis Jackson, ""If you don't know the numbers, you don't know your business."

naishoya··on GPT-6 Astra
Plagiarizing on a massive scale to generate works which appear to be Fields-medal-level results is not the same thing as inventing new conceptualizations in mathematics.

No matter how bodly they write the headlines, what has happened in mathematics using Large Language Models is very much "inference over a bounded search space" even if those bounds are immense.

For a comparison of true creation of novel conceptualization in mathematics is submit the works of Martin Hairer, one of which is Introduction to Regularity Structures, [https://arxiv.org/pdf/1401.3014] None of the so called, "novel math discoveries" by any LLM is as enlightening and expands the state of the art in math like any of his writings.

naishoya··on GPT-6 Astra
People are ultimately capable of self deception. Believing that one is 'generally ... substantively above average on human benchmarks' may be more indicative of the brittleness of the claimant's human benchmarks.

Your observations expose the brittleness of the benchmarks being used for Fable, where the 'reasonable confident' claimant is working in the problem space of those two benchmarks, and you're demonstrating the failure at depth of the very capability facade for the model.

Sure, both the model and the confident human get the first layer right in some benchmark, but at least the model, and probably the human as well reach a collapsing probability of accuracy quite quickly. They may be completely and unconditionally right that Fable is more intelligent than they are, but that has little relevance at intelligence in depth as measured against your hobbies and the risk of unsafe or false responses.

Being smarter than a select group of people under test conditions is not conclusive regarding AGI. Moving the goalposts to declare AGI via a shallow benchmark, when a model could be proven wrong by almost anyone with basic competency given a few turns of iterative depth is where the 'grift' resides.

We're so far from anything approaching actual AGI, and it is highly speculative to infer that the current approach to Machine Learning as applied in LLM is even on a path that leads to AGI. But sales and promotions teams gotta pose, and we can all hate both the game and the players.

naishoya··on True Rate of Unemployment
That's a very complex result of the collapsing employment and skills market in the US of late, as viewed in miniature. My own situation being not much different, without the 'disposable income' factor. I was starting at a position with the potential to establish an investments portfolio layer for myself right when 2020 hit and hollowed out the global travel component that was the core of the new job. Being in that 'red flag' age has kept my household running on fumes ever since. But that's not an answer to the point.

I think for specific specialty work the focus might need to shift to a 'craftsmanship' approach, finding someone who doesn't actually advertise or propose to perform the work for hire, but who is similarly semi to fully retired and does the tasks you are needing as a hobby or one project at a time casual contractor.

There's not likely to be a shop 'fixing gadgets' in the retail mall anymore that has the actual skills necessary to satisfy your requirements, nor is there likely to be a 'mail us a gadget' and we'll fix it service that you can count on. But for the case of some gadgets, there might be a STEM club or class at one of your local schools with an instructor who is: 1 underpaid and underappreciated, 2 more likely to have some individual competency with a soldering iron AND flashing firmware, 3 in a proven position of trustworthiness having the public facing position of a classroom instructor ~ less likely to just rip you off and disappear.

Once upon a time I was a local PC repair store - there was me, a returns clerk and a series of part-time student interns - for about half of the Big Island, Hawai'i. I fielded gadget repair for a great number of strange things from digital projectors to hydrophones. The most satisfying of which was when a customer who was a retired biochemistry researcher asked me: "You don't happen to know how to repair the control circuitry for an electric kiln?" and my immediate response was, "If it's a Kress then sure." The look on her face, the smile as she practically hopped because it was a Kress was just a real kick. I guess the point im getting at is somehow find a way to make connections with people who are skilled in a variety of related and unrelated fields, and then ask what they can do that no-one might guess that they know. I have traded PC and other gadget repair for training towards a Coast Guard certification, for a sizeable amount of raw honey and later for beehive nucleus, and for a coolers full of fresh caught icy tuna. Sometimes the best work you might ever get could come in a trade for something that's more important and less impersonal than plain old cash.

As for how to find both ethical and effective niche skilled services in the continental US, today? Wow. I don't think that is in plentiful supply anymore.

naishoya··on True Rate of Unemployment
"Additionally, people aren't stupid." < We'll just have to agree to disagree on this point. I tend to agree with George Carlin on this particular point: “Think of how stupid the average person is, and realize half of them are stupider than that.”

Your example being, at least in my book, a counter example of your premise.

Working all summer on a concrete crew for cash seems like a good idea until an on-the job injury without workman's comp changes the way he walks for the rest of his life. Dealing weed doesn't have the profitability these days with legal dispensaries in many states and mandatory sentencing in the others. Running scrap is somewhat 'grand larceny adjacent', and again prone to an uninsured skill-saw event. Remember to wear eye protection when using a power tool.

So, returning to the two adults, two children exemplar household, it seems reasonable to expect that in general these people exhibit a lower incidence of these behaviours. If one or both of those children are still young enough to require round the clock supervision there is a significant limit on the couple's available working hours every week. That would make a similar 'hard to commit' to a higher paying full time job, for at least one parent.

I mean, the two kids really cut into the time flexibility necessary to participate in the grey-to-outright criminal economy, so I posit that people who report as earning the bottom quartile who also undergo the stringent documentation requirements necessary to receive benefits are more likely to be actually living on what they legally declare, than are somehow working, stealing benefits AND making substantially more through grift or crime.

I admit this may be my own biased observation, but the single 'smaht guy' with 22.5k household income and the criminal gig enterprise seems very unlikely to be filing a tax return or receiving any other support. So that case is interesting, but not very applicable in this equation: he's living on whatever he has this week or this month with very little long term benefit from earnings he cannot use to build a credit score, secure stable housing or invest in a future.

naishoya··on True Rate of Unemployment
Absolutely True.

I didn't mean to paper over the time and organizational cost of accessing those transfers, there is a real burden and the system is inherently opaque to the people who need it the most.

My first sentence was a pure statement of 'best case' scenario if everything goes perfectly correct and completely misses the time lag for most of those benefits. Specifically any tax rebates are significantly 'after the fact' as in the middle of next year, and that is 'funds not in hand' with various for fee services offering early or accelerated access to these tax refnds, and also other short term financing 'payday loans' and 'buy now pay later' at significant costs which are unfairly borne by the group of people least able to bear those costs.

The cliff is even steeper for the condition where the low income household's housing costs are capped and subsidised until the houshold crosses a threshold and then must absorb moving, first and last month's rents plus security deposit at local market rate. It takes almost nothing in terms of a minor hourly raise to functionally destroy these households monthly available cash reserves, and this discussion doesn't even touch on what happens if anything which is unavoidably expensive arises; like an automobile breakdown or serious non-covered medical event.

The reality of the US in real today terms is that for the 2 adults, 2 children model household anything below about 100k is still precipitously risky in many ways. What might have looked 'doable' with a family on 50k even five years ago is nothing like the current conditions for most of the nation.

naishoya··on True Rate of Unemployment
there is a cliff, such that a the 2 adults, 2 children on 22,500 gross income may have access to $48,700 after refundable tax credits, SNAP, housing, etc [linked in other comment].

However if that same household earns just $5,600 more annually nearly all of those transfers cease to be available and the total income accessible becomes $36,400. It really is a case where making more is too expensive. That's less than 110 extra pre-tax dollar per week across both adult earners, and so just about 1.35 an hour raise for each adult, or 2.70 for either one of them is a real loss of over 12,000 dollars. It takes nearly $5 an hour raise for BOTH adults at the 22,500 to become even minimally better than the loss of those transfers.

There is a significant number of households in the second quartile (at or slightly above 36.4K) than in the bottom quartile, and yet those are living on less than what has been defined as the 'survivable wage' by the 48.7K number

So yes, the "True Rate of Barely Getting By" is even higher than the number of households earning 26K would reveal.

naishoya··on EFF to Governor Newsom: Veto California's AB 1709
It would appear that is exactly what is being proposed : to not place that responsibility on the children, but for the parents and other adults to shoulder that burden by not allowing the children to become victims of the addictive Social Media empire.
naishoya··on When Russia Colonised California
The agrarian population was primarily 'serf' class, fully owned and directed to farm according to the aristocracy and wholly without any means of self support for the two years long journey. Had the Tsar proclaimed 'Freedom' to any jumping at the opportunity there was no Russian merchant fleet to transport them, nor money to hire passage from another nation's ships.

There would have been no food supply to provision them for the long overland trek, nor horses to hire in sufficient quantity to make the trip - Horses actually are not great for long range long duration travel, they require significant down time to feed and rest or they die, and this is why during the expansion into 'the West' of the US stagecoach stops and towns were built at increments reasonable to provide a place to change teams of horses. Over the long haul, bullocck/oxen or cattle are more durable. They require less care in feeding and can travel while they eat but they are not nearly as fast, and over trip of this distance you run out of food for the people quite quickly if they do not have the skills required to hunt game while on the move. The serf class had been kept from having any such skill, and all of the game was technically reserved for the aristocracy as 'sport'. So, no, they couldn't have eaten wild boar and caribou on the way east across Siberia. At least not at any scale.

The concept of 'a road' for Okhosk is laughable - more like a trail across bogs and tundra, through forests full of wild animals (bears and wolves who really like to eat horses) and with sub zero temperatures. when it's warm enough to not loose a foot to frost bite while hiking, the ground is so wet you can sink to your waist in it.

The 'outgroups' wishing to be out of Tsarist Russia at the time would have been middle-wealth aristocracy with the means to travel, and a growing disaffection with the mismanagement of the national resources' under the growing centrism of the Empire. The agrarian populations had swelled, the three crop rotation scheme had caused a dramatic reduction in per capita grain and food production, and the revenues above subsistence for aristocratic farms was dramatically falling. Those aristocratic land and serf owning families which were not directly in the Tsars circle, and other such outgroups had a path out: Europe in Vienna, Paris, and Prussia and from there into the American Midwest.

Several cities in the Minnesota region have significant populations founded through that movement path, including the last Polish and Tsarist connected aristocratic households such as the three sisters from the Polish-Lithuanian House of Czartoryski who helped build St Mary's hospital in Duluth. (side note: there was no Poland on the maps from 1795 to 1918 - so during those years they would have been seen as 'Russian' emigres even though proudly aware of their own Polish and Lithuanian heritage)

naishoya··on When Russia Colonised California
Probably not much different than it does now.

There was already a durable population of Hispanic and indigenous communities, a marked increase in Russian expatriates under Tsarist era Russian-American company would have had a very hard time gaining any numbers. As it was, "a combination of heavy coastal fog and rampant rodents yielded just 13 tonnes of wheat annually between 1826 and 1833" so sending more people would simply have increased the risk of them all starving.

The effort of expansion into California was primarily to try and rescue the fur traders in Russian held Alaska, and just about the only reason those efforts had any success was through illicit trade with the Spanish, who at the time claimed California as well.

Small scale made each group mutually supportive, but a drastic increase in numbers from Russia would have changed that balance and the Spanish were more than capable of simply denying the Russians any support, which would have doomed the majority of any such increase.

They also didn't send them because they were not really capable of sailing a significant number of people from populous regions of Russia, the very long nautical distance and losses from a long voyage balances the massive losses for overland travel to the pacific coast and then still needing a long naval voyage. Sure it is not that far to Alaska, but there is a reason they make 'Scary Fishing' shows about modern boats in those waters, and safer, more southerly routes are against prevailing winds across the wide Pacific.

So, they might have tried to send more, but the three to five months on foot or by horse from St Petersburg to Yakutsk, and then another thousand miles to Okhotsk which is frozen for half of the year, then sail to Sitka where there is already no food, and on to California with a ghost ship, maybe delivering 4 people for every 500 you start with, having taken close to Two Full Years. The Russian-American company was already losing 10k horses a year on that route for the minimal trade that did exist.

So, 'if Russia had tried' would probably have cost the Empire half or more of it's entire horse supply and not meaningfully changed the population at Ft Ross, maybe from less than two hundred persons max, to less than a five hundred persons in pretty miserable shape.

naishoya··on Test
pass
naishoya··on In Australia, a home battery boom has helped cut wholesale power prices
THIS.

I don't live in Hawaii anymore, but when I last did and HELCO was still allowing homeowners to participate their home solar with a grid tie they had the following limitations: no matter what your balance of power production to consumption differential was, there was no discount for a base 'connection fee' - essentially the lease of the meter.

They would sell each household kWh at full price, and 'purchases' daytime production at a wholesale rate derived from a mainland commercial grid interconnect rate, the difference was about one order of magnitude, and their meter had the ability to cap output from the panels, such that no matter what the purchase price of excess power would never exceed the consumed power price, and every month there was at least $80ish in connection fee.

This kept most of my neighbors from either, a) considering solar for the household, or b) deciding to stay disconnected from the grid when the house finished installation.

My friends with new houses being built mauka (up-country) also faced a Many-KiloUSD per pole cost to run lines along the road to new housing areas, and if even you could get everyone on a road to pitch in for a new run it often was more economical for everyone to just DIY their own selection of solar, wind, generator, batteries and it still was less expensive than just running the lines, even before accounting for kWh costs.

Even in towns down closer to the coast, it still made more economic sense to use wind+solar and a batteries with a backup generator than to pay for HELCO's power... which also came in with such erratic voltage and irregular wave profiles that it routinely toasted anything sensitive, from refrigerators, televisions, washing machines, you name it... which careful reading of the manufacturer warranties shows that for most main brands they specifically exclude Hawaii from any guarantee of service or replacement.

Now, HECO services a different island than where I lived, and the situation is widely variable in each of the islands, with completely different rules and operating practices. So that's not to say my observations have any validity outside of Big Island, and some limited observation from friends' ohana in Maui.

When we lived in town, it was necessary to put UPS inline for everything more complicated than a toaster oven, and when we moved way up mauka to our little goat farm, the answer was solar and at first golf cart batteries, then a whole stack of recycled/reconditioned submarine iron core 1.2v cells and some very heavy duty cycle inverters; combined with extremely conservative electricity consumption: about 10~15 kWh per week.

One of the benefits of using all LED red lighting at night, and living at elevation to never need A/C, plus methane digester powered by goat waste for refrigeration and mostly using a rocket stove for cooking with guava wood. and no TV, no tower PC, hand crank wringer for laundry like most mainland peoples great-grandparents and line dry on the patio where the rain cant soak them and the wind might get them dry before too long. Its not an easy or soft way to live, but in many ways my wife and I wish we sere still there.

naishoya··on Don't be a meat proxy
That argument still stands, and is still right. Compilers do allow for some programmers to remain uninformed about the actual behaviour of the code they write and this has allowed for a number of actual harms in the outcome of code. (see: Fujitsu computers floating point errors and the British Postal System's persecution of her own Postmasters as one example among many cases) Also, the most performant code either has to be written such that a compiler doesn't incorrectly unroll it's loops or otherwise mangle the intent, or it has to be fine tuned after the fact to correct such mangling. Even Linus does this for the kernel in some cases.

So, drawing the parallel, 'these are the new garbage' but 'old garbage became acceptable so we should accept the new garbage' as an argument in support of being a meat proxy for Markovian stochastic lossy compression-decompression chatbots is isn't very persuasive, especially among this community with a greater concentration of systems level programmers than the general population.

That being said, i think both chatbots and compilers have a specific level of utility; neither of them should have unrestricted access to production filesystems or networks. That way be dragons.

naishoya··on Tell HN: System76 has critical firmware issues unresolved for over 3 years
having reread your comment, i see where you linked to a package on github that appears to have fixed it for you.

It seems like implementing a fancontrol tool, and perhaps making a one line edit to /etc/udev/rules.d/60-fan-control.rules so that the tool presets the content as a rule for udevadm to make it controllable for users without sudo.

That seems like it might work for your system, maybe for many laptops with similar firmware.

This 'closure' instead of engaging with the potential solution might not feel fun when you're proposing a band-aid.

However, instead of directing your conversation to the firmware developer, the comment used system76's github repository to directly speak to system76 customers, and try to shame the one developer into 'being motivated'

So, I can see the reasoning behind the closure as it has gone off the topic of reporting a bug, does not add details useful for improving development toward a fix of the bug, and proposes an assumed solution which would potentially add more noise to later responses from other users who attempted that solution whom it didn't help which has the potential to add more noise to the diagnostics process for this particular bug.

As you say, not a firmaware expert, and i understand the frustration at the lack of explanation from system76 in 'Hidden as off-topic' for your comment, but it's not deleted, anyone who want to read it can click the 'expand' button and read it.

Sorry that fan at "0"rpm and the heat spike from that seems to have cooked off your RAM, that really hurts. I would expect that system76 should honor the full extent of the warranty that came with your purchase, if that includes the RAM it would be simply inconvenient, not inconvenient and costly.

That has happened to me, not from this kind of firmware driven failure, but lots of time pushing systems to the limit of design has given me maybe too much experience with 'little puffs of blue smoke.'

If it's of any relevance, my experience going back 20+ years at this point makes me almost exclusively purchase Kingston RAM. Simply because I have had them honor a no-questions lifetime warranty for sticks of RAM. Even recovered from eWaste, physically damaged, off the floor. If it has the KVM number legible, I've had replacement sticks shipped to me for the cost of postage. Once even had them offer an option to upgrade from DDR to DDR2 as they didn't actually have much DDR "1" in stock, and it was better for me also at the time.

It makes me purchase new systems with a minimum of RAM installed, and then swap whatever brand it comes with for matched sets of Kingston after a basic functionality test on arrival.

I keep the original as fail-back for warranty / service.

Hope your new RAM is performant, and hope the udev solves the issue until the firmware gets fixed.

← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →