HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

naiveai

114 karma · joined December 30, 2017

submissionscomments
naiveai··on India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet Giants
So compelling, with a dictator, closed-off information and all. So utterly compelling.
naiveai··on India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet Giants
This whole thing is such a phenomenally stupid idea in nearly every way. Foreign companies have had longer to develop and are superior in nearly every single way. Why supress them? The data protection laws are a good idea, though I suspect corruption and surveillance, which the Indian gov wants to keep, will largely nullify any and all benefits of such laws.
naiveai··on If Google bows to China’s censorship, it will put tech giant on a slippery slope
China is an authoritarian state. China isn't going to bow down to Google. The honorable, and the correct, thing for Google to do is not operate in China, but of course they aren't going to do that.
naiveai··on China is laying the groundwork for a post-American world order
Yes, and Xi Jinping is a good candidate for that leadership. Just because, oh, new leadership.
naiveai··on A Pamphlet against R: Computational Intelligence in Guile Scheme (2016)
First class functions does not a functional language make.
naiveai··on Hello, GitHub
Wow, a bunch of words, with no real promises worth a damn. I'm so impressed.
naiveai··on Microsoft Is Said to Have Agreed to Acquire GitHub
You've got a point there. I'm just so sick of all this. The Internet's a great thing, but it just seems to be going downhill with corporate interests.
naiveai··on Microsoft Is Said to Have Agreed to Acquire GitHub
That's really what I meant by efficiency. Ease of use increases that for businesses, that's the only reason they really care about ease of use of products they want to buy.
naiveai··on GitLab sees huge spike in project imports
Google has done a lot of shit before, but I sure as hell trust them more than Microsoft at the moment when it comes to acquisitions.
naiveai··on Microsoft Is Said to Have Agreed to Acquire GitHub
The whole world's demanding it. No one really knows how to do it efficiently, it seems.
naiveai··on Bringing people back to the open web
Didn't really work either though. Trolls gonna troll no matter what.
naiveai··on Sex Workers Say Porn on Google Drive Is Suddenly Disappearing
Why is this happening? I see the argumnent that these organizations are private companies and can do whatever they see fit, including censorship, I see no reason why these should not be opposed on principle. Global expression of ideas should not be controlled by any one jurisdiction or board of directors.

When will we ever find a solution? Decentralisation is fun to talk about but almost impossible to accomplish in practice. So how do we create a compromise scenario that protects the free spread of ideas? I have no idea. I am so sick of all this.

naiveai··on With SESTA/FOSTA, lawmakers failed to separate good intentions from bad law
You're conflating the tech industry (what's with the constant air quotes) with the kind of people who are concerned about these laws and the effects of the dangerous precendent they set.

>People in "tech" overall does not want to study other subjects than computer science

People in a field are fans of that field and want to study it deeply? Surprises me for sure.

naiveai··on With SESTA/FOSTA, lawmakers failed to separate good intentions from bad law
So what you're saying is a vastly less rich and organized populace was never able to communicate their arguments in a concentrated enough manner so that Congress would care? Who would've thought.

This argument is stupid. The fundamental freedoms that the internet provide to the global community are too important to be taken away by old lawmakers with no understanding of the way Cyberspace works.

naiveai··on EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content, including code
Definitely agree here. The EU in general is a good idea in terms of diplomacy, but it really shouldn't have this much power.
naiveai··on EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content, including code
https://www.eff.org/cyberspace-independence
naiveai··on The Rubik's Contraption
Dude, it's a robot. And the very fact that they were able to do this, regardless, is amazing.
naiveai··on Lawmakers Want to Block Pornography at the Expense of Free Speech and Privacy
Wow, they're being so goddamn vague with it as well in order to mislead people. "Protecting children" my fucking arse.
naiveai··on Escaping Hell with Monads (2017)
Personally, I feel the reason we think of these as completely different problems is that it isn't necessarily natural to see the abstraction between all of them. I don't understand monads fully myself, but it's still kind of missing the point to say this.
naiveai··on China's Xinjiang surveillance is the dystopian future nobody wants
> To keep the billion people who live in China safe from civil war and rampant terrorism is already a great achievement -- even it comes at the expense of some nice things such as human rights.

Some nice things? Nice things??? What the actual lord upon almighty.

naiveai··on Are Monads a Waste of Time?
People often attribute this to careful language design - and to be completely honest, I can't say anything about that since I'm just some kid, but I feel like that doesn't make the BDFL immune to criticism. TCO, for example, would change almost nothing that already exists in the language, and would make it faster in at least some cases. As evidenced by Coconut, and in fact the number of libraries that smack TCO onto Python, albeit in a very inelegant way.

And sometimes it seems he intentionally cripples certain features so he can "prove" that certain ways of programming are bad.

> filter(P, S) is almost always written clearer as [x for x in S if P(x)], and this has the huge advantage that the most common usages involve predicates that are comparisons, for example, x==42, and defining a lambda for that just requires much more effort for the reader (plus the lambda is slower than the list comprehension)

(Quoted from https://www.artima.com/weblogs/viewpost.jsp?thread=98196)

If he had made lambdas even a little bit easier to write, then this criticism is completely blown out the window.

I'm not saying that FP is the holy grail and all must bow down to the ivory tower. But it disturbs me that the BDFL seems to be waaayyyyyyy to cautious about adding useful features to the language because Python Is Not A Functional Language.

naiveai··on Are Monads a Waste of Time?
I've been waiting for this for a very, very long time. I've not learned Haskell yet but generally speaking I'm very fond of FP in all languages, including Python.

However, the BDFL has arbitrarily decided that Python shouldn't even have remotely easy-to-use FP semantics (even though Python being so multi-paradigm is often touted as a major advantage), so (as an example) while he gave up on trying to remove `lambda`, he didn't make it simpler and more useful, which makes it so that whenever someone runs into it as a beginner they say, "Oh, what a stupid little thing that I can replace easily, FP is stupid." [1] I've been very upset generally speaking at how much control the BDFL is taking - not necessarily directly, but indirectly through people who seem to think that Pythonic™ programming is literally God and anyone who doesn't do Pythonic is Bad.

[1] https://stackoverflow.com/questions/890128/why-are-python-la...

naiveai··on Countries with more gender equality have fewer female STEM grads
Not only that, but he dryly calls commercial computer science a "symbol manipulation" job, which I find frankly extremely insulting and unnecessary to drive his point.
naiveai··on Facebooks crawls every page recorded by its tracking pixel
Even according to that document, idempotent methods still can update resources as long as the representation doesn't change:

> Again, this only applies to the result, not the resource itself. This still can be manipulated (like an update-timestamp, provided this information is not shared in the (current) resource representation.

This means that tracking is still could potentially affect some stuff, but honestly not by much.

naiveai··on GitHub down
Back up now!
naiveai··on GitHub down
That's kind of missing the point, everyone's git local clones are still there, I can still work on the code. Git's decentralisation is meant to make sure work doesn't stop altogether when the remote is down.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2