HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

najirama

262 karma · joined March 2, 2008

submissionscomments
najirama··on The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupid's Conclusions
[Edit: spelling mistakes]

Based on your response, you do not even understand the terms I've been using.

'Set of classes,' means everything per this discussion - as the discussion has been premised on the statement you made (that skin color is an indicator of class).

So when you say things like...:

"If you're trying to predict someone's behavior, distinguishing someone who makes $59,999 from someone who makes $60,000 makes no sense."

..You suggest that you either do not understand my argument, or, you do not understand what has been meant by the word "class" in this discussion.

So I'll say it again; Classes are defined by an interval on the set of natural numbers. This isn't a discussion about guessing incomes with any greater precision than those provided to us by said classes.

The data provided to us by the census bureau document is the average. Note that the "households" in the census include BOTH family and non-family households.

So, when you say things like...:

"The poverty threshold for a family of four is $22,025. Black households have a "surplus" income of $12,193. White households have a surplus income of $33,505."

...You hint that you didn't quite understand that the average provided was calculated including single-households as well as non-single households with kids. So your whole reply is a bit of a straw-man...

...But it isn't even really a good one. We are talking about race as a predictor so let us control for income and work backwards. Imagine two families, one black, the other white, both living with an income of $34,218, both with four children. Is it then your contention that the Black family is still more likely to produce a thief?

If so, I do consider your mind boggled.

najirama··on The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupid's Conclusions
[Edit: Moved up a node to reflect the actual reply]

1. Socio-econonic classes are artificial constructs - so what? The point is that race is demonstrably unable to map the set of 'people' to the set of 'classes.'

2. If you are not able to accurately quote the figures from the pdf I linked to prior, then what is the likelyhood you even read it?

The ACTUAL median incomes can be found on pages 6-7:

Asian: $65,637

White, non-Hispanic: $55,530

Average: $50,000

Black: $34,218

The differences fall in the interval known as middle-class as I said before - so for the purposes of this discussion, they are not substantial.

najirama··on The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupid's Conclusions
Both of those links engender the proposition that fingernail length is indeed NOT a good indicator of class.

The class status of women as a whole rose significantly in the 80's as women's pay relative to men's rose from 1980 to 1990 (from 60.2% to 71.6%):

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/03/nyregion/03women.html?ex=1...

najirama··on The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupid's Conclusions
You continue to shift terms, so it makes it more difficult to pin you down.

My math is pretty solid - socio-economic classes are defined by values in intervals. So guessing the average income for each race would be guessing what interval? It would be guessing middle class for each race! Remember, you stated the proposition that, 'race is a good class indicator' - thus, we don't care about variance in the interval called middle class...

That is why I explicitly removed it from my analysis - if the only information(class-related) you get from a person's skin color is that they are middle-class, then you have effectively received no information. Certainly you can't be suggesting that those in the middle-class are more likely to commit crimes - can you be?

najirama··on The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupid's Conclusions
Even if I were to allow that the discussion be gender-biased, I'm afraid this wouldn't be accurate...

The very poor tend to have poor grooming habits, both in frequency and quality. As such, access to nail clippers is extremely limited...

Further, the nature of living in extreme poverty forbids the biting of one's nails; you would be shocked at the amount of dirt and grime that gathers there after just a few days without access to a bathroom or running water.

najirama··on The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupid's Conclusions
A "good" predictor must be useful, correct? Well, then how can it be useful if it is wrong more than it is right....?

Simply stated, being right more than one is wrong is the same thing as being more accurate than a random assignment (as we approach a large number of "trials") if the outcomes are equally likely. And that is the point - race tells you nothing more significant about class then guessing does (if we remove 'middle class' as a selection), and class tells you nothing significant about behavior.

Also, you seem to be conflating 'class' and 'culture' now. Culture is a much, much better indicator of behavior than class, as culture speaks to beliefs and value judgements. As such, they are not interchangable ideas (that is, the propostion that 'Skin color is a good predictor of culture' is not the same as the one you made prior, 'Skin color is a good predictor of class' - but is probably just as fallacious).

Clothing and hair (God only knows what you meant by 'accent.' Care to clarify?) in isolation are strong enough indicators of culture, that race quite literally adds nothing to their accuracy - the same can be said of 'style of dress' and 'price of car driven,' for class. Race is superfluous.

najirama··on The Black Damsel In Dating Distress: A Response to OkCupid's Conclusions
Skin color isn't any more an indicator of class than shoe size or fingernail length. To show this, one need only think about the consequences of skin color actually being an indicator of class.

Given a random sampling among a race, if skin color was an accurate indicator of class, you should be able to predict the same class (other than middle class) for each sample, and ultimately be right more than you were wrong. But you can't: http://www.census.gov/prod/2009pubs/p60-236.pdf

Furthermore, I posit that class isn't even a predictor of behavior in the macro-sense. That is, across all classes the proportion of people who behave foolishly, is a constant. The difference money makes is in the degree of associated risk with the behaviors that occur, not in the number of occurrences of the behaviors themselves.

najirama··on You've changed the world - now what next?
Ok - I guess then the question is HOW do I publish the darn thing?

A radical example for clarification: Say you discover a method by which the HIV virus can be detected one day after transmission with 99% confidence...and you live in a homeless shelter. While an exaggeration, this example shows(hopefully) that there is an initial resistance when an idea comes from an unlikely source. What method of publication best overcomes this resistance?

najirama··on You've changed the world - now what next?
Im interested as to where the question contradicts itself(?) In any case, the "perceived noise" question 1 alludes to is precisely the noise coming from the internet; that is, the internet makes it much easier for dabblers from all over to overstate claims. Oddly, it is this same noise that made me come to the internet in search of clever way to announce - an odd duality...
najirama··on You've changed the world - now what next?
That is all well and good, but it doesn't answer either question given the suppositions.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2