HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nate_meurer

4,659 karma · joined August 5, 2009

submissionscomments
nate_meurer··on Alabama man dies after being turned away from 43 hospitals as Covid packs ICUs
If you actually find it odd that any vaccine isn't one hundred percent effective, that says a lot about your level of understanding of immunology.
nate_meurer··on Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016)
It's the supposed benefits of the post-combustion lead oxide deposits that defenders of leaded gas cite. I have never heard anyone cite the lubricity of TEL itself.

The most popular theory is that the lead oxide fouling reduces the occurence or effects of micro-welds between valve and seat surfaces, which otherwise produce abrasive particles that contribute to valve seat recession. While this theory is plausible, it has not been shown to occur under normal operating conditions in automotive engines, nor in aviation engines as far as I know.

The final report from the EPA's Valve Seat Recession Working Group found no evidence that leaded gas reduces engine wear under any but the most extreme operating conditions:

https://archive.epa.gov/international/air/web/pdf/vsr-finald...

"In real world conditions, virtually no evidence of excessive valve wear has been found in vehicle or engine operation in normal everyday use, and several studies that monitored vehicles in actual daily service in countries that eliminated lead found no excessive valve wear."

nate_meurer··on Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016)
Aircraft piston engine makers like Lycoming and TCM have never provided any actual evidence that unleaded avgas increases engine wear. Their assertions that leaded gas provides lubrication are anecdotal and borderline superstitious. TCM pretty much admits this in its literature:

"Field experience has determined the use of unleaded automotive gasoline to be the cause of premature cylinder replacement due primarily to rapid and severe valve seat recession." [1]

They don't ever present evidence from controlled testing that backs up their "field experience". And controlled testing of automotive engines has shown that leaded fuels don't provide any significant protection. [2]

Twenty years ago, aviation writer John Deakin issued a challenge for anyone to provide good evidence that leaded avgas prevents engine wear [3]. As far as I know that challenge was never met .

1 - https://web.archive.org/web/20171004135916/https://pceonline...

2 - https://archive.epa.gov/international/air/web/pdf/vsr-finald...

3 - https://www.avweb.com/features/pelicans-perch-55lead-in-the-...

nate_meurer··on Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016)
Wow, I didn't know that. The engine in my favorite airplane (Fairchild P-47) had 36 spark plugs. That's a hell of a maintenance requirement.
nate_meurer··on Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016)
Hardened valve seats are useful in racing engines and diesels, but car makers stopped using them in gasoline-fueled road cars simply because they weren't worth the cost regardless of whether the fuel was leaded. Reports of excessive valve seat recession after the phaseout of TEL were all anecdotal, and for every mechanic who swears there was a a rash of worn seats, there are others who say there wasn't.

The theory that leaded gas prevents micro-weld induced valve abrasion has not been verified in controlled tests. The final report from the EPA's Valve Seat Recession Working Group found no evidence that leaded gas reduces engine wear under any but the most extreme operating conditions:

https://archive.epa.gov/international/air/web/pdf/vsr-finald...

"In real world conditions, virtually no evidence of excessive valve wear has been found in vehicle or engine operation in normal everyday use, and several studies that monitored vehicles in actual daily service in countries that eliminated lead found no excessive valve wear."

nate_meurer··on Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016)
This is a myth. Lead has no lubricative value in engines, and in fact causes damage. From https://www.shell.com/business-customers/aviation/aeroshell/...:

"The temperature for Lead deposits to form tend to be favourable around the spark plugs (as the whole mixture is quite cool before the flame starts to propagate) and on the exhaust valve stem (as the mixture cools after combustion). The problem is that the deposits are electrically conductive, which shorts out the spark plug - and corrosive, which can start to attack the metal of the valve stems."

nate_meurer··on Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016)
No, this is a myth. In reality, lead fouling decreases engine performance and longevity. From https://www.shell.com/business-customers/aviation/aeroshell/...:

"The temperature for Lead deposits to form tend to be favourable around the spark plugs (as the whole mixture is quite cool before the flame starts to propagate) and on the exhaust valve stem (as the mixture cools after combustion). The problem is that the deposits are electrically conductive, which shorts out the spark plug - and corrosive, which can start to attack the metal of the valve stems."

nate_meurer··on Leaded gas was a known poison the day it was invented (2016)
> TEL also acts as a natural lubricant of its own, the lead acting as lubricant, particularly on valve and other top end engine components.

This is a myth. TEL has no lubricative properties in engines. The reality is opposite; lead deposits are corrosive. From https://www.shell.com/business-customers/aviation/aeroshell/...:

"The temperature for Lead deposits to form tend to be favourable around the spark plugs (as the whole mixture is quite cool before the flame starts to propagate) and on the exhaust valve stem (as the mixture cools after combustion). The problem is that the deposits are electrically conductive, which shorts out the spark plug - and corrosive, which can start to attack the metal of the valve stems."

nate_meurer··on How to properly load a dishwasher (2020)
I completely agree about the fragrances. I hate them, and I'm happy to hear that it's getting better.

> And EWG is one of the most competent, clear, and level-headed organizations working in this space. They provide scientifically supported, solid, and well-researched information in an easy to understand format.

Like I said, they do some good work, but they do some really shoddy, clickbaity stuff too, and this detergent link is a good example. You can tell it was written by people with no knowledge of chemistry.

> I don't think you are qualified to criticize them given what you wrote above.

Instead of an ad-hominim, are you able to defend the EWG's assertions? For example, can you explain why the EWG says a tiny amount of nitric acid used to adjust pH is a hazard of any kind? Can you explain why they think that any nitric acid could possibly survive in the finished alkaline product, or why it would be a problem even if it did? Can you find any studies or evidence of any kind to back them up?

How about the zinc? Or any of the others that I mentioned earlier?

Honestly this isn't difficult. It's not advanced chemistry. It's chemistry 101. EWG has no excuse for not knowing better.

nate_meurer··on How to properly load a dishwasher (2020)
> The way I look at it, chemicals which my ancestors have been exposed to for hundreds and thousands of years come with a lower risk than those which have just been synthesized and were not naturally occurring before the last century.

This clearly isn't true according to the EWG. They want you to believe that the tiny amount of zinc (which is an essential nutrient) that might be present in dishwasher detergent is poisonous enough to slap a big red warning on it. So which is it?

> I do smoke weed occasionally...

I'm all for cannabis, but I'm confused as to why someone who avoids household cleaning products is willing to put their lungs in such danger. It is well established that even occasional smoking increases your chances of lung and heart disease, and exposes you to a pantheon of toxins, including heavy metals and whatever pesticides are being used by growers in the still poorly regulated cannabis industry.

Seriously, whether you smoke or use edibles, you should be growing your own. Pesticides are a problem.

> but I think I take in less smoke than someone living with a campfire, something my ancestors have dealt with on many occasions.

Yes, and it was killing our ancestors, just as it's killing people now. Smoke pollution is a leading cause of disease, disability, and mortality across the world. It's true that your occasional smoke is probably less damaging than living with an open indoor cooking fire, but it's still doing significant damage, and it's a lot worse for your health than proper use of any cleaning product will ever be.

> I don't think fruits and veggies which have been consumed for centuries and millennia are that dangerous.

Why not? Why would you discount the danger of highly carcinogenic mycotoxins that have historically contaminated nuts, grains, and dried fruits, especially in the old days before industrial food production, and which likely killed a lot of our ancestors? And more importantly, why would you give more credence to the EWG's idiotic flagging of zinc in a cleaning product? This is a failure of risk evaluation.

nate_meurer··on How to properly load a dishwasher (2020)
I wouldn't call myself hopeful or optimistic in this regard. Quite the opposite, actually, I downright despair over the ways we've poisoned ourselves and our environment-- for example, with lead, mercury, asbestos, air pollution, and now PFAS chemicals. However I'm also realistic about evaluating risk, and I have just enough familiarity with the chemistry of everyday life to recognize where there is none.

> I choose to take to the overly cautious spectrum, because this is my body and the body of people close to me at stake, and I'd rather avoid unnecessary damage to them.

That being the case, I assume you'll be taking some other sensible precautions, which will prevent exposure to substances that are at least as risky as dishwasher detergent:

- Cut coffee out of your diet (due to acrylamide, a suspected carcinogen)

- Cut all meat out of your diet (especially red meat)

- Avoid citrus fruits, mints, and other herbs that contain limonene, which some researcher said causes cancer in rats.

- Avoid bread, beer, dried fruits and nuts (acrylamide)

- To avoid nitrates, you'll want to avoid high-nitrate foods such as arugula, beets, cabbage, celery, cilantro, endive, fennel, kale, lettuce, parsley, rhubarb, spinach, and many others. Actually, it's probably best to avoid vegetables altogether in the Spring and Summer when nitrate levels tend to be highest.

- Avoid cell phones and wifi

- And for god's sake, don't smoke anything!

This is just the stuff I can think of right now. I'm sure there's a lot more.

nate_meurer··on How to properly load a dishwasher (2020)
Yeah, I really wish manufacturers would knock it off with the fragrances. I hate how smelly everything is, and I think some of it gives me headaches. Laundry detergent is the worst; it contaminates everything with cheap perfume. I use non-fragranced stuff whenever I can.

> with chlorine, you are ignoring the production process.

I think you're confusing the production of hypochlorite, which is among the cleanest and most benign of all industrial processes, with that of chlorinated materials like PVC, which is fed with and leaves behind a lot of super nasty shit. Look up the Hooker process, which is how all hypochlorite is currently made. The only byproduct is sodium chloride (common salt), which is also the degradation endpoint of hypochlorite in the environment. I think you'll be pleasantly surprised at how clean and sustainable this particular corner of industry is.

Did you know that chlorine bleach (such as Clorox) has a shelf life for this reason? It's because hypochlorite is unstable, and eventually that bottle of Clorox will become a bottle of plain salt water.

> with the others your argument seems to be, "it is status quo, so it is ok."

Not at all. What I'm saying is that dishwasher detergent is one of the cleanest, most harmless (to us and the environment) cleaning products we use. It's actually kind of a miraculous substance; it allows a simple machine to perform the hardest household cleaning job reliably and quickly using very little water or energy. It manages to this with no surfactants (such as phosphates, which actually are environmentally damaging) and no volatile grease cutters. The grease is removed only with alkaline minerals, and protein deposits are removed enzymatically.

By drumming up a bunch of implausible and in some cases completely fictitious hazards, the EWG is doing a disservice to one of the most environmentally responsible cleaning products in use. For some reason the zinc thing especially pisses me off. That's so stupid. Pretending that zinc, a mineral that is ubiquitous in food and is essential to human health, is somehow a hazard in dishwasher detergent which is rinsed off anyway... this is basically a lie, and that alone should make you very skeptical of anything else they say.

Anyways, again, I appreciate the fact that you care about this stuff. I imagine you and I would mostly agree about environmental topics in particular.

nate_meurer··on How to properly load a dishwasher (2020)
I appreciate people like you who care about the effects of the products we buy on ourselves and the environment. I do too. But while the EWG does some OK work, they also do a lot of fearmongering, and you can plainly see it in this link. Look at the three big scary red "F" items.

The first scary red "F" is sodium hypochlorite. This is ordinary bleach. EWG cites two reasons for the big scary "F". The first is aquatic toxicity. This is a badly misplaced fear. Consider the fact that chlorine is the most widely used disinfectant in municipal water systems, in the form of hypochlorite and chloramine. Chlorine is dumped by the ton into the water that comes out of your taps and goes down your drains. The extra chlorine from dish detergents is insignificant compared to this and other sources such as laundry bleach.

Also under the chlorine entry, EWG lists a few organic chlorine compounds. This is very misleading. Detergents don't contain any of these chemicals. Rather, they can possibly be generated when free chlorine is added to water containing a lot of organics. Many organohalogens are indeed toxic, but by far most of them that you'll encounter are generated by municipal water treatment systems. You drink and bathe in water that contains random organohalogens every day, by virtue of the chlorine used in municipal treatment. The small extra quantities generated in your dishwasher aren't a threat to you unless you make it a habit to drink the exhaust water.

The second scary red "F" on their list is zinc carbonate. This is absurd. They say it's primarily because of its potential effects on aquatic life, which I suppose might be a consideration if someone tries to use dishwasher detergent to clean a fish tank. The second reason is "general systemic/organ effects". This is the really absurd part. Zinc is an essential mineral in the human diet in large quantities. In very high doses over time, excess zinc can cause problems, but such large doses have nothing to do with dishwasher detergent residues. You'd have to actually eat large quantities of detergent daily for a long period of time, and even that would be unlikely to cause zinc overdose because the carbonate form has low bioavailability.

The third scary red "F" is "colors". They don't say what the colors are, or why they would be more of a concern than in any other cosmetic or cleaning product.

The fourth scary red "F" is "stabilizer". They don't say what the chemical is, so there's no way to know whether it's any less bullshit than the first three, or even if it exists in the product.

The scary orange "D" items continue the absurdity:

- Nitric acid: I think EWG is confused here. Nitric acid would be used only in minute quantities to adjust pH. Dishwasher detergents are very alkaline, so it's not possible for nitric acid to remain in a liquid product.

- Fragrance: Welcome to life. Everything is scented. I hate it, but putting a scary orange "D" next to it should make you roll your eyes in light of the other fragrances that saturate thousands of other products that don't get rinsed away, and thus stay in the air around you.

- Polyacrylates: you know where else you'll find polyacrylates? Fucking everywhere. Nearly every liquid cosmetic product you'll find uses polyacrylates. Shampoos, hand soap, dish soap, etc. All baby diapers are now filled with polyacrylates. They're added to potting soil to increase moisture retention. Don't eat too much of the solid form because it can expand in your stomach and cause bloating and possibly blockage, but tiny amounts of them are not the least bit threatening in your dishwasher.

In summary, don't blindly trust the EWG. None of these ingredients is the least bit dangerous even if they remained in significant quantities on your dishes, which they don't.

nate_meurer··on How to properly load a dishwasher (2020)
What gnarly chemicals?
nate_meurer··on How to properly load a dishwasher (2020)
Yes. It took me a year to figure out why my Bosch sporadically left loads of dishes dirty. It turned out that some of our smaller square dishes are able to poke down through the rack far enough to stop the lower wash arm.
nate_meurer··on What the Heck Happened to Rollerblading? (2017)
Do yourself a favor and wear wrist guards when you skate or snowboard. A fall on an outstretched hand (FOOSH) can easily rupture your scapholunate ligament. This is an injury that often cannot be repaired, and eventually leads to arthritic degeneration called scapholunate advanced collapse (SLAC). The standard of care for SLAC currently involves fusing the wrist bones, which of course means you can't no longer move your wrist. So wear your wrist guards!
nate_meurer··on The Australian federal government is planning to de-anonymize the internet
You've cherry picked an outlier. How many non-crazy conservative pundits or politicians can you name who opposed the Patriot Act, or the formation of Homeland Security, or the expanded powers given to cops and federal agencies? How many prominent conservatives spoke out in defense of Edward Snowden? Was it conservatives or liberals in the media who risked their lives and careers to organize and document the information he released?

During the Bush era, the opposition to the authoritarian trajectory of the war on terror was largely from liberals, although it was often strictly partisan. Conservative media completely fell in line with the Bush administration. I thought this would change when Obama was elected, but it didn't, and authoritarianism remained a driving force in conservative politics and media throughout Trump's presidency.

COVID-19 has brought some more conservatives onto the anti-authoritarian side for sure. But I'm not confident this is a durable change.

nate_meurer··on Japan finds stainless steel particles in suspended doses of Moderna vaccine
Any air accidentally injected into a vein as part of a vaccination would be insufficient to cause injury. It takes tens or hundred of milliliters of air to cause a venous embolism in a typical person.

Covid vaccine syringes are 1 ml. It's impossible to inject enough air using one of these syringes to cause any sort of trouble.

nate_meurer··on Toxic ‘forever chemicals’ contaminate indoor air at worrying levels
Yeah but they use a lot of oil in those woks, and they get them really hot. Any Chinese street vendor with an open fire and cheap steel wok can do shit I can't dream of doing in my fancy ass American kitchen.
nate_meurer··on Toxic ‘forever chemicals’ contaminate indoor air at worrying levels
I don't think I'm lucky, but there is definitely a cost. The cost is that I'm a fucking asshole about my nonstick pots and pans. I keep my stash separate from the rest of the family, I get grumpy if I catch anyone using it, and god forbid anyone scratches my shit.

I buy separate stuff for my kids, and my wife has her own favorite pan.

Of course there's no need to be an asshole like me. But I think it's eminently doable for everyone. I do believe keeping the temperature down is key to longevity, especially for cheaper cookware with simpler two-layer nonstick coating systems. I have a lot of these too, and I just avoid going over 300 deg F or so. No problems so far.

nate_meurer··on Toxic ‘forever chemicals’ contaminate indoor air at worrying levels
> We’re so poisoned by these chemicals it’s impossible to run a study to figure out if one possible source of them specifically is measurably poisoning us.

Sort of. My point is that teflon cookware is not a plausible source of PFAS, because there is no detectable PFAS in finished cookware. Further, because there have been billions of pieces of nonstick cookware in use around the world for decades, if there were negative health effects we would probably notice them by now. But there aren't.

Contrast this to the lead that has been widely used in glass and ceramic cookware and dishes over the same period of time. Manufacturers claimed that lead bearing glazes were perfectly safe. This is false, but we don't need any "studies" to tell us that. Rather we've plainly seen tangible health effects from the use of these items in many medical reports over the years, and we can easily test and verify the presence of lead that is leached into foods that are cooked and served in them.

This is not the case with teflon cookware. There is no detectable PFAS in nonstick cookware, nor are there verifiable reports of health effects from its use, in spite of the millions or billions of such uses happening every day over decades.

> See sibling comments.

Which ones? The ones where I addressed the poorly substantiated risks of overheating?

> I try to avoid synthetic fabrics when I can, so in my case it’s not like your lifeguard scenario.

I guarantee you're not able to avoid PFAS-treated upholstery, carpeting, and other home furnishings. And depending on where you live, chances are good that you ingest significant amounts of PFAS in your drinking water. If you've ever eaten fast food, the wrapper it came in was probably coated in PFAS. Due to these and other sources, I guarantee you have measurable levels of PFAS in your blood and tissues.

So by all means, avoid nonstick cookware if you want. It won't hurt, and it may have value just because it makes you feel better. That's legit. But in terms of actual harm reduction it is very much like the theoretical lifeguard blacking out his windows.

nate_meurer··on Toxic ‘forever chemicals’ contaminate indoor air at worrying levels
Notice that the reports in your first link of PTFE coatings breaking down at less than 260 deg C are anecdotal. The lowest temperature at which PTFE coatings have been verified to give off breakdown products is 240 deg C. Even then, the only detected product was PTFE sublimate (small particles of PTFE flying off), which can lead to what we call "fume fever" if it's inhaled in large quantities, but reports of this happening in real life are rare, even in factory workers who are exposed at higher levels.

PTFE is chemically stable well past 300 deg C (540 deg F) and many nonstick cookware lines are marketed for these temperatures. For example, I have Calphalon pans labelled for use up to 550 deg F, which are advertised for searing steak. I get them pretty hot, and they show no signs of degradation.

At around 360 deg F (650 deg F), PTFE starts to give off detectable pyrolysis products, which are theoretically able to cause health problems, but even then reports of actual harm are few and far between. This is remarkable given that billions of pieces of nonstick cookware have been in use every day around the world for the past seventy years. Between the end users and the factory workers who make stuff, and all of the accidents and episodes of overheating that occur all the time, if there were going to be significant health effects I think they'd show up by now.

The real problem is the PFAS chemicals that are sprayed on our clothes, upholstery, carpeting and other home furnishings, that the military and civilian airports have dumped in our water supplies. This is a shaping up to be a true environmental catastrophe, and the manufacturers of nonstick coatings have no doubt contributed to this pollution. But the teflon cookware itself is not the slightest threat.

nate_meurer··on Toxic ‘forever chemicals’ contaminate indoor air at worrying levels
I agree. My favorite hat is oilcloth, and it's as waterproof as any fancy modern gear.
nate_meurer··on Toxic ‘forever chemicals’ contaminate indoor air at worrying levels
You were right to ask for a shield. I would do the same thing, and I'd be a little pissed that I had to ask.

However there's a big difference, in that the x-ray you got actually delivers a substantial amount of ionizing radiation-- up to one full percent of the average annual background dose. There is no evidence that even a lot of normal x-ray scans have any effect on health, but at least it's a physical possibility.

In contrast, the level of chemical hazard from nonstick cookware is a billionth or trillionth (or even smaller) than what's in the carpets we all grew up playing on, or the clothes we wear and furniture we sit on every day.

To use another analogy, worrying about nonstick cookware is like worrying about the ionizing radiation coming from a banana that's sitting uneaten across the room from you.

I agree about absestos, and I fee the same about lead as well. Those are nasty poisons that, contrary to popular lore, cannot be used and applied safely such that they won't eventually get loose and become a health hazard. I've been thinking about asbestos this week because I've been replacing ceiling light fixtures in my house, and it's impossible to do without causing the asbstos-filled popcorn texture to rain down like snow. It's fucking unbelievable what previous generations afflicted us with.

EDIT:

I feel compelled to repeat that common cooking fumes and smoke are known toxins and carcinogens. It makes no sense to be more concerned about tiny amounts of aerosolized PTFE than the far greater amounts of cooking smoke and fumes that will inevitably be emitted by your food at the same temperatures.

nate_meurer··on Toxic ‘forever chemicals’ contaminate indoor air at worrying levels
This is my experience as well. I also use a lot of slowly sauteed garlic, like pretty much every day, and I'm completely reliant on a small nonstick pot to do it without sticking and burning.

Scrambled eggs too, especially the soft-scrambled kind ala Gordon Ramsay's famous short video. They simply wipe out of nonstick pan, and I've never seen this work with any other kind of cookware.

nate_meurer··on Toxic ‘forever chemicals’ contaminate indoor air at worrying levels
I agree, I love vintage cookware. My favorite pans are a bunch of All-Clad LTD's I assembled from Ebay over the years. I use them for omelettes and french toast. Super thick aluminum clad with a stainless cooking surface, made sometime in the 1980s. They're as tough as cast iron, but they heat way more evenly, they're much lighter, and you don't have to worry about hurting the seasoning.

With cast iron, you can easily destroy the seasoning by overheating the pan, or if your mother who doesn't know how to care for cast iron puts it in the dishwasher. I put my All-Clads in the sink and scrub them with a steel tuffy. They're probably the most indestructable tools I own.

nate_meurer··on Toxic ‘forever chemicals’ contaminate indoor air at worrying levels
Wool is badass. How do you feel about the extra weight?
nate_meurer··on Toxic ‘forever chemicals’ contaminate indoor air at worrying levels
> "Did any birds die?" is an approach to this problem that I would expect from an undeveloped nation a hundred years ago. It is both excruciatingly short-term in focus and so imprecise that the results are useless for anyone who is not himself a rat or a canary.

I sort of agree, but birds do make a convenient study subject because they are exquisitely sensitive, much more so than humans.

The lowest temperature at which PTFE coatings have been seen to evolve breakdown products (that I know of) is 240 deg C. Even then, the only detected product was micro-size PTFE sublimate, which can lead to what we call "fume fever", but reports of this actually happening are rare, even in factory workers who are exposed at much higher levels.

The temperatures at which PTFE pyrolysis really starts to give off nasty shit are way higher [1], but even then, evidence of physiological harm is sketchy. Anecdotally, I know a few people, including my father, who have left a nonstick pan on the stove, got distracted, and burned the coating right the fuck off. Aside from the smell, no ill effects were observed. This isn't scientific at all, but if burning PTFE is that toxic, one might have expected some effects.

> It does not answer the question, "What are the long-term effects on humans of short excursions outside of normal cooking temperatures?"

This is true, but undertaking such a study would be both impossible and pointless, because we are exposed to millions or billions of times more fluorinated compounds from clothing, furniture, and carepeting, than we could evey hope to get from nonstick cookware, even if you overheat it regularly.

Keep in mind that billions of pieces of nonstick cookware have been in use every day around the world for the past seventy years. And all time, factory workers have been exposed to the manufacturing process. That's plenty of time for problems to have been observed on some level, but they just haven't. The problems we're seeing come from the billion-fold higher levels of PFC we get from other sources.

To repeat an analogy from an earlier comment, worrying about nonstick cookware is sort of like a lifeguard who works in the sun all day, but obsessively blacks out the windows in his home because he's worried about UV radiation getting in his house. It makes no sense.

1 - https://sci-hub.st/10.1289/ehp.7511197 - Waritz, R. S. (1975). An industrial approach to evaluation of pyrolysis and combustion hazards. Environmental Health Perspectives

nate_meurer··on Toxic ‘forever chemicals’ contaminate indoor air at worrying levels
No, we have lots of long term information about nonstick cookware. People forget we've been using teflon cookware since the 1950's. There have been billions of pieces of nonstick cookware in use every day around the world for decades.

The problem is that because there are so many free PFAS chemicals around us from other sources, studying the possible effects of cookware is a bit like studying whether it contains evil spirits. You won't be able to come up with a falsifiable hypothesis, because our PFC exposure via other routes is so high.

Another reason long term studies aren't viable is that there is no plausible mechanism of action of toxicity from nonstick cookware under the sort of use that it almost always gets. Unless it's badly overheated, PTFE is completely stable in inert.

Think about this logically: if you handle a water resistant jacket and then eat a sandwich, you'll ingest measureable quanities of PFAS. Every time kids or babies play on a stain-resistant carpetting and furniture, then ingest far greater quantities from their hands and toys.

In contrast, any PFAS that remains in nonstick cookware would be on the edge of detectability. PFAS surfactants are used in the manufacture of the coatings, but it boils off when the coating is baked on, and as far as I know, no detectable PFAS has ever been verified in finished cookware. Even when agressively overheated, nonstick cookware doesn't emit PFAS. It sublimates micro-size PTFA particles, which can lead to what we call "fume fever" but reports of this actually happening are rare, even in factory workers who are exposed at much higher levels than a home cook is.

So put these two things together: you are likely ingesting millions of times more PFAS from your clothes, carpets, and furniture than you ever could from nonstick cookware.

Worrying about nonstick cookware is sort of like a lifeguard who works in the sun all day, but obsessively blacks out the windows in his home because he's worried about UV radiation getting in his house. It makes no sense.

nate_meurer··on Toxic ‘forever chemicals’ contaminate indoor air at worrying levels
> Do you know anyone who measures the temp of the surface of their cookware?

Yes, I do. I have a cheap IR thermometer with my kitchen utensils, and I use it all the time. I use it every time I roast seeds and spices, because I'm picky that way. I've also used it when I've accidentally left a pan on the burner too long. I'm careful but I screw up now and then. I accidentally heated a stainless pan to nearly 500 deg F once, but 've never gotten a nonstick pan over about 400 deg F.

> Teflon and nonstick coatings kill birds (house pets) when overheated. A nonstick pan in the oven to catch the drippings from your chicken baking at 400 or 425 can kill your parrot quickly. A nonstick wok left unattended for a few minutes during a high-heat stir fry easily reaches 400, enough to kill your cockatiel.

Stories of such low temperatures killing birds are anecdotal. The lowest temperature that has lead to bird deaths in a controlled laboratory setting is 280 deg C, which is about 580 deg F. [1]

Keep in mind that birds are easily killed by common cooking smoke and fumes, as well as natural gas. The problem with these anecdotes is that it's likely there were other fumes involved, and there's no way to know what actually kills a bird oustide a controlled lab setting.

> And as another poster has noted, those coatings always start flaking off.

As I noted in another comment, it's not hard to keep a nonstick pan indefinitely. I have a lot of ten and fifteen year old nonstick pans that are as good as the day I bought them. My daily drivers are about five years old now, good as new. I'm careful not to overheat them and I never use metal utensils in them. Following those two rules, even my kids were able to use them without damaging them.

> Why buy something that produces fumes enough to kill your house pets and also has planned obsolescence built in when you can get a cast iron pan that's indestructible and will increase your iron intake a bit?

If you overheat that cast iron pan, or if you burn food in it, it will kill birds just as easily as a nonstick pan. Also note, there is vastly more evidence of harm from excess iron consumption than there is of harm from overheated PTFE coatings.

That said, I like steel and iron pans. I regularly use enameled steel pans for toasting spices, and I cook crepes and pancakes on steel pans. I don't use cast iron for much because it's heavy as shit and its heat distribution sucks.

I've actually had good luck with seasoned bare aluminum pans. This is more common in some restaurant kitchens, but not so much in home kitchens. Aluminum seasons just as well as iron, and the heat distribution is way way better. But for some reason "cast aluminum" doesn't have quite the same old-timey panache as does cast iron.

← PreviousPage 9 of 34Next →