HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nate_meurer

4,659 karma · joined August 5, 2009

submissionscomments
nate_meurer··on Toxic ‘forever chemicals’ contaminate indoor air at worrying levels
> Breakdown begins to occur at either 200 or 260 degrees Celsius (depending on what data you're looking at).

This isn't good data. The stories of PTFE coatings breaking down at less than 260 deg C are anecdotal. The most well known one comes from someone who swears their chickens were killed by coated light bulbs in a coop.

The lowest temperature that has lead to bird deaths in a controlled laboratory setting is 280 deg C, which is about 580 deg F. [1] This is way freaking hot, and likely only to be reached by accident.

Even in the case of accidental overheating of non-stick cookware, there have been only a few verifiable cases of injury, and certainly no fatalities. Most cases of polymer fume fever have been gleened from among workers in factories, which is remarkable considering that billions of pieces of nonstick cookware have been in use every day around the world for the past seventy years.

Also note that cooking fumes from food are themselves toxic, and kill birds and lead to long term respiratory issues in humans much more easily than PTFE coatings.

1 - https://sci-hub.st/10.1289/ehp.7511197 - An Industrial Approach to Evaluation of Pyrolysis and Combustion Hazards

nate_meurer··on Toxic ‘forever chemicals’ contaminate indoor air at worrying levels
I have many pieces of well-used nonstick cookware well over a decade old, which are in pretty much the same condition as when I bought them. This includes cheap IKEA pans that my kids used. Some of them get used literally every day. We don't overheat them, and don't use metal utensils in them, and there's no reason they can't last forever.

Regardless, you can eat the entire coating off of your pan, and there will be no detectable fluorinated compounds in your blood. PTFE is completely inert and indigestible. It is widely used in medical implants inside people's bodies, with no detectable leaching of any chemicals.

nate_meurer··on Toxic ‘forever chemicals’ contaminate indoor air at worrying levels
No, fire retardants used in furniture are not based on PFAS chemicals. Fire retardants are almost exclusively BPDE's:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polybrominated_diphenyl_ethers

PFAS chemicals are used in fire suppression foam at airports and by the military, but that's a different (but still huge) problem.

nate_meurer··on Toxic ‘forever chemicals’ contaminate indoor air at worrying levels
Wicking materials don't use PFAS (although see edit below). The properties that PFAS endows a fabric are pretty much of the opposite of what you need for wicking. Wicking fabrics such as Capilene and polypropylene must be wettable in order to work. PFAS reduces the wettability of fibers. That's its whole point.

PFAS is used in nearly all current water resistant fabrics, including clothing, upholstery, and carpet. The industry calls these Durable Water Resistant (DWR) treatments.

PFAS-free treatments are only just recently hitting the market, but there are only a few so far and they're expensive. The North Face's Futurlight, Helly Hanson's Lifa are the only ones I know by name, but I've heard that Marmot and Mountain Hardware have some PFC-free garments as well.

EDIT:

I searched "PFAS wicking" and I see a some underwear makers are claiming their DWR treated products have enhanced wicking properties. This is confusing marketing. The DWR isn't actually enhacing the wicking. Rather, it's keeping the surface of the fabric that's next to the skin dry, while the untreated bulk of the fabric wicks moisture away. This is sort of like the thin perforated polyethylene membrane used in Band Aids to keep the would dry and prevent adhesion of the dressing.

Nevertheless, it appears we now have to be wary of forever chemicals in our underwear. Lame.

nate_meurer··on Toxic ‘forever chemicals’ contaminate indoor air at worrying levels
There are no mobile PFAS chemicals in nonstick cookware. Nonstick coatings are made from PTFE, which is a completely inert polymer that cannot be broken down into mobile components unless it's overheated. The fluorinated chemicals used in the manufacture of the coatings (largely surfactants) are completely removed when the coating is baked on, and they have to be or else the coating would fail.

PTFE is used in medical implants. You can eat it. In no case that I'm aware of have these things resulted in detectable fluorinated compounds in someone's blood stream.

nate_meurer··on Reddit r/engineering community has gone private
Even if it's not out of context, it's still just a moment of someone's life. Maybe they're normally an asshole, but maybe their just having a bad day, or they're drunk, or whatever, and their moment of foolishness is now enshrined in the most unforgiving way possible.

It's also crazy addictive. I can feel myself getting high on dopamine scrolling through, one hit of outrage after another.

I agree, this material is great for "engagement", but there's not much real value.

nate_meurer··on Unvaccinated teacher infected half her students with Covid, CDC finds
You're erecting a teeny tiny strawman here. I never said they don't reduce infection rates. I said they're designed and tested to prevent serious disease, not infection, and therefore transmission is expected to continue to a significant extent even after we achieve high rates of vaccination.

Please look up sterilizing immunity, and tell me how many common vaccines are known to induce it. I'll give you a hint: there's only one, and it isn't a covid vaccine.

This is a well known feature of vaccines, including the new covid vaccines, and this is supported by the available data, as you might notice from some of the articles that @belter cited earlier.

So I'll ask again, in what way was @belter wrong in your opinion?

nate_meurer··on Unvaccinated teacher infected half her students with Covid, CDC finds
Wrong in what way? It's true that the vaccines against covid don't provide durable sterilizing immunity, and they aren't expected to. In other words, the vaccines are not expected to prevent most people from getting infected, but rather only from getting seriously sick.

This is true of vaccines in general; vaccines are not expected to prevent infection, and almost none do. For example, flu vaccines don't keep you from from getting infected, and the virus is still able to spread even when vaccination rates are high. Rather, flu vaccines cause you to have less severe symptoms.

Vaccines are designed and tested to prevent disease in spite of infection. The current evidence indicates that the vaccines are doing a good job of preventing hospitalizations due to covid, and I wish the CDC would message this more clearly instead of fearmongering about "breakthrough" infections.

nate_meurer··on US special operations vets carry out daring mission to save Afghan allies
Nobody is suggesting they should have kept Bagram instead of Kabul. That would have been just as stupid. The facilities are very different, and they needed both. Here's Tyler Rogoway in the War Zone article I linked:

"Beyond shuttling people from Hamid Karzai International, helicopters could be used to pick up evacuees all over the country at unpredictable locales and they could then be flown out of Bagram."

Gen. Milley suggested that the only reason they gave up Bagram is lack of personnel. Biden apparently didn't want to send any extra troops, even temporarily. (Note that they were forced to send extra troops anyway after things went to shit).

nate_meurer··on Nuclear Regulatory Commission Flags Concerns at Georgia's Plant Vogtle Expansion
I think you're right about the technical advantages and feasibility of properly-done nuclear. I hope you're right about the rest too.
nate_meurer··on US special operations vets carry out daring mission to save Afghan allies
I forgot about that, wtf. One of the worst things about Trump is that he set the bar so very low-- like right on the fucking ground low-- that all the incompetents and evildoers to follow will end up looking not so bad in comparison. Expectations are right in the toilet for the forseeable future.
nate_meurer··on US special operations vets carry out daring mission to save Afghan allies
I can't exactly meet your challenge, but I think it's obvious that they should have kept Bagram and used it to stage the final retreat.

I have yet to hear an argument of any kind to support abandoning it. Biden simply said it didn't add any value, but he didn't support that assertion in any way, and no one else has tried as far as I know.

There are undoubtedly a hundred other things that a competent leadership would have done differently, but I suspect Bagram will be recorded as the biggest blunder.

Tyler Rogoway expounds on this much better than I can:

https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/42128/what-the-u-s-mil...

nate_meurer··on US special operations vets carry out daring mission to save Afghan allies
Yeah I don't know either. I'm really at a loss. It almost looks like sabotage.

The Blaze isn't typical reading material for me, but I'll note that the article you posted doesn't support the notion that the establishment hid the troop numbers from Trump just to make him look bad. Rather, they were desperate to protect our positions, our troops, and our allies in Syria and Western Iraq.

And Trump wouldn't have fired anyone. He's too much of a coward for that. He didn't fire Mattis. Mattis resigned, and then Trump tried to save face by claiming that he fired Mattis. Sort of the way a six year old might.

Biden doesn't have abject stupidity as an excuse. He smart, experienced, and not prone to recklessly disregarding the advice of his charges. And yet he fucked this up about as hard as something can be fucked.

nate_meurer··on US special operations vets carry out daring mission to save Afghan allies
Biden's been pretty tactless throughout this ordeal, but that's really not comparable to what Trump did. Biden blamed the Afghan security forces for surrendering without so much as a shot fired. This isn't an insult; it's just reality, and it's frustrating for everyone.

Trump's barely coherent babbling was an insult to the Syrian Kurds that had no purpose but to save face.

Keep in mind the Syrian Kurds are probably our best allies in the ME, with the possibly exception of the Israelis. And the Kurds are, as warriors, about as far as you can get from the Afghan regular army and police. They fight ferociously. They have no natural allies in the region, only lethal enemies. They have no nation, so a lot of them wear the American flag into battle.

Trump yanked support with no warning and left them to be killed by the Turks. No thanks, no attempt at evac, no thought toward organized retreat or security. Just insults.

Biden fucked up, but at least our military is scrambling to evac as many of our allies as possible. Trump would have pulled out just as recklessly as he did before, but Stephen Miller made it clear that Trump wouldn't even try to evac our Afghan allies.

Sorry for the rant. I'm pissed at everyone right now.

nate_meurer··on Nuclear Regulatory Commission Flags Concerns at Georgia's Plant Vogtle Expansion
And yet, again, the U.S. doesn't appear to have the ability to do what you say.

Vogtle is as close to a standardized design as the U.S. has ever tried to build. It was supposed to be a template for future drop-in Westinghouse AP1000 units.

Thirty billion dollars for a single power plant. I don't pretend to know why we suck at nuclear, but I don't think it's a stretch to say that Vogtle is the final nail in the coffin of American nuclear power generation.

I agree with you on the advantages of nuclear, but this is our reality in the U.S.

BTW, we will never solve the nuclear waste disposal problem in the US. We can't even get the nimby's to let us build enough housing for all of us.

nate_meurer··on Nuclear Regulatory Commission Flags Concerns at Georgia's Plant Vogtle Expansion
And yet, the only remaining nuclear power plant under construction in the US is going to cost nearly 30 billion dollars, which unfortunately may ensure that this will be the last commercial nuclear power plant we ever build here

Regardless of the theoretical advantages of nuclear power, in practice we haven't found a way to make it cost effective going forward.

nate_meurer··on US special operations vets carry out daring mission to save Afghan allies
Yes. The worst, most damaging sort of retreat is a disorderly retreat:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rout

The US forced itself into a disorderly retreat, where our troops are trapped in a small urban airport surrounded by the enemy. The perimeter is barely defensible, and the approaches are controlled by the Taliban, who are only marginally in control of their own fighters, let alone worse actors like ISIS. The entire airport is within mortar range, and most if not all of the landing air space is within RPG range.

The strangest and most damaging move we made was to give up Bagram Air Base outside of Kabul. Bagram was home to the US military for twenty years, and as such it was already set up to facilitate any sort of withdrawal on any desired timeline. It had a defensible perimeter, and enough space to shuttle and buffer the people we needed to get out of the country. We abandoned it before even starting the withdrawal, for no good reason that I can discern.

As a result, we and our European allies may now be forced to abandon hundred or thousands of our citizens, and tens or hundreds of thousands of our Afgan allies who are now prey to the Taliban. And as another commenter pointed out, both the US and the British handed the Taliban detailed lists of these Afghan allies, which may help ensure their slaughter.

Biden and the military leadership put the military into a position where there are no good options. Maybe not deliberately, but the incompetence is stunning in the truest sense of the word.

Note that Trump did a similar thing in Syria in 2019, and may very well have done worse if he was still President. The biggest difference is probably that he wouldn't have allowed as many of our Afghan allies into the US, as his immigration advisor Stephen Miller helpfully pointed out last week. And he certainly would have blamed the Afghans for their own plight; this again is what Trump did in 2019, saying that our Syrian Kurdish allies didn't deserve our help because they didn't help us on D-Day in World War Two, whatever that means. Beyond idiotic.

So that's what the US has to offer recently in terms of foreign policy. Two vain, incompetent presidents helping to set up the next Middle East crisis.

nate_meurer··on My Tungsten Cube (2019)
I love this kind of thing. My favorite fidgeting things are two 2-inch stainless steel ball bearings I got from Ebay. Perfectly round to the eye and mirror smooth. I sit and clack them together; the sound and sensation they make is addictive to me.
nate_meurer··on Nirvana sued by the man who appeared on Nevermind’s album cover as a baby
Small price? Are we talking about the same thing? There are many millions of infants and small children that have appeared in photos and film. How much compensation do you think each should be awarded? How much might that add up to?

Going forward, do you propose we ban all infants and small children in movies and photographs? Do I need to apologize for letting my kids watch Look Who's Talking because its main characters were infants?

nate_meurer··on Infection vs. vaccination: Differences in Covid antibody responses
> If the virus never really gets to take off, you won't be spreading it to others.

That might be true for some virii, but unfortunately not for sars-cov2. It became clear early on that asymptomatic and low-symptom infected people can spread the virus. And there's evidence that vaccinated people-- who can still be infected, but are less likely to fall ill-- can spread it as well.

nate_meurer··on Infection vs. vaccination: Differences in Covid antibody responses
The last line of the article is the most important:

"If the goal is to prevent infection, then boosting will need to be done after 6 to 18 months depending on the immune status of the individual. If the goal is to prevent serious disease boosting may not be necessary for years."

This is a very important distinction. The media mostly gets this wrong, and CDC has been badly negligent in helping the public understand it.

Vaccines are generally not expected to prevent infection. The only common vaccine that is known to prevent infection is HPV. All other vaccines allow some degree if infection, and thus some continued spread of the target pathogen. Vaccines are designed and tested to prevent serious disease due to infection. That's it.

Likewise, these new vaccines are designed and tested to prevent the disease of covid, not infection by the virus called sars-cov2. The extent to which they do prevent infection, and the resulting effect on R0, is yet to be determined, but it is fully expected that the virus will continue to spread, even as hospitalizations and deaths eventually drop.

nate_meurer··on Joe Rogan, confined to Spotify, is losing influence
> if everybody just took the vaccine the virus would be gone within insert timespan

No, the expectation is that a successful vaccination campaign will end the pandemic, by making the burden on healthcare systems manageable. Nobody serious thinks we can eradicate the virus like we did with smallpox. It will always be with us, causing infection.

This is how all vaccines work, with the exception of HPV and possibly measles. Vaccines are not expected to provide sterilizing immunity, and they don't need to as long as they prevent serious disease due to the infection.

Within the field of immunology this is common knowledge, and I wish the CDC would message it more clearly.

nate_meurer··on Joe Rogan, confined to Spotify, is losing influence
> The claim by the experts was that the vaccines were 95% effective at stopping the spread.

No, vaccines are not expected to prevent infection or spread, and almost none do. For example, flu vaccines don't keep you from from getting infected, and the virus still spreads successfully even when vaccination rates are high. What the flu shot does is (hopefully) cause you to have less severe symptoms.

Vaccines are designed and tested to prevent disease in spite of infection. This is a universally understood principle in the field of immunology, regardless of the CDC's confusing messaging.

The current evidence indicates that the vaccines are doing a good job of preventing hospitalizations due to covid.

nate_meurer··on Nirvana sued by the man who appeared on Nevermind’s album cover as a baby
So you're proposing an entirely new legal regime around the interminably gray area of commercial activity, and it's intersection with the equally gray area of consent by children, which is currently centered on age, typically late teens for most uses?

Relief in the courts would require a completely new body of common law. In the mean time, legislation would be the only way to provide compensation to victims of un-consented childhood photography.

What specific ideas do you have for laws that could start to provide this relief?

nate_meurer··on Nirvana sued by the man who appeared on Nevermind’s album cover as a baby
There are billions of photos of infants and young children used in instruction manuals, text books, advertising, and as stock photos. What's more, these are very often necessarily taken in various states of undress, for example the diapered infants on the box of the kiddie pool in my backyard.

Another example: the instructions for my pediatric otoscope used photos of an infant, showing proper placement. This is a commercial use.

Do you propose that all of these photos should be made illegal?

EDIT: And what about movies? Should we ban infants and small children from film as well?

nate_meurer··on Nirvana sued by the man who appeared on Nevermind’s album cover as a baby
Right now I'm looking at the instructions for a pediatric otoscope, showing how to use it on an infant, who probably didn't consent to this use of his photo.

There are literally billions of photos of infants and young children used in instruction manuals, text books, advertising, and as stock photos.

Should all of these be made illegal? Should manufacturers and advertisers be sued for using these photos without the subjects' consent?

nate_meurer··on Nirvana sued by the man who appeared on Nevermind’s album cover as a baby
What is your personal threshold for "naked"? Completely naked? Diapers? Nipples showing?
nate_meurer··on The Coronavirus Is Here Forever
And also just like the other four common coronavirus types that we already live with.
nate_meurer··on Pfizer CEO says a vaccine-resistant coronavirus variant is 'likely' to emerge
Which they will, and we'll eventually end up with a regular rotation of coronavirus vaccines, similar to our yearly flu vaccines.
nate_meurer··on Delta variant will acquire complete resistance to wild-type spike vaccines
This isn't surprising. Vaccines are not expected to prevent infection, and almost none do. Rather, they are designed and tested to prevent disease.

The focus on preventing infection is understandable, but I feel it's largely counterproductive in the national discourse. I wish there were more emphasis on the vaccines' ability to prevent the disease of covid, and the evidence still shows that they are doing this job well.

← PreviousPage 10 of 34Next →