1,264 karma · joined September 26, 2011
Twitter: @{username}
Email: {username}@gmail
[ my public key: https://keybase.io/nateabele; my proof: https://keybase.io/nateabele/sigs/tffmWJKPOzE_9N5C74rXo42NaKXoMsogz1xMZFIkIMk ]
> In short, people value expertise in closed systems, but are distrustful of expertise in open systems. A typical example of a closed system would be a car engine or a knee joint.
What about economics or investments? That's a massively open system on which people trust experts all the time. The true deciding factor is whether following (or rejecting) expert advice costs you something. If you have a brain tumor, an incompetent neurosurgeon is going to cost you a lot more than an incompetent president.
In the parlance of Antifragile (which I cannot recommend highly enough for anyone who works with people & systems—so, most of us), the question turns on whether you have 'skin in the game'.
True natural monopolies are exceedingly rare and usually short-lived — most monopolies created by government[0]. What we observe with startups and venture capital is no exception: the Fed's continuous monetary expansion policy has driven more money into more volatile investments as investors try to achieve 'escape velocity' on their returns, and success has a natural compounding effect.
The underlying assumption (or one of many) is that all perspectives have moral judgements attached, and the offended party is the sole arbiter of that judgement.
In other words, it's one thing to question progress, it's another thing to say 'I disagree with this form of progress, therefore the person working towards it is evil'. Judge action all you want, but assume good intent absent concrete evidence to the contrary.
People find the resources to cover the things they need, and lawyers aren't all crazy unaffordable.
The possible solutions are innumerable.
To my original point, though, making money off of a copyrighted work represents income from an asset, the value of which compounds over time, due to inflation.
Okay, slice the upper quartile and graph it over time. Now it's a proper growth curve, but it communicates the exact same idea.
> On the second, thanks for the reference, haven't read that. Would be interested to hear how you think that change would lead to these effects.
Quick thought experiment that expands on my explanation in the original comment: Suppose you have (a) a wage-earner who spends 90% of their income on goods & saves/invests the other 10%, and (b) an investor who earns an income from assets, spends 10% on goods and reinvests the other 90%.
Now (for the sake of simplicity) suppose inflation is 10% per year. What happens after year 1? What about year 2?
Other people have cited links elsewhere in the thread [0], and I don't feel especially compelled to be redundant. Not sure what to suggest other than googling some Austrian economists and their views on inflation.
As inflation is also a form of government intervention (insert hand-waving gestures re: the Fed not really being a government agency), I think the principle still holds, but generalizes to something I can't articulate succinctly off the top of my head.
An exponential growth curve is an exponential growth curve, irrespective of what it measures. Thanks anyway for the pedantry.
> And if you think some central mechanism has gone horribly awry, what central mechanisms changed around 1980?
In 1974, the US dollar switched from being a store of value to a store of debt: https://www.amazon.com/Creature-Jekyll-Island-Federal-Reserv...
It floors me how anyone, especially anyone with even a basic STEM background, could look at a growth curve that approaches infinity that rapidly, then turn around and say 'gee, I wonder if tinkering around the periphery of the system would solve the problem'.
No! Clearly some central mechanism has gone horribly awry.
The only explanation I've ever seen that adequately accounts for those curves is inflation. Inflation drives up prices, both of goods and of assets. A higher cost of goods narrows the margins for wage-earners (i.e. the poor and middle class), and higher asset prices inflate the net worth of people who earn income from assets (i.e. rich people) — this effect compounds over time.
If I'm wrong, please, convince me. Article & book recommendations gladly accepted.
Anyone with common sense and a knowledge of history knows exactly where this is going. As things continue to move online, internet access and associated technology standards begin to be declared a "public necessity" or some other nonsense along similar rhetorical lines.
You don't even need to look very far for examples. UK accessibility laws (not that they're an unqualified evil, simply a legislative 'gateway drug'), references to 'digital haves and have-nots' from a few US election cycles ago, etc.
I'd really hoped to be closer to retirement before this sort of thing started happening.
Edit for clarity: I'm not saying this is immediately going to turn into some draconian thing, but as a founding member of a standards body[0] with a narrowly-defined intent, I've seen how easy it is for something like this to become a de-facto industry standard that non-experts use to judge things against, even when it's not appropriate.
Coupled with the copious regulations around insurance, pushing it out of the realm of reasonable affordability for all but the biggest corporations, and insurance companies' backroom dealing with major healthcare providers, price discovery for the consumer is basically dead.
As a result, US healthcare costs have ballooned out of control compared to everywhere else in the world, with no measurable improvement in outcomes.
With time at such a premium, that is by far the most valuable information you could possibly communicate. I wouldn't even be bothered by having to read comments/unit tests to figure out how the thing works if you just tell me why I should care in the first place.
Either it's illegal or it's not. If it's not, then shut the fuck up.
The shame isn't that Apple is doing this. The shame is that more people can't.
The best we could do for a 'replacement' is a site that lets you pick which browsers you're targeting, which DOM APIs you want, and generates a polyfill.
If you're privy to some magic whereby a paralegal can appear in her place, then by all means, enlighten me. And send me your PayPal address, because that information is worth actual money.
- Come up with the funds to get out of prison in the first place ($10,000 cash in my case, some % of which you typically never see again; 40% in PA)
- Find and still have funds to retain a competent attorney
- Navigate the interminable legal process, part of which means spending half a day sitting around in a courtroom, over and over and over again, either burning vacation days, or losing your job, or both (not to mention childcare, etc.)
- Reject the coercive and unethical plea bargain they try to scare you into
- Waste a day in court at least once a month, just so the judge can satisfy himself that things are moving along
- Research and retain your own experts, obtain mountains of records, go over what happened and everything leading up to it about a million times with a million different people (it's basically a part-time job)
- Try not to worry obsessively about every aspect of what happened and what you might say
- Take more time off to actually go to trial (and jury selection, and other misc. trial prep)
- Leave your fate in the hands of people who may not be competent, may not be educated, and by-and-large skew toward favoring law enforcement
I have about a million things going for me. I own my own (moderately successful) company, and I have a high profile in a relatively affluent community/industry. That buys me an unreasonably high degree of financial and scheduling flexibility that most people don't have. If not for those things, my family and I would be crushed. If this system is designed to do anything, it's designed to crush the people who get caught in it, with no thought to the consequences for society.
† ES2015 for the super-pedants :-)