HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nautilius

896 karma · joined July 4, 2021

submissionscomments
nautilius··on Netflix to Employees: If you don't like our content, you can quit
Shifting goalposts, are we, after your 'clearly' comment did not even contain a grain of truth about what OP posted?

And yes, you are missing something. Go ahead and watch Chapelle. The issue isn't that he makes a joke about trans people. Sure, I'd assume people in general may not like having jokes made at their expense, but that's not the issue. The issue is that Chapelle dedicates a whole special to argue that their cause isn't worthy to be supported. As much as I like Chapelle and his amazing ability to do hour-long stand-ups where he doesn't even tell jokes and yet you're mesmerized, I'll have to side with the 'punching down' argument. This campaign of his will not age well.

I understand his frustration, and, in his words, jealousy, to see how far LGBTQ+ rights have come compared to the much older issue of Black rights, but that's a really poor justification to rant against the former.

Just imagine that same setup to watch someone rant for an hour against women suffrage, or gay or Black rights, etc. Sure, some will like this.

nautilius··on Netflix to Employees: If you don't like our content, you can quit
Is that before or after they are drafted to serve in Jewish Space Lasers?
nautilius··on Netflix to Employees: If you don't like our content, you can quit
I see no contradiction between our posts.
nautilius··on Netflix to Employees: If you don't like our content, you can quit
OP is making no statement about what they do, only that they find it reasonable to push back against that simple wish of the trans community.
nautilius··on Netflix to Employees: If you don't like our content, you can quit
For me that's the only interesting discussion to be had here. Separation into female and male leagues were installed partially because of sex (so that it's fairer), but initially mainly because of gender (women must not do the same fun things we do).

Then again, it is 'unfair' that Simone Biles has the physique she has that fits to her chosen sport better than mine; Michael Phelps likewise; Alex Honnold processes fear differently from most of us, etc.

nautilius··on Netflix to Employees: If you don't like our content, you can quit
OP very clearly writes that they "don't think it's transphobic to push back on trans activists" who, unlike him, "demand the world accommodate".

Again, the only 'accommodation' that is asked is to just let them live. Seems like not a hard thing to do, and not something one would have to go out of their way of to 'push back against'.

If you don't like the thought of buttfucking, don't. If you don't like the thought of people who identify differently from their biological sex, don't. If you don't like the thought of eating kale, don't. It's simple, it costs you nothing. Nothing at all.

nautilius··on Netflix to Employees: If you don't like our content, you can quit
Do people tell you that you are not really an addict or mentally ill, that that's not even a thing, and that it's just a phase you grow out of once you simply make up your mind?

[edit] Ok, got it. I don't mean to question anyone's personal experience, and sorry that this is what's happening to you.

Also, I don't want to 'rank' the degree of marginalization different groups experience, that's not at all what I'm after. Ideally, none of this would exist and everyone would just live happily ever after.

What I mean is that I don't see a national debate, through politicians or 'celebrities', that deny the existence of, say, alcoholism.

But again, I don't mean to imply that those groups don't suffer. Also, I can just be wrong.

nautilius··on Netflix to Employees: If you don't like our content, you can quit
I disagree. In particular, there is not a gay president. How did Pete Buttigieg do well? He dropped out, ranking behind Biden and Sanders. In other words, he was supported by but a fringe group. Just him running means nothing.

It will be a while before a trans president is a realistic prospect. The U.S. have yet to elect a female leader of the country 40 years after that was a thing in the UK, and 20 years after Germany. The U.S. now have an openly gay secretary of transportation, hardly a key position in the administration. Germany had their openly gay vice-chancellor and secretary of state a decade ago.

nautilius··on Netflix to Employees: If you don't like our content, you can quit
Not sure what that steep price is you would pay to 'accommodate' trans people? It requires nothing on your part except for acknowledging and respecting their existence.
nautilius··on Ask HN: Who decided copy+paste should copy styling/formatting?
It's amazing for job applications if you're on the receiving end: there is no faster shortcut for triaging an application to "Deleted Items" than mismatched formatting of my name, or "I am really interested in $SOME_SNIPPET_FROM_MY_WEBSITE".
nautilius··on Preview, the Mac app people forget about
Awesome, thank you!
nautilius··on Preview, the Mac app people forget about
Is there a pattern to it? I find it an amazing feature, but also find that it doesn't always works. Do I have to do something before I can drag the icon?
nautilius··on How to professionally say
Obviously not generally true, as silvestrov discusses in the very post you reply to.
nautilius··on How to professionally say
Yes, but as vassanas points out, you are not achieving this - because it is different from culture to culture!

If you add the specific culture / region you are targeting this at, it could already mitigate that issue.

As vassanas points out, the phrases you suggest would work to your disadvantage in more confrontational cultures, because you will be perceived as bullshitting and beating around the bush, but not as a serious contributer one should listen to.

nautilius··on Canadians consider certain religions damaging to society: survey
See, and that's where you're a dishonest hypocrite (ah, you got me there!) while moving your goalposts by miles. The religious people are all innocent, because those who aren't, aren't true believers and pharisees; but wow does that threshold drop when it comes to atheists (or 'smug materialists'), because now everything is their true god, and they just haven't realized that they really are religious, and are "just as bad as the religious people" (TM) because nothing can exist outside of religion, hallelujah.

You claim you were an atheist once, for a decade? Maybe you mistook being an atheist for being 'edgy' and smug. All it means is that I don't believe in you sky daddy. Never in my life have I talked about atheism except in response to religious people bringing up their religion and trying to explain to me how really I am religious. I just want to be left alone from your superstition, freedom from religion is the only religious freedom.

nautilius··on Canadians consider certain religions damaging to society: survey
I don't even understand how one could, even theoretically, be insecure about atheism. It would be great to believe in the 'big sky daddy', as someone else calls them here, it would make lives much easier if you don't have to think and worry for yourself. Alas, I wasn't indoctrinated form an early age.

What pisses me off in this discussion here is that you guys aren't able to have this discussion without either lying or goalpost moving. It is completely incomprehensible to you that something outside of your tiny believe bubble exists. Smug remarks about the 'smug materialists' show how insecure you guys are, then proving that atheists really only also are religious, but still need to be enlightened from you guys. Salvation!

nautilius··on Canadians consider certain religions damaging to society: survey
If the only thing keeping you from being a bad person (TM) is the threat of eternal damnation and suffering through some divine almighty being - how are you then not a bad person?
nautilius··on Canadians consider certain religions damaging to society: survey
That's it? That's all your god has to offer? That's all your god is? An ideology? Bureaucrats and formalism? I feel betrayed! To you, god is indistinguishable for from this? How? Now, I am not a religion-apologist, but it seems to me you're selling god short, no?

What about all the metaphysical mumbo-jumbo? Here's Oxford: 1. (in Christianity and other monotheistic religions) the creator and ruler of the universe and source of all moral authority; the supreme being. 2. (in certain other religions) a superhuman being or spirit worshiped as having power over nature or human fortunes; a deity.

Wow! Yeah! Thats's a god! But you're arguing that god is equivalent to formalism and bureaucracy?! Wow, what a disappointment!

nautilius··on Canadians consider certain religions damaging to society: survey
The state? Buildings and bureaucrats? Now that's a low bar for 'god'. That's it? There isn't more to it? That's what all the fuzz is about?
nautilius··on Canadians consider certain religions damaging to society: survey
No one claimed atheists cannot be murderers. But I have yet to learn of an atheist starting a crusade in the name of that god they don't believe in.
nautilius··on Canadians consider certain religions damaging to society: survey
Would they? What's that god they killed for?
nautilius··on An accidental experiment that saved 700 lives
How is that the opposite of "An accidental experiment that saved 700 lives"?
nautilius··on They Thought They Were Free: The Germans, 1933-45
The argument wasn't that you violated a law, it was that your argument is blunt and lacks nuance.
nautilius··on They Thought They Were Free: The Germans, 1933-45
> History has a term

> History records the actions, not the intent

You haven't spent much time with history, have you?

nautilius··on Wealthiest Americans pay just 3.4% of income in taxes, investigation reveals
Oh, I'm not talking legislative probability. I was responding to the comment that it's somehow an unfathomable thought to have different 'carve outs' for different people in tax law (or anywhere, really) when that is standard practice in reality already.
nautilius··on Moskva cruiser sank while being towed in a storm – Russian Defense Ministry
Those are turbojet cruise missiles.
nautilius··on Wealthiest Americans pay just 3.4% of income in taxes, investigation reveals
> - We make a special carve-out for people in that situation so that the tax doesn't apply to them.

Tax law does that all the time. Maybe you've heard of tax brackets. It's so that people who earn less pay a smaller tax rate. I don't see the trouble with that. It's applied in the other direction as well, e.g. with a maximum dollar value with medicare.

nautilius··on Moskva cruiser sank while being towed in a storm – Russian Defense Ministry
Why would it have lots of hypergolics on board?
nautilius··on A new heat engine with no moving parts is as efficient as a steam turbine
Do RTG reach the >2170K necessary for this?
nautilius··on A story about planning for Desert Storm
Human tragedy aside (and it absolutely is, no doubt about it, on all sides), it really depends on the context.

Striking the retreating army is the 'easiest' way to 'neutralize' it, Clausewitz writes about it, and I am sure it's been practiced for thousand(s?) of years before that.

For a timely comparison: would it be 'vindictive' when Ukraine strikes the retreating Russian army in the Kyiv area before they regroup and attack the Donbas? I don't think so. Seems like a good idea, actually.

← PreviousPage 5 of 18Next →