You make a good point, but I disagree. I'm a huge fan of solar and wind. I realize I'm over-simplifying, but the problem is that the sun does not shine (and the wind does not blow) all the time. Either a base load source is necessary, or we need to get fantastically better at storing energy.
In some areas hydro could work, but unless you're near a dam you are still going to need a coal or natural gas plant to provide baseload.
Tl;dr - Why take on greater consequences unless it truly is needed? It truly IS needed.