HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nchlswu

436 karma · joined March 3, 2010

submissionscomments
nchlswu··on New DuckDuckGo design
I suppose given an assumption of who uses DDG it's okay to use the icon, but my core point is really that it's not as common as one may think.

In general, solely using an icon instead of text (or a combination of the two) is poor from a usability standpoint. Within a mobile context, I can understand the general push towards more compact treatments, but an icon with three lines does not intrinsically have any definitive meaning. While the icon may be aesthetically pleasing, I always felt there were some more effective alternatives.

There's been some recent discussion and data generated related to this icon (1,2), some of which can obviously be debated, but I think it's safe to say it's not as ubiquitous as you may think.

Overall, I don't think the hidden drawer pattern (and the associated menu icon) are appropriate for the site when it's being used on a desktop. But, it's OK given the contents of it and understandable when the site seems to have been designed mobile first and responsive. I do think more time should be given to the final 'desktop' state for a lot of responsive designs these days, though.

[1] http://jxnblk.tumblr.com/post/82486816704/an-update-on-the-h... [2] http://exisweb.net/menu-eats-hamburger

nchlswu··on New DuckDuckGo design
Please. There's no need to have the non-descript hamburger icon on a page designed for desktop
nchlswu··on We'd lose our security certificate if we allowed pasting
> My hypothesis is that this is a technical limitation due to the password being stored as a char(6) in their database.

and legacy security policies/requirements that have not undergone any update.

I've worked on a project that touched banking passwords in the past and in a push for modern password requirements (which was met....somewhere in the middle), the response was that since the number of attempts was so restricted (and claims about whatever security/fraud engine they were using), the risk caused by the restrictive passwords were essentially negated.

From a security perspective, how true is this? I'm genuinely looking to be educated. It did seem like a reasonable measure to prevent a bruteforce attack, but I'm not sure if I'm missing anything

nchlswu··on The user is drunk (2013) [video]
The simple answer to your question is that you(the researcher or dogfooder) are not your users.

I'd say most people overestimate how much their own personal experiences generalize (to a meaningful n) or overestimate their ability to empathize with users. Even user researchers.

nchlswu··on Report: 44% of Twitter Accounts Have Never Sent a Tweet
I don't think they've introduced any process. Until then the account has to be truly inactive and you have to know someone at Twitter
nchlswu··on Banks Wage 'Hand-to-Hand Combat' for Tech Talent
As a bank worker in a no engineering tech role, I think the myopia you describe is IMO a significant factor.

From a retail banking perspective, many banks are starting to modernize their practices and play catch up for mobile. But most banks are stuck in rigid methodology, culture and solutions established in what I call the first generation of online banking. Projects are treated as continuations o this foundation and continue with antiquated development methodologies and back end technology. Since acceptable products get shipped, there's no business incentive to modernize.

nchlswu··on Banks Wage 'Hand-to-Hand Combat' for Tech Talent
Quality is the key word. I work for a North American bank (not an engineering role) and at least in my experience you really have to be insanely exceptional junior talent or exceptional in a senior role to command something high
nchlswu··on Any Android app can read your WhatsApp database
I thought WhatsApp had a history of horrendous security?
nchlswu··on Most Winning A/B Test Results are Illusory [pdf]
is the corrected final version uploaded at the same URL? I'd like to distribute to some colleagues.
nchlswu··on Important BufferBox Update
I just wish the team woulda got a boost after the acquisition or immediately wrapped into Google Shopping.

Shopping was the logical place the product would fit, but it seemed like they weren't given much of a boost after the acquisition and they sort of slowed a bit.

nchlswu··on Facebook Paper's gesture problems
And that's my fault for not following the linked sources in the article.

While I agree wih all your points in your assessment, I'm curious about the point the research mentioned about users changing grips depending on task. Will this be a significant problem? Or would it be an unconscious adaptation.

nchlswu··on Facebook Paper's gesture problems
I've been fascinated with phone placement in hands for product shots.

It always seemed like a little bit of a cheat - especially when the elongated 5 came out - just to show one handed use of a device is possible.

For me at least, the way the phone is positioned is hardly comfortable. The bottom right corner at the base of the thumb exacerbates the problem the author's talking about. When I hold the phone higher in my hand with the bottom closer to the base of the index, all thumb-hook problems tend to go away.

Obviously this is anecdotal, but I'd love to see some studies about how people hold their phones. In some respects, I've always felt one-handed device usage was neglected by manufacturers, but I probably didn't fully understand how many users simply use two hands. I imagine data around grips (similar to [this](http://www.razerzone.com/mouseguide/ergonomic)) and hands used for phones will be somewhat surprising.

nchlswu··on Facebook Paper's gesture problems
For now. Switching the app store locale to the US will let you download it though.
nchlswu··on Chromecast now open to developers with the Google Cast SDK
when Chromecast first launched some enterprising individuals found an undocumented API (?) that allowed them to stream whatever content they wanted. Google promptly pulled that functionality with an update. Does this bridge said gap?
nchlswu··on Retailers Ask: Where Did Teenagers Go?
they're cool enough that they are increasing their prices in certain areas.
nchlswu··on The science behind how fonts make you feel
No problem!

Here's an interesting anecdote I just remembered, though. A psychology professor of mine was attempting to replicate another researchers work. The result couldn't be replicated when the stimuli was displayed in sans-serif fonts, but it was replicated when they finally used the font the initial researchers did: a serif.

I'd bet serifs/sans may have some sort or psychological implications but I doubt it's as straightforward a relationship as often presented

nchlswu··on The science behind how fonts make you feel
> "Science", some amorphous entity quite disconnected from real science, has become a religion of sorts for some non-scientifically minded people. Put "science" is a post title and you'll fool many into thinking you speak from authority. I feel the author is well intentioned here, but has gone far beyond what the science suggests.

This is a huge issue I have with a lot of the blog posts I see. Especially related to design.

So much of design has been shaped by a consensus that's been accrued over time and established through intuition, feeling and opinion. A lot of visual design is aesthetic preference that experienced designers have learned through trial and error (speaking in broad terms). The knowledge gets passed on to more inexperienced designers, who tend to append the scientific justification on a post-hoc basis. Since most designers really don't have that scientific background, you really see poor articles like this, even when the literature is hardly conclusive[1]

[1] Good review of related concepts: http://alexpoole.info/blog/which-are-more-legible-serif-or-s...

nchlswu··on The science behind how fonts make you feel
While designers/bloggers tend to cite scientific studies advocating sans over serif (or the other way around depending on the context), no conclusive scientific evidence to prefer one or the other [1]

However, the historical reason why sans-serif are generally recommended over a serif on a computer screen was a matter of practicality. The computer monitor simply couldn't replicate the tiny detail required by serifs. Higher resolution screens are becoming more common place, which is why you'll see more serifs in use online (IMO... correlation vs causation and all that). Somewhere along the line someone cited scientific articles to help justify this practice, but I'm convinced it became common place was really for practical reasons/aesthetics more than anything.

[1] I haven't personally done a literature review, but this post is great in discussing the conclusiveness around the research (and readability vs legibility vs....) http://alexpoole.info/blog/which-are-more-legible-serif-or-s...

nchlswu··on Optimal Characters Per Line
So there were some great points in there, all of which were valid. But immediately addressing those points doesn't mean using large type follows.

Side note: as monitors increase in size, I'm curious of the general population is increasing the distance between their eyes and the screen

nchlswu··on Typeface vs. Font: Terminology Smackdown
wouldn't bold, italic, etc., be variants of a typeface, with a corresponding font?
nchlswu··on How to Pretend You Know UX When You Don't
and as a 'UX Designer', it's hard to avoid this. I loathe when peers use rationale, but I understand.... because as a designer, ou're expected to use your experience as a guide you
nchlswu··on How to Pretend You Know UX When You Don't
to be fair, there are some use cases where focus groups (maybe not traditional focus groups, but focus group style discussion) can be useful. I'd generally still agree with that comment as well though
nchlswu··on Andrew Kim: Minimal to the max
I still find the whole premise of the popsicle and redesigning microsoft - with zero parallels to a popsicle as presented - hard to grasp. But if it worked for him that's all that matters.

His design work aside (which is very strong and that I respect), I'm more impressed and intrigued about how he's leveraged the internet as a platform for his work. It reminds me of Dustin Curtis (although Kim lacks some of the disdain Dustin's managed to acccrue). And while he is very talented, it's not like there aren't designers out there with a similar talent level. Kim's managed to create a following and more importantly for him generate a demand for his work.

Microsoft's interest in pushing him on a page like this demonstrates the brand value Kim's accrued and is quite intriguing.

nchlswu··on Shopify POS
which means chip and pin support is on their radar, as I believe Chip and Pin will be standard within 12(?) months
nchlswu··on Adobe Photoshop CC Has Apparently Been Cracked One Day After Launch
I love how the media keeps portraying CC as an anti-piracy measure. It may be a segue to it, but unless software truly lives in the cloud this would never be the case.

It's changing the revenue stream and in a lot of cases, it's more compelling for users to switch over.

nchlswu··on In Head-Hunting, Big Data May Not Be Such a Big Deal
I took an i/o psychology course during school and a chunk of it dealt with interviewing and finding best candidates (from an employer stand point and equity standpoint), as lots of people who took the course tend to pursue education with the idea of obtaining an HR-related certificate.

The comment about brainteasers vs structured rubrics is sort of surprising to me, given Google's reputation for quantitative data. Speaking from a very high level, structure was really what was emphasized for interviews. It's interesting how culture can get in the way of proven 'fact,' and I love that Google is using their own (much larger data sets) to make these improvements and in/validate other research

nchlswu··on Principles of Flat Design
This distinction is frivolous.

It's a writer just seeking to milk the whole "flat design" thing even more by categorizing small variations as a whole design movement. It's no coincidence that a company selling a kit has the most blog posts dedicated to it. flat and almost flat design have the exact same aesthetic.

Moreover, pegging designers to a trendy aesthetic is ridiculous.

nchlswu··on Square now in Japan
Square has expanded to Canada. We have an impending chip legislation that takes effect I think within the next two years? I'm sure it's in the works
nchlswu··on Facebook Home and Dogfooding
oops. access the Metadata (ie. "Sent from _____) from Twitter without a client
nchlswu··on Facebook Home and Dogfooding
Isn't this a problem inherent with dogfooding, and not isolated to Facebook? Building it and using it doesn't mean you want to in the first place.

>It’s always a sign of trouble when you’ve built something you don’t want to use yourself.

I'm not convinced that this can be isolated to this alone. I doubt a homescreen alone would make someone want to jump ship from one ecosystem to another

>Why does everyone I know who works at Apple carry an iPhone? Every single one? Not because they have to. It’s because they want to.

I was under the impression that this is an Apple culture thing? It's alleged that if you wear a competitor's brand on Nike Campus, you'll be politely asked to leave (or forced to buy a new pair of shoes while they burn yours). what is Apple's culture's take on this?

>(Doesn’t look like it, judging by the “via Twitter for iPhone” metadata on his recent tweets.

I know Twitter clients can still access the data, I'm guessing there's no easy way to do it

← PreviousPage 2 of 11Next →