HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nchlswu

436 karma · joined March 3, 2010

submissionscomments
nchlswu··on Flat UI was Released - Framework for Designers and Developers,based on Bootstrap
LayerVault issued a DMCA Takedown because of it [1]. They did it because there were some assets that appear to be directly stolen [2] and were subsequently changed after the DMCA takedown.

In the discussion threads, you'll find a lot of discussion about what was legally justifiable and whether something was ripped off or not. I've often found that there's a dichotomy between certain views for those who are more designer versus those that are more developer. Take it for what you will.

As a designer, it's hard for me to appreciate the theme itself, let alone support someone with such a reputation. To me, they appear to lack any ethos characteristic of a designer...but I digress...

[1] HN Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5331766 [2] DesignerNews Discussion: https://news.layervault.com/stories/1992-layervault-whats-up...

Edited to add the DN discussion link which I seem to have omitted?

nchlswu··on How I served 100k users without breaking the server or a dollar bill
I'm hardly technically competent, and S3 has served me very well for static files. I've dabbled around with their other products to learn a bit here and there and have definitely been overwhelmed, but S3 is really really simple.
nchlswu··on Flat Design and Color Trends
I think you can only conclude that it's popular among trend-following designers... and I guess tech-turned-design-bloggers as well.

I'm really curious what the general public's perception is (not that it really matters) and if there are really any functional implications for the way some of the interfaces have been designed.

nchlswu··on Twitter Should Shut Me Down
I'd guess that he's 100% prepared for this and has weighed the risks.

I'm making a big presumption about his intelligence though.

nchlswu··on Has The Cupcake Bubble Finally Popped?
definitely has been picking up steam lately and will explode soon enough. It's a lot closer to cupcakes as well ("baked" goods) and likely the novelty of cupcakes is easily transferred to donuts
nchlswu··on Twitter said to be testing two-step security in wake of AP hack
Is that at all mitigated by tools like HootSuite or other corporate Twitter clients that allow multiple people to manage an account?

I'm not saying that it's acceptable that Twitter leaves that in the hands of vendors/users, I'm genuinely curious and wondering why the idea was parked in the first place.

I'd guess that it is part of a future offering from Twitter, but who knows.

nchlswu··on [dead]
"Not vetted by CNN"
nchlswu··on Google Shopping Express looking for Bay Area testers
I feel like people forget that Google is a business.

Google has always retired products and always explored new avenues. I don't see the difference

nchlswu··on Apple looks to protect dropped iPhones by shifting their orientation mid-flight
that's what I was trying to get at. I think it was a neat side effect. I just don't necessarily subscribe to the idea that it was a priori goal or priority when these phones were being designed designed.
nchlswu··on Apple looks to protect dropped iPhones by shifting their orientation mid-flight
as opposed to the convenience and accessibility of phones with conventional removable parts?

I don't deny that soaking up impact energy is an outcome, but I'm doubtful it was a deliberate engineering decision for purposes of impact survival

nchlswu··on Fltdsgn - a showcase of flat UI design
make it stop. please.

showcases like this is just indiscriminate bandwagon hopping and the content hasn't even been curated well at all.

nchlswu··on Sorry Google; you can Keep it to yourself
It baffles me that everyone is so focused on Evernote when the connection is so obvious (probably deceptively so)
nchlswu··on Why I left Google (2012)
I feel like I've read or seen a fair bit of Google criticism from ex-Googlers on the msdn blogs. Can anyone confirm I haven't just been seeing this post over and over?

I don't care if it's just optics; having a post about this on your current employers blog platform makes me highly suspicions, no matter how many people share his opinion

nchlswu··on Got an I/O ticket...only to have payment gateway fail?
Everytime it comes up, I'm always fascinated that online checkout under demand is still unsolved, even by a giant like Google.

Obviously it's a small chunk of all online sales, but it always seems like the process fails somewhere

nchlswu··on Why I created Comic Sans
>A Serif title with Sans body-text for the web makes content easier to read, and the inverse is true for print.

For whatever it's worth, these conventions are largely unfounded.

With respect to readability or legibility alone, a majority of any research of a sans vs a serif has been weak or contradictory; you can't make a conclusion either way. These studies are often cited which continues to perpetuate the myth,

While I admittedly do prefer these conventions, they're largely arbitrary and shaped by historical precedent and evolved over time. For example, poor resolution screens were the primary reason to use serifs, yet I've heard plenty of questionable rationale for it over time

nchlswu··on LayerVault Sends DMCA Takedown Letter re Flat-UI
To add some context, LayerVault posted a blog post outlining "The Flat Design Era"[1]. While the term has been used before in various context, to me, the post seemed to ignite a lot of discussion in the tech/design community about flat design (and by relation, skeumorphs, etc.,)

LayerVault is a vocal proponent of the "Flat UI" approach and uses it almost as a signature look and feel for their product. In the follow up discussions, the blog post author has said that no post or discussion fully understands what he meant [2].

I can't read the takedown letter or discussion where I am (for some reason github is blocked). But based on what I've seen, the kit is similar to LayerVault's approach to employing Flat UI. That combined with the blogpost, I wouldn't be surprised if LayerVault felt that their look and feel was infringed upon. Obviously, this doesn't mean that they actually were infringed upon in the eye of the law, even if the kit was derived from LayerVault.

As a designer, I can sympathize with LayerVault's issue with the kit (I'm making assumptions), but with such a design, I really wonder how valid their complaint is within the law.

[1]http://layervault.tumblr.com/post/32267022219/flat-interface... [2]Designer News thread that I have no link to at the moment.

nchlswu··on Will MOOCs Destroy Academia?
It's interesting because (in Ontario, Canada) there is an ongoing trend to adopt online classes because of the touted lower costs.

Since there is an explosion of demand of students who primarily see post-secondary institutions as job training grounds (and don't necessarily understand academia), the institutions wan't to adopt these online courses to help deal with demand and attract students with the appeal of 'remote' courses, all at lower costs.

If MOOCs can be credentialed and recognized by employers, I think it's logical that they'll steal a lot of the undergrads from universities, which are the primary revenue generator for these institutions.

nchlswu··on Why Clarence Thomas Uses Simple Words in His Opinions
I was always under the assumption that plain english was avoided because being succinct can leave things open to interpretation. This would leaves legal documents up for debate and open to loopholes.

Am I wrong in this assumption?

I often find myself writing things that are too verbose in fear that I won't be interpreted as intended. I recognize that this is an inherent challenge in writing, but is there any intermediate solution? Can there not be a "plain language" version of a document? Or why can't legal documents be primarily written in plain language, with notes (like footnotes) for legal clarification?

nchlswu··on Microsoft Surface Pro Review
That one data point doesn't mean it's a mistake to compare it with the MBA. It's "complete" functionality and more importantly, price after keyboard means the MBA comparison should be made. Comparisons to tablets and other hybrids should also be made.

What I find interesting is the confusion about the product's positioning in the market. I am also confused and don't think it bodes well for the customer. At the base, it's most commonly known as a tablet, but the keyboard begins to confuse things. The moment you get into the Pro territory, the price confuses things even more. Even outside of the "RT/Pro" discussion, I'm not sure if it's lack of clear (existing) product category is beneficial for MS

nchlswu··on RIM Changes Company Name to BlackBerry
For a long time, I agreed that the RIM parent company makes sense if their software services were being licensed out.

I'm making an assumption (and I think the rebrand supports this) that RIM/BB has made a conscious decision to be a consumer hardware company, that is their priority, and any software services are a value-add or in support of their hardware. While this comparison is weak, it's almost like how Apple can be seen as a hardware company and the iCloud is in support of it.

I do think the renaming was probably made in haste, to coincide with BB10's release

nchlswu··on RIM Changes Company Name to BlackBerry
This move makes sense and is well overdue in my mind -- at least from a consumer perspective. The Playbook was branded as the "BlackBerry Playbook" not the RIM Playbook, which was ridiculous IMO (and still is). But they've made the decision and recognize that the RIM name is probably unrecognizable to the consumer, but BlackBerry is. I'm fairly certain the rest of their offerings to business (ie. BIS or BES) are associated or under the BlackBerry name anyways.

Dropping the "RIM" name makes sense, although the timing is distracting

nchlswu··on RIM Changes Company Name to BlackBerry
The problem here is all the accrued Brand Equity was for the BlackBerry brand/identity, not RIM's
nchlswu··on How an unsigned rapper changed music
Okay, I can see your point.

I think it's important to note that labels still have a much larger promotional push than going indy does. If we run with the Drake example, I think he would have easily gone #1 without them, but I don't think he could have become a household name or gone on worldwide tours without the support of big business.

The original post suggested that artists would leave labels. I still think this is more or less another data point that suggests a more balanced artist-label relationship, and not a massive tipping point. But I realize it could be - it's just something i'd have to wait and see

nchlswu··on How an unsigned rapper changed music
For all intents and purposes, blogs are pretty much affiliated with big music now though. And for what it's worth, Drake was only really affiliated with big music after he made it big on his own. Even when he was (allegedly) promoted by big music without being signed, that was in a bid to win build him and win him over.

While I agree that an entirely internet phenomenon is a bit different, I don't think it's a unique case. Macklemore just happens to be exemplifying an extreme case of a trendthat's been going on for a while.

nchlswu··on How an unsigned rapper changed music
No. The rap industry especially especially embraced blogs long before Macklemore got his number 1 hit. In fact, now it's become routine for major labels and artists to seed music and do releases through blogs. These same blogs push unsigned hype and labels respond by signing these artists for a major debut.

Drake is probably made the best use of the internet and blog to grow his stock and ignite a bidding war among majors. Many people speculated that he could remain independent and still be successful. He opted to sign to a major and he's now a superstar. The relationship between artists and labels has shifted for a long time.

From what I know, Macklemore made use of the internet in a way that's more or less routine nowadays. I'm not going to take away from him hitting #1, but the dynamics between a label and artists have been different for a long time

nchlswu··on Almost Flat Design
Man. After LayerVault's post, the term has taken on a life of it's own.

Minimalism never precluded the use of effects or interactions to create depth (and I'd argue that "Flat Design" never precluded this either). Just because skeumorphism was one extreme, doesn't mean everything has to use another extreme as a baseline. Using the "flat" end of the spectrum is entirely unnecessary. A name isn't neessary for everything...

Also, for what it's worth, I much prefer Andrew Kim's characterization of the spectrum as skeumorphic to digital [1]. Digital doesn't have the connotations that "flat" has

[1]see: http://bit.ly/VfSQ7T

nchlswu··on Designer News
It's worth noting that LayerVault are the guys behind the "Flat Design" blog post that's been getting a fair bit of attention recently.

The article was purposefully brief and the author has commented that no one quite grasps his concept of the flat design principle[1], so I'll try not to comment on that blog post specifically.

DesignerNews really seems like a minimal aesthetic is getting in the way of minimal design. There's nothing wrong with minimal interfaces, but I really think DesignerNews is a case where some design decisions sacrificed functionality in favour of aesthetic.

[1] See his comment here (Allan G). The comment system is strangely lacking some key features like permalinks, unfortunately: https://news.layervault.com/stories/558-skeuomorphic-texture...

nchlswu··on Svbtle Funding
I've exceeded my editing time window, but asterisks are located before and after the italicized text.

They were intended as footnotes, but I forgot I was writing in markdown

nchlswu··on Svbtle Funding
It definitely stems from both factors you mentioned. No one really knows who Dustin is and he's established a brand as a person who aspires for the best and is very opinionated. For better or for worse, most commenters only really know that about him. His response to the Svbtle clones on top of the personality he added to the Svbtle announement really acted as a tipping point for most peoples' perceptions about him.

Unfortunately, like you allude to, most people also saw his reaction simply to being a stolen theme, and don't appreciate that it was intended to be much more than that.

The network's introduction introduced Dustin's concept and site. If you ever visited his blog before that, it's clear he was building the site before. Part of the introduction was sharing a novel approach to the blogging workflow and get a glimpse of the CMS. If it's "just a theme," you'd imagine that people would steal some of the more interesting things, like his approach to editing, or build on it. Instead, people insisted on duplicating the theme -- some just to spite Dustin.

Dustin was explicit about his goals in the beginning - to create a great publishing/blogging network. If yoiu look at how it's panned out, people are making Svbtle their personal blogs and the theme is the differentiator. writers were willing to forego a complete branding of their website and demonstrated they were willing to accept this brand. When you're working to build a brand and key piece is plagiarized (and subsequently insulted by people who don't understand the work that goes behind it), the reaction is a bit more understandable.

I'm being polite. I recognize that it interpretations may differ

nchlswu··on Svbtle Funding
If I understand you correctly, you're saying Dustin's reputation can negatively affect the prospects of Svbtle.

While Dustin's brand own brand spills over into Svbtle's, I think the network's prospects can be sufficiently differentiated from Dustin's brand.

Seems to me that the network is becoming large enough where the "tech blog" echo chamber opinion (about one individual) is inconsequential to Svbtle's fate

← PreviousPage 3 of 11Next →