HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

neilk

13,638 karma · joined April 7, 2007

http://neilk.net/

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/neilk; my proof: https://keybase.io/neilk/sigs/NR9GKkLDDu0NtBo9HqjKFJY0Ql_7e3CTfgxIbrZGJBs ]

submissionscomments
neilk··on I am rich and have no idea what to do
I know that people like me do not belong on HN anymore, but:

Calling people "NPCs" is vile.

And, the entire ideology that makes it okay to say that one's fellow earthling is just an NPC? That is probably a major component of this person's problems.

neilk··on Writing Composable SQL Using Knex and Pipelines
Knex isn’t an ORM, it’s a query builder. (Though the closely related library Bookshelf.js is an ORM).

I know your pain of translating SQL back to the ORM language, but what similar difficulty do you have for Knex? You have a query, and it’s isomorphic to the Knex query usually. There are a few things Knex doesn’t do, but it has the “raw” get-out-of-jail-free card for making part of the query just a string without sacrificing anything else.

Every project I’ve ever worked on has many closely related complex queries and writing them out as strings (even with placeholders) becomes either perilous as you write complex string building logic, or tediously repetitive.

neilk··on Tesla's Cybertruck is outselling almost every other EV in the US
(Caveat: I am not a car guy at all, never owned one)

In the US, most trucks sold do very little hauling, towing, or off-reading or anything else that might justify the giant form factor.

https://www.thedrive.com/news/26907/you-dont-need-a-full-siz...

And yet, trucks and SUVs are the best-selling cars in the US, and have been for a long time. There is a weird loophole for fuel efficiency in mileage standards for large vehicles, but obviously that doesn’t apply to the Cybertruck. There is definitely some psychological appeal to having a very dominant-looking vehicle.

So just as a business move, the Cybertruck makes sense. But there’s more overlap with Musk’s politics than you might think.

I read a book a long time ago by this very weird product marketer Clotaire Rapaille, who, several decades ago, was trying to convince executives to put a gun mount on an SUV. His argument was his research showed that the people who loved big cars saw the world as dangerous, and had fantasies of cutting through the hordes with a powerful vehicle. Rapaille’s methods are somewhere between the usual consumer panel interviews and guided meditation, so it’s hardly scientific, maybe more like poetry, but I found it compelling.

Musk actually tried to demonstrate the Cybertruck’s resistance to guns and sledgehammers. Its actual durability is, I gather, more debatable, but he was definitely trying to reach people’s darkest fears and impulses.

neilk··on Do not use secrets in environment variables
That’s what 1Password means, right? If your credentials to 1Password leaks all you have to do is change that one password. Problem solved! /s
neilk··on Mark Zuckerberg Is Done with Politics
As with all stories about powerful people, you need to read this as “Mark Zuckerberg wanted a major news outlet to say he was being neutral in the US election”.

In a definition of “neutral” that only a Silicon Valley CEO could embrace, this article seems to be saying that misinformation will be less policed on the platform and he will be more friendly to Trump.

The article even attempts to pre-apologize for this 40-year old billionaires political choices, framing them as innocent (he’s really a nice progressive libertarian, really) and that he feels so hurt by criticism.

We really have to stop thinking of Zuckerberg as a naive youngster. It’s appropriate to treat his statements with skepticism. I don’t know anything about the man other than what I read in books or news, but many Silicon Valley CEOs are lining up behind Trump because they expect him to regulate them less. The only difference with Zuckerberg is that he seems to prefer to appear above the fray.

neilk··on Mozilla is hiring for positions in Gen AI and Ads
jwz’s decision to leave tech and sell beer looks better and better.
neilk··on The Mystics of Progress (2023)
The author is a Catholic conservative and considers classic science fiction as failed attempts to replace transcendent, divine purpose with mere scientific progress. And yes, I agree with a lot of that. Authors like Arthur C. Clarke, are obviously looking for some new form of transcendence - it shows up again and again, from Childhood’s End to 2001.

It’s well-written and sincerely felt. But like a lot of conservative tracts, for me, it only makes sense if you already feel as the author does. If you have a deep longing to be a soldier obeying divine commands it’s obvious, obvious, that Star Trek is hopelessly inadequate. If you imagine that once upon a time, the universe was well-ordered and filled with light, then of course the grey present is disappointing.

I had a look at other works by this author. He is particularly ticked off by how “wokeism” infects everything now, especially his beloved sci-fi/game universes. For him, the loss of transcendent meaning in culture is intimately bound up with the traitorous inclusion of women in some aspect of Warhammer that I honestly can’t be bothered to investigate.

On a personal note, I too was raised in a very Catholic environment. I do not understand the nostalgia. The worship of science may have produced gods that failed. The gods of religions like Catholicism not only failed, but were never there at all.

The thing that this author apparently cherishes the most - a childhood with exciting visions of the future - is itself a product of modernity. There was no sheltered childhood, no books and stories made particularly for the imaginative adolescent, before the modern period. In the bleak husbandry of Christian religions, women, children, and lesser peoples were property.

TLDR if the Catholic Church was able to run things the way they truly want, you wouldn’t have Warhammer or video games at all. They’d have slapped you upside the head, given you a book of the lives of the saints, and told you to say thirty Our Fathers in penance for wanting anything more.

neilk··on Launch HN: Hamming (YC S24) – Automated Testing for Voice Agents
Why “Hamming”? As in Richard Hamming, ex-Bell Labs, “You and Your Research”?
neilk··on Does the success of LLM support Wittgenstein's position that "meaning is use"?
Not really. Wittgenstein wasn’t making the radical claim that words just float around in utterances, with no connection to ideas in a human mind.

He saying that language doesn’t reduce down to simple “atomic” forms, as he had previously thought. Much of speech is embedded in context in the way we live. You couldn’t take “I CAN HAZ CHEEZBURGER?” and reduce it down to something just by looking at the words and their relation to each other. The person using this statement is certainly not saying “For all elements of the set cheeseburger, there exists in the set of all possible futures one element which is proper to the set of elements identical to myself”. They are invoking a context, a mode of thinking, even a shared memory. This is why the meme is hilarious in some contexts, but would be utterly unintelligible in others.

The existence of LLMs does not provide support for Wittgenstein’s theories, which are more about observing humans - it’s sometimes described as an “anthropological” theory of language. The fact that it’s an impersonal process doesn’t add much. Humans can find random poetry assembled with fridge magnets meaningful too, but that says little about the nature of language.

PS Also, it’s well known that embeddings do seem to have a kind of “conceptual” relationship to each other. Famously some people find that the vector difference of king->queen will usually be related to man->woman. So, in some bizarre high dimensional way they do sort of have concepts. And given enough data they also have contexts. It’s extremely unclear if this is analogous to how humans actually think, but maybe LLMs have some facilities that are similarly powerful.

neilk··on StreamVC: Real-Time Low-Latency Voice Conversion
You’re getting downvoted perhaps because people think you’re saying something political, but I think you mean “a stronger voice for people with physical issues producing speech”.

I have a friend who has a faint, scratchy voice because his throat is riddled with benign growths that a surgeon has to dig out of him every few years. Eventually he will probably lose his voice. Maybe?

neilk··on StreamVC: Real-Time Low-Latency Voice Conversion
Right. I thought of that too, but it doesn’t mask accents, at least not yet

I suppose if you could make agents all sound the same they would be interchangeable, and companies always love that. It’s Anjali or Ligaya or Dolores but now they all sound like “Becky”?

neilk··on Follow the Crypto
“Dwarf” was my word, not hers.

Even so, if you click through she has another page that lists hybrid PACs. I have no idea if even that is the full picture; US politics are complicated. The project is open source so perhaps you can submit a PR to make it better.

neilk··on Follow the Crypto
Molly White’s latest project, tracking political contributions of the cryptocurrency industry. White’s data shows these PACs dwarf even much larger industries in this political cycle.
neilk··on StreamVC: Real-Time Low-Latency Voice Conversion
What are the anticipated use cases?

I know of one: transgender people often would like to alter the timbre of their voice and spend a lot of time training their voice. At least for online scenarios, this can just do it.

But other than that AI voice altering research seems like it benefits mostly scammers? I’m just wondering what they tell themselves they’re doing. I didn’t see this in the paper.

neilk··on Advantages of incompetent management
Sure. Thanks for the color, but let me add some shape.

Perhaps you saw some confirmation of "ruthless meritocracy" in my post. You could not be more wrong. Most people in the organization I am describing would have been rejected as undistinguished weirdo losers from flyover towns. Our strength was that we supported each other.

I personally do not think that market discipline or financial incentives have much to do with producing excellence. At best, those systems can notice, after the fact, that something wonderful has occurred, and that it might be worth bringing to a larger group of people.

neilk··on Advantages of incompetent management
All of this is true but... at what cost?

I have worked for a company where the ethos among the workers was very high, but management was exceptionally incompetent at managing. Zero people skills, and deeply skeptical that people skills were even necessary. (Many companies founded by hackers are like this.) So the CEO and CTO asked people to do things, but did no process management at all and just waited for them to be done.

This worked a lot better than you would think. We had hired people who believed in our mission, and mostly people do want to do what's asked of them. Our codebase was pretty lean, even boring, because there was no incentive to do any promo packet type spectacular development.

Projects sometimes took a long time, but they did get done.

But this stops working when you have projects that require coordination between people with differing incentives. Teams grow tired of waiting for the other team to do their half, so mistrust begins to become endemic. In the vacuum, all your hacker ICs grow fatigued and start doing more "interesting" things just to amuse themselves, because, who's really watching them?

TLDR benign neglect, even under ideal conditions, will eventually be a problem. The company's progress becomes slower and slower, and may even start sliding backwards according to some metrics.

neilk··on Why Triplebyte Failed
Rachofsunshine: for what it's worth, I appreciate that there are people who insist on trying to change the market, rather than doing what the market wants.

I did some early interviews with TripleByte and appreciated they were trying something different.

It's just a different kind of effort and it's hard to change people's minds with just money. Often, a grassroots movement arises that slowly changes consensus, over years, and only then some well-funded player can come in, see which way the trends are going, and capture the value. My current startup is so remote we had to move Friday meetings to Thursday to accommodate Japan and Oceania. In my experience the Silicon Valley practices of the 2000s and 2010s already seem antique.

So maybe TripleByte they were just early? Or as the post mentions, maybe the funding environment was wrong.

We are often told that a loose funding environment encourages new ideas to prosper. But whatever happened in the 2010s with ZIRP seemed to concentrate wealth for people who had already gotten through various gatekeepers. I am sort of in the Silicon Valley ecosystem and sort of not, working remotely for American companies, so this stuff just feels like a distant thunderstorm to me. I can see new graduates getting my salary or higher for doing very basic, mistake-laden work, and I can't figure it out. But this helps put it in context.

Anyway, perhaps a downturn is a better time to start trying to change minds, although that's going to be a very long battle and the TAM is going to be "???" for quite a while.

neilk··on All the remedial classes in one place
The nail salon thing is a stereotype in North America, but maybe not relevant in other countries.
neilk··on BASIC turns 60
I read a book called A People's History of Computing in the United States, which wildly oversells itself, it's just a history of Dartmouth Basic and the culture surrounding it.

https://www.hup.harvard.edu/books/9780674970977

But even then it was very interesting! The philosophy was that anyone could program, and they really did build a culture of amateurs writing programs that answered their own needs. The author has access to a lot of ephemera from that time which gives some flavor of what it was like in the lab.

And then, BASIC culture spread by unlikely methods, like the Pillsbury Dough company. No, really. For whatever reason they got involved allowing local schools in the midwest to time-share with their big mainframes.

neilk··on Quacker News
It's literally just ChatGPT told to sound like n-gate. The prompt begins:

> Create a humorous and mocking summary in the style of n-gate.com.

https://github.com/dfeldman/quackernews/blob/1d7591338579162...

neilk··on Jeff Lawson buys The Onion
According to your comment history you’re a leftist who, among other things, supports Kyle Rittenhouse. I would say this is a rare configuration of positions.

The point you’re making about Collins suffers because you only labelled him an “extreme leftist”, over and over again, without examples of this behavior. So I went looking, myself. Apparently he was pulled off Twitter coverage because he made posts mocking Elon Musk for suspending the accounts of other journalists. While this might be too opinionated for a professional whose beat includes Musk, it isn’t evidence of “extreme left” views.

> Collins has been yanked off the air from NBC and MSNBC but remains on staff. He has been actively tweeting and retweeting the latest developments related to Musk’s controversial decision to ban the accounts of several left-leaning journalists who were critical of his management of the social media app.

https://nypost.com/2022/12/16/nbc-suspends-ben-collins-for-m...

I hope you will concede that the NY Post has not yet fallen to left-wing extremism.

Labeling critics as “extremist”, without evidence, and attempting to make it stick through sheer repetition, is itself a tactic of extremists.

neilk··on I now lack the juice to fuel the bluster to conceal that I am a simpleton
I went looking for more Padget Powell; in particular I wanted to hear his voice. This one is pretty good.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=69cvhp6h2cc

In the interview he also uses "made-up people doing made-up things", so this was not an nonce invention. Perhaps he uses the phrase when teaching literature. Also I would not judge him for this, every person who is frequently interviewed learns to deploy a few stories and phrases that have a reliable effect.

neilk··on The dangers of single line regular expressions
looks like we both updated our answers as we looked up the docs :)
neilk··on The dangers of single line regular expressions
In my experience `$` does reliably mean end of string for regular expressions, unless you specifically ask for "multiline" mode.

Ruby seems to be in multiline mode all the time?

    $ python -c 'import re; print "yes" if re.match(r"^[a-z ]+$", "foobar") else "no"'
    yes
    $ python -c 'import re; print "yes" if re.match(r"^[a-z ]+$", "foo\nbar") else "no"'
    no
    $ python -c 'import re; print "yes" if re.match(r"^[a-z ]+$", "foo\nbar", re.M) else "no"'
    yes

    $ perl -le 'print "foobar" =~ /^[a-z ]+$/ ? "yes" : "no"'
    yes
    $ perl -le 'print "foo\nbar" =~ /^[a-z ]+$/ ? "yes" : "no"'
    no
    $ perl -le 'print "foo\nbar" =~ /^[a-z ]+$/m ? "yes" : "no"'
    yes

    $ node -e 'console.log(/^[a-z ]+$/.test("foobar") ? "yes" : "no")'
    yes           
    $ node -e 'console.log(/^[a-z ]+$/.test("foo\nbar") ? "yes" : "no")'
    no            
    $ node -e 'console.log(/^[a-z ]+$/m.test("foo\nbar") ? "yes" : "no")'
    yes

    $ ruby -e 'if "foobar" =~ /^[0-9a-z ]+$/i then puts "yes" else puts "no" end'
    yes
    $ ruby -e 'if "foo\nbar" =~ /^[0-9a-z ]+$/i then puts "yes" else puts "no" end'
    yes
EDIT: this is documented behavior for Ruby. What other languages call multiline mode is the default; you're supposed to use \A and \Z instead. They do have an `/m` but it only affects the interpretation of `.`

https://docs.ruby-lang.org/en/master/Regexp.html#class-Regex...

neilk··on I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B Israel contract
Yes, that is perfectly safe. And obviously so.

It may be upsetting, or disruptive to work, or a firing offense, but per your description nobody was in danger.

neilk··on Tell HN: We should snapshot a mostly AI output free version of the web
Using "before:2023" in your Google query helps. For now.

A few months ago, Lispi314 made a very interesting suggestion: an index of the ad-free internet. If you can filter ads and affiliate links then spam is harder to monetize.

https://udongein.xyz/notice/AcwmRcIzxOLmrSamum

There are some obvious problems with it, but I think I'd still like to see what that would look like.

neilk··on To make a fortune, target bored young men who want to make a fortune
Many young men are no longer trying to succeed within capitalism. They are trying to exit it.

Faith in this system is dwindling, and whatever your political inclinations, that is dangerous. Fewer people believe that putting in a solid eight hours of honest labor is going to assure a decent lifestyle. Gambling is one potential path out, maybe not even that irrational if you perceive it’s your only shot.

neilk··on To make a fortune, target bored young men who want to make a fortune
Out of curiosity I once went into a very small-time casino. I ended up at a blackjack table with various characters, one of whom was a single mom. She said she was playing to get money to buy the kids Easter chocolate. She was quite experienced and was up a few hundred dollars for a while. And she said that was it, she was leaving. And then she didn’t. And then lost it all. And then gained some back. And lost that too.

By the time I’d slowly bled away my $20 and gave up, she was still there.

neilk··on Embezzlers Are Nice People (2017)
According to the firm that redesigned the website in 2017, Lee Stimmel had written over 600 articles.

https://www.baydesignassociates.com/article/website-redesign...

Mostly relatively dry discussions, but they do seem a lot better structured than the average blog post, and (thankfully) not AI garbage. He is a good writer.

The story OP posted is tagged with "War Stories", and these do seem to be far more literary, with first-person perspective and novel-like dialogue.

https://www.stimmel-law.com/en/articles/category/lessons-com...

I suspect the same writer really has written all of these. It may be the actual person credited, Lee Stimmel, but it impossible to know if it's a ghostwriter without other samples of Stimmel's writing. But I don't think the technical details of the law would be well captured by a ghostwriter. There is a distinct change of style between both kinds of articles, but to me it feels like the same person writing.

neilk··on Embezzlers Are Nice People (2017)
I always thought the gentleman thief was a fictional character. Assuming this is more or less real (the detailed dialogue is a bit concerning) it’s fascinating.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →