HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

neilk

13,638 karma · joined April 7, 2007

http://neilk.net/

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/neilk; my proof: https://keybase.io/neilk/sigs/NR9GKkLDDu0NtBo9HqjKFJY0Ql_7e3CTfgxIbrZGJBs ]

submissionscomments
neilk··on Ask HN: I want to create IMDB for open source projects
OpenHub (formerly Ohloh) tries, or tried, to do this. Seems like it’s not getting a lot of love lately but perhaps you can learn from it.

https://openhub.net/

One useful feature is the ability to coalesce different identities. For example, I've released libraries on my personal accounts as well as through work. For a while I used to link there from my personal site since it nearly summarized that I’d made N thousand commits to OSS. But I stopped. I’m not really sure what the point is for me.

https://openhub.net/accounts/neilk

If it’s bragging rights, we have Github stars. Effectively (and sadly) open source is a resume building tool nowadays, so maybe that?

What use cases do you see?

neilk··on The Guide to Stock Options Conversations
There is no discussion of how the employees are the last to be paid, after founder class shares and investor liquidation preferences are settled.

Borders on misinformation to tell people that owning x% in shares equals x% of liquidity event. Even many founders end up with very little to show from an acquisition.

neilk··on Anatomy of a credit card rewards program
I don’t pay attention to “points” systems at all. I sense that this is the right decision but I’ve never been able to quantify whether this is true.

My logic is that the people who design credit card reward systems are smarter than I am about the topic they spend 8 hours a day on. So, every rewards system they offer is designed to trick me into suboptimal purchase decisions. Even the perception of beating the system is built into the system.

patio11 seems to confirm some of this, but I’d love it if someone who is informed about the design of these programs would say it to me straight. (Experts in “hacking” rewards systems will be disregarded because according to my thesis you are victims of mind control.)

For context I’m one of those never-carry-a-balance credit card users.

neilk··on Yahoo is buying Artifact, the AI news app from the Instagram co-founders
I wouldn't dream to speak for Maciej Cegłowski here. I would require a greater depth of literacy and far more Eastern European family history to achieve that level of sardonic commentary. But... I don't think he'd appreciate the reference.

https://twitter.com/search?q=from%3APinboard%20thiel&src=typ...

Pinboard, the product, should inspire a strategy that might be called Ten to One. Enter an app category which everyone has overspent on, wait for them to smash into the wall, and absorb their users into your self-racked server running PHP.

neilk··on Yahoo is buying Artifact, the AI news app from the Instagram co-founders
> It sounds like there’s also a good chance that Yahoo’s apps might get a bit of Artifact’s speed and polish over time, too.

This never happens. Good design isn’t a quality you can spread around. Speed and polish are the result of focus. In an acquisition by a big company, you’re expanding the number of people you have to work with, who all want to carve up your app into little pieces. Once you integrate with the bigco’s security, auth, ops, design language, branding, adtech, billing, matrix management, and this quarter’s initiatives, there’s no “speed and polish” left.

The best case scenario for retaining good design is that you’re bringing enough users/revenue that you get to be a Very Special Snowflake in the org chart. Or, if your acquired company outputs a software artifact for the rest of the company to use, like a search engine or database.

neilk··on Yahoo is buying Artifact, the AI news app from the Instagram co-founders
As Maciej always says, do not attempt to compete with Pinboard
neilk··on Ask HN: Who's getting their job applications rejected?
We'll probably just work our personal networks harder.

Personal networks didn't work as well during bubble/ZIRP times because everybody good was employed and either they already made more than what you were offering, or were holding out for a company that paid more.

Nowadays everybody knows someone good who has been laid off or is worried about being laid off. Or maybe they made major lifestyle changes during the pandemic and now they'd have to move a small family from Omaha back to the Bay Area.

As for screening questions, there's never going to be an automated way that detects AI or AI-influenced answers, for obvious reasons. There are countermeasures I have in mind but I'm not sharing them here.

neilk··on Ask HN: Who's getting their job applications rejected?
As someone who is trying to hire for server-side and devops roles, we are getting pickier. We have a lot of incoming.

A lot of it is spam and people who clearly are using AI to fill in our form. One applicant didn’t even bother to remove “ChatGPT:” from the answer.

Of the remaining applicants I do feel that even those with years of experience at big companies are kind of hothouse flowers. They are skilled at using complex and costly frameworks, but they are often missing what I used to think of as the basics.

A lot of those frameworks are themselves ZIRPs! I kind of think the current generation has been cheated a bit. If I were starting out today I don’t know how I would have learned anything.

We had a candidate who detailed some of their achievements at their previous employer, things like “I got this third party service to feed their logs into that third party service”. And they are not wrong, this was a titanic effort and they had to navigate complex change procedures to get it done. But… this isn’t what I’m hiring for.

Candidates are also under a lot of pressure. I read an application the other day which was clearly human-written, but they gave two or three word answers to essay questions. The answers were actually correct, just not with the kind of detail we wanted. But I imagine that we were one of ten applications the guy filled out that day. In this environment I don’t know how much time I can legitimately expect a candidate to spend on us.

neilk··on SBF repeatedly lied to get out of "supervillain" prison term, FTX CEO alleges
I need to understand where this quintillion thing comes from. This is not just higher than the current world GDP, but higher than the cumulative world GDP since the origin of our species.

Source: Our World In Data has estimates of global GDP since 1 CE. I imported the raw data into a spreadsheet, and did a rough integral. I added the year 300,000 BCE as an origin point with $0. I get 3.4e16 in 2017 dollars, a mere 34 quadrillion. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/global-gdp-over-the-long-...

neilk··on What is a pig butchering scam? (2023)
For my aging relatives I have set up code words to be used for actual emergencies, in case I'm impersonated over text.
neilk··on What is a pig butchering scam? (2023)
Millennials hold about 9%.

Fun fact: Mark Zuckerberg personally holds over 1% of that 9%.

(That is, he holds ~0.09% of all the wealth of US citizens, and happens to fall into the group of Millennials who as a group have ~9%. This from rough calculations and googling. There's an old reddit post that has about the same numbers. https://www.reddit.com/r/theydidthemath/comments/nbqfvn/requ...)

neilk··on The Best Essay
The original claim was not that geniuses and savants exist. They clearly do!

The original claim was that a genius should be able to easily and quickly attain mastery of any topic, given a grounding in the basics. Like, you give Mr. Super Genius IQ a book on quantum chemistry and the next day they’re putting things together so cleverly they are on the precipice of new discoveries.

Feynman actually did this a couple of times! But I think that just shows the “unreasonable usefulness” of mathematics, as well as his own spirit of curiosity. (And at least one time that we know of, he faked it by reading a colleague’s research before he presented it. Not to take credit, but just as a prank, so he could interrupt and predict every conclusion before the presenter finished.)

neilk··on The Best Essay
In my experience, this is more of a fictional trope than a reality.

There aren't any Tony Starks who become experts in thermonuclear astrophysics overnight.

Richard Feynman was as close to this trope as you can get in reality, but insisted that his reputation for being able to solve difficult problems was due to having a "different box of tools" than others. And he obtained that by studying rather obsessively, well beyond assigned texts.

I have been lucky enough to know a few people who also might qualify as geniuses able to produce miraculous results. One of them decorated his laptop with the logos of defunct computer companies of the 1950s-1980s. He drew a lot of inspiration from papers and books that few others have read in thirty years.

neilk··on Money bubble
I mostly agree but I have a few quibbles with some arguments.

For instance, Bray considers the adage "The CIO is the last to know". From the 90s until now, developers have always snuck new technology in without management approval. You put Apache on a forgotten Linux box in the corner because it's easy and fun, and a few months later the whole company relies on it. Developers are not rushing to deploy skunkworks generative AI solutions, so, the argument goes, probably generative AI isn't that good.

There's a couple of problems with this.

1. Not everything that is good can be deployed skunkworks-style.

It might be that AI is only really good with incredibly high up-front costs and extremely specialized developers. Like launching a satellite. You can't do it yourself with stuff you have lying around, and even if you had the money to do it you probably don't have the expertise to do it safely. But it's still extremely valuable!

2. Sometimes we are using this technology to hack up solutions to personal problems!

I had a video which I wanted my hearing-impaired father to watch. I could have paid a human or AI-powered service to generate subtitles, but I found that I could do it myself with OpenAI's Whisper, on an old laptop, and then munging text files together in the usual way. I was a little shocked that this worked offline. I could have done it on a plane. This absolutely fits into a hacker workflow.

neilk··on In Defense of Simple Architectures (2022)
https://www.wave.com/en/

Fintech targeting Africa

neilk··on In Defense of Simple Architectures (2022)
In this very comment page, there is a guy who flew Dan to a different city, just to hear this thoughts on random issues.

Also, if you look at his other writings, he's often noted trends in how software developers are paid. And the paradox that with even small tweaks, he's sometimes saved his employers far more than he could have earned in ten lifetimes. He's a free agent now... so why not charge what his advice is actually worth?

Dan is a very unusual person, in that he tries to do what is predicted by the data he has, rather than waiting for it to become conventional wisdom.

neilk··on Sora: Creating video from text
https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/sad-2
neilk··on Sora: Creating video from text
I think this analysis is flawed. New technologies are usually bad at substituting for things that already exist. It's 100% true this will not substitute for the existing genre of film and video.

New technologies change the economics of how we satisfy our needs.

When search engines became good, many pundits confidently predicted Google would never replace librarians or libraries. It didn't. It shifted our relationship to knowledge; instead of having to employ an expert in looking things up, we all had to become experts at sifting through a flood of info.

When the cost of producing art-directed and realistic video goes to zero it's hard to predict what's going to happen. Obviously the era of video = veracity is now over. And you can get the equivalent of Martin Scorsese and a million dollar budget to do the video instructions for a hair dryer. Instead of hunting for a gif to express how you feel, captured from an existing TV show or something, you could create a scene on the fly and attach it to a text message. Or maybe you dispense with text messages altogether. Maybe text is only for talking to computers now.

My personal prediction is that the value of a degree in art history is going to go way, way up, because they'll be the best prompt engineers. And just like desktop publishing spawned legions of amateur typesetters, it will create lots of lore among amateur video creators.

neilk··on Dean of Engineering at University of Nevada wrote a paper that’s bad
No paywall, but it’s not loading for me.

https://archive.ph/EZr39

neilk··on Tesla driver pulled over after wearing new Apple vision headset on highway
The latency of passthrough video through glass windows is really good. Like way less than 1ms. Also, they’ve figured out how the passthrough keeps working even if the device isn’t powered.
neilk··on I used to not worry about climate change. Now I do [video]
That’s too pessimistic. Dozens of countries have some kind of carbon tax right now. Important and influential jurisdictions like California, also have them. Even oil-producing regions have them.

They are universally rather timid in their scope, and politically fragile. So maybe they aren’t going to get us there, at least not in their current form.

But it’s going too far to say they just don’t exist or can’t exist.

We have plenty of treaties that inhibit states. Nuclear weapons, slavery, pollutants. Enlightentment and enlightened self-interest isn’t out of the question.

neilk··on I realized chess pieces can be redesigned to be geometric attack directions
Piece value is determined by how many squares it can threaten.

This is why rooks are worth 5 and bishops are worth 3, despite both having apparently equal freedom of movement (just rotated 45 degrees). The bishop will be able to access strictly fewer squares than the rook even in the best case, and usually much fewer. And the bishop is stuck on one color.

neilk··on The Failed Saint: On George Orwell's India
I’ll give you this: I was not aware of the Brownell-CIA connection at all, so thanks for that.

The common American perception of Orwell as anti-communist had something to do with that. But even if there had not been such a direct connection, that would have happened anyway. The Cold War made all political dialogue unidimensional for almost 50 years. Even today many people's minds are so shriveled they cannot encompass the thoughts of someone critical of both American capitalism and Soviet state communism - as your comments demonstrate.

Any serious examination of Orwell’s writing will show he was resolutely of the left. He was a socialist intellectual who was disdainful of the cultural fringes that the movement attracted. He largely romanticized the working class as naturally virtuous and with the right instincts for solidarity. In that way, and only that way, was he similar to right-wingers who dreamed of a return to pastoral tradition.

neilk··on The Failed Saint: On George Orwell's India
Orwell himself thought that his primary abilities were “a facility with words and a power of facing unpleasant facts”.
neilk··on The Failed Saint: On George Orwell's India
The article notes that Orwell’s father was an overseer of an opium farm in India.

You might ask if it was just for medicines. Nope, the British Empire was also in the drug business, and it fought two wars against China to keep the opium trade going.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opium_Wars

Setting aside the horrors and humiliations of colonialism (not to mention what came afterwards too), ultimately this is why Hong Kong and Shanghai are different from the rest of China. That has its effects on the technology industry even today.

neilk··on Google has no visionary leaders and a pervasive sense of nihilism
That comports with my observations. But there are still differences to explain. For example, we even have natural experiments across the Chinese internet and American/European internet. The outcomes aren’t entirely fixed in advance, and individual actions, personalities and values do matter, when something new is being created.
neilk··on Google has no visionary leaders and a pervasive sense of nihilism
To be clear, I think you can and should avoid a “pervasive sense of nihilism” at any organization. My quibble is with the people who think somehow Google should overcome this by finding their inner Googliness or tapping into founder magic. The solutions exist but they are hard work. They are probably more about abandoning illusions like that.

(The example of Steve Jobs might suggest that founders might have some magic after all. Maybe in this one way: he was a brutal editor and simplifier, and he was a good talent spotter. So if he had any founder magic it was _focus_, not some “spark” of indulging dreamy creativity.)

neilk··on Google has no visionary leaders and a pervasive sense of nihilism
How does this relate to Tolstoy? I don’t know much about him other than reputation as an author and moral reformer.
neilk··on Google has no visionary leaders and a pervasive sense of nihilism
I feel like no one is willing to face up to the obvious truth: founders are not magical, they’re lucky. There isn’t a magic spark that gets lost. They get lucky with breakthrough products. They are incredibly smart annd hardworking but also lucky. Even under ideal circumstances of fostering and developing new ideas, there is no reason to believe their luck will continue, no matter how much talent there is under one roof.

And this is not even considering the other structural barriers to innovation! The vast income streams create their own disincentives to disruption. Coordination is hard when you need to get buy-in of many departments. And despite best efforts, at scale, you end up promoting people good at politics or appearances. But even if all that were somehow eliminated, and true startup-style innovation was possible inside a giant company, the company must be careful to defend their existing winners.

If Google ever started to enter a death spiral like Apple in the 90s, maybe they could pivot if they were lucky enough to get visionary leadership. But now? Why would they?

I worked at Google briefly during the post-IPO period. It was a kind of wonderland, I won’t deny that. But all the really big hits were acquisitions or extensions of Google’s core competencies: search and ads. Everything else was unfocused and half-baked, and this especially applied to ideas that came directly from the founders. (Anyone remember Google Base?)

If you really want Google to return to those days you’d have to tolerate a lot of crap that gets abandoned later. (Which is the other complaint that people have about Google. Too experimental or not experimental enough, make up your minds!)

neilk··on I regret selling my startup
Like any engineer, I know more than a few instant-millionaires.

The ones who were capable of being happy before money continue to be capable of being happy. They had sources of self-worth outside of money, social connections outside the office or hanging with their startup bros, and interests that are intrinsically satisfying even if they are not profitable.

You don't need all of the above, but you do need at least one. The ones who don't have any of the above will go to dark places.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →