I keep them on a wooden stand on my desk, plugged into an Apogee Duet 3 interface.
152 karma · joined June 20, 2020
I keep them on a wooden stand on my desk, plugged into an Apogee Duet 3 interface.
The millions of children, teenagers, and adults who find inspiration in likes of Kobe Bryant, Serena Williams, Michael Phelps, Lionel Messi etc. might disagree with you. Many of us learn to be better from their ambition, discipline, leadership, etc.
These qualities become imprinted on young people who look up to these figures. In nearly every country, there are young people who see professional athletes as their greatest role models. Can you seriously say that creates no value for the world?
As an aside, elite athletes have refined the art of practice and study for their entire lives. I've learned more about the process of learning from interactions with them than anywhere else. If you don't think there's something to learn from this entire category of intelligence, you're missing out.
It would be wonderful to be proven wrong, but I have a feeling that we’re unlikely to see a perfect text generation system with no bias anytime soon. What perfect system exists in the world?
You seem to specifically have an issue with the Democrat vs. Republican leaning demonstrated in the article you linked. If the small bias that exists disqualifies your support for this wildly useful tool, then I suppose there’s not much that can change that. We’re left to hope that another model pops up soon whose biases are more favourable to you.
Other than the D/R bias, other biases seemed to correlate pretty well with protecting oppressed groups. Once again, under the premise that bias will always exist, I personally think that OpenAI has done a pretty good job at channeling that bias towards protecting groups that tend to be the subject of most hateful content.
But then, I’m also coming from a position of being supportive of good moderation. That’s why I like forums like Hacker News, and I suppose why we’re having this conversation at all. If I only saw utility in raw, unbiased, unfiltered text, I’d probably go read elsewhere.
I see far more instances from posters who are unhappy that ChatGPT won’t say something negative about women/POC/LGBT people, but will about men/white/straight, etc.
Personally, I don’t mind that ChatGPT is protective of systematically oppressed groups.
I have yet to see an example where it convincingly leans left on any sort of nuanced argument. If you or anyone else would be able to post an example, I think it would be an interesting addition to the discussion!
The article you linked specifically focuses on ChatGPT’s ability to generate hateful content.
It’s hard not to read what you’re expressing as “I won’t pay for it until it’s adequately able to generate hateful content”. There are a number of other domains where you might find it useful.
I'm sure many others here have followed note-taking/PL ideas for years, waiting for the one that will come along and give us superpowers. It feels like we're "so close"... all these tools/languages are almost the perfect blend of concise, expressive, interactive, etc.
It's occurred to me recently that we may already be among the last programming languages and note-taking systems to be built. We've tried for decades to design notes and code in ways that suit storage access patterns of our brains. I used to think that meant a breakthrough was inevitable, but now I'm starting to see the efforts having diminishing returns.
ChatGPT and its brethren are almost certainly the way forward for most knowledge storage (and the knowledge work that goes with it). The entire class of organization problems melt away when you can communicate in plain language what you'd like to store and retrieve. As chat assistants start to become more integrated in our work, the storage phase will become completely passive. The assistant will automatically accumulate the context it'll need when we come back to it for retrieval.
Why would we design new languages and note systems when, quite literally, a general-purpose second brain already exists?
I don't mean to discount the creativity and effort of all language and note system designers today. All exploration is valuable, and there are certainly better designs out there to be found. But the best designs don't always win, and we might just be at the point where the imperfect designs that have critical mass might be the ones that stick around forever.
How is a new Hacker News reader supposed to understand what’s considered unacceptable behaviour unless it’s called out? I don’t want a comment stream full of people unaware they’re about to violate a rule when they post.
Personally, I find dang’s feedback to be helpful and respectful.