HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

neonological

88 karma · joined February 12, 2021

submissionscomments
neonological··on How ayahuasca changed my perspective
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27027730
neonological··on The Animal Is Tired
The causative factor for the result of the surveys is kids.
neonological··on People who live past 105 years old have genes that stop DNA damage
First off nobody realistically talks about this. It's speculation. The topic at hand is talking about endeavors in the realm of reality. Not even mountains can last billions and billions of years, nobody is talking about immortality at that scale simply because it won't ever happen.

So if we're speculating here your argument is that boredom is a curse. At my age I'm already bored every single day of my life.

I'd rather be bored than be dead. But again this is speculation. I'd rather be bored for 50 years than die at 50 but would I be the same at 5 billion? Truthfully nobody knows. Even 50 Years is a long time to be bored but if you're not bored at 50 what makes you suddenly conclude that 5 billion is too much?

There's no evidence or weight behind this philosophy. Boredom does not equate to being cursed.

neonological··on How ayahuasca changed my perspective
>Materialism does not have an imperfect explanation of consciousness - it has zero explanation of consciousness.

First off zero explanation does not validate other explanations. Second off what you said is strictly false.

Much of neurology research operates on physically manipulating the brain through material means including brain surgery, drugs and even removal of certain aspects of the brain.

See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Split-brain

Subjects with Material damage to the brain where the connections between the two hemispheres of the brain are physically severed display behavior that is consistent with two consciousnesses existing in a single person.

This is physical evidence that your consciousness is tied to physical and biological material. It further implies that because this consciousness is material based that consciousness can be recreated by simply simulating the material structure that creates it.

See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Brain_Project

The blue brain project is a research endeavor with the first step goal of emulating a full mouse brain and consciousness on super computers by using models of cellular neurons.

This is real material based research on consciousness that is funded with a lot of money.

neonological··on How ayahuasca changed my perspective
Failure doesn't validate other forms of explanations.

Materialism is an imperfect explanation but imperfection is not a metric for reliability. Evidence is the metric for reliability and so far as imperfect as materialism is... it has the best evidence.

Moving to other explanations means moving to explanations with less or no evidence and therefore are at high risk of being false.

neonological··on How ayahuasca changed my perspective
Yes. By probability any attempt at an answer is absurd.

I have a giant box, guess what's in the box. I'm willing to bet 1 million dollars that any guess you make is wrong simply because there are too many possible things that could be in the box. Is that a reasonable bet? Yes.

I have a universe, guess what created it. I'm willing to bet 1 million dollars that any guess you make is wrong simply because there are too many possible things that could have created the universe. Is that a reasonable bet? Yes.

The agnostic makes a different bet. He says he doesn't know what's in the box but there's a 50% chance it's god and a 50% chance it's not.

The real probability is god is but a 1 out of infinite probability where the domain encompasses Bolzman brains and cosmic hippos. The better bet is to say it could be anything BUT god.

Anything but god yields a (infinite - 1)/infinite probability of being correct, aka 100%.

neonological··on People who live past 105 years old have genes that stop DNA damage
How is it logical to know living forever is bad when you there isn't a single person on the face of the earth who has done so? This is not a rational statement or philosophy. It is simply speculation as we have no evidence whether this is good or bad unless we talk to someone who has experienced it. Fundamentally speaking... no one has experienced this so we have no evidence FOR or against it.

Additionally "living forever" isn't invulnerable immortality where you are doomed to float around alive in the solar system long after the sun has inflated and pulverized the earth as a red giant... You'll still die well before that.

You can also always choose when to kill yourself, whenever. Logically any form of "living forever" described as a scientific possibility is actually more of a "you can choose when you die" or a "you can live much longer than normal"

neonological··on People who live past 105 years old have genes that stop DNA damage
I'm sorry but this is extremely weak none of this brings it anywhere close to 99%. This is youtube, a blog and reddit. Seriously.
neonological··on How ayahuasca changed my perspective
Enhancement is a matter of opinion. One man's enhancement could be another man's dehancement. So this is an unreliable metric. We cannot truly know which reality is more actual. The reality experienced while sober and the reality experienced while high. Whether one reality is enhanced is again a matter of opinion.

The key metric here to recognize is consistency. You give a thousand people psychedelics how consistent are there observations? Does every man describe the same thing? In addition how clear and exact are their observations?

Science and logic described by normal sober people is more consistent and more exact then the reality described by people on psychedelics. People who are sober generally agree on the basic principles of logic and mathematics. Consistent consensus is the diffentiating factor.

Additionally which drug better enhances the mind? Cocaine? Heroin? Bleach? Whose to say one experience under one drug is more enhanced than the other? This world described by drugs is cloudy and inconsistent not only among individuals but also across your drug of choice. So you not only have different descriptions of reality from different people, but different descriptions when they use a different drug. Which reality do I trust?

Trust in the consistent description of reality. It's the best bet in my opinion. But of course this also a personal choice.

neonological··on How ayahuasca changed my perspective
Grandiose rhetoric... Is the article itself not grandiose? God and spiritual experiences are grandiose topics. Take a very careful look at the language I used here dang. It's carefully worded to avoid personal attacks.

I'm willing to bet your being biased here and you can't see it. It is very hard to recognize in yourself without asking for personal opinions. I'm willing to bet that you personally highly highly disagree with what I wrote.

If I am right then I think it's quite likely you are completely unaware that your personal opinion influenced you to see what I wrote as grandiose because frankly this entire topic is grandiose. He makes grand claims about the nature of reality citing drug induced experiences as evidence, is that not grandiose?

neonological··on The origin of Covid: Did people or nature open Pandora’s box?
Did you read the article. The investigative group is compromised. The doctors who were part of the group have strong connections and even experiments running in the same lab.
neonological··on The origin of Covid: Did people or nature open Pandora’s box?
Why in your opinion is the lab leak so low in probability?
neonological··on The origin of Covid: Did people or nature open Pandora’s box?
Covid was discovered in Wuhan by an eye doctor who died. Experts of corona viruses did not "discover" the virus, rather other people in the same vicinity did. The hospitals where regular doctors work discovered it.

The virus was location tracked to the wet market which is Right next to this virology lab.

Now correlation does not equal causation. But correlation and common sense is strong evidence for causation.

Chemo therapy is correlated with cancer deaths. It does not mean chemo causes cancer. The common sense does not match up, but it does for covid and it is highly unwise not to consider this lab as the causative source of the pandemic.

neonological··on How ayahuasca changed my perspective
The article itself is about a man validating the truth behind his drug induced spiritual experience of god.

I can't use science to disagree with that opinion because it's religious flame war?

Then logically the article itself is instigating religious flame war.... He argues his side I argue mine.

I don't think your being impartial here. His post attacks my beliefs and I attack his in return who is instigating war here? Your saying he can attack my belief but I can't argue for mine.

Are you saying that if an article shows up on HN supporting logic and science and atheism no religious person can argue against it or offer their opinion?

neonological··on How ayahuasca changed my perspective
Do you trust a man experiencing a high or a "powerful experience" to drive? If such a man cannot be trusted to drive why should we trust anything that comes out of his mouth.

For all intents and purposes physical evidence points to a brain that is compromised and intoxicated.

There has been a lot of serious research into LSD. The research points to an intoxicated brain just as common sense does.

neonological··on How ayahuasca changed my perspective
You accept testimony from one man whose judgement is compromised by psychedelics and whose testimony will be inconsistent with others who believe in gods and spirits and do drugs and get high?

We cannot confirm which reality is real. The drug induced experiences or the reality you experience while sober. However when you talk to sober people they describe a reality that is consistent. A shared consistent reality with concreteness. All other descriptions are inconsistent. This man's experience is inexact and will no doubt be very different from what another man experiences when high on some drug.

Bet on the shared consistent experience. Science and logic and common sense is the shared and consistent reality and these things point to man whose brain cells and judgement have been compromised by drugs. You don't even trust a man high in drugs to drive, you gonna trust his judgement about reality itself? Don't be stupid.

neonological··on How ayahuasca changed my perspective
Do not mistake an open mind for an unbiased mind. A higher dimensional being is equivalent to the cosmic hippo in a tutu, prancing across the stars. One concept sounds absurd but both concepts have in fact the same level of absurdity.

The evidence of god, or higher dimensional beings is equivalent to the amount of evidence that exists for the cosmic hippo.

Both concepts do not have zero probability of existing but are you really open minded by being agnostic and considering the possibility of the cosmic hippo existing? I just made up the cosmic hippo, like just now. Zero material evidence exist for either concept. But we lend more credit to profound descriptions of god. This is human bias at work. Higher dimensional is a complicated word that is just as absurd as hippo in a tutu.

Agnosticism is not open mindedness it is closed mindedness because the logic behind agnosticism supports consideration of the cosmic hippo as a valid argument for existence.

The key insight is that all descriptions of god are equivalent in absurdity to the cosmic hippo and therefore agnosticism is an an absurd philosophy.

We do not know what created the universe. But because virtually zero evidence exists or hints at what created the universe I can safely say any guess you come up with is completely and utterly wrong. It's like guessing a number between 1 and 9999 trillion trillion. I can safely say if any human on earth made a guess about what this number is... They'd be wrong.

neonological··on How ayahuasca changed my perspective
All available evidence points to the materialistic viewpoint. You cannot trust your feelings or experiences. You cannot even fully trust science and logic.

However science and logic delivers more consistent results. You may feel like there's other "wavelengths" of reality when you do a psychedelic but everyone's experience is different. The only consistent experience most of humanity shares is the scientific and logical reality we experience when sober.

So as far as we know science and logic is the more accurate and consistent barometer. This man has a claim, his article does not give adequate evidence for that claim. In fact this article shows an intense lack of basic understanding of the nature of logic and science and it's relationship with reality.

If 1000 atheists did Ayahuasca will that change all their perspectives? Does a change in perspective or a the opinion of a brain compromised by an hallucinogen serve as accurate evidence? No.

Don't be stupid. Not even photographic evidence or a video of a god serves as adequate evidence.

If you have a clear perspective on the nature of logic, probability and science and it's relationship with reality... drugs will not change your viewpoint. These kind of experiences are only valid for people who have a lack of deep understanding of reality and the tools we use to understand it.

Let's just put it logically and plainly. If drugs compromise your brain and it's ability to drive and it's ability to perceive things than how on earth does a claim about god by a person on drugs serve as an accurate account? You don't trust a man high on some drug to drive, you're going to trust his opinion on God? Don't be stupid.

The man's description and judgement is compromised and I'm surprised and disappointed so many HN readers voted this up.

neonological··on The Blue Hole in the Red Sea is the deadliest dive site in the world
One part of being human is the ability to rationalize situations rather then be rational about the situation. Two very different things.

Our biases prevent us from recognizing this in ourselves ever.

Not saying you're rationalizing your behavior, but I'm saying it's a possibility. The only way to know for sure is to provide data to back up what you're saying.

What is your statistical risk profile based off of the conditions your provided?

neonological··on Dynamic Programming vs. Divide-and-Conquer (2018)
All recursion can be translated into a loop and a stack. In the tail recursive case you don’t even need a stack, a loop would suffice.

That means all divide and conquer algorithms can be implemented without recursion.

neonological··on The unreasonable effectiveness of print debugging
There's another methodology that Brian and Rob Pike miss.

Rather then stepping through a program. Add breakpoints and just step from breakpoint to breakpoint.

With a good IDE, adding a breakpoint and hitting a shortcut key is faster than a print statement and on the GUI IDE your debugging sessions are not transient.

The only time their advice makes sense to me is when I'm in an environment without a gui. Even then jetbrains has a "ssh full remote mode." However at my company I have found that this feature doesn't work under Nix (nix-shell) so we all just use print statements.

neonological··on Why we chose Elm for Humio’s web UI
You need to try elm. Elm is better despite not having everything you mentioned. I’m not a fanboy either. I just used elm for one project, but from that it’s already enough to know.
neonological··on Facebook gives money to America’s biggest news organizations
Anybody know of a good news source that doesn’t fall into this trap? I hear the economist is pretty good.
neonological··on There Are No Good Arguments for Intellectual Property (2010)
Mickey Mouse is obviously a loophole. The purpose of the law was not made to do this and the time limits are not unreasonable.

The problem you bring up is not a problem with the concept of IP. It is the problem of the exploitation of loop holes by lawyers and entities with enough money to pay these lawyers. It’s in the same class of problems as tax loopholes. You can’t ban the concept of tax simply because there are loopholes.

Not saying loopholes aren’t an issue. I’m just saying Mickey Mouse is an argument against loopholes, he is not an argument against the intent and purpose of Ip law in the US.

neonological··on Facebook deliberately made people sad. This ought to be the final straw (2012)
Like for example you’re clandestinely manipulating me right now. Everything you say is manipulation of me towards your opinion.

And you say it’s a cost paid by others? Can you give me an example of how I don’t pay the cost? Right you can’t because you didn’t know that I’m a user of Facebook. Logically it is impossible for you to know whether I “pay” for these costs or not.

Basically without knowing who I am you made up a lie out of thin air. There is no other logic that can explain what you just said as you know nothing about me. Is lying in itself not clandestine manipulation? Are you not lying in attempt to clandestinely manipulate me and others reading this towards your opinion?

You obviously have no skin in the game, you don’t even use Facebook, you’re just harping off about it because you don’t give a shit about freedom of speech at all.

Is the paragraph above true or a manipulative lie? Did lying like that make you angry? What about that garbage lie you made up about me? Is this the same brainless response and fury everyone is reacting to Facebook “experimenting” on us without deeper consideration?

Does me or you being angry about manipulative bullshit give either of us the right to clamp down on our right to say it? Should I have the right to call the police on you for making up shit and lying?

No. And honestly outside of the context of “giving you an example” I suggest you check yourself. The drivel coming out of your mouth is deliberately offensive. “A cost paid by others” is an outright lie made up for the express purpose of manipulation and inciting anger. Emotional manipulation is no less evil then experimental manipulation.

Careful what you do to your own freedom of speech rights... If you succeed, one day your ideas will be muzzling your own manipulative vitriol like a dog.

Perhaps I can call out to dang, have him come over and moderate this thread. No let’s make it so that the government can moderate Facebook, which then in turn means they can moderate you.

What do you think is the justification the CCP gives themselves when they moderate the entire internet in China? It’s the same justification you’ve given me, they seek to moderate clandestine manipulation.

neonological··on Facebook deliberately made people sad. This ought to be the final straw (2012)
No but when you restrict clandestine manipulation you restrict freedom of speech. Giving the government such power gives them the oversight to use the "clandestine manipulation" excuse on other things as well.

Like I said, not so clear cut. It's a complex world we live in. But I get why someone would vote me down. It's easier to see everything in terms of black and white. The truth, however, is grey.

Take freedom of religion for example. Freedom of religion allows cults like Scientology to form. If we allow the government to have the power to eliminate Scientology what kind of power does it give the government over Christianity or Buddhism?

Personally my view is that the cost is worth the benefit, because the alternative is much worse.

neonological··on Facebook deliberately made people sad. This ought to be the final straw (2012)
This is a psychological experiment on me and all the users on this site and I am now outraged.
neonological··on Facebook deliberately made people sad. This ought to be the final straw (2012)
No it's not a crime against humanity, let's not go that far and let's not unreasonably promote cancel culture by burning the witch at the stake before giving the issue some deep thought.

It's a much more complicated issue then you describe. Many corporate organizations have been selectively distributing information to deliberately influence sentiment for decades. Facebook is not the first nor will they be the last.

Restricting any entity from doing this is a complicated issue that has to do with restricting freedom of speech.

Fox news comes to mind when I think of another organization that does this deliberately. To add more complication to the issue one should consider the fact that the success of Fox news can also be attributed to it's customers: people. People choose what they want to hear, and many people prefer news viewed through a biased right leaning lens.

Just like how the above poster wants to paint this issue as a crime against humanity, I think part of the problem is that on some level we all want to lie to ourselves. We want to view the world in a very specific and certain black and white way.

neonological··on There Are No Good Arguments for Intellectual Property (2010)
No what you said is completely wrong. Publication is not required for an exclusive monopoly it is only required for a patent.

There are many many monopolies and oligopolies over products that are enforced without patents or use of intellectual property laws.

Oil was an example of a oligopoly enforced by geography. OPEC.

The f35 is a publicly and internationally distributed product for which a monopoly by lockheed is obtained by unparalleled and uncopyable technical aptitude crystallized into the product itself. This as well as astronomically high costs, and trade secrets help make sure very few entities can copy the product.

The only incentive for highly complex products to exhist in the market place is the ability to monopolize the product to a certain extent. What is the point of selling the product if anyone can make it?

The point is that there are barriers of entry that every business uses to stay relevant. A patent is simply one barrier in a toolset of economic barriers.

Make no mistake, the monopoly google holds over search has fundamentally the same economic effect as a patent. Same with monopolies held by facebook, uber and apple all held without patents.

neonological··on There Are No Good Arguments for Intellectual Property (2010)
Many IPs likely wouldn't even exist if the 10 year monopoly didn't exist.

Yeah they patented some parts of DNA and there was a huge debate over it but that patent is almost expired now so the whole debate eventually becomes irrelevant.

It's worth it.

← PreviousPage 4 of 11Next →