Some vague “ a probing speculative mind” is not a good definition for a field of study. It’s way to broad and lacks preciseness.
88 karma · joined February 12, 2021
Some vague “ a probing speculative mind” is not a good definition for a field of study. It’s way to broad and lacks preciseness.
You have a limited fuzzy understanding of science and I believe it is interfering with how you interpret the fusion of philosophy and science how it generates category errors.
Yeah I can meta the entire universe together if I wanted to. What’s the set of all things that can be talked about? Metaphysics and the Milesian school of thought are both elements in that set. There’s no point in this categorization however compelling you find the arguments within their respective fields.
Religion from certain perspectives is just made up stories. Should these made up stories be made into a field of study that is a sibling branch of science? Call it the study of religion or made up stories, no point in calling it a philosophy and giving it the same weight as science.
Sure if you classify all deep thought as philosophy then any argument against philosophy that is deep is in itself philosophy. It’s just meta games with words no point in bringing it up.
Your argument basically says philosophy is an umbrella term for everything in existence. There’s no point for such a term that asks “what do we mean when we talk about x”. In fact such a term already exists without the pretentiousness. It’s called “definition” you can look up the definition of science and religion on Wikipedia. Does that make Wikipedia a philosophy web site?
I highly disagree with this.
A statement made on the basis of logic or science has more weight then any sort of random speculation made in “aesthetics” yet philosophy places them on equal grounds. There is a clear error in hierarchy here similar to the phylum based nomenclature in biology.
A lot of religious people ascribe to a religion because some aspect of that religion helped the in some way. Does this make all aspects of the religion the absolute truth? People following this flawed wisdom end up supporting creationism as the one and only truth. Are people doing the same thing with philosophy?
Sure you can learn logic from a philosophy class, but that logic cannot in turn explain why “aesthetics”, “religion” and “ethics” is a sibling philosophical field of study to “science”.
Can such speculations lead to real science? Sure. Does this continue to make the philosophy of religion and the philosophy of science being placed in the same “philosophy” bucket a category error? Yes. You can still speculate on science within science and you can still speculate on religion within religion. No need to classify both under “philosophy”
That documentary showed real knowledge on the ground. It literally filmed someone buying a knockoff from a mall that sold only knockoffs. Like come on, that’s as close to on the ground knowledge you can get. All I need you to do is explain where that knockoff in that video came from and why I see these knockoffs all over the place every time I go to Shenzhen.
The topic of this conversation is not about your disagreement with counterfeiting or not. I don’t care about whether you blame anyone or not.
The topic is about whether or not such an industry of cheaters exists in China. Your initial claim is that they don’t. My claim is that not only do they exist but they’re everywhere in China. The entire Chinese culture is all about scams and the people buying and selling pirated goods play a huge part in this culture.
Science and logic attempt to describe something central to the universe while religion and aesthetics are central to only the human experience. To place the two in the same box is a huge category error akin trying to scientifically derive creationism.
Philosophy is essentially just a mish mash of deep thoughts and ponderings of unrelated topics. There is no deeper overarching connection here. Academia came to realize later that certain deep thoughts were “better” then others and formalized those deep thoughts into math and science.
Historically things like science and math and logic comes from “philosophy” but ultimately philosophy is just an old way of thinking in the sense that we as humans now have enough information to understand that aesthetics, religion and science don’t belong in the same category. Philosophy is a outmoded concept that only is still around for the same reason technical debt in software is still around.
The inevitable philosophers response to this is that all experience is technically human in nature. We cannot experience the universe without human bias injected into the observation thus it is not a category error to place Christianity in a field side by side with number theory because it’s all human made up stuff anyway.
To which I respond that all of academia is structured around hypothetical axioms. We can’t prove anything is real but we assume it’s all real. We can’t prove that there is any other way to experience the universe outside of the human experience yet we still assume and structure our science such that the human experience is not central to the universe. Our observations of the universe lead us to believe that the human experience is just a random phenomena in the corner of some galaxy and that is the best available information we have. To discuss anything outside of what we know is like trying to ask someone who is born blind to describe color.
Sure I may buy stuff if it's more convenient. But that's not the issue here. The issue here is that I and many others are capable of cheating and won't shy away from it if a viable opportunity presents itself. Same with pretty much a good chunk of people in China.
I can assure you that thing is not hand made. It's coming out of a factory. Your anecdotal evidence pales in the face of visual evidence and information distributed by a wired documentary.
Whether you or your friends buy knock offs doesn't change the fact that a huge industry of cheaters exists.
I think you haven't been to the States. What you may consider "normal" is actually far off from what happens in the west. The western perspective on China: https://youtu.be/5ncOyYzOP3w?t=274
I'm not poor, far from it, yet I still use stremio to stream movies just as conveniently as netflix without paying a dime. It's wrong. There is no way to justify what I'm doing. Yet me and many other people both in America and in China use the app without the need for justification.
Don't think that the guilt you feel is something other people feel. I can assure you I feel nothing.
It's unfortunate, I recognize it's wrong, but at the same time... I don't actually care.
You can vote me down, but I'm being candid here. There are tons of people like me and most of them won't be candid about there apathy towards piracy, so this is a window into our mindset if you're a person who can't relate. If you want to make the world a better place you need to account for bad actors in any model because they can never be fully eliminated.
Some are legit parts. Many are pirated. There's even android phones sold under the apple brand with a reskinned android OS. You 100% don't know what you're talking about at all. You want proof? Watch it:
https://youtu.be/e4wbFdePb-k?t=278
The more you watch the more educated you'll be.
>Look at the iPhone sales figure from Apple, and look at android sales numbers. And you are trying to suggest that "the rest of China" buys a counter fake iPhone? You are either dishonest or you know nothing about China.
Yes. Dude. In China they have entire factories that build counterfeit stuff.
>And the worst part of your story is that you attribute what you did to something not yours, so you don't have to take the responsibility of your own behavior. It is wrong.
This is where you're wrong. I never admitted or justified what I was doing as right or wrong. In fact I think it's wrong. I'm human and I'm not perfect. I'm very capable of doing things that are wrong. The difference between you and me is that I don't have to lie to myself about the reality of what I'm doing. I don't have to justify it to myself. It's wrong, but I do it regardless without lying to myself. There are moral lines I don't cross, but I'm no boy scout.
If you can't see that pirated goods are rampant in China than you're lying to yourself. Stop lying. Accept reality for what it is, don't let national pride blind you from the absolute truth.
The cultural attitude I talk about dominates most of the culture in china. You walk into shenzhen not only is software pirated but entire phones, products and hardware is pirated and sold publicly. It's completely normal in china. Not to mention many people are proud of their own businesses.
Whatever your experience is I feel you're telling it from within some social strata that is largely different from the rest of china and this is only a minority opinion.
Like the author I say this in the most non judgmental way possible.
Though there is one truth that is inevitable that the author glosses over just like many do when talking about global warming. It’s hurtful but I have to say it.
The worst case scenario of China being the dominant global economic super power is the most probable outcome of the future.
The entire country is a country of scammers where the rules of the game are to cheat as much as possible. Like the article said, literally think of yourself as a member of a gang where killing people gets you “street cred”. Cheating is an aspect of street cred for Chinese people.. if you cheat and get away with it, it’s something to be proud of. The Chinese will ‘lie’ to authorities about cheating, but among friends it’s high fives all around.
How do I know this? I’m Chinese. Born in the states but with ties to the east. I don’t know if it’s genetic or if it’s cultural but growing up I never purchased a single game or purchased a single movie or piece of music and I was proud of cheating the system. In fact me and many people in Asia think you’re stupid if you pay money for any form of electronic digital media when all of it can be pirated easily.
This is the mentality of basically most of Asia with the exception of Japan and to a lesser extent Korea.
I get your mentality though. The rules of US culture is basically fairness. It pervades the mentality of the country but you have to understand different games have different rules. For example in mafia the name of the game is to deceive everyone. Deception is therefore praised and you are proud if you win the game via deception. Just like how a simple game can flip a switch so can culture. China is playing mafia while the US is playing chess.
Just replace all available energy with a free triple A battery gifted to you by the government per day. That battery can’t even push your car 100 meters. If you can’t drive then the suburban layout of US cities can’t even function. Every aspect of the economy will grind to a near standstill.
Energy is the primary resource that drives everything in an economy, everything. Because energy is limited the game in every economy is in actuality overall zero sum.
Because energy is relatively abundant right now, certain models of the economy sort of do work for certain scenarios when they don’t account for energy. But I think these models are still bad because, practically, even differences in energy utilization correlate with how technically advanced an economy is.
Once energy is used up, then all economies are basically dead. There is no positive externality here. Every economic transaction involves energy and is thus zero sum. If the United States uses up all the oil in the world to build its advanced economy then other countries and people in the future and past cannot build that same economy because there is no oil. Zero sum.
A generalist practitioner in the case of a Doctor isn't really a specialist. You need additional schooling to specialize. So a specialist technically knows more than a "general practitioner" for doctors. For this context, a generalist refers to someone who specialized in more fields than one. So a brain surgeon and a cancer specialist would be more general than someone who only does brain surgery.
>How many subfields does a mechanical engineer need to be competent in before they can be labeled a generalist?
Don't know. It's not formally defined. But it has got to be more than one.
>What about lawyers?
Same as above, I guess.
This is what you said about my penchant to use quotation marks. There's not a single person on the face of the earth who won't find that rude.
It's subtle but it's akin to saying "go learn English" or "go learn proper grammar" in the middle of a debate but disguised as a "suggestion." You can't even say that garbage to a person who speaks English as a second language.
It's a low blow and I'm calling you out for what you are. You did that on purpose and you are a rude person. Your initial apology is therefore not accepted because I know it's fake.
We're done. I have no interest in continuing a conversation with you.
I'm not saying they were specialists, I'm saying these people were competent.
Most people are only competent or a specialist in one of these fields.
Does that make every CS student a generalist? No. The generalist must have competent capability to be hired in several of those fields.
Design patterns is a unique phenomenon in programming. No other field is pretentious enough to refer to domain specific vocabulary as design patterns.
Land is made more scarce then it actually is. We all live on land so there is plenty to go around. The artificially induced scarcity comes from the fact that people live on land they don’t own. For this to happen it means Certain people own more land then they need. The extra land is not owned for personal utility, it is bought so that another person has no choice but to pay you money to use the land.
Everyone would jump into the market if they could. The reason why they don’t is because you need to front a lot of money to buy property. So if a house costs a million I can just buy the house and rent it out. I didn’t lose the million because I can always resell the house and I gained rental income on top of that. What prevents people from executing this strategy is that they don’t have 1 million dollars. For a loan, barrier to entry is lowered to the down payment.
It’s not a necessary evil. The most successful economies today involve a combination of capitalism and socialism. An aspect of the economy, like property can be enforced to be made fair. It’s never been tried but in no way would I call it a necessary evil. Either way I benefit from this evil so I’m against it.
You don’t understand because your reasoning is off. Owners of capital are protected from inflation because most owners of capital don’t own cash. Inflation is a phenomenon related to cash lowering in value. Owning assets that are not cash tends to make inflation not apply. Poor people tend to own cash and rich people tend to own assets, hence during inflation poor people tend to lose. Poor people continue working hard while their salaries stay the same and get inflated. The work that they do improves the worth of the company they work for. Who owns that company? The owners of capital. In short the owners of companies pay people less for productive labor.
Then a feedback loop occurs where laborers can no longer purchase as much from a company and the companies begin to lose as well. Overall the feedback loop hits companies later. Inflation hits the workers first during inflation.
But this is besides the point. My point is capital grows faster then productive labor. The main reason why this happens is because capital represents the output of productive labor in aggregate. This output in wealth allows owners of capital to easily climb over barriers for entry and purchase more capital. It’s like playing Texas Holdem, the more chips you have the more power you have.
I read your example, transfer of knowledge is a separate issue. The shock to immediately changing a system also can have bad side effects. I’m not suggesting that the current status quo should be fixed either, nor am I suggesting there is a easy solution. I am saying that in the status quo I benefit from money gifted to me by my tenants while contributing nothing to the economy.
Too put it tersely some people on HN throw under the cover insults by being subtly condescending so as to not trip any red flags and get warned by the admin. For example, like suggesting I look up the purpose of quotations.
Don’t play games, I hate that stuff and while manipulative under the cover insults can get around Dang’s filter it really goes against the spirit of HN.
Cheers.
I disagree. These people are just specialists in web dev. The knowledge within web development is diverse and actually easy to learn but it does not make you a generalist.
You are a generalist if you have knowledge about different fields within software engineering.
So for example, if you’re good at:
machine learning and writing compilers,
doing operating system development,
front end development with react,
OpenGL/Vulcan development with c++,
Database development.
then you are a generalist.
Generalists are truly rare. specialists in compiler development are also rare. Specialists in web development are abundant. Practically every show HN is some sort of website.
The reasoning has the potential to change the way you think about his claim or it has the potential to be completely wrong. But the context of the situation makes it so that you cannot ignore the potential.
Scarcity is not the issue here. Energy is the issue. This is where you lack intense knowledge.
In every scenario you describe energy was used to compress the air and place it into the canister. That it productive work.
For air and land in your typical scenario, there is zero productive work. This is what I'm referring too. Your scarcity argument is off topic. Nobody is talking about that scarcity in your sense. What we are talking about is artificially induced scarcity. By owning air, and owning more land that I need, I artificially induce scarcity and force people to pay me rent to live off of land I don't need and contributed nothing to the economy in exchange for economic gain.
The important factor here is that each instance of artificially induced scarcity sets up a scenario where the person who owns capital does not have to contribute to the GDP in order to benefit from the profits coming out of the asset. I'm not going to be paying a dime for the house I currently will own or sell. I am simply using a complex financial tool, to redirect wealth towards me.
>I already described some criteria for unfair transactions: compulsion or deception. You could also make arguments that if one side captures nearly all the economic surplus, the transaction is unfair (generally maintained via government-enforced monopolies limiting competition).
What do you think is going on when "one side" owns property that can house 400 people and just rents it all out? Also who do you think actually allows one person to own more property than they need or to even own air if such a concept existed? The Government.
>Rather than trying to assert Adam Smith's obsolescence, you should probably try googling "Adam Smith landlord". I expect you'll like the quotes. (I'd recommend learning more about the context more than just the quotes, but hey, it's the internet).
What do you mean trying to assert? You're the one talking about an invisible hand in a world that is clearly not auto-magically heading towards equilibrium. Nobody and I mean basically nobody deciding economic policy and nobody in academia thinks this stuff is relevant in the discussion of a modern economy. If you knew what you were talking about you'd realize that I'm not asserting anything. I'm just restating the assertions of the rest of the world. https://hbr.org/2012/04/there-is-no-invisible-hand
Heck, why do you think the Fed exists if Adam Smith had any relevancy today? Why do you think bubbles and market crashes exist? Adam Smith is basically famous for being like Sigmund Freud. The Father of a modern academic field of study but still mostly wrong in the face of scientific evidence. By referencing him in a conversation about the modern economy makes you look like you don't know what you're talking about.
As for the quotes, it's not that I don't understand the context of "quotes" it's just that you're not quick enough to grasp the context of why I used the "quotes." See? I did again, let's see if you can kick that brain into gear and "grasp" why I chose to put the quotes around this "word."
You post basically declares every scientific or academic or professional field as "pattern languages."
Then you conclude to say.that there are books much more well put together then the gof book. I agree, like pretty much every axiomatic math book that proves each theorem starting from base axioms is more elegantly put together than GoF.
And none of these books have the pretentiousness to call what they're doing a "pattern language." The concept is unecessary and is only used by books that are actually very informal. The Gof book is essentially just "oop programming tricks" retitled to "design patterns" to sound more academic when in fact its so far from academia, most schools don't teach it as part of foundational computer science.
Also all the books you defined are informal and opinionated. Especially capital by marx. None of those books come close to the rigor of "pattern languages" established by even a basic math book on number theory.