HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

neonological

88 karma · joined February 12, 2021

submissionscomments
neonological··on Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay
Does this model include energy that continuously decays into higher entropy states?

You need to model energy alongside an economy and population.

Logically, If you limit energy, you limit the size of the economy. Therefore, energy is an important variable in any economic model.

To not include such a factor in your model means your model is inaccurate.

neonological··on Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay
It is zero sum within the earth system because the energy is limited.

Trees compete for light. The taller trees win, the shorter trees are deprived of sunlight and therefore are the losers.

neonological··on Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay
Nah this is still zero sum. It's limited by the amount of watts we can reasonably extract from the 100 petawatts per day.

We use a fraction of the energy hitting the earth because we can only extract a fraction of it. In this case rate of replenishment functions as a limit. If our rate of usage exceeds the rate in which we can viably extract useful energy from the sun then that means not everyone can have access to this energy. This is a limit. Zero Sum.

If Energy truly was unlimited nobody would be paying for it.

neonological··on Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay
You have to go deeper and trace the products to the source of creation. Land, Water and Sun is limited if not by total supply then by rate of availability.

Simply by obtaining these resources others are deprived. The people who are deprived are the losers, the people who aren't are the winners.

neonological··on Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay
The point I am making is that the people making the transaction are not the losers in the game. You have to trace the origin of the product back to how it was produced and what limited resource was used to produce it.

The loser here is other person who could've potentially used that limited resource for his own gain.

neonological··on Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay
Yes and the person living in my shadow didn't get a sunburn as a result. Zero sum.
neonological··on Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay
I highly disagree with this. It may seem to you what I'm saying is pedantic but it is not.

The entire culture of the United States from all the art, to all the technology, to all the food to all the music is sustained by this same energy.

It is not sustainable for everyone in the world to use the same amount of energy that is used by the United States. This is literally the definition of zero sum.

In fact it is well known that entire civilizations have fallen because they've used up all available energy reservoirs. The most famous example is the Rapa Nui people on Easter Island. Easter Island collapsed because the situation was not only zero sum but even negative as high entropy energy is not useful to any participant in the game.

What people don't realize is that the economy is limited by physical actuality. It is not simply supply, demand and your limitless "imagination" on what you can potentially deem as "valuable". Supply and demand alone is a short sighted measure. The better metric for intrinsic value must include energy/entropy in the equation.

There is a limit and that limit practically effects everything around you.

neonological··on Dr. Seuss books deemed offensive will be delisted from eBay
Economies are zero sum. Your statement is a fallacy I see touted everywhere.

All economic products cost energy to generate and all energy is limited in totality by the available energy on earth.

When someone uses this energy, another person cannot use it.

This holds true even for the most abstract product. Say the economic product of poetry produced/sung by a poet.

The poet needs energy to sustain himself and the time needed to produce the poem. When he uses that energy, entropy increases and someone else now cannot use it.

That is zero sum.

The transaction you are describing is the equivalent of two people taking gold from limited reserves and trading that gold. The fact of the matter is, the gold is still missing from the shared reserve regardless of how fair the trade was.

neonological··on Twin sisters worth millions thanks to female gamers
Hey, stop being a creeper. Don't stalk my old posts, wtf.
neonological··on Twin sisters worth millions thanks to female gamers
Ok one more response. A Gender Identity by definition is more than just a verbal issue where the person cares only about getting identified as the word "He" or "She." When you identify with a gender you identify with certain "roles" and "conditioning" associated with a gender. See definition: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_identity

The two phrases "role" and "identity" are similar enough that within this context I can use the terms interchangeably.

Also please don't go like "I find it ironic that you..." or "I find it interesting that you..." or "I find it fascinating that you still believe..." or any of that kind of language like that. It's condescending and insulting and not to mention manipulative.

If you truly are open minded you'd talk to someone who shares a different opinion than you as an equal rather than refer to them as if you were observing some "fascinating" animal with "interesting" behavior that lives in a zoo.

That's it no more replies. Thread ends here. 100% I swear. Don't ban me, Dang.

neonological··on Twin sisters worth millions thanks to female gamers
I urge you to read the below: https://sites.psu.edu/evolutionofhumansexuality/2014/04/07/g...

TLDR: males castrated at birth and raised as females still had a male gender identity.

There is no controversy behind this in science. Most of this controversy exists in gender politics. But the politics is so strong one of my repliers just assumed I didn’t do any research when the opposite is true. Research indicates gender identity is biological if you don’t know this you didn’t do the research. You can still choose to hold a different conclusion then the entire scientific community... that is your right.

Now I’m not here to start a debate. I couldn’t resist replying to you but for the sake of not starting an off topic gender flame war and violating HN rules I’m not going to respond. Just read the evidence and take what you will from it is just information to add to your existing knowledge.

neonological··on Twin sisters worth millions thanks to female gamers
>If you don't feel like doing that, a good alternative is that you should not be definite about any of it.

I can be definite about anything I want. Additionally, how do you know I haven't already looked at the enormous amount of research?

Either way, the research supports my views in a pretty definitive way.

I'm just saying that game genres should cater to the definite biological differences in interests between men and women.

Do you disagree? Fine. I accept your disagreement. Let's agree to disagree and not let this turn into a gender flame war. I'm not going to reply this thread.

neonological··on Twin sisters worth millions thanks to female gamers
I remember when I was like 3 or 4 years old the themes of the pictures I drew were markedly different from the pictures girls drew. I drew pictures of warriors, ninjas, dinosaurs, jet planes, guns, swords, explosions and weaponry.

I noticed the girls always drew pictures of houses and family and I thought that was the stupidest thing ever.

So yeah it's definitely the genre, and dare I say definitely in part biological in origin.

neonological··on Trust: The Need for Public Understanding of How Science Works
Falsification in science is possible.

If I hypothesize that all zebras have stripes then observing one zebra with spots falsifies the entire hypothesis. This is definitive.

However, no amount of zebras that I observe with stripes can ever prove my hypothesis correct. I can observe 500 zebras all with stripes and at any point in time the 501st zebra can have spots. I can observe 1 billion zebras with stripes and the possibility still remains open that the next zebra I see has spots.

Science is not symmetric. Falsification is possible, proof is not.

neonological··on Trust: The Need for Public Understanding of How Science Works
> You seem to be very strong down the nihilism philosophy. I have a view point that nihilism isn't a useful philosophy & doesn't yield any particularly meaningful insights that help you find success in this world. It's very much, at least to me, of the same vein as the Omphalos hypothesis (also known as Last Thursdayism by atheists such as myself) which says "Sure sure. You've got all these fancy theories. But how do you know the universe wasn't created in its current state Last Thursday & so all your measurements are meaningless?".

What I'm talking about isn't a philosophy. This is the fundamental tenet as illustrated by academia. I'm not pulling this out of my ass. This is what educated scientists understand about science. If you don't know this you literally don't know what you're talking about. I am not arguing my opinion here, I am arguing the academic definition of science.

To prove it to you I'll literally quote Einstein:

  "No amount of experimentation can ever prove me right; a single experiment can prove me wrong."
If you don't understand why he said the above quote. You don't understand science in the same way a physicist or a scientist understands science. In fact the above was said in reference to Einsteins and newtons theories.

What einstien is basically saying is this. Science can never prove anything to be correct. It can ONLY falsify things.

>I'm always fascinated by people who claim that Einstein's theory of relativity somehow undermines the bedrock of scientific inquiry when it's 100% the thing that supports it. Newton's theories weren't wrong. They were 100% correct for the environments we were testing them in.

Your fascinated at the entire academic definition of science being different from your own personal definition? You're misunderstanding of science is the real enigma here.

Nothing is undermined. I'm not against science I am simply elucidating what science is to you in the sense that science can never prove anything to be true. Science can ONLY falsify things. It is a very limited tool, but it is also the only tool we have.

I'm an atheist like you, I get where your coming from. But you have not explored science deep enough. Look deeper into this as you are not understanding what is going on here. I am not arguing for religion or creationism or any of that BS as "valid" I am simply stating a fundamental well known flaw with science that is known by all people who know the technical definition of science.

Additionally, Newtons theory is 100% wrong in every environment. It only appears to be correct given limited accuracy of tooling. When you increase the accuracy of the observation the environment is irrelevant, it is always wrong.

>If it helps you, the scientific method of inquiry of in some ways is directly supported as a fundamental tenet of mathematics via calculus.

This is highly highly misguided. Logic and Science are completely separate. This is well known among people who understand the concept.

Logic is a game with rules axioms and a well understood domain. We create the rules and universe and therefore we're able to prove things within that universe.

Science is not the same. It is not an axiomatic game created by us. Science is the consequence of applying certain assumptions to a universe we did not create but only participate in.

We assume two things that are true in science. We assume logic is true. We assume rules like induction will always work even though we have no means of verifying it will work. We also assume probability works. We assume rolling a six sided dice will produce a certain outcome based off of probability and we again currently have no way of verify why or how this occurs. We just assume it.

Based off of these two assumptions we can create the scientific method. But this method is limited as it can only axiomatically falsify things. We can never prove anything to be true with science. This occurs, again because the domain of the real world is not limited like it is in our logical games of math. At any point in time the domain can change, shift and we can encounter a new unexpected observation that can change the entire arena.

Again, this isn't some BS I'm pulling out of my ass. This is science as Feynman and Einstein understood it. You lack understanding and I suggest you read up on the notion of what "proof" and science is.

Proof is only relevant in maths and logic, it is irrelevant in science and therefore reality as we know it. Science is the best tool we have but it is highly highly limited in the sense that it can never actually prove anything.

What ends up happening is science at best produces conclusions in the form of "We think this is true because our repeated attempts to falsify this hypothesis have failed." It can never produce anything definitive.

neonological··on Trust: The Need for Public Understanding of How Science Works
Ok let's be real. You're the one splitting hairs now. There is a clear difference between what either occupation does but of course sometimes a scientist needs to do carpentry or machinist work to build the tools for his experiment. Does this make machining and carpentry the same thing as science? No.
neonological··on Trust: The Need for Public Understanding of How Science Works
Yeah I'm already aware of this. Almost no one else is though.

Keep in mind though, Incremental refinement is not a given. There is still no way to know if each new theory is actually closer to the truth. In fact it may even be a step backwards.

Additionally limited accuracy in observation tools actually make it impossible to falsify anything either. Can you trust that the critical observation was 100% accurate? But tbh this is just splitting hairs.

neonological··on Trust: The Need for Public Understanding of How Science Works
I'm not splitting hairs.

There are people who are called "scientists" who test models with scientific experiment. Then there are people are "engineers" who use the models. If our social structure splits the difference by occupation how am I splitting hairs?

Literally if you didn't run an experiment with a hypothesis you aren't doing science, and people in society therefore won't refer to you as a scientist.

neonological··on Trust: The Need for Public Understanding of How Science Works
For sure. If someone can come up with a way to prove anything to be definitively true, most of these arguments would be over.

It is this flaw in science that is the origin of all these controversial debates that surround science, religion, global warming and other controversial topics.

Nothing can be proven and therefore reality will always be open to interpretation.

neonological··on Trust: The Need for Public Understanding of How Science Works
No that is not science.

Science is a process of falsification. You have a hypothesis and you attempt to falsify the hypothesis.

What you're describing is a model that has stood the test of falsification. Someone comes up with a mathematical model that can predict the future. They test that model under science to see if they can falsify the model.

If they fail to falsify the model then at best they say this model might as well be true because we couldn't determine otherwise.

That is science.

When you use the model to predict how something will happen in the real world for some real world application. That is more called "engineering."

Engineering is application, science is best attempt verification.

neonological··on Trust: The Need for Public Understanding of How Science Works
No. This is incorrect. You're talking about model accuracy and observation accuracy.

I am talking about something far more fundamental. Using axiomatic logic and probability, you cannot prove anything in science. Even with observations that are 100% accurate with 100% precision. This literally has fundamental consequences on our interpretation of reality as we know it and has affected out perception of reality and our science as well.

This occurs because at any point in time a new observation can be made that falsifies a theory. Let's say you have a hypothesis that all zebras have stripes. You can observe 500 zebras with 100% accuracy and see that all of those zebras have stripes. But at any point in time in the future you can happen upon a hidden island that has 2 million zebras on it that has spots instead. 500 observations is minuscule in the face of 2 million and it literally renders your initial hypothesis ludicrous. Zebras are creatures that are more likely to have spots then stripes is the complete U-turn conclusion based off of new observations.

Keep in mind the new conclusion occurred regardless of how methodological and accurate your initial observations were. The accuracy of the observation is Completely and utterly irrelevant. Because at any point in time I can encounter another new island with 1 billion zebras that has stripes rendering my second conclusion completely wrong, again.

This is the fundamental flaw of science. It is far more fundamental then limited accuracy in observational measurements.

For example take newtons laws of motion. There is no 99% right or wrong on that model. Assuming that our observations are accurate, Newtons laws of motion are 100% percent wrong.

Yes they may be accurate numerically to a certain extent but the theory has ultimately been falsified and we now know relativity is a more accurate description. However, keep in mind that even relativity is not "proven" it can Never be proven and it will always be open for a complete reversal the same way Newtonian motion was.

In fact Newtons laws of motion is the perfect example. It was the ultimate example of scientific verification. All experiments pointed to the theory being completely accurate, to disbelieve the science was to disbelieve reality. It was at the time equivalent to disbelieving evolution.

This is the fundamental flaw with science. Nothing can ever truly be proven. And everything even the fundamental pillars of reality we rely on today from Newtons laws to evolution can never actually be proven to be true, and is always open for a complete rewrite.

This is the exact reason as to why people can pick and choose the reality they believe in, whether it be Christianity or evolution. Neither can in actuality be proven, nothing has and nothing ever will.

neonological··on Trust: The Need for Public Understanding of How Science Works
I see it as a flaw because in logic and math, it is very possible to prove your theorems to be true. It is just not possible to do so in reality. Logic is a game with a limited domain. Reality has an unknown domain, hence the inability to prove anything.

Because this feature doesn’t exist in science it is therefore a flaw.

Additionally it doesn’t align with human intuition. Humans assume by default that things can be proven and that facts exist. The truth is that nothing can be proven and facts don’t actually exist. This is counter intuitive and therefore although science is the best tool we have, the counterintuitive qualities science possesses justifies calling these things flaws.

This relatively unknown “flaw” is what drives most of the debate in the political arena. No scientist can ever prove global warming to be true. It is fundamentally impossible. The debate would be over long ago if there was some way for science to prove global warming to be real.

neonological··on Trust: The Need for Public Understanding of How Science Works
yeah that’s true.

Most people are searching for definitive truths. The problem is it doesn’t exist, and science is the closest thing it.

neonological··on Trust: The Need for Public Understanding of How Science Works
In a sense yes. Science cannot prove things to be true, but falsification is conclusive. If observations are 100% accurate you can definitively falsify things and conclude that something is false.

The same cannot be said for proving something to be true.

neonological··on Trust: The Need for Public Understanding of How Science Works
Most people on hacker news don’t understand science.

Probably you don’t either. Did you know it is axiomatically impossible to prove anything to be true in science?

Every claim made by every scientist from the beginning of science to eternity has never ever been proven true. In science you can only falsify things.

If you don’t know this or don’t logically understand why this is the case then you never truly understood science.

People understand science from a cultural and political perspective. From a logical and axiomatic perspective, in science you cannot actually prove anything to be true.

This flaw within the actual framework of science itself is the origin of much of the misunderstandings and debates in the cultural and political arenas of science. For example no scientist can actually definitively prove global warming is real.

It is literally fundamentally impossible. Hence the politics.

neonological··on Trust: The Need for Public Understanding of How Science Works
These are political flaws and flaws with human systems.

You are missing the logical flaw buried within the scientific method itself.

Nothing in science and therefore reality can be proven to be true. We can only falsify things in science.

What this means is every claim ever made by anyone or any scientist from now to eternity can never be proven to be true.

We can only make repeated attempts at falsifying things. After we fail to falsify a thing enough times we can say, hey this theory is maybe true. That is the best science can do and that is what nobody, including most of the people on hacker news do NOT understand.

There is literally no such thing as an actual “fact” in science and therefore in reality as we know it.

This flaw is the origin of most of the distrust in science it is also the reason why blind trust of the scientific method itself is wrong. No claim made by a scientist has actually ever been proven.

neonological··on Trust: The Need for Public Understanding of How Science Works
It can be paired down to one thing: the scientific method.

When you exclude all human variables, including politics and errors and mistakes, the question is do you trust the scientific method?

Most people don’t understand that even with all these variables removed there is a flaw in the scientific method that is the origin of most of these misunderstandings in science.

In science and therefore in reality as we know it, we cannot prove anything to be true. No claim made by any scientist has actually been proven.

Scientists can only attempt to falsify things. At best, after many attempts at falsifying something we can say that a theory might be true, we can never prove it to be true.

neonological··on Trust: The Need for Public Understanding of How Science Works
No. You misunderstand what science is. Science is the process of attempting to falsify a model that is already built.

Modeling in itself is not science. It is the verification of the accuracy of that model that is science and there is even a huge flaw in this science.

The keyword is falsify. Nothing in science and therefore in reality as we know it can be proven to be true.

When a scientist engages in the scientific method, no scientist has ever proved any claim ever made by humanity to be true. They are simply attempting to falsify a claim. Truth remains forever dubious for eternity.

We can only say that a theory is probably true because all our attempts to falsify the theory have failed.

neonological··on Trust: The Need for Public Understanding of How Science Works
The key to the quote above is that nothing is proven right.

That is the fundamental flaw with science, if you understand this, you understand science.

In science and therefore reality as we know it, nothing can ever be proven true. It is fundamentally impossible. Every single claim made by every single scientist since the beginning of science has never ever been proven true.

This “flaw” is what drives most of the debate and misunderstandings about science in the cultural and political arena. For example... No scientist can ever prove global warming to be true... it is fundamentally impossible. Hence the debate rages on endlessly.

neonological··on Trust: The Need for Public Understanding of How Science Works
Science has political problems and social problems yes. But many people don’t understand that from a purely logical perspective there is a fundamental flaw with science. Almost no one knows this.

You cannot prove anything to be true with science. Therefore, in other words, you cannot prove anything to be true in reality as we know it.

Even when your observations are 100% accurate it is fundamentally impossible to prove anything in science (and your observations can never be 100% accurate).

If you understand this concept then you fundamentally understand science and you’ll be able to see where all the debate and misunderstandings about science comes from. Every single claim made by a scientist has never ever actually been proven ever. The key is that you need to understand why science can’t prove anything. There is an extremely logical explanation for why proof is impossible in reality. Proof is the domain of logic, not science.

To quote Einstein:

  “No amount of experimentation can ever prove me right; a single experiment can prove me wrong.”

Additionally there are two main axiomatic assumptions about the physical world that has to be made that have to be made in order for science to work as a logical consequence. You must assume logic is true (which is recursive and obvious) but you also must assume probability is true. Probability applying to the real world does not arise as a theoretical consequence of axiomatic logic being true. Probability itself must be assumed to be an axiom alongside logic, science works because we assume it works.
← PreviousPage 10 of 11Next →