HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

neosat

662 karma · joined January 5, 2016

submissionscomments
neosat··on Ping-pong robot beats top-level human players
As a player myself, and having seen much higher level player than me, reading the spin from the ball rotation (and in fact trajectory) of the ball is a common (if advanced) skill. Sometimes the movement of the bat can be deceptive (since with the same movement, where it contact on the bat, the finger pressure can affect the spin).

For example, backspin/underspin balls will move slower after the first bounce and feel 'damper' while topspin will jump. So it's def. possible (and in fact reliable) to read the spin from the spin and trajectory of the ball.

neosat··on Workspace Agents in ChatGPT
Great work on the feature and sure I'll do that. :)
neosat··on Workspace Agents in ChatGPT
Tried it to automate something that was on my to do list for the day. I had blocked off a few hours for this and managed to get the agent working reasonably well (85%) of the way there in < 15 mins.

The main remaining part is the poor docx / pdf / final output but will create a skill/workflow to get around that.

Worked really well end-end!

neosat··on I still prefer MCP over skills
The juxtaposition of MCP vs Skills in the article is very strange. These are not competing ways to achieve something. Rather skills is often a way to enable an optimization on top of MCPs.

A simplified but clarifying way to think about it is that MCP exposes all the things that can be done, and Skills encode a workflow/expertise/perspective on how something should be done given all the capabilities.

So I'm not sure why the article portrays one to be conflicting with the other (e.g. "the narrative that “MCP is dead” and “Skills are the new standard” has been hammered into my brain. Everywhere I look, someone is celebrating the death of the Model Context Protocol in favor of dropping a SKILL.md into their repository.").

You can just not choose to use a skill if it's not useful. But if it's useful a skill can add to what an MCP alone can do.

neosat··on Meta Horizon Worlds on Meta Quest is being discontinued
The sign of a company in absolute decline is when the worst possible place to get info about it, is their official announcement. Whoever wrote the announcement went out of their way to obfuscate the crux of the announcement (compare the clear heading on hackernews to their own heading)

If your (well paid) job is to write and communicate clearly, and for a major announcement you come up with this...not much left to say.

neosat··on Terence Tao, at 8 years old (1984) [pdf]
I don't think Walter is implying anything about how common or uncommon this is. His core insight seems fairly objective and plausible to me: "...your chances for happiness are increased if you wind up doing something that is a reflection of what you loved most when you were somewhere between nine and eleven years old". I.e. if you do end up being lucky and wise to do something as a profession closely related to what you *loved* doing when you were ~11 , because you end up spending time doing what you love (and equally importantly not spend that time doing something that sucks up energy) you increase your chances of being happier.
neosat··on SQL Studio
Kudos on the beautifully and thoughtfully designed landing page - which is becoming a rarity these days. Most product landing page highlight adjectives and abstract value propositions with links to join waiting lists for 'priority' access - providing little insight into the value proposition of the product itself. Not to mention the gratuitous visual effects.

So its a pleasure to see a thoughtfully done product landing page (which strongly signals that the same care will have gone into the product). The page is performant, no gratuitous visual effects. It clearly highlights the core product value propositions in the context of product visuals. Addresses key hesitations clearly and upfront (e.g. no cc required, pricing information), and a simple, obvious call to action.

Hopefully more people follow this template than the slop generated by auto generators.

neosat··on An illustrated introduction to linear algebra
Delightful explanation! A great example of how deep concepts can be made accessible and fun.
neosat··on Trump signs off on TikTok deal that puts US app's value at $14 billion
President Trump signs off on TikTok deal that puts US app's value at $14 billion
neosat··on Mitochondria Are More Than Powerhouses–They're the Motherboard of the Cell
This metaphor may be misleading. For a compelling alternate view, read the excellent: "Is the cell really a machine?" https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00225...

From the article:

"It has become customary to conceptualize the living cell as an intricate piece of machinery, different to a man-made machine only in terms of its superior complexity ......"

" ..... However, the recent introduction of novel experimental techniques capable of tracking individual molecules within cells in real time is leading to the rapid accumulation of data that are inconsistent with an engineering view of the cell ...... which emphasizes the dynamic, self-organizing nature of its constitution, the fluidity and plasticity of its components, and the stochasticity and non-linearity of its underlying processes."

neosat··on Show HN: A pure WebGL image editor with filters, crop and perspective correction
Nice! Good performance, clean UI, and core functionality.
neosat··on Sora: Creating video from text
"having a very good product isn't a moat"

It definitely is. Having the best product and being able to maintain that best-in-class product status over time through a firm's 'internal capabilities' is very much a moat and a strong one at that. A moat is the business strategy sense is anything that enables a firm to maintain competitive advantage. Having the best product in a category, and being able to maintain that over releases is a strong competitive advantage (especially when there is high willingness to pay or price is a strong competitive dimension compared to the value created).

neosat··on Leave work slightly unfinished for easier flow the next day
One tip that I (and many others here ;) ) are going to find pretty easy to do :) That's the kind of research I can get behind.
neosat··on Want employees to return to the office? Then give each one an office
No - it may work for some employees but it's not far from what will make people who prefer remotely want to suddenly return to office.

More importantly, return to office, as the end goal isn't a good end-goal. Sure it can work reasonably well when everyone is in the office, but the pandemic 'experiment' has clearly shown us that remote, hybrid are also workable models. Each model: all on-site, hybrid, flexible have their pros and cons and the outstanding organizations of the future will be the ones that can create an environment where people who thrive in each model and co-work.

The right end-goals should be around more around the lines of productivity, teams hitting/exceeding their goals consistently, employee retention, employee happiness among other things.

neosat··on Modern language models refute Chomsky’s approach to language
interesting point!
neosat··on Modern language models refute Chomsky’s approach to language
The author (bafflingly) seems to have completely missed the point- since anything they state up to page 15 (at which point I stopped reading) does not refute Chomsky's points at all. The author talks about LLMs and how they generate text and then goes on to talk about how it refutes Chomsky's claim about syntax and semantics. However it does not since Chomsky's primary claim is about how HUMANS acquire language.

The fact that you can replicate coherent text from probabilistic analysis and modeling of a very large corpus does not mean that humans acquire and generate language the same way. [edited page = 15]

neosat··on Chat Notebooks
Neat idea, but some of it is made out to be unnecessarily complex and esoteric. E.g. giving it your name, and now it becomes 'aware' of your name. I guess in normal programming that would be like saying once you declare your variable the program is 'aware' of it. It's not wrong to say that, but unnecessarily makes it more complicated. The tacking of multiple such instances makes the overall post more complicated than needed. The core idea is neat though.
neosat··on Never trust a programmer who says they know C++
Many years ago as an undergrad student I applied for an internship. They asked if I knew "C++", and having studied it and programmed in the only 'C++' I knew I said yes. After arriving at the internship they showed me the codebase and it a lot of it looked very foreign to me. Turns out they were using Symbian C++. I had quite a few weeks of extended evenings and few all night coding sessions to try to keep up and get basic things done. Luckily, I somehow managed to deliver on my ask, but lesson learnt!
neosat··on DOJ Preps Antitrust Suit to Block Adobe’s $20B Figma Deal
Adobe pays a high valuation in an inflated market for Figma, to continue showing growth that has mostly stalled. Also helps them cross-sell their other products once they get into smaller companies where Figma has a strong foothold.

Market Tanks, valuations tank (to reasonable levels or perhaps still slightly inflated levels but not as crazy as before)

Generative AI brings a new threat (and new potential acquisition targets in the near future)

Adobe: How do we get out of this (now) bad deal? .....Oh wait..

DOJ: Preps anti-trust suit

... now Speculating....

Adobe doesn't really contend strongly the anti trust charge. Pays $1B or so (saves $19B for future acquisitions)

Figma......some dreams crushed, but I guess $1B is not too shabby

neosat··on YouTube CEO Susan Wojcicki is stepping down
YouTube has been riding it's content momentum for too long. It really needs a change of leadership to continue to innovate.

For some searches, it's baffling that the top results are clearly intuitively wrong (e.g. showing videos where dislike to like ratio is very high, compared to clearly better alternatives that you can find if you wade through the results)

neosat··on Meta to ask many managers to become individual contributors or leave
FB and Zuck have always prioritized a culture of building, and created a place (at least in the early days) where builders could thrive. Over time with massive hiring this obviously changed. If they need to further 'trim the fat' Part of this move could also be as a mechanism for selecting out people who are not comfortable with IC responsibilities as a way to identify people who would not have been a fit for FB in the early days, and thus an attempt to revise at least some of the early culture.
neosat··on Meta to ask many managers to become individual contributors or leave
Product Manager can refer to an individual contributor IC or someone who also manages other Product Managers (and sometimes even adjacent functions) e.g. a Group Product Manager. The titles are not very standard though. Many of these roles are hybrid as well. For example, a Product manager who will be responsible for a Product portfolio and some products in that portfolio as an IC, while managing/supporting the work of PMs working on other products in that portfolio.

Same for TPMs. They can be ICs or managing other TPMs.

neosat··on Bard and new AI features in Search
There was a different dynamic there. Apple was clearly focussed on the higher end of the market (price point) and unwilling to compromise on profit margins, while willing to sacrifice pure market share. Google took advantage of that to win the distribution space focussing on lower price point phones on Android (and then expanding to higher price point devices).

With ChatGPT the threat is different and both are going after expanding usage.

neosat··on Bard and new AI features in Search
The blog post is an example of why when you go through a number of edits and additions from various internal groups, marketing, legal, compliance etc. you end up with a message that's a lot of words but not a lot of information for any key audience.

I went through the article 3 times thinking I missed the link to try out Bard, get some sense of timeline, roll-out plan...nothing. Come on Google...

neosat··on ChatGPT is a ‘code red’ for Google’s search business
>> Google already has Meena and Lambda which are the same thing and arguably superior.

Arguably superior on what dimension? For revenue potential through a chat based AI interface, assuming revenue is going to be some function of end-user usage, there is nothing even close to ChatGPT in the open market currently. ChatGPT is being used by millions of people already, which is a way way higher number than whatever competing service Google may have.

>> Google would within the same year simply do the same with Meena or Lambda

Like they did with social networks? or Whatsapp? With something like ChatGPT the 'easy to copy' argument is going to be even more difficult since 1. with usage ChatGPT will get better. 2. Once people get used to ChatGPT to switch the competing service from Google will have to be significantly better (not just marginally better).

So while it may not yet be a existential threat to Google, to make a point that ChatGPT should alarm Google is definitely not "laughable" IMO.

neosat··on Music Mouse
Esc worked for me!
neosat··on Music Mouse
Incredible - loved it! This is what a modern digital music instrument should be like :)
neosat··on Withdrawals from BlockFi continue to be paused
A lot (most?) of what's happening in Crypto is quite at odds with the proposed direction in the bitcoin paper (e.g. transparency, (de)centralization) So while a much needed correction for 'crypto' in general, this is not necessarily bad for bitcoin long term.
neosat··on The currency of the new economy won't be money, but attention (1997)
You're not wrong. But that's not how the headline pitches the article. It specifically says 'the currency of the new economy won't be money'; hence my comment.
neosat··on The currency of the new economy won't be money, but attention (1997)
The dichotomy between attention and money (in this context) is forced and not necessarily true. While it is true that attention is valuable, it is valuable primarily because there is an expectation that it can be monetized (either now or in the future). There can be some other minor use cases for attention being valuable for its own sake but those are a minority. The primary goal is to leverage attention (eyeballs) for some kind of advertising.

Attention , when it is hard to monetize it, is less valuable (again in the majority case). A case in point would be messaging apps such as Snapchat or WhatsApp compared to something like Pinterest or FB newsfeed. Attention in one of those systems is more economically valuable than others. It's true that WhatsApp was valued high because of usage/attention despite having no monetization but that was more of a strategic play to thwart competitive threat as well as the belief that they could monetize it in the future (as evident in the current direction that the messaging apps are going in)

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →