HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

neosat

662 karma · joined January 5, 2016

submissionscomments
neosat··on Microsoft Full Circle
This ^ is spot on. While the general 'abstraction' argument is spot on, MS is in fact poorly placed to be the 'OS' that becomes that abstraction. In fact, arguably it doesn't even need to be an 'OS' level concept. An example is google docs or WhatsApp. I can work on documents seamlessly across different actual 'OS' because the application abstracts that away - and it is sufficient. If an OS were to abstract all of this, it would also involve numerous compromises, notably on the tightly integrated end-end experience (hardware to UX), which is Apple's entire strategy against the likes of Microsoft.

So no MS is not the best situated to be that 'OS'. 1. It is unclear if such an OS (with the benefits and trade-offs) will be preferred to a world where cross-OS applications can abstract away the OS. 2. Someone like Google (minus their execution woes that seem to get worse in recent years) is better positioned to abstract away the complexities for a regular consumer.

neosat··on Why doesn't Stripe use Stripe Billing?
Hey AnhTho - the points in your post resonate, and y'all seem to be doing some exciting work at Lago - good luck!
neosat··on Why doesn't Stripe use Stripe Billing?
Thanks for some internal insights. I think the original post wasn't making the point that such a use case is not possible to build but rather that the architecture and design choices of Stripe Billing are not optimized for these use cases and don't make it easy.
neosat··on Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B
Agree. Macromedia products were amazing for their time. Dreamweaver, Flash (Creating flash apps including ActionScript), Fireworks with vector + bitmap, were all very cool until Adobe acquired them
neosat··on Are all brains good at math?
Rather than generalizing ability to "Math" as a whole, I think it might be more meaningful to state that individuals may differ in the type of problem solving their brain is better at (or at least they enjoy more and thus with effort get better at it). Enjoying and being good at abstract mathematical concepts of sets and number theory might be different than being good at geometrical manipulations or calculus. Some capabilities required for certain types of math problems might cluster closer with problem solving capabilities in other domains (e.g. chemistry or computer science or even writing) than they do other capabilities in math.
neosat··on Dark Matter Doesn't Exist
Thank you for the informative and thoughtful response. My comment and question was certainly not intended to be combative. I was genuinely curious for a perspective quite like the one you provided above, because it seemed odd that a claim so strong would not have a counter view given the active area of research. I think the original article would benefit from some perspective like the one you provided. While you're aware of the relevant threads of research that balance out the view in the original article, for someone not familiar with that even things that one would consider "well known" will not be so.

The view you provided helps understand the counter argument of why competing factors (e.g. losing mass) result in more sophisticated outcomes than "we would expect lighter galaxies orbiting heavier ones to be slowed down by dark matter particle". I still don't know enough about the subject to understand if the original authors claim and expectation is still likely. But your context helps me understand other factors that are in play.

neosat··on YouTube disrupted in Pakistan as former PM Khan streams speech
would you care to point out at least one "glaringly ignorant statement" backed by a fact that shows it is glaringly ignorant?
neosat··on Dark Matter Doesn't Exist
Yup, no one still seems to have an answer to a simple, straightforward question, and the lack of any convincing counterargument makes it even more convincing.
neosat··on Dark Matter Doesn't Exist
Can someone with the appropriate background please confirm or refute? "But a simple test suggests that dark matter does not in fact exist. If it did, we would expect lighter galaxies orbiting heavier ones to be slowed down by dark matter particles, but we detect no such slow-down."

Is that hypothesis correct? (i.e. would we expect lighter galaxies orbiting heavier ones to slow down if dark matter exists)

If it is correct, and we don't observe that effect, would it not be a very strong argument refuting the existence of dark matter?

For folks mentioning this as a "crackpot" or "anti-dm" theory, is the strong claim that the hypothesis is incorrect?

neosat··on The integrated timetable of Switzerland
Having experienced this during an exchange program, without any car there, I never once felt constrained that I couldn't travel where I wanted. A great example that I wish every country aspired to emulate
neosat··on Consciousness is not computation
One core issue that the author struggles with (like almost all of these theories) is a crisp definition of consciousness, that allows you to create a falsifiable hypothesis of what is "*not* consciousness". Till you cannot crisply define consciousness crisply, you cannot create a scientific falsifiable hypothesis to test it, and hence all you are debating and persuading around is philosophy or semantics.
neosat··on Coinbase employees petition to remove execs
>> It leads with the collapse of NFTs, which has little if anything to do with Coinbase or its execs; it complains about infra/tech debt but says nothing about why that's bad, much less the execs' fault;

It has everything to with Coinbase and it's execs. The astronomical compensations at C-suite and leadership is to build strategy and vision around where to invest (e.g. NFTs?), how to differentiate your offering (e.g. vs. Open Sea), and how to minimize risk, and maximize success (e.g. adoption).

Investing too much in new initiatives, while not building the right platforms, and tech infra for it, will lead to even higher tech debt and more chaos - so they seem like logically reasonable complaints. Whether they are true or not I have no idea but the points do not seem vague at all.

neosat··on Plain text, with lines
Just the kind of things that keep me coming back to hacker news. Thanks for building and sharing.
neosat··on Data Science in Context – Peter Norvig's New Book
I was really looking forward to diving deeper into this, having enjoyed, and learnt, a lot from Peter Norvig's blog and writings in the past. I especially enjoyed the succinctness and density of knowledge in his writing.

Disappointingly, to me, this book seems to lack both of those properties. It seems to meander between talking about core data science concepts, and also about privacy, ethics etc. Given the title of the book perhaps this content makes sense, but it was not useful for me personally. Wish the authors the best.

neosat··on A PM's guide to communicate effectively with software engineers
>> Product managers are incentivized to deliver features faster. This is a misconception. Product managers are/should be (depending on your organization) incentivized to maximize value. Sometimes it may mean being faster to market to validate a hypothesis, other times it may mean pausing on launches for a month or two to make sure you've built a strong enough foundation to set up for the future. Often, it means balancing of your team's portfolio to take on "execution wins", invest in tech for the future, and explore some big bets.

Agree 100% that every PM needs to understand the operational burden the engineering team is facing as well as other blockers in their way, and proactively ensure that they focus on the work with utmost clarity and without unnecessary interruptions.

neosat··on Times are great for programmers now. How does it end?
>> Higher salaries mean less profit. It’s just how the game works.

This is a false premise. As a counter argument it would be easy for a rational CEO to pay higher salary if the net incremental ROI on that salary is positive.

Then there are second order benefits. A players attract A players, and so on. So you have to also consider the non-financial ROI on the higher salary to attract the best talent.

There is a reason why the top companies are willing to pay higher salaries ...

neosat··on The future of education looks a lot like TikTok and Twitter
It doesn't. In fact, to the contrary, these forms of communication don't lend themselves to certain types of topics and deeper thinking critical for education (read Neil Postman's Amusing ourselves to death for a great exposition). True, they have an important place in education and I'm excited for the changes they can bring, but they are only a small piece of what the future of education will look like.
neosat··on What’s so hard about understanding consciousness?
The whole point is, that's not an obviously valid replacement in the context of consciousness. What's your definition of "passive"?
neosat··on What’s so hard about understanding consciousness?
exactly ^. The first central question is "how is it possible that we have any experience at all?" That leads naturally to the other important question "who is the observer that's aware" i.e. who is the "we"/I that is aware.

It's telling that science has made incredible progress (e.g. in the last 100 years) but on questions such as these above, we know little more than people knew then. Although we do know a lot more about the mechanics of what and how we experiences things.

neosat··on Matrix Multiplication
so useful - thanks!
neosat··on Interview success can depend on how you schedule interviews
While interview success "can" depend on these, along with 100s of other factors, these are most likely not the principal contributing factors to interview success on average. So, sure, if you've got the principal factors figured out, optimize to this level, but if not, your energy will be far better spent elsewhere (e.g. understanding the most likely asked questions for a company, and the framework they evaluate on, ensuring you're communicating well (verbal & non-verbal) )
neosat··on Brain-Computer Interface Smashes Previous Record for Typing Speed
Addictive. Thanks for sharing :)
neosat··on Clip: Connecting Text and Images
Impressive work! Their approach makes a ton of sense: "by not directly optimizing for the benchmark, we show that it becomes much more representative"

and is evident in the generalization and robustness: ~74% higher on the adversarial benchmark and similar/superior results on the standard Imagenet

neosat··on Facebook Declared War on Apple, and It Just May Signal the End of Facebook
Not really a failure. It's important to realize that people are not necessarily always paying for the 'actual value of a company' (subjective itself) but for what other agents will be willing to pay for the stock. If that value is higher than the current price, they'll buy.
neosat··on Facebook Declared War on Apple, and It Just May Signal the End of Facebook
I believe John Maynard Keynes
neosat··on Facebook Declared War on Apple, and It Just May Signal the End of Facebook
Because it assumes a rational market. And the market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent.
neosat··on What Satoshi Did Not Know (2015) [pdf]
That's true for distributed computing in general so it has nothing specifically to do with the blockchain protocol itself.
neosat··on Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge grants emergency stay
> other than when the drivers choose to work. That's not true. What about who else they can work for? That's not enforced either.

Which other businesses commonly allow people to work when they want, work for whatever competition they want, take any amount of 'vacation' in between?

You're fitting something new into an existing category by handwaving away lot of important nuance, when it is exactly this nuance that makes a ton of difference and why the new type of work may not fit into an existing category.

neosat··on Modelling a Wealth Tax: A Response to Paul Graham
>> nowhere did he model the benefits received, either to himself or others

Fair point about others, however with regards to themselves, I believe you missed the point of PGs article. Without the extra wealth tax they would have almost certainty been better off because they can choose how to benefit from that money.

Regarding others, I believe the onus should lie on the government before implementing the tax to show that everyone - including people paying the tax - will be better off because of the benefits from the wealth tax to others. Given how (in) efficient government can be in spending tax money, it's not an unfair expectation to have.

neosat··on Apple for the first time makes a top-of-the-line iPhone model in India
This is really big deal IMO, but perhaps for a reason not directly mentioned in the article and for which you have to realize something about India. Progress in India is usually quite slow (and far slower if you compare to places like US or China). But once there is one shining example, then (partly because of the competition, partly because of the numbers of people) the momentum is strong and only gets larger.

This is potentially one of those events and has the potential to catalyze high end devices manufacturing in India leading to other second order effects of expertise in other hardware manufacturing. Looking forward to the innovation and confidence this unlocks.

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →