HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

netfire

244 karma · joined October 3, 2011

submissionscomments
netfire··on DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
You may want to check out this TED talk and the corresponding site. I think its basically what you are talking about.

- http://www.ted.com/talks/marcin_jakubowski?language=en

- http://opensourceecology.org/portfolio/tractor/

netfire··on Project Sunroof
I'm guessing you left the average monthly electric bill slider at the $125/month position. You'd have to adjust the to what it actually is for City Hall, which I'd think is a lot more than $125/month.
netfire··on VW Has Spent Two Years Trying to Hide a Big Security Flaw
True, but isn't the whole point of an alarm system to draw attention to the thieves? If a thief can bypass the alarm system or other security measures, it may not look they are stealing the car. This gives them a significant amount of time before law enforcement can be informed and greatly lessens the chance of them being caught.
netfire··on Why Las Vegas has coped well with drought so far
Wouldn't it be cheaper to build the desalination plants on the coast and sell it to California cities/famers in exchange for water that usually goes down the Colorado River from Nevada to California. Pumping it upstream seems like a waste of energy and infrastructure when the cities in Southern California already want and need the water for their residents.

The problem isn't that there isn't enough water for Vegas passing through Lake Mead. Its that legally they are obligated to send it downstream. Nevada gets a meager 4% of the lower basin of the river, while California gets 58.7% [1]

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colorado_River_Compact

netfire··on Federal Judge Strikes Down Idaho ‘Ag-Gag Law’
So, are you suggesting we should eliminate or limit 1st amendment rights in cases where the parties involved in defamation wouldn't have the money to cover the defamed's losses?

If the film is popular (and therefore does more damage), the filmmaker will probably have the means to adequately compensate the farmer. If it isn't popular, it probably won't do much damage to the farmer.

Limiting free speech isn't a good solution.

netfire··on A Company Copes With Backlash Against the Raise That Roared
Whether you support a minimum wage increase or not, to think that it won't affect other people than those that are getting the increase just isn't true. Here's some possible side effects.

- Prices of products or services increase to compensate for the increase in salary.

- Higher paid employees don't get raises since the money that was previously allocated for that is being used to pay for the minimum wage increase. (This seems to be happening in this case, where more experienced workers received little to no increase in compensation).

- Other benefits are removed or reduced to cover the additional cost (health insurance, vacation, sick leave, etc)

- The company can no longer be profitable with the additional costs and reduces the size of their workforce or shuts down completely.

Which of these side effects (if any) occur, depends on the company and its current profits, management and/or investors, as well as how much they are already paying employees.

netfire··on Our plan for a more diverse Pinterest
Really? Pinterest is ranked #16 by Alexa in the US for internet traffic[1]. Do you really think running such a site with that much traffic doesn't require top talent?

[1] http://www.alexa.com/topsites/countries/US

netfire··on How a car works (2012)
Nice site.

Suggestion: It would be nice to have some sort of search box at the top that would instantly filter the list of articles as you type. Instead of having to dig through the "more articles" links to find what you are looking for, you could just type "oil", "air filter", or other terms and see the corresponding articles immediately.

Also, sometimes the ads cover page content and when this happens sometimes you can't close them. I'm using Chrome on a Mac.

netfire··on Firefox makes click-to-activate Flash the default
Github claims that the flash version is "currently the only reliable way to put data in the clipboard". This seems to indicate that they looked at the native browser option and found it unacceptable for their use case.

https://github.com/blog/1365-a-more-transparent-clipboard-bu...

netfire··on 'Happy Birthday' Hits Sour Notes When It Comes to Song's Free Use
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I thought it was not just enough to have a phrase enter the public vernacular, but that it would have to be in the vernacular in such a way that its no longer directly associated with the product that was trademarked.

I like the general idea though. It seems that if the general public no longer associate a work of art with the artist or company that holds the IP, it should go into public domain.

In this case, Happy Birthday probably never would have been popular in the first place had the copyright been aggressively enforced in the 1920's. In my opinion, the lack of defense of broad copyright infringement from 1920-1980 should be grounds for copyright invalidation.

Generally copyright has lost its original intent of providing value and protection to the original creator, while encouraging people to create something that will eventually become part of the public domain.

netfire··on Show HN: Density – Anonymous People Counter and API
Too long of a queue could discourage customer attendance as well, as people may not want to wait a long time, no matter how prestigious the business is. In addition, a lesser-known business could use lower wait times as a competitive advantage.

What really matters, in my opinion, is whether having a long line during certain peak times generates more revenue for the business (by being able to charge more, or by gaining attention due to its long queues) or whether providing a faster and better customer experience with shorter wait times does (and perhaps more customers during non-peak times)

Whether one is better than the other may depend completely on your business. Also, I'm not sure this technology forces you to publish your current density information. You could simply use the information for business intelligence gathering and for providing promotions during non-peak times.

netfire··on Buffer's transparency dashboard: Public salaries, equity and more
I find the location modifier interesting. Obviously, the living costs in major cities are being factored in here, but if two employees provide the same amount of value to the company, it seems odd to pay someone more just because they choose to live in a big city. It seems like that might also cause some resentment between the two employees.

Does the company get some additional value from having their employees live in a big city? Is there some other factor I'm missing?

netfire··on Safari is the new IE
I don't see how you can justify being off on your facts by 3-4 times by saying its still in the same order of magnitude. You overestimated their cash on hand by about 422 billion dollars. Again, I see the cash on hand as a weak argument. What really matters is how much annual revenue and profit it brings in. Apple is going to be concerned about anything that adds or takes away from their revenue in a significant way.

Its telling that App Store sales are a significant source of revenue for Apple. One that could possibly justify not making improvements to Safari that could make it better compete with native applications.

netfire··on Safari is the new IE
Again you post information without any sources. A more accurate figure is $178 billion in cash at the beginning of this year.[1] That means they have around 59 times more than that amount in cash, not the 200 you claimed. Also, I think its telling that Apple themselves mentioned App Store Sales as a main factor in their revenue earnings for Q4 of their 2014 fiscal year. [2] What's important is how much of their total annual revenue and profits are derived from App Store sales, not how it compares to the amount of cash they have on hand.

As others have mentioned, there are other benefits from native applications, like vendor lock-in, which Apple isn't going to get with web-based applications.

[1] http://money.cnn.com/2015/01/28/investing/apple-cash-178-bil...

[2] http://www.apple.com/pr/library/2014/10/20Apple-Reports-Four...

netfire··on Safari is the new IE
I don't necessarily attribute it to malice either. Their interest in making money and being successful will motivate where they spend their development dollars in maintaining older software and keeping current customers happy on their older systems versus developing new features and software that will increase sales.
netfire··on Safari is the new IE
I did, and I should have read it more carefully. That being said, I think there is a balance that Apple tries to maintain here. If there experience on older systems is terrible, they run the risk of people switching to a different operating system and platform. If the experience isn't significantly better on newer hardware, however, customers won't be motivated to upgrade.
netfire··on Safari is the new IE
Curious where you are basing your revenue numbers from. Per Apple's reported statistics for 2014[1], developers pulled in $10 billion dollars in revenue from the app store. That means that Apple's revenue from the app store should also be in the low billions (based on the 70/30 cut they take from app store sales and purchases).

All without manufacturing logistics and hardware production costs. Obviously the computing infrastructure, payment processing and software engineering of the app store has a cost, but I'd imagine much less than those involved with building, distributing and selling a computer or mobile device.

It may not generate as much as hardware sales do, but billions of dollars hardly seems like spare change.

[1] http://www.apple.com/pr/library/2015/01/08App-Store-Rings-in...

netfire··on Safari is the new IE
Its in Apple's interest to not have Safari work well on older machines (since they want people to buy new machines), or improve it in ways that would make the browser better compete against the app store (especially on mobile).

It is in their interest to have it be a very nice looking document viewing platform, which is where I imagine most of their developer resources are going towards.

netfire··on Ask HN: I'm owed 8k by a startup that's going under. What do I do?
If they are truly going down and are a LLC or otherwise incorporated, there's probably not much you can do. Going forward, there are a few options:

- If you are doing project-based work with specific deliverables, delay delivery of the project until payment is received.

- Ask for a deposit from the client up front to cover such an eventuality. Depending on how much you want to cover your risk, this could be somewhere between 1/2 to a full month's worth of pay. To the client, if they ever want to terminate your consulting agreement, this becomes part of the last month's pay.

- Ask to be paid in advance for your work, stop working if payment isn't made in advance.

- Setup your consulting agreements so you are paid more frequently and stop working if you aren't paid when agreed. This limits the amount of money that could be owed to you.

If you are going to seek legal options for compensation in your current situation, you should try to do it before they shut down and still have assets. Of course you should consult a lawyer and get real legal advice from someone who knows the law before pursuing this option.

netfire··on SpaceX CRS-6 Hard Landing – Tracking Cam
Thanks for the links! I'll try to look at those when I have some time. On a quick glance, it looks like most of those systems are ground based and pretty large (which works great for launch footage), the video posted appears to be looking down on the landing pad at the end, which leads me to believe the camera is located on a helicopter.

Could a radar based camera be mounted on a helicopter, or could land-based tracking devices work in conjunction with a helicopter mounted camera to achieve the tracking?

netfire··on Same-Sex Marriage Is a Right, Supreme Court Rules
I mostly meant within the context of the current law and the historical understanding that marriage was only between a man and a woman when the 14th amendment was added. In my opinion, the constitution, as it currently stands, doesn't consider prohibiting same-sex marriage to be gender-based discrimination.
netfire··on SpaceX CRS-6 Hard Landing – Tracking Cam
Curious how they are tracking the rocket's descent to catch it on camera. It seems like they lose visual of the rocket and then are able to re-acquire it fairly quickly. Are they using some sort of infrared or other tracking beacon on the rocket that the camera can follow or using trajectory data to determine where the camera should be pointed?

Also, I'd love to know when these launches are going to happen further in advance. The Launch Manifest page just shows the next launch as happening in June[1]. Is there a better place to get more exact planned launch dates further in advance?

[1] http://www.spacex.com/missions

netfire··on Same-Sex Marriage Is a Right, Supreme Court Rules
Because the institution, historically speaking, has been between people of different genders. It is only recently that people have even considered allowing same-sex marriages. It certainly wasn't considered or was part of the intent of the 14th amendment, when it was added to the constitution.

If you want to add a law to consider prohibiting same-sex marriage as discriminatory, then go through the process to add a law through the legislative process. Changing the meaning and intent of the current laws through the judicial process seems like the wrong way to go about it. It just isn't currently part of the constitution.

netfire··on Same-Sex Marriage Is a Right, Supreme Court Rules
I should have phrased my earlier comment more specific to same-sex marriage, that's true. I don't think your second argument that marriage is sex discrimination is valid though. As you point out, both men and women have been allowed to enter into non same-sex marriages, regardless of their orientation or gender.

What's in question here is whether its discriminatory to not allow same-sex marriages to occur and whether states should be able to determine what marriage means and restrict it accordingly. Marriage has traditionally been between a man and a woman and certainly wasn't intended to be part of the 14th amendment when it was added to the constitution in 1868.

To add it more than 100 years later seems like a case of the judicial branch legislating and adding to the law, more than interpreting existing law in the context and intent of which it was passed.

netfire··on Same-Sex Marriage Is a Right, Supreme Court Rules
Rights of a minority should not be left to the democratic process.

If the constitution and the its amendments, which protect minority rights (and people's rights in general) aren't the result of a democratic legislative process, what are they a result of?

The question is whether the current constitutional legislation provides these minority rights. The court's role is to interpret existing laws, not add to them because it thinks its the right thing to do. That's the legislature's role.

netfire··on Same-Sex Marriage Is a Right, Supreme Court Rules
Can you specify what part of the constitution is being violated here? There are amendments that protect race, color, gender, etc. Protection based on sexual orientation doesn't seem to be covered, at least not specifically.

In my mind, the correct solution to this issue should have been legislative (that is, add an amendment to the constitution), not judicial.

netfire··on Stripe Is the New PayPal
That's a good point, hellbanner should have used the test API, but this is still troubling. First, due to the lack of the communication and a proper ticket system from Stripe. Second (and more troubling), the idea that someone could maliciously cause you to lose the ability to process payments on your site simply by submitting a bunch of fake (or half-fake) transactions.

Creating a system that processes payments can be an involved process, requiring significant development effort, even when using API and libraries like Stripe provides. It seems like Stripe should only be shutting people down as a last resort, after repeated warnings with a clear way on how to fix the problem. This is also just good business practice. No one wants to be shut down without a good reason and without any recourses for appeal or reconciliation.

netfire··on SpaceX Hyperloop Pod Competition
Yeah, I wondered if some sort of on-ramp/off-ramp or multi-lane system might work, but given the distance it would take to get up to full-speed (or decrease speed to stop), that could greatly increase the cost of construction, especially if there are a lot of stations.

For the Hyperloop to make any sense in a shorter distance metro setting, you'd probably want to have no stops between where you start and your destination. (So you might go directly from Anaheim to Santa Monica, for example) With smaller cars/trains, this may be possible (since you might be able to fill trains quickly enough to not make people wait too long), but potentially very expensive to build enough lanes to manage that amount of traffic with greatly varying speeds efficiently.

Without that sort of system, however, I think the additional stops would delay you so much that the gain over a traditional metro train would be small and not worth the extra expense of building it.

netfire··on SpaceX Hyperloop Pod Competition
Would a Hyperloop system work well in a system with frequent stops, where you wouldn't be able to get up to full-speed because you needed to stop and the stops could disrupt other express traffic. Would you really be gaining that much over other traditional rail transportation options?

It seems like the strength of the Hyperloop is extremely fast travel over long distances. Personally, I think having a line between Las Vegas and Los Angeles would be awesome, as the traffic can be horrible on that route, especially on weekends and probably significantly affects traffic in LA in general. Its also around 100 miles less than the LA to SF route, through mostly undeveloped desert, so it could be a lot cheaper to build.

netfire··on Silicon Valley’s Dark Secret: It’s All About Age (2010)
I think the point is that the decisions aren't as high-risk when you are single and don't have other people to support (especially children). The consequences of failure aren't as high.

Instead of being able to share a place with a few people (maybe even sharing a room) and sharing utilities, internet, cable and so on, you are paying significantly more for housing, food, utilities, transportation (bigger car), clothes and insurance/medical costs. Those costs could easily be 3-4 times as much as a single person.

If you are a dual income family, you may also be paying for child care and have the extra responsibilities of getting your children to and from child care and/or school (let alone actually spending some quality time with them). Working late has a much higher cost and being out of a job has much greater consequences.

← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →