HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

neuronerdgirl

169 karma · joined April 20, 2023

submissionscomments
neuronerdgirl··on Large language models lack deep insights or a theory of mind
That's not what theory of mind is. Theory of mind is the understanding - not academic understanding, but functional, meaningful understanding that guides your behavior - that the other people (AIs?) around you have their own separate thoughts and feelings from your own. This is what leads to the stark behavioral differences as a child develops from ~3-6 years of age. Imagine a child is playing with their toys and puts one of them in a box out of the room, then later asks you to retrieve it for them. A 3 year old will assume that, because they know they put it in the box, that you know it is there as well. (Incidentally, this is where a lot of tantrums come from, because they can't understand why you aren't reading their mind and get frustrated.) A 6 year old will not make this assumption.

While this is a simple example, the concept extrapolates to more complex issues as we develop cognitively and emotionally. Not only is theory of mind about recognizing that your thoughts and feelings are separate and distinct, but also being able to project your understanding into others to predict how they might be thinking and feeling in their own separate circumstance. This is the fundamental basis of empathy, or being able to predict and understand how others around you may be feeling given their unique current circumstances even if they are different from your own.

LLMs have not demonstrated any of the above understanding. Again, I'm sure they could generate a definition for it, and on any given prompt they could probably even generate some generic-ish text that could pose as empathy, but so can a horoscope. But there is not the deep, continuous comprehension of the user as a separate thinking and feeling agent that is fundamental to the idea of theory of mind.

neuronerdgirl··on Elon Musk: "Don't advertise. Go f*** yourself"
The problem with this chain of discussion is that no self-respecting expert in the relevant fields would give armchair diagnoses or discuss evidence for them like this on a public forum, so all you will end up with is speculative garbage from unqualified people.
neuronerdgirl··on At Meta, Underage Users Were an 'Open Secret,' States Say
> They're taking their developing brains and going up against billion dollar algorithms designed by armies of professional psychologists

You WISH they were developed by professional psychologists. They were mostly designed by undergraduate-trained programmers and UX "researchers" who took 2 semesters of basic psychology and learned what the word "heuristic" means and ran with it wholesale. I can tell you first-hand as a psychology PhD I'm basically unhireable for those positions because in training for my actual degree I didn't get the programming skills they require.

neuronerdgirl··on Life expectancy can increase up to 10 years by shifting towards healthier diets
You most likely got downvoted because you are advocating for a long-term juice cleanse, which is widely regarded as unhealthy and potentially dangerous [0]. The benefits you claim are not scientifically supported, and the lack of protein almost certainly means that most of the weight loss your unfortunate companions experienced was muscle loss. I would discourage anyone reading this comment chain from following the advice above for any meaningful period of time.

0: https://www.livescience.com/48887-juice-cleanse-dangers.html

neuronerdgirl··on Zoom Fatigue Is Real, According to Brain Scans
Gather Town was tackling this issue surprisingly well during COVID, but anytime I tried to convince people to use it they defaulted back to Zoom because Gather was too confusing. I think it would take a real paradigm shift from the "call with video" model to get decent adoption of something like that, and now that it's so expensive to use Gather I don't see how they can get enough exposure to really convince the public at large.
neuronerdgirl··on Kyle Vogt resigns from Cruise
They cut the video they first showed the DMV of the accident to remove the last error made by the car, which was arguably the worst aspect of the accident as far as Cruise's default behavior failures. The DMV found out about the cut segment from the news.
neuronerdgirl··on Ilya Sutskever "at the center" of Altman firing?
It's really not.
neuronerdgirl··on OpenAI's board has fired Sam Altman
Yes, this can happen, though generally the ousting party would also need to be able to point to some policy or legal transgression to do it without putting themselves at risk of a lawsuit.
neuronerdgirl··on Canned food went from military rations to fancy appetizers
All hail the safety can opener[0]!

0: https://youtu.be/i_mLxyIXpSY?si=kXrTddErZvju6wIF

neuronerdgirl··on Walking has plummeted across America
As someone who was just there, you can't walk practically ANYWHERE in disney world. Within the parks sure, but getting between places is a nightmare if you don't have a car. There are zero sidewalks anywhere between any of the resorts and parks. We stayed at the Port Orleans resort and were forced to take a bus to Epcot (15 minute drive, for the record) when the entrance is literally across the highway! We had to add almost an hour for transit anytime we wanted to shift sites, and there was never an option to walk. We couldn't even access a pharmacy when my partner realized their contact solution was out - we would have had to pay for a Lyft because not only were there no sidewalks, the parking lots were literally fenced in. Coming from more regular trips to the Anaheim location where you can easily walk from any nearby hotel to anywhere you need to go, I was shocked at how aggressively anti-pedestrian it all felt.
neuronerdgirl··on The Benefits of Walking Backwards
Probably not. Both right side up and upside down viewing are processed in the same circuit of interpretation (eye - lateral geniculate nucleus - visual cortex). The phenomenon you are talking about occurs because control processes that "flip" your interpretation of the upside down visual field are directly altering this circuit, and thus control is required again to reset it back to right side up interpretation. By contrast, walking forward is driven by central pattern generators directly in the spinal cord [0], while backward walking is a controlled process governed by the prefrontal and motor cortices, so there is no real overlap in the systems that would cause mutual interference.

0: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11728329/#:~:text=Central%20....

neuronerdgirl··on The Benefits of Walking Backwards
The study appears to be a part of one of the authors' dissertation which focuses on approach avoidance behaviors and their relationship to cognitive control [0]. The inclusion of sidestepping is not "fishing" but is used as a control to have participants doing a similar level of motor engagement on the task but that is neither approaching nor avoidant. The deeper hypothesis being tested is a part of the embodied cognition literature [1] which posits that not only does our cognitive system influence the state of our bodies, but that likewise the state of the body influences our cognitive state. Thus, the study aims to address whether the body being in a state of approach or avoidance influences our level of cognitive control being implemented on our assessment of other stimuli in our environment. Including sidestepping a control would absolutely have been an a priori decision with a legitimate scientific reasoning.

As a dissertation and a psychology study, the small sample size is somewhat expected, and a power analysis would (i suspect) indicate that it is perfectly valid for the statistical test being used (36 subjects is pretty close to 80% power for a moderate effect size for simpler experimental designs like this, if I remember correctly). These studies are not intended to serve as a critical and seminal authority on the subject but to add evidence to the literature, which then is taken as a whole to understand the underlying phenomena. Especially in a world where grants are reserved for only the flashiest and trendiest technologies and topics and publish or perish rules the day, papers with small sample sizes are a symptom of a lack of funding for these questions and relentless demands on researchers' time and effort, and I would bet that these researchers were doing the best they could with the resources they had. I think hackernews is rather uncharitable about psychology research in these respects.

As a note, this study was published in 2009 and thus likely conducted at least a year or two prior, at which point preregistration was not common for the cognitive field (and indeed it is still in its infancy). So, it is not surprising that this study was not preregistered and nor, I would argue, should it be considered a red flag.

0: https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/16161138.pdf#page=82

1: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embodied_cognition

neuronerdgirl··on The Benefits of Walking Backwards
I suspect it would. There is a well-documented similar effect called the congruency sequence effect [0] in which performance on a given incongruent trial improves if the previous trial was likewise incongruent (and, interestingly, performance on a given congruent trial will degrade). The current understanding of this phenomenon is essentially that you take just a bit more time and care on the current trial after recently experiencing a more demanding trial, which would parallel the hypothesis here.

0: https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.3758/CABN.7.4.380.p...

neuronerdgirl··on Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Markets Repress
How well does that hypothesis fit the maps experience?
neuronerdgirl··on 'Not of faculty quality': How Penn mistreated Katalin Karikó
Also like the one time you most typically use the Dr honorific is specifically when you are speaking about the person in reference to their profession.
neuronerdgirl··on California slams San Francisco for 'egregious' barriers to housing construction
People see FIDI and think that level of density is happening in Pac Heights or Sunset and don't realize how thin things get once you get out of the main downtown strip.
neuronerdgirl··on Flannelette Cure: Fire Tests with Textiles (1910)
Interestingly, going down the rabbit-hole a bit found this letter snippet [0], which suggests this new fabric may have been less of a success in the long term than the article suggests.

[0] https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1910Natur..84..429P/abstra...

neuronerdgirl··on A suicide crisis among veterinarians
I personally agree with the government that you should probably have an advanced degree before being allowed to cut into or administer drugs to a living creature.
neuronerdgirl··on Lego MRI Scanners donated to hospitals to help children cope with anxiety (2022)
Having worked in the GT/GSU center, it's worth noting that that mock scanner (and indeed the MRI itself) are research-only, but yes the attention my forebears put into the experience particularly for children. Back then there were just a handful of us supporting labs from all 3 schools!
neuronerdgirl··on BofA says–it's a housing recession, 1980s-style
It's a problem if you can't sell at all, which happens to many people in a collapse like this.
neuronerdgirl··on BofA says–it's a housing recession, 1980s-style
They're talking about having to sell the current house, obviously.
neuronerdgirl··on Advice for Prospective PhD Students
There is absolutely high competition in neuroscience PhD programs. I have no idea why you would think otherwise.
neuronerdgirl··on Driver hits woman in SF, then Cruise driverless car runs her over
Pedestrians in california have de facto right of way over cars in any scenario so this is irrelevant here.
neuronerdgirl··on US finally moves to cut $2,350 fee for renouncing citizenship
Given its foundation in chattel slavery America has always been what it was founded to oppose.
neuronerdgirl··on Workers strike at all 3 Detroit automakers for bigger share of industry profits
[sources needed]
neuronerdgirl··on The shrinking number of primary care physicians is reaching a tipping point
That's not the reasoning, its a continued descriptor of "that once attracted the best and brightest"
neuronerdgirl··on Why new furniture doesn’t last long
They used to just make them out of zinc so they wouldn't snap at the drop of a hat. Guess that $0.10 savings per unit was worth the shipping though
neuronerdgirl··on Why new furniture doesn’t last long
We have also come to accept wildly poor standards for clothing construction because of our disconnect between expense and quality. Can you imagine brushing off those little snags you get in your tshirts after one wash as "just how these things are"if you had paid the real modern (local labor) cost for them? As a sewist I would estimate that the labor and materials cost for one well-made, good material t-shirt would be at least $45 [0] before even accounting for profit margin, yet people grumble at paying $20 for slave labor cotton blended with plastic made at the hands of an overworked, underpaid sweatshop worker. Our ability to source clothing so cheaply coupled with our lack of direct interaction with the making and maintenance of them has lowered our expectations in a race to the bottom.

[0] back of napkin math - i might be able to find a decent knit cotton with some veneer of ethical sourcing at a rock-bottom price of $10-12 per yard (in practice F to doubt). Assuming a pittance for the thread (and ignoring the upstart costs for acquiring a sewing machine), I would peg my skillset at a value of $35-50 per hour given my experience based on the rates of similarly skilled artisans in the US.

neuronerdgirl··on Study: Carbon offsets aren’t doing their job, overstate impact
Carrying this forward, stop buying shit. Humans today consume an ungodly amount of unnecessary crap. Just in terms of clothing the fast fashion industry has absolutely demolished our sense of longevity and repairability and convinced us we need entire new goddamn wardrobes every other year.
neuronerdgirl··on What can historical clothing reveal that other sources cannot?
Codswallop. Corsets were not the restrictive garments our modern mythology would have you believe. Except for a few specific types of fashions, corsets throughout history were designed to be well-fitting and maneuverable. Women wore these garments while working - including lower class women working fields, factories, and other hard jobs. Corsets were effectively bras for these women, and you could absolutely bend down to get your own handkerchief. These myths have been well documented and debunked by the historical costuming community [0-3].

0 - https://youtu.be/zNwTqanp0Aw?si=3duaZETPo2IZwFqU

1 - https://youtu.be/rExJskBZcW0?si=sx1oClP0avxEMUUB

2 - https://youtu.be/Xpie2GL0M4I?si=HzP2g76ycNLiPCxB

3 - https://youtu.be/4XBLBfWNH7I?si=Kkr7t0y9bINlWsqw

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →