HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

neuronerdgirl

169 karma · joined April 20, 2023

submissionscomments
neuronerdgirl··on A video of the transformation of a single cell into a salamander
Really cool video and I appreciate the deft editing hand on the different zooms and perspectives so we could see the most interesting details. My only critique would be that the sounds (especially the water slosh sounds) were a little distracting. The heartbeat was cool to indicate when the pulsing emerged and I guess the underwater sound was trying to set an atmosphere, but mostly I would have preferred to simply appreciate the video for what it was. Props to the maker regardless!
neuronerdgirl··on Eye scans detect signs of Parkinson’s disease up to seven years before diagnosis
DBS is very much a late-stage treatment - it can stop your uncontrollable shaking once you're at that point, but it does nothing as far as reversal is concerned
neuronerdgirl··on Students are submitting answers saying “I am an AI language model”
No need for that, just have in-class writing sessions.
neuronerdgirl··on Scientists are only beginning to understand how PFAS impacting our health
To further your point, there is shockingly little education to the general public about cooking oil smoke points. I've cooked more or less exclusively with grapeseed or safflower oil since learning about it, but so many people use low smoke point oils (olive oil mostly, thanks health craze) for high-temp purposes and there's nothing to indicate to them that there is a problem
neuronerdgirl··on Schizophrenia drugs may have been off target for decades, study finds
> the problem is they are treating a symptom not the cause of depression which is immune dysfunction.

Yeaaaaa that's gonna be a serious "citations (plural and trustworthy) needed" from me there

neuronerdgirl··on A surprisingly simple way to foil car thieves
I'll give you that I misread bullet 2, so the total is a little over 31k. But grants that fund salaries for predoctoral scholars don't just fund the salary itself, they also cover the additional funds listed on that page. You can't partially fund a trainee on a grant. In any case, this wildly misses the forest for the trees - 1.2 mil in grants does not cover 6 years of salary plus research costs for 2 trainees and 2 professors full stop.
neuronerdgirl··on A surprisingly simple way to foil car thieves
Cover the two PhD students at the NIH payscales for PhD students on a standard training grant[1] ($43,894 not including benefits) and you've used up over a quarter of your budget on less than half the salary needs, completely ignoring any research costs that need to be covered on top of the much higher payscales of the professors. Plus a large number of PhD students in this kind of work make more than the states stipend above. Not extravagant.

https://osr.ucsf.edu/news/nih-update-ruth-l-kirschstein-nati....

neuronerdgirl··on How to register a Kei truck in Pennsylvania
You not wearing a seatbelt puts other people in the vehicle at risk because your body becomes a massive flying object in the cabin when you are hit that can injure or kill others in the vehicle with you.
neuronerdgirl··on Brainkey review: MRI scan brain health and cognitive impairment markers (2022)
Hilariously, brain size is actually a pretty meaningless stat.
neuronerdgirl··on FDA approves first nonprescription daily oral contraceptive
Last time i had to pay out of pocket (because insurance won't cover more than 3 months at a time and I was going out of the country for 6) my GENERIC BC was 89.99 per month. The brand name is something like $189. I can't take cheaper forms because they have negative interactions with my brain chemistry that make me suicidal. BC is offensively expensive and needlessly difficult to obtain.

As an aside, the amount of patronizing in these comments along the lines of "but these women will clearly take the medicine wrong or fail to understand the consequences of their actions if we don't have them speak to a doctor first!" is just... really telling.

neuronerdgirl··on FDA approves first nonprescription daily oral contraceptive
Good time to remind people that tylenol dosages as written on the bottle are just within the safety window to avoid toxicity[1]. Having done the math myself, you can't even take the extra strength stuff at the recommended timing without skipping a dose each day. Drugs, even OTC ones, have very real risks, and gatekeeping BC is laughable given the risks of not having it freely available.

[1] https://www.health.harvard.edu/pain/acetaminophen-safety-be-...

neuronerdgirl··on Submarine missing near Titanic used a $30 Logitech gamepad for steering
... yes?
neuronerdgirl··on John Carmack on shorter work weeks (2016)
>Sometimes I have so much to do at work that I need to just read fiction or play around in the darkroom to relax. But this is not the norm -- it's happened twice in the last decade, and lasted for about a month.

Ok but you're literally describing a burnout cycle. Some people would prefer to just skip that part and have a completely sustainable working pace.

neuronerdgirl··on Fuck Nuance (Healy, 2017)
I found this article somewhat ironically on the heels of completing a second-round manuscript review. Healy presents an argument for how the consideration of "nuance* in scientific theory muddles the development of theories that are strong and impactful. While Healy discusses his specific interactions within the world of sociology, I think his argument applies to a great many fields in science, and I saw it in the reviews from round one of this neuroscience manuscript. The paper itself was quite strong; all of the reviews (admittedly including my own) were asking for some flavor of nuance, which the authors then had to provide explanations for while defending the scope of their work.

Ultimately, very little of their work needed to change, which made me wonder just how much value those questions added to the science. I think this question can be asked broadly not only of peer review but of scientific discourse as a whole - what are we trying to accomplish by playing 20 questions with someone's presented work? How do we shift the discourse to be more collaborative and productive rather than resembling pre-med students taking digs at each other to try to gain favor with the professor? Or is Healy wrong and this is the only way we avoid pitfalls in theorizing in the vein of Clever Hans?

neuronerdgirl··on Europeans Take a Major Step Toward Regulating A.I
What do you mean deliberate? If GPT has a bias it it likely just reflecting latent imbalances in the training data due to extant imbalances in public opinion, not some overlord in a dark closet turning a dial between left and right wing. As the saying goes, "reality has a liberal bias".
neuronerdgirl··on The Deliberate Practice Guide (2021)
When I was a kid, I had a coach that would always say "Practice doesn't make perfect, practice makes permanent." I feel like that captures the difference here pretty well. If you practice something 10,000 times poorly, you're just going to engrain that poor performance to "expert" level. You can't magically get better at something just because you do it over and over, there has to be some evaluative component that shifts your actions over time.
neuronerdgirl··on Walkout at global science journal over ‘unethical’ fees
Publish or perish my friend, you've hit the nail on the head. There is not currently a widely accepted avenue for free open publication in neuroscience because the preprint system (and its lack of peer review) are distrusted, and the A-tier journals know their status and can set their prices based on demand. I, on the other hand, am effectively required to show a regular pattern of publishing in A- and B-tier journals to even be considered competitive for a potential tenure-track position, let alone land one and earn tenure.

This is a major reason I am evaluating alternative career options.

neuronerdgirl··on Walkout at global science journal over ‘unethical’ fees
The NIH indeed requires all work published under their grants to be made available open-access. Problem is publishers figured out that meant they could charge EVEN MORE for submissions to be made open access than they charged for standard closed publishing. Wiley charged me $2,975 last year for an accepted submission to Human Brain Mapping.
← PreviousPage 3 of 3