169 karma · joined April 20, 2023
Yeaaaaa that's gonna be a serious "citations (plural and trustworthy) needed" from me there
https://osr.ucsf.edu/news/nih-update-ruth-l-kirschstein-nati....
As an aside, the amount of patronizing in these comments along the lines of "but these women will clearly take the medicine wrong or fail to understand the consequences of their actions if we don't have them speak to a doctor first!" is just... really telling.
[1] https://www.health.harvard.edu/pain/acetaminophen-safety-be-...
Ok but you're literally describing a burnout cycle. Some people would prefer to just skip that part and have a completely sustainable working pace.
Ultimately, very little of their work needed to change, which made me wonder just how much value those questions added to the science. I think this question can be asked broadly not only of peer review but of scientific discourse as a whole - what are we trying to accomplish by playing 20 questions with someone's presented work? How do we shift the discourse to be more collaborative and productive rather than resembling pre-med students taking digs at each other to try to gain favor with the professor? Or is Healy wrong and this is the only way we avoid pitfalls in theorizing in the vein of Clever Hans?
This is a major reason I am evaluating alternative career options.