HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

newbie789

1,109 karma · joined February 6, 2020

submissionscomments
newbie789··on I would like closure, but I'll take honesty
Sorry, I’m genuinely confused here.

I asked his defenders if they support his views on race science, and brought up the possibility that people dislike him for reasons other than the 2017 event.

Your position is that it’s impolite to bring up a writer’s body of work because… why?

Edit: It’s kind of hard not to interpret your post as “I believe in race science and it makes me uncomfortable to be asked a question like that so plainly, so I will fall back on calling you rude.”

newbie789··on I would like closure, but I'll take honesty
Is it unambiguously a lie if I were to say “Based off what I’ve read of this guy’s writing, this guy is a piece of shit racist who has openly admitted to being randomly abusive to strangers.”? Or am I morally obligated to say “He also appears from my perspective to leverage the language of mental illness to excuse himself and attack his critics.”?

What if I don’t believe his narrative _AT ALL_? Am I a liar then? All I’ve read here is a guy insisting that it’s unfair to dislike him. I certainly don’t trust his intellectual honesty, why on earth would I be compelled to believe his narrative simply because he insists that it’s hurting him that I don’t?

newbie789··on I would like closure, but I'll take honesty
His position is that “If you don’t support my extensive writing about race science, you’re a bigot and a liar because of an incident unrelated to my extensive writing about race science, which has singularly made me a victim of the mob - not my actual writing or opinions. Any criticism of me personally is by definition predicated on the thing I said in 2017 and not my body of work since then.”

That’s the condition that he set!

newbie789··on I would like closure, but I'll take honesty
Legitimate question to the folks on here that are defending this guy: What are your thoughts on this guy’s (thoroughly spelled out) views regarding race and intelligence?

I’ll start: I think his opinions are wrong and bad, and I sincerely doubt that the people that take issue with him do so explicitly because of what to place in 2017. This strikes me as a deliberate misdirect to enable his victimhood.

And to answer his question: “What do you want from me?”

Answer:

“Nothing. I want nothing at all from you. I want to stop hearing racist dogwhistle bullshit from big publications (even if the racist dog whistle bullshit is written by somebody that suffers from mental health issues.) My issue isn’t with you, it’s with the folks that pay you.

Will I go out of my way to undermine your career? No. I will probably not think of the Poor Abused Race Scientist ever again after today, but should I somehow come across your writings on the future, I’ll decline to read it. It’s kind of sad that you view this opinion as some sort of hate crime, but that’s not my problem.”

newbie789··on The Bug in Paxos Made Simple
Ah, thanks. I was confused by the title.
newbie789··on The Bug in Paxos Made Simple
Wait the author says that this isn’t a bug in Paxos but one that he intentionally and arbitrarily introduced? The ‘bug’ here is maybe a bit of ambiguity from a book?

Edit: I appreciate being corrected on this.

newbie789··on Richard ‘Lowtax’ Kyanka, founder of Something Awful, has died
Hi! Have you ever been the owner of a free hosting service of any kind whatsoever?

A long time ago I was, and I can assure you that horrific child/animal abuse material does literally show up as an emergent phenomenon, necessitating moderation in 100% of platforms. I don’t think that it was the result of some complex conspiracy by the government to undermine my site since the only time I had contact with the police was when I reached out and provided the authorities with logs and whatever other relevant information I had on hand.

The factually correct statement is your first one. CP is publicly everywhere and police do nothing. The issue that you’ve maybe missed or chosen to ignore is that it’s indeed everywhere. It’s everywhere to such a huge extent that the police have to rely on private operators to self-report CSAM to them.

I’d suggest that you try making a website where people can upload images or videos for free, getting the word out, and counting the hours/days until you are contacted by your users about horrifying content that you’re hosting.

That would require actually putting money (and legal liability) into providing a free-speech-themed service though, which for some reason nobody wants to do.

Edit: Pedophiles do not necessarily act rationally, and tend to put a lot of effort into protecting their anonymity. They aren’t like you and I. They are fucking deranged.

newbie789··on .plan
What is this?
newbie789··on Richard ‘Lowtax’ Kyanka, founder of Something Awful, has died
I’m still waiting on your publicly accessible upload portal for tentacle porn. At this point, your reticence to give me access to your personal website’s storage has crossed from censorious to violating the non-agression policy. It’s quite telling that you’re aggressively anti-free speech.
newbie789··on Richard ‘Lowtax’ Kyanka, founder of Something Awful, has died
Yeah, these “free speech at all costs!!” folks really don’t think that individuals and private organizations should have the right to curate what appears on the platforms they own and pay for. Their version of “free speech” necessarily requires taking away others’ rights to property, which seems kind of odd because that same crowd is often going on about ~liberty~.

Every time I see people shaking their fists and yelling “MODS!!!!” at the sky it gives me a laugh because that person almost certainly has never actually tried to provide an open forum or image hosting service. They’re usually actually fully averse to the idea of doing so, hence why nobody has offered to host my collection of tentacle porn for free and in perpetuity.

It’s not an issue of what these people believe is morally right like is often claimed, it’s an issue of how they feel entitled to be treated as an individual regardless of how that impacts the freedom of others. There’s no ideological consistency of “freedom”, just a tantrum about not getting enough free services.

newbie789··on Richard ‘Lowtax’ Kyanka, founder of Something Awful, has died
So, how do I upload my collection of tentacle porn to your personal website? A true advocate for free speech would post their SFTP credentials in the open on this website.
newbie789··on Richard ‘Lowtax’ Kyanka, founder of Something Awful, has died
What Are You Talking About
newbie789··on Richard ‘Lowtax’ Kyanka, founder of Something Awful, has died
Wait are you part of this conversation? Edit: It literally can’t be the answer to my question so
newbie789··on Richard ‘Lowtax’ Kyanka, founder of Something Awful, has died
So how do I move my tentacle porn collection to your personal website? SFTP? Git? Rsync?

I would love to hear your position on free speech

newbie789··on Richard ‘Lowtax’ Kyanka, founder of Something Awful, has died
Sorry for the repost but: What exactly are you trying to have a discussion with me about?
newbie789··on Richard ‘Lowtax’ Kyanka, founder of Something Awful, has died
> I essentially challenged the creator to advocate for his new platform by supporting the speech rights of child abusers to promote their ideas

I wouldn’t do that. I’m not sure why anybody would.

newbie789··on Richard ‘Lowtax’ Kyanka, founder of Something Awful, has died
“Basically” was a modifier here, meant to indicate that he was not auto-banned in the traditional sense but rather quickly in a way that resembled being auto-banned.
newbie789··on Richard ‘Lowtax’ Kyanka, founder of Something Awful, has died
Oh sorry, I didn’t realize that we’re talking about “unfettered free speech” which doesn’t appear in the article. Yes, it is true that he did not advocate for your flavor of “freedom” (forcing private entities to host and serve any and all content that you can possibly barf up in perpetuity)
newbie789··on Richard ‘Lowtax’ Kyanka, founder of Something Awful, has died
Having rules on a private website is against the concept of free speech?

How much of your own money are you willing to spend on hosting and serving an unlimited amount of user-uploaded hentai tentacle porn on your privately-owned domain? If the answer is anything less than “infinite money”, you’re anti-free-speech.

newbie789··on Richard ‘Lowtax’ Kyanka, founder of Something Awful, has died
Lowtax was by all accounts a real piece of garbage by the end, but he undoubtedly created a place that changed the internet permanently.

I find it kind of funny the amount of ire he drew long before the abuse allegations surfaced though. For example, he was basically auto banned from Twitter by… somebody with the ability to make those decisions at their discretion. I’ve always wondered who that was. In my head, it’s always been a funny thought that Jack Dorsey is some embittered ex-goon that never got over losing $10. (I have no reason to believe this is the case, but it gives me a chuckle)

newbie789··on Richard ‘Lowtax’ Kyanka, founder of Something Awful, has died
Moderation on a private forum is a form of (free) expression.
newbie789··on Why has HN become so hostile to differing opinions?
The poster in this case is intentionally trying to astroturf the idea that they are somehow a victim of an imaginary social force by posting bullshit and then whining when people prefer not to read said bullshit.

It’s a pathological impulse of a person that’s unwell.

newbie789··on Axie Infinity: Infinite Opportunity or Infinite Peril?
Agreed. I’d rather pay the $2k to somebody that can address my immediate specific concerns in an interactive way, and I’d certainly not give it to somebody that suggests that I don’t understand an entire market because I think their silly newsletter is overpriced.
newbie789··on Axie Infinity: Infinite Opportunity or Infinite Peril?
Yes. It would be a “steal” for somebody that somehow both can’t run etherscan and extrapolate meaningful information but is in a position to make big financial decisions.

Are you a customer of this service?

newbie789··on Axie Infinity: Infinite Opportunity or Infinite Peril?
> not everyone can just open etherscan and download insight straight into the brain.

So… this is for execs that lack the core competency for being an exec in this space?

newbie789··on Axie Infinity: Infinite Opportunity or Infinite Peril?
It’s a constellation of different methods of money laundering. If you enjoy money laundering (or have some sort of disorder that makes you enjoy assisting money launderers), it’s all fun!
newbie789··on Axie Infinity: Infinite Opportunity or Infinite Peril?
$2,000 per month for this drivel is absolutely hilarious. Normally I’m not a big fan of outlandishly overinflated egos peddling nonsense for cash, but the sheer arrogance on display here is actually somehow impressive.

That being said, the subject matter here is so incredibly stupid that I have no option other than to hope that it fails magnificently (along with the ‘games’ it tracks).

newbie789··on All adults can get a Covid vaccine booster in CA, not just those CDC listed
Can’t you just bike for recreation? Biking is both “core to your identity” but also something you don’t do unless you strictly have to?
newbie789··on Show HN: You.com, private search engine that summarizes the web – built for devs
Fair enough. Instead of signing a big check for an incredibly valuable domain, Benioff transferred the incredibly valuable domain from his personal possession to the company.

I’m not personally of the opinion that this is an important enough distinction to avoid talking about my larger point of “This is an expensive endeavor and there is no reason to believe that there is any barrier preventing an exit that involves compromising in the event that Marc Benioff or the other investors at some point want their money back.”

Even if the domain was “free”, the rest of the endeavor is incredibly costly. I’m not really filled with confidence that the founder here either straight up didn’t understand the spirit of my point, or found it advantageous to feign ignorance about this.

newbie789··on Show HN: You.com, private search engine that summarizes the web – built for devs
5 is the most important because without a reasonable revenue model, selling to a larger company and washing your hands of your privacy promises is the clearest way to make money later.

Edit: you guys didn’t buy you.com from anybody? The domain “you.com” was up for grabs and you guys bought it for $10 on godaddy?

Edit 2: Thanks for answering 3a in the affirmative :). Yes, this is funded by folks that have made millions from investing in businesses that sell user data.

← PreviousPage 2 of 12Next →