HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ngneer

634 karma · joined June 8, 2015

submissionscomments
ngneer··on The insecurity of telecom stacks in the wake of Salt Typhoon
I was not commenting on VoIP, it works nicely and has for a long time, in the network core too. Mobile carriers do not use VoIP with the MS, to my knowledge. There's "Wi-Fi Calling", but that is the closest you're gonna get to packetized data streams reaching your phone (it sees traction where other reception is bad and the carrier has to rely on the Internet). Your use of "Bellhead" as a derogatory term is noted, and is more reflective on you than anything else. Feel free to have the last word, though.
ngneer··on The insecurity of telecom stacks in the wake of Salt Typhoon
Judging by this and your other comment, you seem to have made up your mind that the powers that be are not interested in end to end security. You seem to be ignoring (or disregarding without explanation) similar engineering feedback independently provided to you by different people. Good luck to you, sir!
ngneer··on The insecurity of telecom stacks in the wake of Salt Typhoon
Conversely, you might be vastly overestimating channel capacity. If ALL subscriber calls were on WhatsApp or Signal, the network would grind to a halt.
ngneer··on The Insecurity of Telecom Stacks in the Wake of Salt Typhoon
First, can you point to examples where using LLMs to find vulnerabilities works?
ngneer··on The Insecurity of Telecom Stacks in the Wake of Salt Typhoon
They will!
ngneer··on The insecurity of telecom stacks in the wake of Salt Typhoon
Great example. Anyone who cavalierly states "let's do PKI!" has not done PKI.
ngneer··on The insecurity of telecom stacks in the wake of Salt Typhoon
Not without redesign. I am telling you that whatever key exchange you run, it will result in key material that is accessible by the telco and therefore by your adversary (e.g., PRC). This is true even if you deployed authenticated Diffie-Hellman between endpoints. You might be able to do secure VoIP on top of that, but you cannot use existing telco infrastructure for your calls without expecting the tower to be able to decrypt the call. The ability of the telco to decrypt the call is the very basis of CALEA and LI, or lawful interception modules, and the reason why Salt Typhoon works.
ngneer··on The insecurity of telecom stacks in the wake of Salt Typhoon
You can "easily" convert a block cipher to a stream cipher on paper (e.g., using OFB or output feedback mode), but you will not get the performance. You clearly have no working knowledge here.
ngneer··on The insecurity of telecom stacks in the wake of Salt Typhoon
Right, let's redesign telecom infrastructure...
ngneer··on The Insecurity of Telecom Stacks in the Wake of Salt Typhoon
Right, let's redesign telecom infrastructure...
ngneer··on The insecurity of telecom stacks in the wake of Salt Typhoon
Of course I know how TLS works, as well as PFS. I recommend Kaufman on the subject. The general scheme you refer to is known as hybrid cryptography, and the key material that is derived is used to generate symmetric keys for the TLS session (several keys, in fact, separately for confidentiality and integrity, and for duplex communications). You missed my point completely, though. Unlike TLS sessions, which rely on packets, calls are multiplexed with TDMA or CDMA, for example. Unlike TCP, these channels have realtime requirements that necessitate stream ciphers be employed. I could ask you if you know how telecom works, but that would be childish and demeaning. As ephemeral as you wish to make it, the telco must know the secret key, for imagine if the call is being relayed to Timbuktu and must be passed in plaintext.
ngneer··on The insecurity of telecom stacks in the wake of Salt Typhoon
You appear to be neglecting the need for symmetric stream ciphers to achieve realtime communications (needed for performance reasons). No matter what you do, you are going to have a symmetric key in there somewhere for adversaries to extract. Once the adversary owns the telco, it is over (i.e., calls can be decrypted), no matter how strong the cryptography is. Your strongest cryptography cannot withstand a key leak.
ngneer··on Apple M3 Ultra
ARM/IoT community: https://community.arm.com/support-forums/f/architectures-and... https://community.arm.com/arm-community-blogs/b/internet-of-...

Security practitioners and academics: https://github.com/enovella/TEE-reversing/ https://media.ccc.de/v/36c3-10859-trustzone-m_eh_breaking_ar... https://www.blackhat.com/docs/us-15/materials/us-15-Shen-Att... https://i.blackhat.com/USA-19/Thursday/us-19-Peterlin-Breaki...

Sorry you could not cite an attack demonstrated on x86 and not on ARM or vice versa. Well, maybe TikTag (https://github.com/compsec-snu/tiktag) was demonstrated against ARM MTE, since you mention, and Pacman (https://pacmanattack.com/) against PAC. I was hoping for an actual response, no offense.

ngneer··on Apple M3 Ultra
Hardly. x86 and ARM follow similar security underpinnings and outcomes. ARM has TrustZone, x86 has TEEs. I cannot think of a single attack demonstrated on x86 and not on ARM or vice versa. Could you please cite one?
ngneer··on Another Conflict Between Privacy Laws and Age Authentication–Murphy v Confirm ID
Not applicable today, but older games such as Leisure Suit Larry used to ask age verification questions, anonymous in a way that a government issued ID is not.

https://allowe.com/games/larry/tips-manuals/lsl1-age-quiz.ht...

ngneer··on The Pentium contains a complicated circuit to multiply by three
Incredible, thanks for sharing. My understanding is that ternary computers would have been based on tri-state logic which was less reliable than say transistors or even vacuum tubes encoding binary state. Is that understanding correct?
ngneer··on Firefly ‘Blue Ghost’ lunar lander touches down on the moon
The moon has a very thin atmosphere, or at least so the mission science reporters said.
ngneer··on 'Impossible-to-hack' security turns out to be no security
Hardly. There are simply two ways to expose incompetence. You can be nice or you can be a prick. Your choice. Seeing your handle, you may find it interesting to note that my master's degree in CS was completed at the Technion. I am not looking for marketing people or buzzwords. I am looking for people mature enough to handle other people and get the job done. For example, if you tasked a security boy genius with pushing a fix and all they ended up doing was alienating the dev team, then you are scoring an own goal. I want bright AND mature. I am picky that way.
ngneer··on 'Impossible-to-hack' security turns out to be no security
Concur. Tone comes off as "toxic manboy". Not sure why the author chose that tone. I would not hire them for their security services just yet, no matter how big a genius they are. Maybe once they understand the world is made of people, not rational actors.
ngneer··on 'Impossible-to-hack' security turns out to be no security
CEO felt a threat to his company and responded accordingly. He is clearly green and impolite. Sending a vulnerability disclosure to someone without knowing their experience, and given the amount of spam on the web, one should not be surprised at the response. Trying to do a good thing and getting scolded for it feels terrible, though. One might understand why the researcher would put up database details for the world to see and fail to realize it is petty to do so. I hope both gentlemen learned their lesson.
ngneer··on Meta claims torrenting pirated books isn't illegal without proof of seeding
I suppose this comment wasn't adding much to the conversation, or not realistic enough in the context of a legal argument. More to life than law, though.
ngneer··on Meta claims torrenting pirated books isn't illegal without proof of seeding
The gall!

Next they'll say that "just because we downloaded the content does not mean we USED the content, and you have no proof we used the content, so we are not pirates".

ngneer··on Grok3 Launch [video]
Great question to ponder. Surely people would have seen their own reflections in water, but the mirror itself would have made "Reflection Technology" for "Artificial Introspection" more scalable. I suspect the mirror offered modern people a new viewpoint, allowing one to see how one is perceived by others. I do not think selfhood and identity would have been affected. My main question is about when people came to behave differently than apes. Douglas Hofstadter's "The Mind's I" may have a few hints on perception of self for you.
ngneer··on Grok3 Launch [video]
That's not really a fair question. To answer it, the OP would have to define intelligence. If you have done so already, then by all means, do share your definition. If not, then you are in no better position to claim intelligence than the OP is in claiming lack thereof.
ngneer··on Grok3 Launch [video]
No. Just means we are easy to fool. Like apes who see themselves in the mirror and fail to recognize they are seeing themselves in the mirror, thinking it is a different ape (and trying to mate with or attack it).
ngneer··on Grok3 Launch [video]
Best analogy so far. I am adopting this for the next wave of "wait until the next model" and "but humans hallucinate, too" comments. Yes, when we feed back our own output (language on the web) into ourselves, things become tricky to tease apart, and it would seem like intelligence to us. Then again, the mechanical turk appears intelligent, too. If we point out how it works, then the "magic" should vanish.
ngneer··on 50 Years of Travel Tips
I have a feeling that male and female travel experiences may differ in this regard. "To stay safe, smile." seems pretty naive to me. Clearly, the author is male. I would proffer "always have an exit", "do not walk into something you cannot walk out of" and "do not stray too far from the crowd".
ngneer··on Amazon ends kindle ebooks "Download and Transfer via USB"
BOOX: GOTO BOOX
ngneer··on Understanding Reasoning LLMs
Hardy har har; serves me right for poking fun. Good day, sir.
ngneer··on Understanding Reasoning LLMs
I do not view it as dismissive at all, rather it accurately characterizes the question as a silly question. "swim" is a verb applicable to humans, as is "think". Whether submarines can swim is a silly question. Same for whether machines can think.
← PreviousPage 2 of 16Next →